RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Cats

Is the critically reviled Cats about to enter the next of its nine lives, reborn as a cult classic worthy of repeat – and, er, influenced – viewings? We're getting jellicle in our latest pod... whatever that means.

by | June 10, 2021 | Comments


(Photo by © Universal Pictures / courtesy Everett Collection)

With In the Heights dancing into theaters this week on a wave of incredible reviews – it’s currently Certified Fresh at 97% – we thought we’d cast our minds back to the last big movie musical to hit theaters… one that arrived on a wave of, shall we say, less positive press.

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher | TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

It was late 2019, a lifetime ago it seems, when Universal offered us the Christmas gift of their adaptation of Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Cats, his own adaptation of poems from T.S. Eliot. And for most critics, what lie beneath the heavily-CGI wrapping was a big old lump of coal. Folks who guffawed at the shiver-inducing trailer, with its small and bizarre humanoid cast of famous-faced felines, had their worst fears (or hopes in some cases) confirmed: Cats, the movie, was a disaster.

Scathing reviews drove its Tomatometer score down to a Rotten 19%; the movie would go on to dominate that year’s Razzies.

But lo, in the wake of its release, something “jellicle” started to develop around the movie. (No, we do not know if we are using that term correctly, as we still have no idea what it means let alone if it’s a verb, noun, or otherwise.) The star-studded laughing-stock began to develop a reputation – surprisingly quickly – as something weird, yes, but also wonderful, a film that could become a cult favorite. Midnight screenings started to pop up, the atmosphere akin to late nights with The Rocky Horror Picture Show and The Room; when the pandemic hit, fans turned to online viewing parties at which, powered on by libations and edible treats, they were able to fully make peace and become one with the sights and sounds of a furry Rebel Wilson chomping on dancing cockroaches.

A gloriously messy fever dream? A cult classic in the making? Or just really, really bad? That’s what we’re asking in the latest episode of our podcast, Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong, and to help our hosts Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley paw through it all, we enlisted the big guns: Angie Han, Deputy Entertainment Editor at Mashable, film critic extraordinaire, and yes, one of the 19% of Tomatometer-approved critics who filed a positive review for Cats, a little red tomato she will defend to this day. But can she convince Mark and Jacqueline to love the film that, as she wrote in her review, “had broken me, and I’d never felt happier”?

