RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Spider-Man 3

For the very first episode of our new podcast, Jacqueline Coley, Mark Ellis, and Roxy Striar swing into the Audience-Critic divide over Sam Raimi's bloated, ambitious, messy, and (maybe?) genius final Spider-Man flick.

by | September 17, 2020 | Comments

Spider-Man 3

(Photo by ©Sony Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection)

In 2007, Sam Raimi’s Certified Fresh run of Spidey movies came to an end with Spider-Man 3, the barely-Fresh and definitely bloated threequel that saw Tobey Maguire’s Peter Parker doing battle with not one, not two, but three villains – while the audience had to battle with a cinematic villain of their own, the jazz-loving Emo Peter.

Today, the movie is largely seen as a big misstep for all involved, the film that ended the Maguire Spider-Man era and precipitated the 2010s reboot franchise with Andrew Garfield. (See the 51% Audience Score, the lowest of any live-action Spider-Man movie.) But at the time of its release, critics were happy-ish with what they saw, with enough reviews tilting Fresh for the movie to be sitting at 63% on the Tomatometer.

Who’s right? Who’s wrong? And – we can’t stress this enough – what the hell was with that dance sequence?

Listen Now:  Spotify |  Apple Podcasts  |  Stitcher  |  TuneIn  |  Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

Spider-Man 3 is the subject of the first episode of our brand-new podcast series, Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast from Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline Coley and Mark Ellis and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

This week, swinging with them through the 2-hour-and-19–minute clash of awesome FX and bizarre soap that is Spider-Man 3, is pop-culture commentator and unabashed Spidey 3 fan girl Roxy Striar, who believes that, despite its flaws, the much-maligned film is Fresh AF; our hosts don’t quite see it that way. In this episode, the trio digs into how the glow of Spider-Man 2 might have boosted that score for Spider-Man 3, what went on off-screen that led to an all-in villain fest on-screen, and whether the movie holds up 13 years later in the wake of The Dark Knight trilogy and the MCU.

Is Rotten Tomatoes “wrong”? Tune in to find out and join the discussion.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

