RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Bohemian Rhapsody

We decide if the killer Queen biopic that rocked the Oscars should remain a champion or bite the dust.

by | April 21, 2022 | Comments

Rami Malek as Freddie Mercury in Bohemian Rhapsody (2018)

(Photo by Nick Delaney/TM & copyright ©20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

Queen is unquestionably one of the most popular and influential rock bands of the last half century, if not all time, and a biographical film about their formation and the life of its lead singer Freddie Mercury in particular had been in serious development since at least 2010. But fraught with “creative differences” and turmoil behind the scenes, the film that would become Bohemian Rhapsody would take eight years to make. Was it worth the wait?

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | StitcherTuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

A lot — and we mean a lot — of people seemed to think so; the film’s impressive 85% Audience Score is proof enough of that. On top of that, though, not only was Bohemian Rhapsody a monumental box office success, racking up over $900 million worldwide, it also took home four Oscars at the 91st Academy Awards, more than any other film, including Alfonso Cuarón’s Roma, Marvel’s Black Panther, and Best Picture winner Green Book. (OK, so it wasn’t the most spectacular field of nominees.)

The critics weren’t quite as enthusiastic as the fans, unfortunately. Bohemian Rhapsody is just Frest at 60% on the Tomatometer, which, on paper, is a bit surprising for the most successful musical biopic ever. The movie won four Oscars, for crying out loud. Where’s the disconnect?

Well, about those Oscars… The one you’re likely to have heard about is the film’s win for Best Film Editing, which a lot of folks found downright puzzling, considering it was widely criticized as one of its most glaring issues and even inspired a video breakdown that went viral. Even John Ottman, the editor who won that award, went on record expressing deep regret about the scene that became the subject of that video.

But that wasn’t entirely Ottman’s fault. The aforementioned turmoil resulted in a new director (Dexter Fletcher) taking charge with only three weeks of filming left, among other things, and in one sense, Ottman deserves some credit for doing what he was able to do with what he was given. The other behind-the-scenes factor was twofold: Brian May and Roger Taylor, the two members of Queen who served as consultants and reportedly ensured the story was so sanitized that, to some, it felt inauthentic or, even worse, inaccurate. They were the reason the original star, Sacha Baron Cohen, who many believed to be pitch-perfect casting, opted to leave the project.

Speaking of which, when all was said and done, Rami Malek managed to acquit himself rather well in the lead, despite what many felt about the potential of Baron Cohen’s take on Freddie Mercury. He was one of the bright spots of the film, and he shone in the masterful climactic Live Aid sequence. For a whole lot of folks, that recreation of the iconic performance alone made Bohemian Rhapsody worth the price of admission.

