RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... The Suicide Squad (2021)

Is James Gunn's take on the DC antiheroes the gory, irreverent remix we all needed or a barely better medley of things we've seen plenty of times before?

by | February 10, 2022 | Comments

Poster for The Suicide Squad

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

We’re not going to rehash the messy drama surrounding James Gunn’s temporary divorce from and eventual reconciliation with Marvel — this is not the place for that — but we can acknowledge that it offered just enough of a window for Warner Bros. and DC to snatch him up to redo a film they had just released a few years earlier. We’re also not going to rehash that earlier movie — this is the place for that, and we’ve already done it — but with the HBO spin-off series Peacemaker barreling towards its season finale, we thought it was a great time to talk about the movie that spawned it: last year’s The Suicide Squad.

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

At this point, it’s clear that 2015’s Suicide Squad suffered through its share of behind-the-scenes battles, but whatever the root causes were, most folks — critics and fans alike — simply did not care for the movie. So when Gunn, whose Troma-bred sensibilities helped make Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy a blockbuster success, was hired to take another crack at DC’s own gang of misfit antiheroes, fans were understandably excited.

By most accounts, that excitement was not misplaced. Gunn’s The Suicide Squad ended up with a Certified Fresh 90% on the Tomatometer and a much more fan-friendly 82% Audience Score. Compare that against the earlier film’s 26% Tomatometer and 59% Audience Score, and it’s clear not only that Gunn was a good fit for the material, but also that the studio finally learned the value of letting a crazy dude just do his thing.

But hey, we wouldn’t be here if everyone agreed, right? So are there folks out there who think the praise for the film is a little overblown? Are there those who didn’t think Gunn’s penchant for graphic violence and dick jokes made for particularly engaging entertainment? Are there those who just don’t get what all the hype was about?

Well, yes and no. Joining regular co-hosts Jacqueline Coley and Mark Ellis this week is Josh Tapia aka JTE, co-host of the Film Review Weekly podcast. He doesn’t think The Suicide Squad is a bad movie, per se — he still thinks it’s a good time, and the cast is great — but when he came out of the theater, he found it a little difficult to understand why everyone around him was so excited about it. He wonders if maybe letting Gunn run wild isn’t the best idea, and maybe the PG-13 limitations of the MCU force him to be more creative with his humor. Maybe fans were just so disappointed by the earlier film that they were hungry for anything better, even if it was only marginally so. Then again, maybe The Suicide Squad really is just a damn good time at the movies.

Jacqueline tends to agree with Josh; she thinks the film’s 90% Tomatometer score is “a little strong.” But she also acknowledges and appreciates the film’s homages to 1970s exploitation films and still thinks it’s a fun film overall. Mark is much more generous here, calling the film James Gunn’s “crazy weekend in Vegas” before he returns home to the much more family friendly trappings of the MCU.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

