RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Eternals

Does Chloé Zhao's sprawling superhero epic really deserve to be ranked at the bottom of the MCU?

by | December 30, 2021 | Comments

Poster for Eternals

(Photo by ©Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Part of the success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe is due to the studio’s ability to tweak its moviemaking formula just enough to offer something fresh for fans even as they continue to utilize all the familiar trademarks those fans have come to know and love. One element of that tweaking process has involved folding unique, capable filmmakers — people like Kenneth Branagh, James Gunn, and Taika Waititi — into Marvel’s overarching vision. These efforts have, by and large, born critically acclaimed, incredibly profitable fruit.

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

Then Eternals happened.

The prospect of introducing nearly a dozen new superheroes all at once was daunting enough, never mind the fact that these particular heroes were powerful immortals who had presumably lived through the events of the Infinity Saga without so much as lifting a finger to fight Thanos. But the folks at Marvel had the good sense to hire a young, up-and-coming director by the name of Chloé Zhao to helm the film after Zhao, an MCU fan, presented them with a pitch they couldn’t refuse.

At the time, Zhao had just come off of her second feature film, 2017’s acclaimed The Rider, and by the time Eternals was released in late 2021, she had become a Best Picture and Best Director winner at the Oscars for her third, Nomadland. In other words, expectations were sky high, and when the film landed with a 47% on the Tomatometer — the lowest of any film in the MCU and the only Rotten one of the franchise — it baffled a lot of folks.

So what went wrong? Not only did Eternals have an Academy Award-winning director, it featured an impressive cast that included Angelina Jolie, Salma Hayek, Kumail Nanjiani, Richard Madden, Gemma Chan, and Brian Tyree Henry, just to name a few. The film boasted an epic, centuries-spanning story and expansive, sweeping cinematography, and juggled multiple characters while it delivered the requisite superhero action.

According to some critics, particularly those who were hoping Eternals would be the MCU’s first “arthouse” superhero movie, there simply weren’t enough of Zhao’s fingerprints on the film. But hold on, still others complained that Zhao’s influence was far too strong. With all of that in mind, regular co-hosts Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley invite returning guest Coy Jandreau — talk show host, pop culture commentator, and all-around comic book expert — to rehash the film and figure out how and why the critics are so at odds with the fans, who rewarded Zhao’s efforts with a 78% Audience Score.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

