RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them

With The Secrets of Dumbledore in theaters this week, we look back at the first Fantastic Beasts to determine if it's just as charming as its predecessors, or if the magic has fizzled.

by | April 14, 2022 | Comments

IMAX poster for Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Author J.K. Rowling was living in poverty and studying to become a teacher when she penned Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone in 1997, and there’s no way she could have known the full-blown global sensation her fledgling series of fantasy novels would become. Almost two and a half decades later, not only does the so-called Wizarding World media juggernaut include her insanely popular book series, but also a multi-billion dollar feature film franchise, theme parks around the world, video games, a stage production, and more.


Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | StitcherTuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19


Speaking of the films, if the books themselves hooked millions of fans, the eight Harry Potter movies blew their minds even more, so when the initial franchise came to an end in 2011 with Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2, Warner Bros. was understandably eager to continue expanding the Wizarding World however they could. Their solution was to adapt Rowling’s 2001 companion book Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find Them, originally presented as one of the textbooks that Harry Potter himself and his classmates studied from, and transform it into a prequel series all its own.

The film adaptation Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them premiered in 2016 to much fanfare, particularly from the Potter fandom, and it earned solid reviews; it’s Certified Fresh at 74% on the Tomatometer and boasts a 79% Audience Score to match. Led by Oscar-winner Eddie Redmayne as “magizoologist” Newt Scamander, the author of the titular tome, Fantastic Beasts transported the action to 1920s New York City and introduced fans to a host of new characters embroiled in a new magical adventure, and for the most part, people seemed to be on board with it all.

But with the second installment, The Crimes of Grindelwald, earning poor reviews, and this week’s The Secrets of Dumbledore doing marginally better, it made us wonder if the critics were just so eager to dive back into the world of Harry Potter that they were perhaps a bit generous with Where to Find Them. Is the first film a genuinely rousing adventure with likable characters, spectacular visuals, and a rich mythology, or is it merely a blatant attempt by a studio desperate for reliable blockbuster box office to milk one of its most reliable cash cows? Can it be both?

Joining regular co-hosts Jacqueline Coley and Mark Ellis is returning guest Andres “Ace” Cabrera, write for Geeks of Color, co-host of The Meaning Of podcast, and co-founder of YouTube channel First Cut. Like millions of others, he also happens to be an unabashed fan of all things Harry Potter, including the Fantastic Beasts films, and acknowledges that people generally might not be as invested in the new series because, unlike the original Potter movies, they didn’t grow up with them. With that caveat in mind, he thinks the Tomatometer for Where to Find Them feels about right, if a bit lower than he’d like. Mark, on the other hand, thinks the movie misses the mark, even if it’s not outright terrible, and wouldn’t consider it Fresh, while Jacqueline simply thinks the film is terrible.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”


Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:


If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.


Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Tag Cloud

boxing TLC 79th Golden Globes Awards Video Games theme song Spring TV japan foreign stoner streaming movies Heroines ITV boxoffice Drama Shudder biopic golden globes 2020 rt labs critics edition Cartoon Network Star Wars National Geographic social media Superheroes E! biography Marvel Television Valentine's Day archives book adaptation comiccon Lionsgate jamie lee curtis Animation The Walt Disney Company Creative Arts Emmys Horror Trailer facebook Disney+ Disney Plus Rocky YouTube Premium Adult Swim Martial Arts universal monsters WGN romance Warner Bros. Pop TV video Tubi ESPN Captain marvel Turner FX on Hulu crime documentary cancelled TV shows Awards Tour blockbusters Calendar VICE children's TV christmas movies TNT strong female leads President psycho natural history Syfy revenge Brie Larson TBS El Rey hispanic king kong Endgame HFPA Instagram Live Spectrum Originals Box Office dramedy New York Comic Con south america new zealand singing competition Legendary Extras USA American Society of Cinematographers Mary Poppins Returns video on demand dreamworks james bond Comics on TV supernatural golden globe awards green book NBC blaxploitation telelvision Apple TV Plus hollywood CW Seed SXSW 2022 2019 Vudu hidden camera godzilla YouTube Red romantic comedy Sony Pictures ABC Signature 20th Century Fox die hard Comic Book high school rt archives superhero TIFF BBC America Fox News Black Mirror Logo Television Critics Association Music vampires Baby Yoda DC streaming service travel leaderboard sopranos Election comedies Mudbound Pride Month Pixar festival NBA GIFs YA satire spain Oscars popular Binge Guide hispanic heritage month Interview Spike Sci-Fi Netflix Christmas movies deadpool Sundance Now Super Bowl indiana jones independent Amazon Studios Ghostbusters Biopics child's play Kids & Family diversity animated BAFTA Hallmark Christmas movies Funimation HBO Max Best Actress parents Premiere Dates Song of Ice and Fire Tarantino free movies crime thriller Toys scene in color quibi all-time Rom-Com MGM dragons marvel comics heist movie TruTV toy story Winners composers Holiday Peacock football young adult Marvel A&E Tokyo Olympics 4/20 Best Picture Freeform stand-up comedy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Winter TV scorecard The CW Polls and Games Hulu Amazon Hallmark Trophy Talk DGA criterion Teen war laika prank Classic Film docudrama Academy Awards ABC Family Lifetime Christmas movies Acorn TV Photos 1990s television nbcuniversal mockumentary talk show Pet Sematary TV Land rom-coms Amazon Prime a nightmare on elm street Apple Alien Universal Pictures period drama batman Reality Competition Disney BBC One venice Podcast Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DC Comics TV renewals reboot PBS films dark sequel Reality Masterpiece Rock canceled TV shows sitcom Holidays Opinion The Witch rotten movies we love what to watch indie dceu OWN Shondaland versus comic book movies screen actors guild Esquire best Image Comics Hollywood Foreign Press Association NYCC 93rd Oscars movies MTV casting Arrowverse Writers Guild of America Christmas Film Festival comic books The Walking Dead ViacomCBS Avengers ratings Columbia Pictures Comedy franchise police drama rt labs Character Guide genre USA Network women ghosts Set visit X-Men SXSW Sundance basketball Rocketman 2015 Emmys 007 VH1 Exclusive Video transformers A24 slashers art house The Academy Comedy Central razzies halloween mcc docuseries Pirates streamig game of thrones The Arrangement discovery CBS 72 Emmy Awards remakes spanish SundanceTV WarnerMedia summer TV cats GLAAD E3 posters Marathons know your critic HBO cancelled TV series Mindy Kaling DirecTV Star Trek Chernobyl critics feel good Grammys PlayStation award winner kong Sundance TV robots anthology VOD MSNBC cars BET Awards witnail trailers Paramount dexter adventure blockbuster doctor who 2017 Fall TV Marvel Studios Black History Month Tomatazos Nat Geo kids Travel Channel Superheroe sequels anime Paramount Plus spinoff marvel cinematic universe Emmy Nominations comic 2021 ID vs. series thriller AMC Plus Turner Classic Movies See It Skip It Ovation 71st Emmy Awards Elton John RT History binge reviews cartoon mission: impossible Neflix finale directors festivals black pirates of the caribbean technology LGBTQ SDCC summer preview spy thriller Universal Mystery Summer Women's History Month stop motion CMT disaster IMDb TV DC Universe IFC live action rotten MCU Year in Review CNN Best Actor dogs TV movies Bravo new star wars movies chucky HBO Go RT21 Tumblr AMC halloween tv Epix debate legend TCA Amazon Prime Video Paramount Network First Look zombie summer TV preview obi wan Countdown based on movie Nickelodeon ABC elevated horror cops Quiz royal family crossover cancelled television TCA Awards adaptation Ellie Kemper nfl saw name the review breaking bad OneApp suspense Disney streaming service kaiju Mary poppins Britbox toronto spider-man joker Action scary Stephen King historical drama latino harry potter Walt Disney Pictures The Purge renewed TV shows TV hist PaleyFest science fiction movie YouTube Lucasfilm jurassic park cancelled worst Disney Channel Anna Paquin Red Carpet Tags: Comedy Musical FX Best Director TV One Country Oscar Trivia dc Fargo Western Infographic Family 90s cults Mary Tyler Moore aapi Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Musicals Watching Series Starz 45 sag awards Sneak Peek monster movies black comedy Comic-Con@Home 2021 richard e. Grant Broadway 24 frames action-comedy king arthur Apple TV+ 2018 CBS All Access olympics gangster wonder woman comics slasher Disney Plus Schedule crime drama lord of the rings 94th Oscars BBC Dark Horse Comics japanese documentaries obituary australia french Showtime concert Awards book cooking trophy Nominations Pacific Islander emmy awards Pop TCA 2017 canceled fresh TCA Winter 2020 Thanksgiving Best and Worst werewolf Discovery Channel politics political drama Television Academy Food Network teaser medical drama fast and furious zombies adenture worst movies scary movies true crime nature psychological thriller Hear Us Out spider-verse LGBT streaming live event target news tv talk FXX unscripted aliens South by Southwest Film Festival FOX TCM Wes Anderson Fantasy APB comic book movie Prime Video game show 99% international critic resources Film mutant italian Certified Fresh asian-american cinemax History twilight 2016 Crackle 21st Century Fox serial killer IFC Films sports justice league GoT classics Cosplay miniseries Netflix Cannes First Reviews zero dark thirty spanish language Fox Searchlight space mob screenings Lifetime Crunchyroll San Diego Comic-Con new york BET 73rd Emmy Awards superman