RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... The Holiday

Special guest and Rare Beasts writer-director Billie Piper takes on the grinches who called Nancy Meyers' modern yuletide classic an over-egged, Rotten Christmas mess.

by | August 26, 2021 | Comments

The Holiday

(Photo by ©Columbia Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection)

No podcast fans, your ears do not deceive you: It’s August, the country is sweltering, and we – like your local Cracker Barrel gift shop – are rolling out the Christmas things, with a brand-new episode devoted to Nancy Meyers’ house-swap rom-com, The Holiday.  


Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19


Now, before you can say “But we haven’t even done pumpkin season yet!”, hear us out. The Holiday is an absolute Christmas cracker of a film and worthy of debate, any time of year: two rom-coms in one, with some of Hollywood’s most charming and beautiful people at the peaks of their powers, and enough real-estate porn to rival a 24-hour HGTV marathon.

Also, it was the film of choice for a very special podcast guest, but we will get to that in a minute.

If you are one of the rare movie lovers who doesn’t check in with the movie every December, here’s a quick refresher: LA-based movie trailer producer Amanda (Cameron Diaz) swaps her SoCal manse for the Surrey cottage of British journalist Iris (Kate Winslet), both women looking to get away from their day-to-day lives for a holiday. (OK, “vacation” for the Americans.) Each discovers a little something about themselves while away, as well as the potential loves of their lives in the form of Jude Law (for Amanda) and Jack Black (for Iris).

Oh, and Eli Wallach shows up to steal the entire movie as a Golden Age Hollywood screenwriter.

Sounds divine, right? Well, according to critics at the time of its 2006 release, it was a little too divine, with the schmaltz laid on too thickly and the story far too predictable. They slapped the film with a Rotten Tomatometer Score of 49%; fans, on the other land, have grown to love it, and its Audience Score stands at a very lovely 80% Fresh.



One such fan is British actor Billie Piper, who joins us for our latest episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong to stand up for The Holiday as well as to chat about her debut film as a writer and director, the very un-Holiday-like Rare Beasts, a savage comedy that some critics are calling a nervy and auspicious debut. Will she convince regular RT Is Wrong co-hosts and notorious grinches Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley that The Holiday deserves to be a Christmas classic?

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”


Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:


If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.


Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Tag Cloud

Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt unscripted The Purge child's play 20th Century Fox 2020 criterion award winner PaleyFest BBC One scene in color news spy thriller Paramount vampires DC streaming service Star Wars streamig movie Summer Binge Guide Certified Fresh documentary golden globe awards game of thrones versus blockbusters Rock 2017 71st Emmy Awards new york Red Carpet Fox News south america 2015 E! scary prank 2019 adaptation Toys Disney Plus Holidays Pop TV crime drama Shudder revenge boxing stand-up comedy Syfy Baby Yoda VH1 Freeform TV MCU latino TV movies TCA comic book movie movies SXSW APB Oscar Classic Film Mary poppins cinemax true crime rt archives cars dragons game show MGM HBO parents Tubi superman cats disaster Film GIFs TV One Mary Poppins Returns Adult Swim Trophy Talk canceled TV shows Country Trivia Disney+ Disney Plus comic books GLAAD YouTube Premium ID basketball Tags: Comedy ghosts BBC ABC Family Sundance Nominations crime thriller teaser Rocky 79th Golden Globes Awards USA lord of the rings nfl Biopics Teen rt labs critics edition mutant Endgame 2021 social media live action Black History Month Indigenous Disney Calendar halloween tv tv talk Tomatazos video on demand Emmy Nominations indiana jones Universal Pictures worst leaderboard stop motion Comic-Con@Home 2021 Reality Creative Arts Emmys adenture TCM worst movies twilight godzilla talk show Pixar Paramount Pictures fast and furious Marathons TBS Character Guide Hulu Academy Awards blockbuster Starz Sneak Peek GoT indie Ellie Kemper cooking Universal Trailer Dark Horse Comics christmas movies The Arrangement crossover NBA Star Wars Celebration First Look DC Comics technology debate Video Games sequels green book hispanic American Society of Cinematographers Pet Sematary miniseries justice league BET Infographic Comic Book ESPN Amazon children's TV TCA Winter 2020 posters Valentine's Day independent transformers dc DGA marvel comics FX Interview superhero biopic vs. IMDb TV FXX Set visit gangster Esquire YA Shondaland chucky Reality Competition TLC Awards National Geographic Box Office PlayStation franchise documentaries aliens kids breaking bad natural history Sony Pictures Avengers historical drama Masterpiece japanese Bravo Animation Instagram Live Fantasy book adaptation emmy awards History a nightmare on elm street golden globes rom-coms telelvision Hallmark Superheroe 2016 Spring TV Thanksgiving interviews Ovation Awards Tour facebook Disney Channel elevated horror obituary animated theme song archives football FOX casting kaiju Watching Series feel good NYCC hispanic heritage month festivals directors book batman Schedule TV Land The Walking Dead Cannes medical drama free movies RT21 pirates of the caribbean based on movie video San Diego Comic-Con marvel cinematic universe Lifetime Walt Disney Pictures CW Seed toronto discovery Marvel Studios heist movie war politics Action royal family Apple TV Plus Extras quibi diversity cancelled TV series science fiction Premiere Dates 73rd Emmy Awards Winners 94th Oscars 2018 Amazon Prime critic resources Marvel spanish Neflix fresh saw Legendary spider-verse space Turner Classic Movies First Reviews Black Mirror Amazon Prime Video Paramount Network Heroines Drama all-time ITV richard e. Grant police drama canceled CBS All Access DirecTV El Rey adventure asian-american cults monster movies A24 The Walt Disney Company sag awards docuseries slashers romance MTV Pirates screenings Turner A&E reviews trophy Spike Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The CW Crunchyroll TCA 2017 composers harry potter ViacomCBS SDCC streaming king arthur Tokyo Olympics AMC Plus 93rd Oscars remakes X-Men renewed TV shows hist BBC America ABC Signature Epix series Family cancelled television Amazon Studios Fox Searchlight broadcast TIFF Hallmark Christmas movies cancelled TV shows Year in Review Chernobyl Spectrum Originals live event Best Actor best Paramount Plus Music king kong 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 24 frames Pacific Islander sports art house sequel Mindy Kaling spain anthology television dark Lucasfilm classics comics 45 dreamworks kong werewolf romantic comedy biography zombies Elton John ABC Polls and Games Hollywood Foreign Press Association CMT Vudu Lifetime Christmas movies aapi Photos mcc Funimation 21st Century Fox australia zombie Exclusive Video Song of Ice and Fire rotten summer TV YouTube HFPA Arrowverse blaxploitation Western USA Network Fall TV target scene in color dexter Pride Month action-comedy obi wan See It Skip It jurassic park 90s witnail finale scary movies slasher satire YouTube Red razzies crime Peacock 99% Writers Guild of America Oscars Hear Us Out Nat Geo Star Trek Marvel Television BET Awards summer TV preview Showtime Tumblr hidden camera Martial Arts international Native streaming movies Comedy Central spanish language SundanceTV Travel Channel new star wars movies 007 Mary Tyler Moore genre binge MSNBC docudrama HBO Go zero dark thirty Discovery Channel Horror New York Comic Con comic legend Netflix boxoffice The Academy films Podcast Focus Features sopranos Sony Television Critics Association Superheroes olympics james bond VICE TruTV Winter TV Food Network Netflix Christmas movies screen actors guild Rocketman Quiz Ghostbusters Opinion scene in color film series Brie Larson serial killer dceu The Witch Cartoon Network Sundance Now mob popular IFC Best Picture dramedy Holiday target comic book movies cartoon doctor who young adult Grammys South by Southwest Film Festival Comedy Comics on TV Musical die hard anime Women's History Month 72 Emmy Awards Kids & Family CNN halloween high school singing competition laika 4/20 Crackle supernatural Fargo OWN mission: impossible Tarantino suspense PBS Election Image Comics OneApp Sci-Fi DC Universe critics nature psycho Stephen King rt labs scorecard Apple TV+ spider-man E3 Acorn TV wonder woman black Logo CBS Prime Video LGBT scene in color series strong female leads TNT VOD President political drama IFC Films Film Festival Emmys women jamie lee curtis TCA Awards Best and Worst psychological thriller comiccon LGBTQ WarnerMedia Cosplay deadpool Apple Anna Paquin period drama Captain marvel 1990s hollywood RT History Television Academy SXSW 2022 WGN Warner Bros. black comedy Britbox spinoff joker Christmas Mudbound Pop ratings robots mockumentary Broadway universal monsters Sundance TV sitcom comedies travel rotten movies we love Mystery name the review AMC cancelled cops Lionsgate Rom-Com Geeked Week NBC HBO Max new zealand summer preview reboot Super Bowl venice italian Best Director nbcuniversal trailers dogs thriller Countdown toy story Disney streaming service Alien festival TV renewals japan Best Actress stoner foreign french concert Musicals Columbia Pictures what to watch BAFTA Nickelodeon FX on Hulu know your critic Wes Anderson