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Winners screenings TCA Awards Holiday werewolf Rocky Heroines Red Carpet cartoon 45 worst Lionsgate TV concert golden globe awards Spectrum Originals Tomatazos comiccon Comics on TV talk show Starz twilight travel Pop war Reality Competition Awards Tour christmas movies Sundance TV criterion Binge Guide Cannes Walt Disney Pictures Pet Sematary zombie saw FXX Christmas 2018 blockbuster international nbcuniversal telelvision Funimation teaser Black Mirror psycho APB docudrama Exclusive Video cats halloween tv dark popular foreign book adaptation Biopics Rock NBC The Witch reboot japanese Superheroes news docuseries medical drama new york breaking bad social media Legendary movies Watching Series psychological thriller Thanksgiving Kids & Family new zealand Interview Alien Fantasy American Society of Cinematographers robots CNN joker satire laika police drama documentaries Infographic Vudu emmy awards binge Paramount transformers marvel cinematic universe crossover heist movie rotten 007 TLC Tubi casting Trailer Podcast hist Year in Review reviews Music Star Wars Cartoon Network natural history golden globes universal monsters See It Skip It die hard harry potter Hallmark witnail archives Election Photos MCU cooking canceled Horror finale 72 Emmy Awards Musical Awards video on demand worst movies San Diego Comic-Con A24 game of thrones TIFF Family FX on Hulu women sequel 2016 Warner Bros. child's play rt archives rom-coms PBS asian-american festival biography TBS thriller crime Country President CW Seed monster movies ABC Rocketman adaptation Ovation italian DirecTV X-Men fast and furious blockbusters serial killer Elton John HBO Max First Reviews scorecard Anna Paquin Disney cancelled TV series revenge BBC America Netflix ABC Signature crime drama kids Comic Book Trophy Talk kaiju LGBTQ halloween Film obituary Disney Plus anthology cinemax historical drama spanish language HBO Go YouTube Premium Musicals crime thriller AMC children's TV E3 Trivia cancelled Opinion Fox Searchlight black Super Bowl Marvel Studios deadpool mission: impossible science fiction YA TruTV dc Disney Channel best Video Games remakes comics hispanic 71st Emmy Awards Writers Guild of America Sci-Fi series The Academy Adult Swim Women's History Month Nominations political drama theme song Logo Freeform Pacific Islander pirates of the caribbean directors prank Tarantino Image Comics superhero Emmys justice league blaxploitation technology Animation Ghostbusters Spike spinoff Sneak Peek PlayStation Shondaland Endgame IFC Films Amazon Prime Video Britbox Drama Epix Amazon Studios adventure scary movies animated Captain marvel TV One composers Marvel Television VICE Pirates Western ratings Set visit TCA Winter 2020 Countdown Tumblr TCA 2017 ITV video MSNBC game show Hulu anime unscripted toronto Comedy space Arrowverse 21st Century Fox book independent MTV stoner Holidays live action Star Trek DC Universe supernatural CBS spy thriller Apple TV Plus Oscars Fall TV DC streaming service award winner Emmy Nominations Discovery Channel sitcom El Rey Character Guide Dark Horse Comics Crackle films Bravo parents a nightmare on elm street FX Turner Classic Movies Disney+ Disney Plus quibi Martial Arts period drama dceu TV renewals Quiz Paramount Network hollywood vampires Showtime Fox News romantic comedy singing competition Reality diversity venice spanish Teen Mary poppins streaming james bond sequels cancelled TV shows Baby Yoda movie king kong Amazon classics The Purge Mystery know your critic Chernobyl ABC Family aapi south america disaster 93rd Oscars GoT SundanceTV Pop TV ID doctor who WGN documentary VOD slashers VH1 Television Academy Nickelodeon french YouTube Brie Larson nfl new star wars movies zombies Premiere Dates Comedy Central Calendar WarnerMedia Mary Poppins Returns Paramount Plus Apple mockumentary critics miniseries Peacock The Walking Dead based on movie RT21 Lifetime Christmas movies CMT Pride Month 2019 BET Awards 2017 indiana jones TNT batman Broadway NYCC comic books Academy Awards Stephen King kong PaleyFest RT History YouTube Red Best and Worst name the review Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt godzilla 2021 Superheroe A&E Grammys Lifetime Creative Arts Emmys HBO cars Syfy dogs tv talk Columbia Pictures Toys BAFTA Sony Pictures Certified Fresh spain Television Critics Association fresh Mudbound Sundance spider-man 20th Century Fox BET aliens The Arrangement comedies GIFs ESPN Food Network high school Universal Hear Us Out Mary Tyler Moore TCM toy story IFC chucky true crime versus Ellie Kemper Lucasfilm 2020 BBC USA cults Valentine's Day Marvel SXSW discovery Acorn TV franchise 4/20 mutant Esquire Polls and Games OWN Crunchyroll Winter TV USA Network Song of Ice and Fire sports cops National Geographic canceled TV shows DC Comics Action DGA razzies lord of the rings dragons 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Black History Month GLAAD Amazon Prime richard e. Grant History television Classic Film facebook New York Comic Con all-time dramedy Cosplay boxoffice festivals Box Office ViacomCBS Travel Channel jamie lee curtis Sundance Now Netflix Christmas movies TV Land BBC One Rom-Com hidden camera elevated horror strong female leads 2015 Schedule Film Festival Extras scene in color politics superman CBS All Access green book 24 frames sag awards target E! Apple TV+ latino Shudder First Look ghosts australia Summer Avengers Marathons indie free movies Pixar Hallmark Christmas movies The Walt Disney Company The CW nature TCA zero dark thirty FOX boxing Turner Masterpiece LGBT screen actors guild Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cancelled television SDCC jurassic park what to watch comic Mindy Kaling stand-up comedy rotten movies we love stop motion romance Disney streaming service Spring TV 99% renewed TV shows football trailers Nat Geo OneApp