RT21 Oscars HBO Go TCA razzies award winner vampires Comedy Alien AMC Plus Avengers Television Critics Association Fox Searchlight Travel Channel prank satire Epix Superheroe critic resources Quiz Hollywood Foreign Press Association rotten slashers Character Guide fast and furious witnail crime Disney streaming service A&E serial killer 1990s series OneApp directors E! hispanic biopic Film Festival Ovation Disney disaster know your critic versus anthology singing competition black comedy revenge discovery VOD miniseries Crackle Spring TV Summer SXSW 2022 Mudbound police drama Red Carpet YouTube Premium Apple streamig 4/20 Kids & Family Shudder japanese Black History Month Sundance screenings docuseries gangster First Reviews documentaries Podcast worst stoner batman video on demand werewolf dceu Thanksgiving comic book movie TCA 2017 robots 99% Superheroes women GLAAD video politics harry potter comiccon OWN 72 Emmy Awards cults CBS cancelled television Mystery FOX international leaderboard NYCC crossover Discovery Channel New York Comic Con renewed TV shows Elton John Awards Tour art house Hallmark Christmas movies RT History 2017 Paramount kaiju TIFF reboot scene in color Captain marvel mission: impossible Britbox Lifetime Christmas movies Pride Month Ghostbusters 94th Oscars dogs SundanceTV trophy comic Action Best Actor Tumblr Turner thriller Tokyo Olympics book adaptation Pirates what to watch comic book movies USA zombie action-comedy finale transformers Teen ESPN fresh YouTube Red Hallmark worst movies Logo Pacific Islander Horror 73rd Emmy Awards book The Walking Dead Spike football doctor who Animation toronto Comic Book mob Peacock Nickelodeon BET Awards Sony Pictures a nightmare on elm street Super Bowl Chilling Adventures of Sabrina richard e. Grant 20th Century Fox legend romantic comedy jamie lee curtis Apple TV Plus canceled Netflix streaming movies 90s aapi kids spanish language teaser ABC Signature spain GoT news political drama adventure Ellie Kemper ABC Family Fargo 2018 game show CMT Pet Sematary slasher Sundance TV Tarantino Turner Classic Movies MCU DC Comics cops Valentine's Day feel good black Amazon National Geographic South by Southwest Film Festival USA Network Election Comic-Con@Home 2021 Paramount Network Video Games Best Director 2019 new zealand Trailer cats marvel cinematic universe canceled TV shows Neflix Arrowverse king arthur Rom-Com Lifetime CW Seed The CW elevated horror Mindy Kaling crime drama king kong franchise Photos BBC One Heroines ID technology Stephen King royal family IFC Films vs. comics 2021 festivals Winter TV aliens Best Actress Esquire Funimation Tubi FXX mockumentary TNT concert MSNBC Endgame binge Film rom-coms Netflix Christmas movies summer preview stop motion 93rd Oscars Winners BET justice league medical drama Amazon Prime Video quibi Legendary Lucasfilm PlayStation PaleyFest scorecard BBC El Rey Marathons facebook Brie Larson blockbusters GIFs History LGBT halloween tv popular romance YouTube Countdown Universal Pictures psycho spanish dramedy rotten movies we love The Walt Disney Company spinoff cars TBS YA scary true crime Star Wars Prime Video rt labs critics edition FX james bond 2016 71st Emmy Awards TV Drama genre Premiere Dates ITV Cosplay dreamworks Opinion Set visit basketball cartoon Holiday Spectrum Originals young adult ratings Best and Worst die hard Women's History Month NBC Infographic X-Men green book The Purge Apple TV+ Martial Arts TV One 24 frames talk show Acorn TV The Arrangement Cannes Song of Ice and Fire zero dark thirty 79th Golden Globes Awards chucky Amazon Prime travel Writers Guild of America Year in Review TCA Winter 2020 christmas movies VICE foreign indie HBO movies Mary Tyler Moore south america all-time HBO Max superhero Cartoon Network child's play godzilla IMDb TV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards comic books Black Mirror docudrama classics dragons comedies space Fall TV independent Emmy Nominations TLC spider-verse Showtime remakes stand-up comedy critics wonder woman Pop halloween ghosts boxing 007 period drama Broadway toy story Creative Arts Emmys summer TV superman telelvision spy thriller Mary poppins trailers Rocketman Dark Horse Comics anime Wes Anderson Christmas posters Columbia Pictures Nominations The Academy rt labs obituary twilight Bravo animated Country dark CBS All Access Rocky PBS cinemax Biopics rt archives pirates of the caribbean diversity Mary Poppins Returns Grammys Classic Film Pop TV social media Universal Academy Awards Starz President biography hist based on movie Musicals Paramount Plus casting cooking venice saw emmy awards Oscar Interview new york jurassic park DC Universe movie natural history hispanic heritage month latino Awards Exclusive Video sequel SDCC Holidays Crunchyroll Music Western boxoffice Sci-Fi Extras Sneak Peek Reality See It Skip It Warner Bros. Schedule MTV 2015 monster movies Toys ABC high school Marvel Television Amazon Studios game of thrones Best Picture ViacomCBS festival BAFTA target japan reviews Emmys blockbuster TCM Masterpiece TV renewals Marvel Studios theme song Trivia archives TCA Awards suspense TV Land A24 dexter 2020 E3 American Society of Cinematographers tv talk nbcuniversal Disney Plus CNN Shondaland Watching Series sopranos LGBTQ olympics Tags: Comedy sag awards adenture IFC zombies television asian-american indiana jones First Look mcc screen actors guild nfl heist movie adaptation golden globe awards australia Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt mutant golden globes HFPA WGN VH1 Chernobyl cancelled TV series Reality Competition Freeform Adult Swim free movies cancelled TV shows Vudu Walt Disney Pictures Fox News Instagram Live war San Diego Comic-Con Pixar Binge Guide Comedy Central lord of the rings DGA DirecTV best live event films AMC cancelled live action sitcom Hear Us Out new star wars movies Trophy Talk composers Image Comics BBC America hidden camera laika Tomatazos summer TV preview MGM Musical Rock Marvel Disney Channel Food Network breaking bad nature Hulu name the review universal monsters sports FX on Hulu Nat Geo APB strong female leads Polls and Games streaming 21st Century Fox criterion hollywood Television Academy Anna Paquin TruTV parents psychological thriller debate historical drama WarnerMedia TV movies scary movies sequels obi wan Comics on TV blaxploitation children's TV The Witch italian crime thriller Sundance Now supernatural marvel comics DC streaming service 45 Fantasy Star Trek Certified Fresh SXSW Family french joker documentary Calendar kong NBA Syfy Lionsgate spider-man science fiction deadpool unscripted Box Office dc Disney+ Disney Plus Baby Yoda