RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Spider-Man 3

For the very first episode of our new podcast, Jacqueline Coley, Mark Ellis, and Roxy Striar swing into the Audience-Critic divide over Sam Raimi's bloated, ambitious, messy, and (maybe?) genius final Spider-Man flick.

by | September 17, 2020 | Comments

Spider-Man 3

(Photo by ©Sony Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection)

In 2007, Sam Raimi’s Certified Fresh run of Spidey movies came to an end with Spider-Man 3, the barely-Fresh and definitely bloated threequel that saw Tobey Maguire’s Peter Parker doing battle with not one, not two, but three villains – while the audience had to battle with a cinematic villain of their own, the jazz-loving Emo Peter.

Today, the movie is largely seen as a big misstep for all involved, the film that ended the Maguire Spider-Man era and precipitated the 2010s reboot franchise with Andrew Garfield. (See the 51% Audience Score, the lowest of any live-action Spider-Man movie.) But at the time of its release, critics were happy-ish with what they saw, with enough reviews tilting Fresh for the movie to be sitting at 63% on the Tomatometer.

Who’s right? Who’s wrong? And – we can’t stress this enough – what the hell was with that dance sequence?

Listen Now:  Spotify |  Apple Podcasts  |  Stitcher  |  TuneIn  |  Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

Spider-Man 3 is the subject of the first episode of our brand-new podcast series, Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast from Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline Coley and Mark Ellis and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

This week, swinging with them through the 2-hour-and-19–minute clash of awesome FX and bizarre soap that is Spider-Man 3, is pop-culture commentator and unabashed Spidey 3 fan girl Roxy Striar, who believes that, despite its flaws, the much-maligned film is Fresh AF; our hosts don’t quite see it that way. In this episode, the trio digs into how the glow of Spider-Man 2 might have boosted that score for Spider-Man 3, what went on off-screen that led to an all-in villain fest on-screen, and whether the movie holds up 13 years later in the wake of The Dark Knight trilogy and the MCU.

Is Rotten Tomatoes “wrong”? Tune in to find out and join the discussion.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

