RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Cats

Is the critically reviled Cats about to enter the next of its nine lives, reborn as a cult classic worthy of repeat – and, er, influenced – viewings? We're getting jellicle in our latest pod... whatever that means.

by | June 10, 2021 | Comments


(Photo by © Universal Pictures / courtesy Everett Collection)

With In the Heights dancing into theaters this week on a wave of incredible reviews – it’s currently Certified Fresh at 97% – we thought we’d cast our minds back to the last big movie musical to hit theaters… one that arrived on a wave of, shall we say, less positive press.

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

It was late 2019, a lifetime ago it seems, when Universal offered us the Christmas gift of their adaptation of Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Cats, his own adaptation of poems from T.S. Eliot. And for most critics, what lie beneath the heavily-CGI wrapping was a big old lump of coal. Folks who guffawed at the shiver-inducing trailer, with its small and bizarre humanoid cast of famous-faced felines, had their worst fears (or hopes in some cases) confirmed: Cats, the movie, was a disaster.

Scathing reviews drove its Tomatometer score down to a Rotten 19%; the movie would go on to dominate that year’s Razzies.

But lo, in the wake of its release, something “jellicle” started to develop around the movie. (No, we do not know if we are using that term correctly, as we still have no idea what it means let alone if it’s a verb, noun, or otherwise.) The star-studded laughing-stock began to develop a reputation – surprisingly quickly – as something weird, yes, but also wonderful, a film that could become a cult favorite. Midnight screenings started to pop up, the atmosphere akin to late nights with The Rocky Horror Picture Show and The Room; when the pandemic hit, fans turned to online viewing parties at which, powered on by libations and edible treats, they were able to fully make peace and become one with the sights and sounds of a furry Rebel Wilson chomping on dancing cockroaches.

A gloriously messy fever dream? A cult classic in the making? Or just really, really bad? That’s what we’re asking in the latest episode of our podcast, Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong, and to help our hosts Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley paw through it all, we enlisted the big guns: Angie Han, Deputy Entertainment Editor at Mashable, film critic extraordinaire, and yes, one of the 19% of Tomatometer-approved critics who filed a positive review for Cats, a little red tomato she will defend to this day. But can she convince Mark and Jacqueline to love the film that, as she wrote in her review, “had broken me, and I’d never felt happier”?

