RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Transformers

Is there more than meets the eye to Michael Bay's explosive action blockbuster, or is it a prime example of the director's most excessive instincts?

by | February 17, 2022 | Comments

Transformers (2007)

(Photo by ©Paramount Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

For a certain segment of the moviegoing population, Michael Bay’s 2007 blockbuster Transformers was their introduction to the world of the shapeshifting robots known as Autobots and Decepticons. For a certain older generation of fans, however, it was an exciting moment of childhood wish fulfillment, an opportunity to see their beloved robots in disguise on the big screen in “live action.” When the film finally released, it topped its opening weekend en route to earning over $700 million at the global box office, but it largely failed to impress the critics.


Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19


Of course, Bay, who had already done The RockArmageddon, and a pair of Bad Boys movies up to that point, had built a reputation for larger-than-life action cinema, so in some sense, he was a great fit for the material. Plus, visual effects had come such a long way by 2007 that folks were eager to see how well the previously 2D-animated Optimus Prime and Megatron would translate to a live-action film with a $150 million budget.

And what was the end result? It kind of depends on who you ask. Transformers is just shy of Fresh at 58% on the Tomatometer, which means that, technically speaking, a small majority of the critics who saw the movie thought it was a good effort. Some of them thought the film was a breathtaking action spectacle populated by likable performances, even if the story felt a little thin. Others thought the big set pieces were choppy and incoherent, and the choice to focus primarily on the human characters more so than the robots was baffling.

Also depending on who you ask, those human characters either helped anchor the film with hilarious, relatable performances, or they ruined it by distracting from the main attraction and taking an obnoxious kitchen-sink approach to comic relief. Shia LaBeouf is either a jittery “crackhead dialed up to four” of a protagonist, or he’s a perfect audience surrogate, and yes, it’s nice that Megan Fox is more than just a damsel in distress, but her gearhead Mikaela Barnes is consistently shot as if she’s the eye candy in a hypersexualized music video.

In contrast to the Tomatomter, the Audience Score sits at a staggeringly healthy 85%, so what’s with the discrepancy? Much to the chagrin of some movie fans who love to roll their eyes at any mention of the director, there are certainly plenty of Michael Bay apologists out there. The man loves his explosions and spinning cameras, sure, but he also knows his way around complicated visual effects and compelling action set pieces. At the end of the day, Transformers remains his second-best-reviewed film behind The Rock, and both are tied for his highest Audience Score.

But there are absolutely fans from that older generation, the one that grew up watching the after-school cartoons in the 1980s, who bristled at the dramatically altered character designs (Optimus Prime has lips? Bumblebee is a Camaro?) and bizarre character choices (we need to talk about Jazz). What we’re trying to say here is that people have feelings about this movie, which makes it kind of perfect for us to talk about.

Joining regular co-hosts Jacqueline Coley and Mark Ellis this week are two guests who have appeared separately before but never together, and we’re so glad they could both join: Jay Washington and Winston A. Marshall of Blerds N the Hood. Jay, who grew up with the original series and even recently rewatched it, remembers going into Michael Bay’s film excited and coming out so angry he wanted to “fight people, just because” – he thinks Transformers’ Tomatometer should be lower. Winston, on the other hand, thinks 58% is about right; Mark is willing to go Fresh on it, and Jacqueline? Well, she’s the biggest fan of them all, and she thinks it might have something to do with the fact that she had no emotional attachment to the characters before she saw the film. She might not be far off on that point.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”


Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:


If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.


Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Tag Cloud

RT History Apple rt labs psychological thriller The Purge WarnerMedia screenings what to watch Prime Video ESPN genre news halloween tv BBC Bravo concert First Look Amazon Prime comics franchise Lifetime Christmas movies Song of Ice and Fire dogs crime thriller Rom-Com anthology criterion game show wonder woman psycho LGBT Television Academy Turner Disney Channel Elton John nature debate ghosts CMT Character Guide toronto japanese cops Countdown Summer TruTV Podcast summer TV preview slasher cinemax TV Land Best and Worst Toys toy story true crime posters Sundance Winter TV MGM stop motion Arrowverse TNT reboot IFC Films Ellie Kemper spanish trophy Star Wars Fall TV new zealand DirecTV Superheroes video on demand Women's History Month Polls and Games Thanksgiving DGA SundanceTV tv talk mockumentary based on movie hispanic heritage month TV renewals AMC Plus zombies die hard venice Hulu Apple TV+ YouTube Red Instagram Live Netflix Christmas movies Starz black The Academy fresh spider-verse sopranos Holidays elevated horror USA rom-coms movies PaleyFest Paramount Plus HBO Go dramedy Discovery Channel CBS Walt Disney Pictures stoner VICE 20th Century Fox comic book movies marvel comics Hallmark Christmas movies Britbox VOD comic book movie HFPA monster movies BAFTA Awards Tour christmas movies Holiday chucky Amazon Superheroe Photos Mary poppins king arthur series Rocky Pacific Islander scary movies cancelled TV shows PlayStation blockbuster American Society of Cinematographers discovery Hallmark Brie Larson latino Cannes YouTube Premium Disney+ Disney Plus marvel cinematic universe classics Reality Competition prank romance Drama Quiz Sony Pictures SXSW Valentine's Day obi wan Disney Spike HBO live action vampires Shondaland Watching Series quibi scene in color sports Sneak Peek casting historical drama Showtime james bond game of thrones 2016 kaiju History aliens nbcuniversal Best Picture rotten movies we love politics sequel TV movies Calendar emmy awards jamie lee curtis Trailer 2015 feel good OneApp indiana jones adaptation political drama breaking bad dceu Year in Review richard e. Grant Creative Arts Emmys Shudder suspense USA Network cats Anna Paquin facebook 99% doctor who scorecard legend stand-up comedy spain Rock ABC Family cartoon Image Comics Awards Action cancelled international dark 2021 Comic-Con@Home 2021 adenture Cosplay films Amazon Studios dexter docudrama italian Music 007 unscripted directors golden globe awards MSNBC spanish language NBA french Paramount Network vs. crime art house Columbia Pictures Cartoon Network Election thriller canceled TV shows justice league Chernobyl worst movies travel south america Amazon Prime Video comiccon AMC IFC The Arrangement mcc Tarantino laika universal monsters documentaries 73rd Emmy Awards Universal Kids & Family finale Super Bowl golden globes crime drama Paramount National Geographic Star Trek Dark Horse Comics young adult MTV satire Black History Month El Rey The CW Exclusive Video rotten Film 94th Oscars ABC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Country parents Mary Poppins Returns know your critic IMDb TV Academy Awards royal family Sci-Fi composers zombie Crackle remakes PBS President Comedy Central Turner Classic Movies women 79th Golden Globes Awards CW Seed hist period drama slashers First Reviews technology TCA Winter 2020 Horror blockbusters nfl twilight Disney streaming service Hear Us Out binge hispanic Pet Sematary video animated scary Stephen King Fox News Film Festival Emmy Nominations strong female leads Mystery 2017 hollywood Spectrum Originals WGN singing competition anime Broadway YouTube sag awards Peacock adventure Oscars Apple TV Plus cancelled television YA supernatural BBC America blaxploitation Family E3 television godzilla independent free movies Pirates Vudu FX on Hulu critic resources GIFs Tumblr FXX docuseries sequels telelvision Logo miniseries festivals 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards all-time Premiere Dates 21st Century Fox renewed TV shows CBS All Access talk show Esquire Pride Month festival NYCC Television Critics Association medical drama target LGBTQ Masterpiece book adaptation japan australia police drama Warner Bros. NBC children's TV SDCC Red Carpet Marvel Television 24 frames Endgame Ghostbusters A&E FOX See It Skip It streamig Nat Geo comic Freeform Sundance Now rt archives critics ID Wes Anderson Rocketman Marathons Nickelodeon green book Avengers hidden camera dreamworks Sundance TV Opinion Trophy Talk archives Infographic indie Lifetime saw Syfy kong live event worst 93rd Oscars ITV jurassic park Schedule Nominations 72 Emmy Awards canceled BET biopic A24 New York Comic Con asian-american razzies 2020 joker aapi streaming movie DC Comics Fantasy Crunchyroll witnail black comedy spinoff sitcom versus Spring TV Tubi mob Heroines Tokyo Olympics streaming movies GLAAD fast and furious South by Southwest Film Festival TCM best Fargo dragons space olympics mutant heist movie dc batman reviews cancelled TV series kids Mary Tyler Moore Marvel high school Teen natural history ABC Signature new star wars movies Reality boxing comic books gangster RT21 Western Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Box Office Musicals book VH1 Pixar theme song The Walt Disney Company obituary Legendary DC streaming service popular BBC One cults Christmas summer TV Funimation The Walking Dead APB Trivia Food Network Video Games TCA 2017 Mudbound Hollywood Foreign Press Association diversity Alien The Witch 71st Emmy Awards crossover superman Animation MCU TLC Musical Comics on TV BET Awards TCA Awards Adult Swim Oscar DC Universe Disney Plus Pop Grammys revenge screen actors guild Fox Searchlight Emmys mission: impossible documentary comedies Travel Channel FX child's play robots a nightmare on elm street Set visit Winners leaderboard romantic comedy action-comedy king kong award winner basketball Certified Fresh spy thriller Neflix Mindy Kaling trailers Best Director new york pirates of the caribbean Ovation 2019 ratings cooking Netflix Tags: Comedy name the review serial killer rt labs critics edition Best Actor harry potter Biopics TV One San Diego Comic-Con teaser disaster Classic Film Writers Guild of America TIFF Universal Pictures 2018 Baby Yoda TBS transformers Epix Pop TV war Marvel Studios Comic Book 90s Interview Comedy lord of the rings 1990s GoT Tomatazos foreign social media Captain marvel TV Black Mirror summer preview Acorn TV 4/20 SXSW 2022 deadpool boxoffice 45 superhero ViacomCBS halloween Lionsgate E! HBO Max X-Men Lucasfilm science fiction cars Best Actress zero dark thirty werewolf biography football Martial Arts TCA Binge Guide OWN CNN Extras spider-man