new zealand indie women 2015 FXX docudrama NBA screenings Premiere Dates genre supernatural Esquire CNN BBC One revenge south america basketball Cartoon Network live event news Super Bowl dark technology sag awards The Academy Tubi asian-american Holidays HBO Max TNT Emmys films documentaries DC Universe pirates of the caribbean History Grammys series theme song Chernobyl Walt Disney Pictures Tags: Comedy SXSW Shudder RT21 VH1 concert Image Comics ABC Signature kong critic resources spy thriller teaser aapi Vudu HBO Go Opinion japan Mary Poppins Returns classics heist movie Martial Arts video on demand live action thriller all-time Awards Tour Showtime 007 discovery stop motion remakes Lifetime Christmas movies anthology Stephen King slashers Trivia mob kaiju Amazon Prime Video SDCC Nickelodeon nbcuniversal Heroines know your critic cops cartoon Shondaland legend binge hidden camera Food Network WarnerMedia slasher streaming godzilla Western dogs Dark Horse Comics golden globes National Geographic archives zombie Calendar dexter Fargo scary 73rd Emmy Awards scene in color TLC Spike werewolf superman romance cancelled television Lifetime movie football Academy Awards scorecard high school Exclusive Video Character Guide YouTube Red Oscars Arrowverse Pop target 72 Emmy Awards Song of Ice and Fire Biopics comic book movie Box Office transformers rt archives nfl BAFTA 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards harry potter Paramount child's play ESPN Quiz TCA Hallmark Christmas movies black comedy Epix Universal Pictures foreign Britbox Emmy Nominations mutant breaking bad social media Schedule what to watch reviews Film Festival Ovation TCA Winter 2020 science fiction Universal new star wars movies AMC sports A&E versus true crime LGBT jurassic park Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Apple TV Plus IFC BBC Discovery Channel Spectrum Originals Disney Plus war The Walt Disney Company zero dark thirty New York Comic Con boxoffice wonder woman royal family Starz Broadway Baby Yoda latino See It Skip It Holiday Sci-Fi Anna Paquin Musical Winners Action composers TBS talk show Pirates Netflix Christmas movies The Walking Dead action-comedy Crunchyroll posters sopranos green book The CW worst X-Men universal monsters children's TV Netflix GLAAD spider-verse spanish hist Hulu 4/20 Musicals Nominations name the review toronto new york Legendary black Peacock Cosplay dramedy 2021 venice MCU cancelled worst movies fast and furious singing competition medical drama streaming movies tv talk Marvel HFPA The Purge RT History Mystery 2019 hispanic heritage month stand-up comedy Pacific Islander rotten movies we love FOX Women's History Month DGA miniseries hispanic king kong Comic Book cinemax joker video FX canceled Podcast Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Animation Marathons Rom-Com Countdown PBS TCA Awards HBO Star Wars Masterpiece prank APB a nightmare on elm street crime drama Comic-Con@Home 2021 OneApp richard e. Grant rotten Ghostbusters aliens spain zombies VOD Superheroe Star Trek TruTV anime Reality vampires 90s criterion christmas movies unscripted superhero psychological thriller crossover Travel Channel Disney+ Disney Plus Christmas Polls and Games TV Land El Rey adaptation blaxploitation crime Superheroes quibi ID australia Spring TV boxing travel E3 disaster Photos The Witch sitcom Captain marvel Paramount Plus Sneak Peek satire kids Rocky San Diego Comic-Con E! NYCC Apple First Look Hear Us Out movies Bravo cults indiana jones cooking Winter TV Summer elevated horror rt labs crime thriller Infographic adventure Creative Arts Emmys young adult Tarantino Pixar Tomatazos ViacomCBS saw Marvel Studios Film parents Amazon Prime VICE scary movies 99% YouTube Premium Drama Paramount Network Pet Sematary mission: impossible dceu justice league trophy strong female leads leaderboard LGBTQ batman japanese monster movies jamie lee curtis YA Country A24 OWN CMT Television Critics Association sequel Logo Watching Series Nat Geo television Columbia Pictures renewed TV shows Rock IFC Films ABC Family halloween best nature PlayStation Comedy die hard USA reboot biopic dragons CW Seed First Reviews toy story Adult Swim psycho Television Academy Reality Competition witnail Tokyo Olympics emmy awards italian Year in Review Writers Guild of America french Marvel Television Pride Month Syfy Sundance Apple TV+ lord of the rings facebook blockbuster popular 71st Emmy Awards Freeform American Society of Cinematographers Toys dreamworks olympics natural history BBC America FX on Hulu telelvision Black Mirror police drama Turner Classic Movies finale Interview halloween tv Ellie Kemper Red Carpet PaleyFest gangster ABC 45 marvel comics robots Funimation independent Endgame GoT IMDb TV Alien docuseries TV renewals twilight comic Rocketman Lionsgate fresh CBS All Access ITV deadpool Prime Video DC Comics MSNBC Mary poppins Lucasfilm razzies romantic comedy international Black History Month Trailer diversity Video Games Neflix YouTube Mudbound Comics on TV Fall TV cancelled TV series rom-coms Election cats 2020 space SundanceTV adenture Wes Anderson casting GIFs ratings BET President Crackle Awards comedies CBS mockumentary Hollywood Foreign Press Association Disney Channel rt labs critics edition TIFF 21st Century Fox trailers The Arrangement Family Brie Larson doctor who Disney TCA 2017 Amazon Pop TV Avengers Disney streaming service james bond Binge Guide debate Kids & Family politics MTV franchise Comedy Central Sundance TV ghosts TCM based on movie free movies WGN hollywood USA Network dc comic book movies Certified Fresh Set visit political drama TV book adaptation mcc chucky DC streaming service Fantasy Best and Worst 24 frames 1990s cancelled TV shows laika directors art house 2017 serial killer vs. BET Awards sequels blockbusters Fox Searchlight AMC Plus Music king arthur feel good golden globe awards Amazon Studios Mary Tyler Moore biography book cars spanish language game show TV One comiccon comics festivals animated Cannes comic books Teen 93rd Oscars NBC Hallmark Thanksgiving Sony Pictures Warner Bros. 20th Century Fox historical drama Mindy Kaling game of thrones Extras Instagram Live award winner suspense Valentine's Day Sundance Now screen actors guild critics Tumblr Horror marvel cinematic universe 2016 festival Fox News Classic Film obituary stoner canceled TV shows 2018 Turner TV movies Acorn TV Elton John spider-man DirecTV spinoff 79th Golden Globes Awards Trophy Talk documentary period drama