RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Fifty Shades of Grey

Romance is in the air... or is that the smell of leather? We look back at the infamous erotic drama to decide if it's truly hot and steamy or just a hot, steaming pile.

by | February 3, 2022 | Comments

Dakota Johnson and Jamie Dornan on the poster for Fifty Shades of Grey

(Photo by ©Focus Features)

We’ve had erotic dramas that skirt the edges of propriety for as long as we’ve had motion pictures, but rarely do any of them earn the kind of fanfare and mainstream attention that 2015’s Fifty Shades of Grey attracted. They also typically aren’t based on steamy fan fiction inspired by a series of young adult novels about sparkly vampires.


Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19


If you were somehow unaware, you read that right. A British woman named Erika Mitchell became so obsessed with the Twilight films and books that she wrote her own sequel, which eventually morphed into the self-published novel that then became the feature film about a naive coed who enters into a sadomasochistic relationship with a handsome billionaire.

Mitchell, who initially published under the pen name “Snowqueens Icedragon” before settling on the much more respectable E.L. James, admitted that the Fifty Shades books contained “all my fantasies” and were her “mid-life crisis, writ large,” but the success of the series — both the books and the films — would imply that she was absolutely not alone. The first book has been translated into 52 languages and has sold more than 150 million copies worldwide, and the film adaptation earned over half a billion dollars at the global box office.

As far as the critics were concerned, well, the film (and the book, for that matter) failed to set their hearts aflutter. Fifty Shades of Grey sits at 25% on the Tomatometer (even Twilight at least notched a 49%) with a  higher but not particularly impressive Audience Score of 41%. Looking at its box office haul, whoever was into this movie was really into this movie.

But is there anything to this film beyond its promise of titillation and wish fulfillment fantasies? Were the charms of Jamie Dornan and the guileless depth of Dakota Johnson enough to overcome the inherent silliness of the story? Is it an unexpectedly entertaining and competently filmed if somewhat campy exploration of power dynamics in contemporary relationships? Is it, in fact, more than just mommy porn for dirty housewives, or are its fans just gluttons for punishment?

As a rare treat, regular co-hosts Jacqueline Coley and Mark Ellis do not have a guest with whom to whip these questions around. No, this week, it’s all about the symbiotic, loving, and mutually respectful relationship between Jacqueline and Mark, as they discuss the runaway success of the film, the little things it actually got right, and why, as Jacqueline would have it, it should be Fresh.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”


Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:


If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.


Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Tag Cloud

target directors Emmys Musicals Hallmark Christmas movies superhero south america TLC YA godzilla DirecTV police drama nbcuniversal halloween tv TV renewals Kids & Family PaleyFest Stephen King olympics medical drama rom-coms USA mockumentary black GoT hist cops Rocky TCA Winter 2020 HBO free movies spain Mudbound rt labs trailers 24 frames mcc Martial Arts Alien HBO Go vs. game of thrones discovery obi wan A&E Amazon Paramount Plus best OneApp Marvel Studios Film RT History casting live action lord of the rings Legendary documentaries VH1 SXSW Women's History Month Holidays hollywood tv talk Western comics Food Network Super Bowl Election deadpool dexter Action Showtime Heroines slashers Year in Review green book APB Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt AMC FX on Hulu witnail anthology Marvel die hard franchise Winners scorecard name the review 21st Century Fox Disney Comedy Central The Walt Disney Company doctor who vampires Amazon Prime ratings TCA Awards sitcom japan Comic Book Infographic RT21 VICE worst movies 2018 transformers 4/20 Emmy Nominations Universal pirates of the caribbean travel sopranos Fox Searchlight new star wars movies TIFF superman Writers Guild of America Dark Horse Comics action-comedy CBS All Access Best Picture IFC Films MTV Adult Swim 93rd Oscars Comic-Con@Home 2021 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Calendar singing competition disaster Netflix sequel serial killer Bravo BET nature zombie Cosplay Logo debate crossover HFPA crime thriller Pop Crackle GIFs Binge Guide dc popular video on demand President streaming Toys social media Apple FX period drama worst aapi Disney streaming service WarnerMedia crime Freeform Wes Anderson Black Mirror Marathons DC Comics Tags: Comedy rotten movies we love comic book movies strong female leads dreamworks Television Academy summer preview festival politics MSNBC Creative Arts Emmys marvel comics scary blaxploitation hidden camera golden globes international space Hallmark Captain marvel 2019 Summer children's TV 2016 HBO Max Columbia Pictures Mary Tyler Moore technology VOD Mary poppins Chilling Adventures of Sabrina marvel cinematic universe San Diego Comic-Con screenings Tumblr TV movies Lionsgate Interview jamie lee curtis canceled YouTube Red Pirates live event Spring TV Nickelodeon adventure 2021 Spectrum Originals Mystery robots toronto Star Trek SXSW 2022 stop motion Fox News See It Skip It spy thriller kong critics cartoon BBC America Superheroes Country Thanksgiving South by Southwest Film Festival films christmas movies binge WGN SundanceTV indie Pet Sematary Horror Premiere Dates high school Fall TV New York Comic Con Ovation facebook E3 The Walking Dead dragons Photos Rock young adult sports Pixar Countdown Exclusive Video parents Image Comics Disney Channel Biopics indiana jones stoner summer TV preview TCM TruTV biopic Marvel Television The CW ghosts renewed TV shows cinemax james bond anime obituary Comics on TV ID IMDb TV Nat Geo Peacock The Purge MCU TNT 2015 versus ITV Trophy Talk toy story AMC Plus Sci-Fi docuseries suspense Ellie Kemper royal family basketball 94th Oscars Universal Pictures legend Broadway black comedy streaming movies streamig DC Universe jurassic park boxing new york Tarantino Lucasfilm aliens Television Critics Association composers movies MGM concert cancelled X-Men Funimation based on movie Polls and Games king arthur Paramount E! 007 Oscar Pride Month Set visit Endgame stand-up comedy miniseries criterion french dceu Sony Pictures psycho Crunchyroll Acorn TV movie Hulu scene in color book adaptation summer TV biography Schedule supernatural spanish series blockbusters chucky TCA 2017 genre women Turner Comedy YouTube Premium Apple TV+ Shudder Best Actor political drama Quiz twilight 20th Century Fox History slasher documentary CW Seed 2020 Nominations TV Land Apple TV Plus zero dark thirty Family rotten Awards Tour cancelled TV shows DC streaming service Brie Larson video war 1990s mutant Pacific Islander Fantasy Black History Month satire Anna Paquin Prime Video Red Carpet screen actors guild Rom-Com elevated horror italian Film Festival GLAAD mob comic books El Rey spanish language Pop TV adaptation prank hispanic heritage month cooking Esquire ABC Walt Disney Pictures romance crime drama diversity leaderboard cars justice league saw Awards Extras independent PBS BET Awards Cartoon Network American Society of Cinematographers Holiday batman Neflix foreign docudrama Classic Film Fargo television Amazon Studios Mindy Kaling Video Games Watching Series spider-man NBC comic Ghostbusters Reality breaking bad Trailer Superheroe heist movie Reality Competition Certified Fresh The Academy The Arrangement sequels Tubi telelvision Britbox archives cults ViacomCBS Hear Us Out book posters science fiction razzies Baby Yoda SDCC finale unscripted Travel Channel cats talk show news Music historical drama ABC Family Sundance Academy Awards Tokyo Olympics fast and furious Sneak Peek ESPN critic resources laika revenge art house child's play Epix Teen comiccon award winner Syfy teaser comedies wonder woman ABC Signature PlayStation TBS thriller kaiju harry potter true crime gangster trophy king kong rt labs critics edition First Look Masterpiece mission: impossible Best Director Opinion Musical Spike Starz Star Wars Best Actress The Witch 72 Emmy Awards Valentine's Day Sundance Now Discovery Channel TV One nfl Shondaland all-time Elton John monster movies rt archives asian-american NBA venice Oscars FOX animated werewolf quibi YouTube richard e. Grant dark BAFTA new zealand cancelled TV series A24 hispanic australia Lifetime Sundance TV Warner Bros. japanese Paramount Network Grammys psychological thriller Netflix Christmas movies 45 football Podcast Tomatazos joker LGBTQ Disney Plus OWN universal monsters Turner Classic Movies Character Guide Amazon Prime Video BBC comic book movie feel good FXX cancelled television Vudu 73rd Emmy Awards 90s kids National Geographic remakes romantic comedy Rocketman classics Arrowverse BBC One USA Network a nightmare on elm street theme song festivals First Reviews TCA CMT spider-verse Cannes Animation CBS 2017 Best and Worst NYCC Avengers Lifetime Christmas movies canceled TV shows latino Disney+ Disney Plus Christmas spinoff DGA Hollywood Foreign Press Association golden globe awards game show dramedy Winter TV halloween what to watch 79th Golden Globes Awards dogs Instagram Live sag awards reviews Chernobyl adenture IFC natural history LGBT Drama Trivia fresh blockbuster 99% zombies 71st Emmy Awards know your critic emmy awards Mary Poppins Returns boxoffice Song of Ice and Fire TV CNN Box Office reboot scary movies