RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... The Amazing Spider-Man 2

We revisit Sony's only Rotten Spider-Man movie to consider whether Andrew Garfield's second outing as Peter Parker is actually better than we thought.

by | January 13, 2022 | Comments

Jamie Foxx as Electro in The Amazing Spider-Man 2

(Photo by ©Columbia Pictures)

Film buffs — and particularly superhero movie fans — have long been aware of the complicated relationship between Marvel and Sony Pictures/Columbia Pictures over the rights to one of the comic book company’s flagship heroes, Spider-Man. The latter has held the film rights to the character since 1999 and shepherded three different franchises (four, if you count the animated Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse) featuring Spidey to the big screen. All of them have been successes, both critically and commercially… with one exception.

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

After Sam Raimi’s inaugural Spider-Man franchise fizzled out sometime around 2010, Sony’s second go-round with Peter Parker began in 2012 with The Amazing Spider-Man, which rebooted the character’s story with Andrew Garfield in the role and Emma Stone as love interest Gwen Stacy. Because the film earned a respectable 72% on the Tomatometer (against a 77% Audience Score) and made over $750 million globally, a sequel was as inevitable as Uncle Ben’s death. And so it came to be.

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is the only Rotten Spider-Man movie ever made.

Maybe that shouldn’t have been such a surprise. Andrew Garfield is a phenomenal actor, but he was a 30-year-old playing a high school senior, and the facade cracked just a bit at times. Oscar-winner Jamie Foxx raised expectations for the film as its primary villain, Electro, but the character was so mishandled that when Spider-Man: No Way Home brought him back, he was given a complete makeover. And we won’t even get into that Rhino business.

But — and be warned: major spoilers for Spider-Man: No Way Home follow here — there has been something of a reassessment of TASM2 in the wake of No Way Home, not only because of Foxx’s revamped Electro, but also because of Garfield’s scene-stealing, heartbreaking performance as an alternate-universe Peter Parker. And, as our guest this week would argue, that’s because the heart of The Amazing Spider-Man 2 lies in the romance between Peter and Gwen. This is what sets the film apart from the others, and this is the reason why Garfield’s presence in No Way Home helped elevate the film even further beyond its myriad other pleasures.

Joining regular co-hosts Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley this week is a guest who has been our go-to for Spider-Man-related episodes, the actress, podcast host, and pop culture commentator Roxy Striar, who also joined our discussions on Spider-Man 3 and Venom. Roxy is, unsurprisingly, a huge fan of The Amazing Spider-Man 2 and points to the passionate chemistry between Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone as one of the main reasons the film deserves a Tomatometer score much, much higher than its current 52%. Jacqueline, on the other hand, thinks “this movie is trash” — yikes — and Mark is stuck playing referee somewhere in the middle. Good luck, Mark!