So who’s right, and who’s wrong? Jacqueline is still recovering from awards season, so this week Mark brings on two guests to help suss it all out: regular RT and Fandango correspondent, pop culture commentator — and part-time rattlesnake wrangler — Nikki Novak; and Tomatometer-approved critic and host of Pay or Wait on YouTube, Sharronda Williams. Sharronda not only believes RT is wrong about Bohemian Rhapsody, but she feels the Tomatometer score is highly disrespectful and can’t comprehend why so many folks have it out for the movie. Nikki, on the other hand, advocates for two scores here: one for the first hour and 53 minutes, and another score for the final 13 minutes, because they feel like two vastly different movies.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Alien summer TV preview Women's History Month Pop TV adaptation satire cartoon The CW superman Spring TV comic book movie TIFF blockbuster godzilla true crime Thanksgiving james bond 20th Century Fox Lifetime Christmas movies VICE cats Television Academy Horror Anna Paquin Mary Poppins Returns scene in color Best Director canceled 007 Box Office PBS dragons TV Land Oscars revenge Emmy Nominations AMC Plus genre psychological thriller Video Games LGBTQ Fargo new york ITV Watching Series anthology Masterpiece Polls and Games Mary poppins live event Set visit 2020 screenings Sci-Fi 90s christmas movies CBS All Access Marvel Musicals streaming movies Mary Tyler Moore sequels transformers screen actors guild Baby Yoda Grammys Captain marvel Fantasy dark OWN Toys razzies Apple TV Plus Travel Channel emmy awards worst HBO USA Mudbound free movies Columbia Pictures 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Spike comics FOX football talk show History 2018 TV movies YouTube Red BBC America Shudder book adaptation worst movies Freeform Avengers Certified Fresh YA Family french New York Comic Con docuseries Ellie Kemper ghosts boxing Amazon Prime Song of Ice and Fire Best Actress ABC Holiday independent remakes Ovation casting animated Apple TV+ rt labs critics edition die hard Holidays Disney IFC MCU Rocky Nominations Oscar 45 king kong police drama ID comic books BBC movies streamig Prime Video foreign wonder woman Christmas Black History Month kids Election composers boxoffice Interview WGN kaiju Best Actor Hear Us Out South by Southwest Film Festival Sundance TBS legend ABC Signature TCA Winter 2020 politics hispanic heritage month ESPN E3 Black Mirror YouTube 94th Oscars toy story what to watch australia laika SundanceTV doctor who The Witch Logo Vudu high school Summer Lifetime Marvel Studios international italian scary VH1 MTV game of thrones Awards Tour Stephen King The Academy BET women Universal Pictures kong hollywood FX on Hulu Rock know your critic binge Spectrum Originals Creative Arts Emmys thriller Endgame posters sitcom Nat Geo aliens Amazon Prime Video black TNT Tokyo Olympics 73rd Emmy Awards golden globes DC Universe series Sundance TV CW Seed Discovery Channel Exclusive Video YouTube Premium Nickelodeon Funimation Tarantino Opinion Apple rom-coms Pirates halloween tv teaser ViacomCBS spy thriller Britbox Music 79th Golden Globes Awards Pop technology dceu The Walking Dead Calendar 99% ratings unscripted SDCC Infographic Schedule child's play romance cancelled GIFs Image Comics stand-up comedy prank Neflix aapi Adult Swim Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pixar new zealand Hulu Television Critics Association Disney Channel Elton John south america Teen indiana jones HBO Go political drama Awards festivals Disney+ Disney Plus summer TV NBA summer preview Rom-Com sopranos breaking bad rotten japanese WarnerMedia criterion mob period drama space mutant Paramount DC streaming service TCA Awards Ghostbusters spain video movie Bravo new star wars movies Fall TV zombies adventure PaleyFest zombie Trivia President CMT supernatural nfl slasher Musical Universal E! Film Festival spider-verse green book TCM crime Tubi basketball Superheroe chucky crime thriller Chernobyl Pacific Islander 93rd Oscars Paramount Network Amazon name the review Paramount Plus critics Tumblr Walt Disney Pictures target Pride Month scary movies fast and furious justice league Action asian-american Reality Competition 24 frames Red Carpet Star Trek Star Wars Premiere Dates FX theme song DGA NYCC debate based on movie action-comedy Syfy Classic Film classics PlayStation royal family Comedy Central IMDb TV hispanic richard e. Grant disaster finale Pet Sematary batman TLC Cosplay latino natural history 4/20 VOD mcc comic book movies jamie lee curtis spinoff FXX 2015 toronto rt labs films Comedy gangster First Reviews 2017 video on demand heist movie rt archives Tomatazos mockumentary joker reviews marvel comics Valentine's Day SXSW 2022 BAFTA biopic sag awards dramedy singing competition marvel cinematic universe vampires Best and Worst hist tv talk CNN Wes Anderson Disney Plus pirates of the caribbean Dark Horse Comics medical drama live action archives serial killer spanish language black comedy venice obi wan children's TV Comic Book critic resources stoner RT21 parents Legendary 2016 trophy witnail Epix dreamworks OneApp Cartoon Network Countdown A&E Lionsgate cancelled television American Society of Cinematographers monster movies cooking 2019 RT History versus 21st Century Fox travel Winners AMC obituary harry potter Shondaland 72 Emmy Awards ABC Family The Arrangement NBC Cannes docudrama Superheroes Animation Hollywood Foreign Press Association Emmys deadpool cars cults rotten movies we love facebook Biopics zero dark thirty CBS universal monsters leaderboard IFC Films Mindy Kaling X-Men Tags: Comedy cinemax nature psycho franchise TV One Lucasfilm Amazon Studios Mystery National Geographic Sneak Peek all-time The Walt Disney Company Hallmark Instagram Live book strong female leads adenture comic telelvision spider-man APB dexter Crunchyroll Heroines Turner Classic Movies Peacock MGM quibi San Diego Comic-Con Reality mission: impossible streaming LGBT nbcuniversal renewed TV shows fresh king arthur Starz art house superhero Disney streaming service cops dc Kids & Family game show discovery A24 young adult award winner crossover Western Writers Guild of America comiccon directors Marvel Television scorecard television See It Skip It GoT Turner concert Year in Review miniseries saw 1990s documentary Binge Guide Comic-Con@Home 2021 jurassic park elevated horror Drama 71st Emmy Awards feel good BBC One best Esquire vs. Winter TV DirecTV Acorn TV popular Brie Larson Martial Arts Trophy Talk MSNBC Fox Searchlight Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt indie blockbusters stop motion japan trailers Best Picture Arrowverse Academy Awards USA Network crime drama canceled TV shows Rocketman SXSW science fiction news Hallmark Christmas movies TV historical drama documentaries Showtime Marathons Character Guide 2021 twilight halloween Photos The Purge spanish reboot werewolf sequel diversity lord of the rings Broadway Comics on TV golden globe awards DC Comics cancelled TV series TruTV HFPA war HBO Max Film Sundance Now Sony Pictures Podcast festival GLAAD a nightmare on elm street Warner Bros. hidden camera Netflix Christmas movies Trailer Netflix Crackle TCA 2017 biography olympics Fox News Country anime sports BET Awards cancelled TV shows El Rey First Look dogs blaxploitation social media suspense TCA comedies Food Network TV renewals Super Bowl romantic comedy Extras robots slashers Quiz