Tag Cloud

aliens hispanic heritage month ratings LGBT MSNBC documentary ABC Signature Television Critics Association Comedy BET Awards discovery based on movie documentaries dc versus reviews BET Marvel Tubi Acorn TV YouTube Red Tumblr comic book movie Star Trek Emmy Nominations YA Photos independent Podcast posters crime thriller Elton John Television Academy directors animated australia target Baby Yoda olympics First Look USA tv talk zombie golden globes festivals nbcuniversal sag awards hollywood Film Festival boxoffice live event Amazon Prime Walt Disney Pictures laika LGBTQ sopranos Freeform breaking bad IFC Films social media Neflix Election heist movie Hallmark DirecTV Crunchyroll mob police drama scary movies BAFTA Hallmark Christmas movies prank Disney+ Disney Plus black comedy wonder woman Quiz Women's History Month romantic comedy biopic Tomatazos dramedy 93rd Oscars latino Lifetime Christmas movies Trophy Talk king kong PBS blockbusters fast and furious criterion Red Carpet worst comiccon Binge Guide witnail parents ID franchise know your critic monster movies green book HBO Go Toys Universal children's TV 72 Emmy Awards rom-coms Set visit japan video Crackle Premiere Dates hist BBC America sitcom The Arrangement international Paramount Disney Plus TV movies spanish language Oscars Vudu Action Shudder talk show NBA dceu ABC PlayStation Hulu Calendar golden globe awards doctor who MCU 2017 Marathons teaser TCA Awards leaderboard lord of the rings revenge medical drama Showtime Esquire canceled TV shows VOD Countdown crime drama Amazon name the review cancelled TV series Fall TV game show Awards Pop godzilla Anna Paquin telelvision Apple TV Plus a nightmare on elm street black IMDb TV aapi Arrowverse ITV BBC TV One anime Paramount Plus trailers casting Cosplay worst movies stoner TCA 2017 nature high school Universal Pictures vampires Academy Awards supernatural GIFs universal monsters Turner Classic Movies Teen cats singing competition book MTV A24 kaiju mcc Apple TV+ 2021 FOX TBS screenings saw new star wars movies X-Men dark NBC 45 Winter TV Black History Month foreign rt labs critics edition space football GLAAD justice league CBS All Access batman richard e. Grant Endgame Musical History Adult Swim National Geographic Legendary Watching Series renewed TV shows science fiction hispanic all-time President venice pirates of the caribbean RT History political drama comic Lucasfilm Holiday 24 frames Grammys south america Alien Polls and Games Mudbound Valentine's Day Cartoon Network feel good binge child's play kong Mary Poppins Returns stand-up comedy spider-man cults Epix ESPN Emmys christmas movies Spike chucky young adult royal family Year in Review die hard italian Ellie Kemper indiana jones werewolf japanese AMC Plus New York Comic Con superhero Biopics TIFF streaming movies Amazon Studios 2015 robots Spectrum Originals GoT rt labs streaming SundanceTV scene in color A&E stop motion TV renewals TruTV toy story archives 4/20 Captain marvel Animation VH1 cancelled dogs psycho live action kids WGN Tokyo Olympics 2019 TV Best and Worst blockbuster FXX Travel Channel Disney The Witch free movies DC Comics elevated horror Broadway American Society of Cinematographers CNN Pacific Islander legend 20th Century Fox Mary poppins Character Guide Britbox Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt crossover diversity Syfy Superheroes Starz superman Nickelodeon cars 2018 serial killer zombies Netflix rt archives facebook Kids & Family toronto Peacock FX on Hulu Shondaland Star Wars Pirates Mary Tyler Moore TCM E! E3 jamie lee curtis spanish halloween james bond SDCC Horror sports YouTube Funimation Amazon Prime Video Disney Channel Hear Us Out WarnerMedia SXSW Interview technology thriller Comic-Con@Home 2021 Family DGA king arthur asian-american Avengers mutant FX Holidays 007 The Walt Disney Company theme song concert gangster docudrama dreamworks new york Rock Music travel Pixar YouTube Premium scary HBO 73rd Emmy Awards Nat Geo Black Mirror dragons cinemax Trivia nfl award winner fresh Heroines The Purge biography Food Network slasher Musicals BBC One scorecard Pop TV Tarantino Rocky Lifetime Spring TV CBS Sundance TV Marvel Television AMC festival emmy awards jurassic park news hidden camera First Reviews Ovation Fargo disaster Apple ABC Family Awards Tour art house twilight joker OneApp Western psychological thriller unscripted Dark Horse Comics 99% Pet Sematary OWN docuseries boxing films Rocketman Sneak Peek series book adaptation Fox News VICE adenture Reality Trailer indie critics Extras suspense basketball television canceled Exclusive Video 1990s Classic Film cancelled TV shows Sundance Now spy thriller spinoff composers comic books Writers Guild of America CMT action-comedy Reality Competition Infographic Christmas spain true crime Turner Fantasy Lionsgate Pride Month critic resources Superheroe french Sundance Opinion Mystery harry potter 21st Century Fox movie RT21 Fox Searchlight Columbia Pictures slashers 90s game of thrones remakes Comic Book Disney streaming service debate razzies crime satire Comics on TV Mindy Kaling rotten movies we love Thanksgiving 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The CW Warner Bros. Schedule 71st Emmy Awards CW Seed Stephen King romance movies Sci-Fi spider-verse adventure cooking Rom-Com historical drama adaptation rotten Ghostbusters Video Games trophy The Walking Dead cops El Rey classics Cannes Box Office finale 2016 video on demand Film ViacomCBS new zealand period drama Masterpiece TV Land Super Bowl cancelled television what to watch Instagram Live Song of Ice and Fire TCA Winter 2020 vs. Sony Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina mission: impossible politics reboot USA Network See It Skip It best DC Universe ghosts DC streaming service APB obituary comic book movies blaxploitation Logo sequels Wes Anderson Drama Winners HBO Max TNT San Diego Comic-Con cartoon marvel cinematic universe Nominations Country Creative Arts Emmys Bravo PaleyFest genre Discovery Channel deadpool Image Comics miniseries comics popular Comedy Central strong female leads NYCC transformers IFC sequel comedies Chernobyl zero dark thirty TLC screen actors guild Marvel Studios halloween tv Netflix Christmas movies anthology Brie Larson The Academy war Paramount Network TCA dexter marvel comics Martial Arts Certified Fresh women Summer mockumentary natural history quibi 2020