RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Annie (1982)

As we approach its 40th anniversary, we reexamine the musical adaptation to determine if the little orphan deserved such a hard knock life after all.

by | April 23, 2022 | Comments

Poster image for Annie (1982)

(Photo by ©Columbia Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

For folks of a certain age, the 1982 musical Annie is synonymous with childhood, right up there with other formative films of the decade like E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial and The Goonies. At just 49% on the Tomatometer, though, it didn’t impress critics (or audiences, for that matter) nearly as much as the latter two, and as it prepares to celebrate its 40th anniversary with a screening at the TCM Classic Film Festival, we thought it was high time to give it another look.

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | StitcherTuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

It’s clear there is something about the story of little orphan Annie that resonates with audiences. It began as a poem written in 1885, which then inspired a long-running comic strip that began publication in 1924, which in turn eventually inspired a Broadway musical in 1977 that won an impressive seven Tony awards. The 1982 film adapts that musical for the big screen, but it was only the first; it was followed by a made-for-TV sequel in 1995, a made-for-TV remake in 1999, and yet another theatrical remake in 2014. That’s quite the journey.

But back to the 1982 film. The cast included such folks as Albert Finney as “Daddy” Warbucks, Carol Burnett as the cruel head of Annie’s orphanage, Tim Curry, Bernadette Peters, and a young Aileen Quinn, who beat 8,000 other girls to win the title role. On top of that, the man behind the camera? John Huston. Yes, the same John Huston who gave us The Maltese FalconThe Treasure of the Sierra MadreThe Asphalt Jungle, and The African Queen.

Critics were understandably puzzled by this late-career move, though Huston had expressed interest in directing a musical in the past. They felt that his sensibilities didn’t quite match the material at hand, and that the end result lost much of the charm of the musical, even if its production value was impressive. But is the film any better in retrospect?

A lot of folks seem to think so, at least judging by the 69% Audience Score. That’s not necessarily a ringing endorsement, but it’s a whole lot more generous than the critics were willing to be. Most of the praise is aimed squarely at Aileen Quinn herself, a beacon of boisterous energy in a surprisingly dark film, but there’s a lot of love for the musical numbers as well. Anyone who grew up in the 1980s (and even a lot of people who were born later) can recite the chorus of the show-stopping “Tomorrow” on cue.

Should Annie be relegated to the dusty annals of movie musical history, or is it a triumphant adaptation worth celebrating? Our guest this week has a lot to say on the matter: Alicia Malone is a TCM host who is taking her talents to the TCM Classic Film Festival from April 21-24, and she brings a lot of knowledge and historical context to the discussion. She saw the film as a child and admits she may be looking at it through rose-colored glasses, but still believes the Tomatometer is wrong. Mark is right on board with that take, noting that the film was also an integral part of his childhood, and while Jacqueline doesn’t think it deserves to be Rotten, she completely understands why. There are some problematic elements, and in her words, “The cheesy things about Broadway don’t work.”

