RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Man on Fire (with Special Guest Jay Ellis)

The star of HBO's Insecure is out for vengeance against the critics who felt this Denzel Washington thriller fizzled more than it sizzled.

by | December 16, 2021 | Comments

Poster image for Man on Fire

(Photo by ©20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

The late Tony Scott worked with Denzel Washington five times over the course of his nearly three-decade Hollywood career, forging a relationship with the powerhouse actor that began with 1995’s Crimson Tide. The one collaboration that proved to be a miss for critics was Man on Fire, the 2004 action thriller based on a novel about John Creasy, an alcoholic former soldier and operative who takes a job as a bodyguard for a young girl (Dakota Fanning) in Mexico City and embarks on a tour of vengeance when she is kidnapped.


Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19


At 38% on the Tomatometer, the film ranks near the bottom of both Scott’s and Washington’s extensive filmographies, and it’s the worst-reviewed of the movies they did together. Critics largely agreed on Washington’s uncanny ability to fill up the screen with his brooding charisma, but many of them also pointed to what they felt was the film’s bloated runtime and excessive, unnecessarily brutal violence.

But there remains a contingent of fans who were fully on board with John Creasy’s particular brand of vigilante justice. The movie’s title is Man on Fire, after all; you sort of know what you’re in for when you sit down to watch it, and “Denzel Washington takes out a bunch of bad guys” was essentially the selling point. In fact, Man on Fire’s 89% Audience Score is the highest of the five movies Scott and Washington made together — even higher than Certitifed Fresh winners like Crimson Tide (83%) and Unstoppable (72%).

So what did audiences see that critics missed? Or, more to the point, what were audiences able to stomach that critics weren’t? Our very special guest this week has some thoughts on the topic. Jay Ellis is just about to wrap up the fifth and final season of HBO’s hit comedy Insecure, on which he plays the longtime boyfriend of star Issa Rae’s character. However, Ellis also happens to have a Tony Scott-related project on the horizon, as he’s set to appear in next year’s Top Gun: Maverick alongside Tom Cruise.

Ellis joins RT’s own Mark Ellis (no relation… they think) and guest co-host Sharronda Williams of Pay or Wait (Jacqueline is away covering awards season developments) to chat about why this critically maligned film is so beloved by the fan community. While Sharronda admits a recent rewatch of the film revealed a few problematic moments, she still loves it, and Jay recounts the first time he saw Man on Fire as a college kid in Oregon. Then, of course, they dive into the final season of Insecure and the other projects Ellis has coming up.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”


Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:


If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.


Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Tag Cloud

supernatural BET Awards medical drama reboot Oscars E3 what to watch Comic-Con@Home 2021 Nominations video on demand women crime drama foreign Shondaland vs. rotten movies we love Spectrum Originals werewolf Britbox Pixar cars Pop TV broadcast The Walking Dead sopranos Endgame Song of Ice and Fire Creative Arts Emmys nbcuniversal Western cancelled television Best Director rt labs critics edition Discovery Channel Anna Paquin franchise razzies animated quibi best TruTV Best Actor psycho crime thriller batman directors indiana jones American Society of Cinematographers Awards Tour TV movies toy story nature 2021 Best Actress documentary Adult Swim royal family 72 Emmy Awards Teen police drama black Lifetime Christmas movies king arthur rotten Spring TV Chernobyl Bravo concert slashers ghosts art house south america Television Academy Sci-Fi target suspense reviews halloween Marvel Television Comedy Central Epix venice revenge binge Pride Month award winner free movies Cartoon Network E! olympics a nightmare on elm street screenings TCM Writers Guild of America HBO popular Netflix Christmas movies satire sag awards Grammys dexter The Purge japan El Rey Native Trivia festivals Tumblr dogs Family Spike LGBT OWN indie Disney Channel SXSW 2022 Horror jamie lee curtis Columbia Pictures Binge Guide MGM Disney Plus Extras CMT FX on Hulu marvel comics Wes Anderson PaleyFest Tokyo Olympics chucky jurassic park emmy awards Women's History Month young adult legend marvel cinematic universe crime Video Games summer preview Quiz Neflix dragons sequel new york Exclusive Video VOD biography Geeked Week Avengers Rocky Martial Arts obi wan sports National Geographic Lionsgate justice league BBC facebook MTV mission: impossible spider-verse cancelled TV shows hist Tomatazos HBO Go Reality USA Network Classic Film streamig GLAAD Interview MCU WarnerMedia NYCC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Tubi Fox Searchlight Star Wars king kong christmas movies Prime Video Election ratings Warner Bros. thriller Action universal monsters true crime Film Festival green book TIFF Alien name the review stoner 20th Century Fox Lucasfilm Awards natural history FOX Pop target scene in color unscripted gangster twilight rom-coms classics TV Land travel Walt Disney Pictures YA know your critic Syfy Showtime President VH1 Countdown SXSW X-Men blaxploitation DC Comics spanish Funimation interviews 73rd Emmy Awards technology Amazon cinemax rt labs die hard hispanic transformers Rock comics richard e. Grant HBO Max comic book movies DGA based on movie Hulu stop motion ITV USA superhero Mary Tyler Moore Best and Worst scorecard child's play Black History Month Pacific Islander OneApp Freeform Year in Review 94th Oscars zero dark thirty feel good summer TV teaser YouTube strong female leads DC Universe Acorn TV Tarantino all-time Marvel Studios The Witch french football hollywood book BAFTA Toys Black Mirror Comedy Watching Series HFPA talk show Disney+ Disney Plus new zealand Sony Pictures Red Carpet movies romance adaptation Vudu Emmy Nominations films Character Guide Sundance Now Hear Us Out Valentine's Day pirates of the caribbean zombies series Disney streaming service war miniseries kong Apple TV Plus BBC America Indigenous FX Holiday 45 Holidays Tags: Comedy trailers genre Emmys 79th Golden Globes Awards Universal BET Crunchyroll fresh TNT cults scary movies Sony Set visit festival 24 frames San Diego Comic-Con The Academy tv talk spinoff dark Nat Geo Legendary robots GoT 2017 cancelled Pirates mob kids IFC Sundance TV political drama Shudder joker nfl Summer Starz AMC Plus ABC Family PlayStation golden globe awards Fox News biopic comic books boxoffice ID TCA Winter 2020 Animation cats DirecTV comic comic book movie docudrama high school news zombie Pet Sematary Marvel Cannes Marathons Paramount Cosplay dc cancelled TV series action-comedy parents prank Premiere Dates Turner Mystery History TV One Infographic TBS leaderboard Fantasy Photos 2020 docuseries ABC mutant 71st Emmy Awards Drama See It Skip It Musical Lifetime heist movie lord of the rings serial killer FXX aliens hidden camera Best Picture Elton John spy thriller Schedule IMDb TV godzilla LGBTQ remakes composers deadpool ABC Signature movie video IFC Films new star wars movies Biopics dceu YouTube Premium PBS japanese Broadway science fiction Christmas Academy Awards harry potter Paramount Pictures Musicals cartoon live event Rom-Com kaiju latino First Reviews 93rd Oscars canceled TCA 2017 Trailer sitcom 4/20 dreamworks SDCC renewed TV shows breaking bad Peacock TCA Awards critic resources toronto Calendar Universal Pictures elevated horror anime New York Comic Con Reality Competition DC streaming service blockbuster Superheroe trophy APB disaster independent aapi 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards NBC Paramount Plus 1990s Winter TV debate anthology YouTube Red Captain marvel criterion diversity politics Comics on TV game show black comedy AMC Nickelodeon Amazon Prime streaming ESPN cops television 90s MSNBC RT21 period drama romantic comedy dramedy Star Trek theme song Dark Horse Comics 99% Trophy Talk historical drama canceled TV shows james bond The Walt Disney Company TLC comiccon game of thrones Paramount Network Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt space monster movies discovery 2016 Instagram Live asian-american Baby Yoda singing competition 21st Century Fox halloween tv Turner Classic Movies spanish language Ghostbusters doctor who Podcast A24 CBS obituary hispanic heritage month scene in color film series Opinion A&E First Look screen actors guild Mindy Kaling Hollywood Foreign Press Association Mary poppins documentaries Disney Masterpiece spider-man Television Critics Association slasher Ellie Kemper Amazon Studios 2018 Amazon Prime Video critics book adaptation Super Bowl Hallmark Christmas movies rt archives 2019 casting telelvision Polls and Games Winners witnail Heroines Mary Poppins Returns psychological thriller BBC One GIFs South by Southwest Film Festival Kids & Family Apple TV+ scene in color international Sundance Image Comics Fargo saw boxing worst worst movies Box Office CBS All Access summer TV preview ViacomCBS mockumentary Sneak Peek adenture Crackle 2015 Brie Larson archives Superheroes versus Thanksgiving basketball superman Mudbound social media The Arrangement Hallmark Comic Book comedies live action RT History Netflix The CW 007 finale spain Ovation Film Travel Channel SundanceTV adventure golden globes fast and furious WGN australia VICE stand-up comedy Country Esquire Arrowverse posters Fall TV Focus Features Star Wars Celebration CW Seed CNN scary Stephen King sequels NBA Apple Food Network vampires wonder woman mcc TV renewals Logo Oscar TCA Rocketman laika children's TV scene in color series italian crossover blockbusters streaming movies cooking TV Certified Fresh Music