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

video on demand cops criterion james bond Sneak Peek Awards Tour 2018 TCA Awards Legendary MSNBC Indigenous biography HFPA TV One slasher 20th Century Fox Drama Mary Poppins Returns Crunchyroll Fox Searchlight TV renewals toronto mockumentary war cats Comedy Central Marvel Studios festivals GIFs Cosplay Photos The Walking Dead TV game show gangster interviews Creative Arts Emmys Holiday BET Awards streaming movies PaleyFest cults ITV Podcast CW Seed documentaries Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Interview Esquire wonder woman GLAAD dramedy Amazon black Mindy Kaling south america streamig Star Wars Celebration Polls and Games FXX spider-verse breaking bad 2015 teaser Freeform miniseries 93rd Oscars AMC Plus justice league Arrowverse stop motion new star wars movies indiana jones godzilla Summer marvel comics rt archives PlayStation summer preview ABC Family composers Year in Review Comic Book psycho tv talk Crackle scene in color film series sequels Comic-Con@Home 2021 vs. CBS Star Trek 2020 Acorn TV Opinion NYCC quibi American Society of Cinematographers Peacock harry potter boxoffice a nightmare on elm street series Apple TV Plus live event Tokyo Olympics popular concert SDCC Reality target crime drama Marvel asian-american 71st Emmy Awards Comedy Animation Mystery 4/20 Pacific Islander Ellie Kemper sitcom TV movies casting Schedule docudrama Alien 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards broadcast Hallmark Christmas movies high school First Reviews movie based on movie Sony Pictures hollywood Awards First Look critic resources heist movie mission: impossible vampires ESPN VH1 obi wan Netflix Christmas movies ABC Signature twilight dreamworks South by Southwest Film Festival Captain marvel royal family Lucasfilm dogs The Arrangement Television Academy See It Skip It Trophy Talk versus comic book movies rotten independent Hallmark Horror rotten movies we love BBC America comics Pet Sematary Fall TV latino Disney streaming service international comedies mutant binge psychological thriller mob biopic Turner Classic Movies Paramount name the review WarnerMedia anime RT History Disney TCA 2017 Watching Series Prime Video Endgame Fox News Character Guide social media Rocky summer TV preview 24 frames Masterpiece theme song remakes deadpool Neflix Starz cartoon book adaptation action-comedy romance children's TV Christmas CNN Shudder GoT travel Cartoon Network Mary Tyler Moore universal monsters SundanceTV Hear Us Out Universal Pictures Paramount Pictures kids television Music aapi Marvel Television fast and furious unscripted CMT Nominations Countdown MCU ViacomCBS Warner Bros. critics HBO Go legend TNT DGA king kong die hard space TV Land cooking Bravo feel good kaiju 007 Black History Month Showtime Red Carpet scene in color series Anna Paquin BBC One jurassic park DC streaming service witnail TCM Best Actor Sundance APB The CW emmy awards 45 zombie LGBT PBS werewolf cancelled cars Classic Film leaderboard YA YouTube Premium Song of Ice and Fire Universal Pride Month Mary poppins disaster TBS Tumblr documentary DC Comics FOX nature Oscars Comics on TV Lifetime Kids & Family Star Wars canceled TV shows Ghostbusters spain sequel Baby Yoda A24 italian Winter TV serial killer Superheroes Musicals films trophy elevated horror National Geographic young adult best free movies french lord of the rings obituary singing competition Disney+ Disney Plus archives suspense blaxploitation black comedy Spectrum Originals sopranos Britbox art house cancelled TV series game of thrones Fargo FX japanese dceu technology rom-coms 94th Oscars Calendar comic book movie Mudbound DirecTV 99% blockbusters fresh Epix Logo Emmy Nominations 79th Golden Globes Awards golden globe awards NBA Lifetime Christmas movies Paramount Network VICE Chernobyl talk show VOD The Walt Disney Company Apple TV+ Video Games El Rey Food Network japan science fiction The Purge new york adaptation worst police drama Paramount Plus animated OneApp Turner australia dragons Infographic Heroines Focus Features Amazon Prime BAFTA renewed TV shows HBO sports Thanksgiving LGBTQ E3 90s Binge Guide scary reboot zombies all-time Travel Channel Black Mirror BBC Tags: Comedy Best Director romantic comedy TLC spy thriller ABC Family Rom-Com scary movies TIFF Lionsgate canceled Country E! Election superman Best Actress SXSW green book Biopics 73rd Emmy Awards Sundance Now Television Critics Association IMDb TV crossover Film foreign prank slashers Stephen King IFC genre joker diversity Cannes Valentine's Day worst movies Holidays Fantasy Pop TV USA Network The Witch king arthur saw YouTube Toys summer TV laika rt labs olympics History blockbuster comic books Amazon Studios Columbia Pictures Pop christmas movies franchise hist MTV Wes Anderson Disney Channel halloween streaming spanish language AMC Netflix Musical Grammys cancelled TV shows video dark TCA robots spinoff historical drama medical drama Certified Fresh Best Picture news Superheroe Best and Worst nbcuniversal ratings classics 2021 Brie Larson crime thriller Hulu rt labs critics edition ghosts Broadway sag awards Teen 72 Emmy Awards Action Western SXSW 2022 Women's History Month politics Extras Geeked Week San Diego Comic-Con kong pirates of the caribbean Super Bowl Set visit Apple trailers stand-up comedy screen actors guild transformers Instagram Live directors venice Amazon Prime Video Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Dark Horse Comics richard e. Grant 2019 CBS All Access crime posters nfl batman cancelled television strong female leads BET period drama golden globes screenings comiccon Oscar monster movies jamie lee curtis A&E supernatural Ovation Winners anthology 2016 Sony 21st Century Fox spider-man Film Festival what to watch cinemax Writers Guild of America spanish Rocketman chucky halloween tv Martial Arts Image Comics Marathons 1990s Spring TV Sundance TV book WGN Premiere Dates dc indie Elton John YouTube Red marvel cinematic universe football Pirates USA Trailer Adult Swim hispanic NBC scorecard Pixar toy story Trivia DC Universe Walt Disney Pictures Rock true crime MGM child's play Nickelodeon HBO Max RT21 scene in color award winner adenture facebook comic Spike revenge Hollywood Foreign Press Association Quiz 2017 New York Comic Con Box Office mcc political drama stoner razzies FX on Hulu OWN Tubi doctor who President target scene in color Funimation Exclusive Video dexter Syfy Vudu hispanic heritage month satire Emmys adventure women thriller reviews TCA Winter 2020 TruTV Tomatazos Academy Awards X-Men Avengers new zealand finale ID superhero telelvision boxing zero dark thirty natural history debate Nat Geo Native Disney Plus basketball hidden camera parents Shondaland docuseries Sci-Fi festival live action aliens Tarantino movies IFC Films Discovery Channel know your critic discovery The Academy Reality Competition