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

CMT PlayStation FXX Nickelodeon 73rd Emmy Awards Comedy Central monster movies Dark Horse Comics book adaptation Endgame trailers Summer all-time PBS young adult Animation 21st Century Fox high school Crunchyroll marvel cinematic universe disaster romantic comedy Comic Book SundanceTV zero dark thirty PaleyFest TCA 2017 Character Guide football Tumblr nature Paramount Network The CW obituary First Reviews feel good OneApp kong 99% elevated horror Fall TV renewed TV shows Election 79th Golden Globes Awards Nat Geo Family breaking bad Musicals WGN green book Hear Us Out Set visit Sundance Now Marvel Studios Women's History Month sopranos Calendar Spectrum Originals Polls and Games Holidays Disney Plus Mary Tyler Moore strong female leads Awards king kong best boxoffice Cartoon Network serial killer independent Reality asian-american summer TV cancelled TV series The Purge GIFs ABC Family 2020 Country Winter TV TCM jurassic park black japanese ViacomCBS Pet Sematary action-comedy San Diego Comic-Con spy thriller summer preview Turner Starz NBC cancelled Apple TV Plus Mary Poppins Returns Mystery Captain marvel Best and Worst Premiere Dates Amazon Prime Video indiana jones politics reviews Quiz Superheroe Star Trek dragons 4/20 TBS Spring TV theme song sports BBC police drama french Best Actor child's play international witnail slasher Certified Fresh DC Universe Amazon Studios satire Travel Channel Fox News The Walking Dead 2017 zombie DC streaming service basketball Netflix Christmas movies 71st Emmy Awards scorecard true crime Prime Video NYCC Action Brie Larson free movies sag awards chucky HBO Max doctor who Rock anthology BBC One facebook singing competition Pixar streamig blockbuster The Arrangement nfl book X-Men Ellie Kemper Rocky Mindy Kaling TV LGBT king arthur Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Marathons Sneak Peek Lionsgate 2018 Ghostbusters A24 directors venice movies Mudbound TCA ratings Writers Guild of America Video Games Watching Series political drama DirecTV Box Office Disney streaming service Countdown Fox Searchlight Tubi Marvel scary movies NBA live action royal family Interview deadpool Image Comics superhero Cosplay lord of the rings rotten movies we love Podcast news cars festivals 72 Emmy Awards fresh unscripted popular Year in Review toronto target genre hollywood parents dreamworks National Geographic Rom-Com finale leaderboard TIFF 90s RT21 concert El Rey YouTube Holiday 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards VOD Vudu anime HBO Go BET Awards rt archives Shondaland foreign legend Infographic crime thriller adaptation Emmys dogs telelvision Logo APB Sci-Fi Martial Arts 20th Century Fox new york halloween hispanic Peacock A&E Alien spain thriller DC Comics sitcom Classic Film Star Wars TCA Awards Apple miniseries hidden camera stoner war MSNBC SXSW Amazon Prime blockbusters Chilling Adventures of Sabrina social media Super Bowl wonder woman what to watch toy story Hallmark mission: impossible Emmy Nominations summer TV preview mockumentary Nominations Universal dramedy black comedy FX on Hulu harry potter Black History Month Trophy Talk FOX james bond The Walt Disney Company Best Actress women rom-coms period drama History Cannes olympics spider-verse AMC revenge Spike transformers Biopics spider-man Christmas heist movie Ovation based on movie Best Picture obi wan mcc adenture USA space Acorn TV First Look Tags: Comedy Freeform See It Skip It dark 24 frames posters crossover remakes Columbia Pictures screen actors guild classics game of thrones hispanic heritage month President Syfy video cults nbcuniversal Showtime psycho Britbox australia razzies cinemax Hulu VH1 Thanksgiving adventure Song of Ice and Fire Exclusive Video BAFTA supernatural 94th Oscars Funimation Mary poppins discovery Binge Guide TV movies Fargo vampires Fantasy south america sequel MTV HBO Amazon Apple TV+ Neflix golden globes Food Network Elton John binge Musical GLAAD Photos Wes Anderson cats sequels children's TV robots criterion comic crime drama batman HFPA docudrama rt labs critics edition 2019 video on demand Lucasfilm Disney+ Disney Plus die hard medical drama The Academy streaming movies comic books Sundance ABC series Chernobyl ghosts ESPN Discovery Channel MCU biography Schedule debate worst BET Avengers Awards Tour IFC Films Broadway Film Festival scary Sundance TV Heroines movie Horror Black Mirror pirates of the caribbean teaser VICE Pop prank Turner Classic Movies travel superman USA Network Opinion blaxploitation Kids & Family Arrowverse Esquire streaming know your critic RT History Hallmark Christmas movies documentaries South by Southwest Film Festival docuseries American Society of Cinematographers marvel comics YouTube Premium Tomatazos spanish language comedies comics SDCC E! BBC America TNT christmas movies Baby Yoda YA composers films Trailer Reality Competition TV One hist Pirates halloween tv GoT suspense Lifetime Red Carpet 1990s werewolf biopic 45 Tarantino cancelled TV shows science fiction critic resources dexter screenings spinoff IFC Warner Bros. DGA Bravo New York Comic Con Pop TV CBS All Access Drama historical drama justice league japan award winner Pacific Islander cops Pride Month Oscar aapi OWN Film comiccon italian CBS CNN fast and furious cancelled television kids comic book movie Netflix jamie lee curtis new zealand Marvel Television new star wars movies versus talk show latino CW Seed Music Sony Pictures Universal Pictures boxing crime rt labs Comics on TV festival godzilla TLC reboot dceu richard e. Grant ID The Witch Academy Awards Legendary WarnerMedia television Television Academy canceled TV shows MGM saw Trivia zombies Grammys live event Tokyo Olympics canceled emmy awards diversity Paramount Walt Disney Pictures Winners Hollywood Foreign Press Association name the review Epix 2015 universal monsters Best Director Comic-Con@Home 2021 SXSW 2022 mutant Disney Anna Paquin Disney Channel scene in color Oscars Lifetime Christmas movies archives 2016 joker aliens stand-up comedy Instagram Live indie cooking 2021 rotten TV Land documentary cartoon Toys stop motion comic book movies laika tv talk ITV Crackle TruTV YouTube Red 93rd Oscars spanish Comedy Rocketman Shudder TV renewals casting psychological thriller a nightmare on elm street Extras animated Stephen King critics dc Masterpiece Paramount Plus technology art house Superheroes Adult Swim Western Creative Arts Emmys golden globe awards Teen quibi TCA Winter 2020 worst movies Television Critics Association ABC Signature LGBTQ trophy IMDb TV kaiju natural history game show 007 Valentine's Day romance twilight E3 slashers mob vs. franchise AMC Plus gangster FX