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Neflix Premiere Dates X-Men Avengers boxoffice 79th Golden Globes Awards SXSW The Walt Disney Company Baby Yoda 71st Emmy Awards History E! Sci-Fi space posters royal family hispanic heritage month trailers vampires television Country franchise Crunchyroll Amazon Prime sopranos period drama Warner Bros. First Reviews Peacock book Logo toy story remakes godzilla Certified Fresh Chernobyl Drama Alien The Purge anthology Cartoon Network biopic Exclusive Video leaderboard New York Comic Con international Marvel Studios best Turner Classic Movies SundanceTV king arthur 2019 See It Skip It hollywood Reality Competition richard e. Grant Rom-Com Tags: Comedy spider-man rt labs critics edition talk show Character Guide Horror TCA 2017 Pet Sematary vs. NBC Hulu rotten MTV Comics on TV superhero YouTube criterion christmas movies festivals rt archives E3 ABC Britbox The Academy Emmys Rock joker festival Ghostbusters marvel cinematic universe AMC Plus dramedy stoner Teen TLC Mary Poppins Returns scene in color reboot cancelled TV series nbcuniversal Walt Disney Pictures child's play Fargo thriller facebook japanese aapi tv talk dark Ovation Universal GLAAD action-comedy 73rd Emmy Awards ABC Family historical drama Creative Arts Emmys Pixar Masterpiece breaking bad documentaries Awards Tour VICE Photos Writers Guild of America docudrama TCA Winter 2020 dexter boxing comics jamie lee curtis Quiz independent supernatural BET new star wars movies BBC America Disney streaming service werewolf blockbusters Grammys Music Comic-Con@Home 2021 asian-american crime Cosplay Fox News Western french anime heist movie green book Interview Animation Amazon Sundance Now Valentine's Day TruTV 20th Century Fox comiccon live action DC Universe canceled Winners series foreign crime thriller mission: impossible ghosts scary emmy awards legend golden globe awards comic italian Pop all-time cancelled TV shows Women's History Month BET Awards singing competition Columbia Pictures Showtime Fantasy Black Mirror rt labs theme song 2016 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina nfl TV Land adenture Disney sag awards Set visit Universal Pictures 2017 VH1 trophy cars Video Games 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Television Academy DC streaming service Epix new york Nickelodeon 4/20 Starz feel good Apple TV+ PaleyFest die hard Shudder finale Pacific Islander Spring TV king kong south america Martial Arts olympics Disney Plus football popular 2020 PlayStation satire movie NBA Binge Guide robots 90s cults TCM Hallmark obituary spider-verse Image Comics war hist The Walking Dead binge FX based on movie high school TNT HBO Go IFC CNN cats basketball Christmas YouTube Premium Reality Pop TV justice league FXX Captain marvel Elton John Comedy Central Mary Tyler Moore Schedule A24 elevated horror police drama Trailer Super Bowl Paramount Plus Star Wars BAFTA Academy Awards Prime Video Sony Pictures The Arrangement hispanic Netflix Christmas movies streaming toronto A&E Turner worst worst movies PBS 007 screen actors guild 99% fast and furious The CW President casting rom-coms kong universal monsters OWN new zealand laika First Look Sundance ID IMDb TV name the review TIFF Instagram Live Spectrum Originals Infographic golden globes 93rd Oscars comic books social media Film Crackle ABC Signature Action TV renewals true crime Winter TV young adult video revenge Song of Ice and Fire comic book movie biography spy thriller Fall TV Anna Paquin jurassic park twilight crime drama Polls and Games GIFs Hallmark Christmas movies TCA Awards Summer romance natural history Opinion ITV composers Cannes scorecard politics game show Lifetime Christmas movies Dark Horse Comics transformers mob target Travel Channel what to watch FOX free movies TCA Paramount Network prank genre Disney Channel TBS reviews Esquire Amazon Prime Video Box Office Calendar Tarantino Classic Film animated WGN TV One DC Comics razzies nature Shondaland ESPN Pirates Wes Anderson HBO ratings black comedy harry potter Lionsgate films doctor who Paramount art house scary movies Hollywood Foreign Press Association Marvel latino telelvision kaiju RT History NYCC USA Network Netflix cancelled television deadpool Discovery Channel Trivia AMC mcc dc know your critic Emmy Nominations Kids & Family lord of the rings Red Carpet renewed TV shows APB 24 frames Superheroe Disney+ Disney Plus Extras Ellie Kemper DirecTV spain Best and Worst Marvel Television spanish Bravo BBC One james bond FX on Hulu Black History Month YA indiana jones spinoff Television Critics Association SDCC Countdown technology Mary poppins critic resources Sundance TV discovery Year in Review Trophy Talk Superheroes Mudbound RT21 Lucasfilm Awards directors slasher Freeform Vudu Legendary LGBT screenings teaser canceled TV shows psycho Rocketman 45 CMT Amazon Studios Marathons pirates of the caribbean hidden camera dceu romantic comedy Food Network spanish language Funimation monster movies political drama 1990s Rocky a nightmare on elm street Pride Month Mindy Kaling wonder woman sports unscripted indie travel Holidays Apple TV Plus serial killer Musicals chucky dreamworks marvel comics book adaptation cinemax comedies National Geographic psychological thriller saw blaxploitation Hear Us Out OneApp cancelled Tubi critics Acorn TV australia Nat Geo Brie Larson batman TV versus fresh Apple LGBTQ sitcom IFC Films cooking rotten movies we love cartoon Tumblr movies video on demand crossover comic book movies kids disaster zero dark thirty MCU Toys CBS miniseries Family Comic Book WarnerMedia CW Seed dogs quibi Broadway Biopics sequel superman El Rey news venice Stephen King San Diego Comic-Con award winner black diversity DGA ViacomCBS stand-up comedy Mystery witnail USA YouTube Red Nominations medical drama halloween suspense MSNBC parents streaming movies cops science fiction aliens docuseries debate Spike American Society of Cinematographers sequels Tomatazos stop motion archives documentary 2018 21st Century Fox GoT blockbuster concert HFPA Comedy Syfy HBO Max japan live event halloween tv TV movies Oscars Musical Adult Swim Fox Searchlight Watching Series VOD game of thrones zombies Sneak Peek Endgame Podcast Holiday adaptation The Witch gangster Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Tokyo Olympics Heroines slashers 72 Emmy Awards BBC mutant zombie mockumentary Election CBS All Access Star Trek Lifetime children's TV 2015 Arrowverse women Thanksgiving classics Film Festival adventure strong female leads 2021 dragons