Tag Cloud

Bravo 2017 blockbuster Song of Ice and Fire E3 supernatural Netflix Christmas movies The Walt Disney Company Fox News Writers Guild of America classics asian-american PaleyFest Holiday fast and furious Lifetime Christmas movies game of thrones book Anna Paquin police drama doctor who chucky comics crime drama Extras Disney Channel canceled TV shows cancelled TV shows Tumblr anthology rt archives Infographic travel Superheroe Sci-Fi BET razzies period drama Freeform comedies anime Dark Horse Comics DirecTV Kids & Family Comics on TV Valentine's Day children's TV biography Disney Plus CBS All Access critics dceu cancelled TV series social media Mary poppins HBO Max Logo ID Disney streaming service festivals mutant Lionsgate USA Alien Certified Fresh Hallmark Christmas movies cooking A24 directors 2015 Apple festival golden globes TNT 99% Showtime SDCC ViacomCBS zero dark thirty Quiz elevated horror latino adventure YA franchise DC Comics SXSW space quibi breaking bad The Purge hidden camera serial killer GoT Pirates Sundance Now Marathons television prank romantic comedy Ovation 45 LGBT Trailer Rocketman toy story Pet Sematary Endgame thriller Crackle sequel documentaries docudrama award winner Pop TV Lifetime war Funimation romance TruTV talk show Awards Star Trek football crime thriller Comic Book Trophy Talk venice Classic Film video on demand SundanceTV Pop The CW indiana jones richard e. Grant jamie lee curtis Emmys comiccon BBC One docuseries films Fox Searchlight USA Network RT21 cars documentary scary movies ABC Signature 20th Century Fox YouTube Premium cartoon Action Reality italian Syfy die hard Cosplay hispanic Vudu Martial Arts Nominations stop motion Rock remakes Spike halloween tv Tomatazos disaster news kaiju Musical X-Men south america robots Legendary Christmas OWN Sneak Peek ESPN popular medical drama renewed TV shows Drama Paramount Network twilight A&E james bond Marvel Television animated Sundance TV DC streaming service Lucasfilm Cannes joker 4/20 Premiere Dates Mary Poppins Returns TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina best worst Oscars child's play sitcom singing competition Comedy Sony Pictures Ellie Kemper halloween Comedy Central IFC science fiction reboot superhero TV renewals Baby Yoda hollywood finale screenings french Mary Tyler Moore cats foreign Superheroes President Amazon Prime ghosts Set visit cancelled name the review 007 TCM Starz GIFs mission: impossible movies YouTube Photos strong female leads Spectrum Originals FX MSNBC TCA boxoffice The Witch Epix APB San Diego Comic-Con ITV stoner Schedule batman king kong Universal Countdown Marvel Studios Rom-Com New York Comic Con Super Bowl Television Critics Association criterion blockbusters series rotten movies we love hist American Society of Cinematographers TBS The Walking Dead E! political drama jurassic park Polls and Games superman Character Guide zombies spain parents YouTube Red women stand-up comedy TCA 2017 spider-man Disney TLC DC Universe Winners Academy Awards Turner Classic Movies screen actors guild Film Festival facebook Britbox MCU Pixar godzilla Nickelodeon IFC Films scorecard based on movie Fantasy Winter TV MTV diversity Country fresh Pride Month Holidays golden globe awards cinemax trailers justice league VICE Warner Bros. pirates of the caribbean a nightmare on elm street Avengers dramedy 2020 Best and Worst Heroines OneApp toronto AMC Turner Chernobyl composers streaming CNN Election Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Awards Tour historical drama Calendar VH1 Amazon Studios Captain marvel Peacock harry potter Reality Competition comic zombie TIFF deadpool archives spanish dogs politics NBC Stephen King 24 frames kids TV Land Binge Guide nbcuniversal slashers RT History NYCC Emmy Nominations transformers canceled Opinion Thanksgiving nature Paramount CBS Hulu BAFTA CW Seed Summer Ghostbusters Star Wars japanese Apple TV+ Grammys binge boxing CMT indie Toys spinoff dragons 71st Emmy Awards Amazon Prime Video kong Amazon unscripted tv talk Western Walt Disney Pictures black blaxploitation worst movies spanish language Paramount Plus 2016 cancelled television See It Skip It 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Animation VOD werewolf Spring TV Musicals Food Network TCA Awards universal monsters Hear Us Out FOX monster movies mockumentary 21st Century Fox Sundance adaptation Apple TV Plus independent Film 2018 Disney+ Disney Plus Shondaland Music WGN vampires Trivia rom-coms Esquire BET Awards psychological thriller Exclusive Video cops witnail The Academy free movies cults true crime PBS Mindy Kaling dc game show Mystery versus revenge sports theme song Discovery Channel aliens Podcast emmy awards Women's History Month Netflix discovery HBO Go christmas movies comic books Cartoon Network PlayStation Red Carpet The Arrangement Marvel Broadway Brie Larson Year in Review Watching Series Travel Channel Arrowverse LGBTQ Interview Biopics 2019 DGA Fall TV Hallmark Television Academy teaser Acorn TV natural history nfl Adult Swim laika crossover ABC Family satire El Rey sag awards FX on Hulu Black Mirror Mudbound TV One concert rotten Box Office BBC America psycho ratings obituary ABC telelvision Teen crime casting Horror Nat Geo technology 2021 Creative Arts Emmys Black History Month sequels First Reviews australia TCA Winter 2020 Crunchyroll FXX WarnerMedia Tubi 72 Emmy Awards First Look video National Geographic dark Columbia Pictures Elton John movie Shudder all-time BBC what to watch Rocky Family spy thriller Tarantino Masterpiece Video Games HBO reviews History green book GLAAD miniseries