Fall TV Scorecard 2015

Adjusted Score: 40.212%
Critics Consensus: The Player's convoluted premise weighs down a game cast, bringing nothing original to the table.
Synopsis: The first season of this crime drama follows a security expert named Alex Kane (Philip Winchester) who encounters an elite... [More]

Adjusted Score: 44.212%
Critics Consensus: Focusing on special effects and unearned melodrama at the expense of the original's initially intriguing narrative, Heroes Reborn is a series revival with seemingly limited prospects.
Synopsis: Ordinary people discover they have extraordinary powers in this retooling of the TV show "Heroes".... [More]

Adjusted Score: 50.67%
Critics Consensus: While adding nothing new to the established medical procedural formula, Dick Wolf's Chicago Med hits its familiar beats forcefully enough to satisfy a few genre enthusiasts.
Synopsis: Set in the busiest emergency room in Chicago, "Chicago Med" is the third installment of Dick Wolf's Chicago-set franchise. The... [More]

Adjusted Score: 48.597%
Critics Consensus: Kurt Sutter's The Bastard Executioner doesn't want for dark thrills, but it unfortunately has more enthusiasm for brutality and gore than necessary narrative focus.
Synopsis: Following the adventures of a warrior knight during the Middle Ages.... [More]

Adjusted Score: 65.148%
Critics Consensus: Into the Badlands is loaded with off-kilter potential that's left largely unfulfilled -- although its well-choreographed action sequences should satisfy martial arts fans.
Synopsis: Season 1 of this martial arts drama series follows Sunny (Daniel Wu)a highly trained warrior and MK (Aramis Knight) a... [More]
Directed By: David Dobkin

Adjusted Score: 51.698%
Critics Consensus: While not reinventing the stethoscope, Code Black is an above-average medical drama, with appropriately theatrical storylines that make up for sometimes cheesy dialogue.
Synopsis: From creator Michael Seitzman comes this medical drama that follows Residency Director Dr. Leanne Rorish (Marcia Gay Harden) as she... [More]

Adjusted Score: 71.753%
Critics Consensus: Too tasteless for mainstream viewers and too silly for horror enthusiasts, Scream Queens fails to satisfy.
Synopsis: A series that mixes black comedy with a heavy slice of slasher flick begins on a college campus experiencing a... [More]

Limitless: Season 1 (2015)

Adjusted Score: 60.083%
Critics Consensus: Even with a likable hero, Limitless cannot overcome its credulity-straining premise and shaky, hole-riddled narrative.
Synopsis: A heavy dose of humor and fun lightens this procedural drama based on the 2011 film of the same name... [More]

Adjusted Score: 63.377%
Critics Consensus: Its nuanced female relationships makes Flesh and Bone a realistic portrayal of a professional ballet company, though it suffers from a lack of levity.
Synopsis: A drama miniseries that follows Claire Robbins (Sarah Hay), a troubled young dancer who lands a job with a prestigious... [More]

Adjusted Score: 65.083%
Critics Consensus: High stakes and bawdy plots make Blood & Oil's plain premise and characters tolerable.
Synopsis: A young couple run afoul of a tycoon and his wife while trying to cash in on the Bakken oil... [More]

Pages: Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next

  • johnnywrong

    Ash Vs Evil Dead is sooooooooo bad.

    • Douglas Young

      Yeah it’s supposed to be. True fans know when it’s bad and why.. Just one thing that’s sooooooooo great about it.

      • Phil

        True Douglas, It is suppose to be. Ash Vs. Evil Dead is suppose to be intentionally very campy, exactly like the original movies that spawned it. It is not meant to be taken seriously and it is suppose to have a lot of tongue in cheek humor.

    • Sickly Jackal

      Soooo bad ass. Best show this year I think.

  • Derek117

    I agree with “Man in the High Castle” and “Supergirl” being in the top five. And think Quantico and Blindspot need to be higher up. On the down side, Jessica Jones is the number one disappointment (All hype and no intelligence)

  • Alpaca Male

    Supergirl is feminist pandering 101, man in the high castle has 2 awful leads but the story is a bit entertaining, Jessica Jones is sort of an OK Daredevil which owes David Tennant a LOT! in short, not many good tv shows to watch right now, but keep your chin up! the Expanse looks really really good!

  • Shawn McDonald

    That Colbert and Noah even made this list undermines the credibility of every other ranking.

    Chalk that up to my opinion. And after your done with that, do six seconds into research for the ratings of both of those shows since Colbert and Noah took over and come back and tell me again that I’m the only one who doesn’t think either one of them is entertaining.

    • Dashing28

      You’re the only one who doesn’t think either one of them is entertaining.

      • John White

        You’re not the only one … as least when it comes to Colbert (haven’t seen Noah yet). Sorry, just don’t find Colbert the least bit funny or entertaining, and I’m into offbeat humor. It’s tough to explain, but it’s like I’m watching Colbert doing an exaggerated parody of Colbert or something. Craig Ferguson … now there was a funny late-night host.

  • Pimplestiltskin

    Ash vs Evil Dead is the greatest thing on TV right now.

  • Sofnr .

    Switch Jessica Jones and Supergirl and i’m mostly happy with the top 10. No real interest in grinder but i can’t knock it since i havn’t watched 🙂

  • Dashing28

    Master of None FTW!!

  • Happy for Supergirl!

  • Jjajangmyeon Kimbap

    w/ Bob and David should be 100%

  • Burden of proof

    I have a natural aversion to buy-a-new-car, lose-some-weight and fix-your-wrinkles commercials on repeat. And so opted for Netflix’ Jessica Jones. Within the first few minutes, there was nary a silly shaky-cam effect to be found. Could this series have well-trained actors, realistic CGI effects and catchy screenwriting all-in-one? Yes! Jessica Jones will go down in history as one of the greats.

  • J_123

    Supergirl in number 3 and above Jessica Jones shows why the people don’t care and don’t trust anymore in the critics and the reviews.

  • Philndeb

    Giving fresh tomatoes to Grinder and Blood & Oil kind of de-legitimizes your entire ranking process!

  • Max Milstein

    Fargo isn’t on this list…

    • THGhost

      98% for season 1, 100% for season 2. It should definitely be on here.


    • Micah Mahaffey

      Yeah a lot of higher rated shows were skipped for some reason.. season 9 of Doctor Who has 100% but was left out as well

    • Phil

      Is intelligence completely gone on the internet?!?!?! All the shows on this list have one thing in common…. SEASON 1….. ONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Fargo is in its 2nd season, Doctor Who is in its god knows what season……….. If this were a list for TV shows in general I can understand these comments, but its a list for NEW TV Shows. NEWWWWWWWW….

  • THGhost

    “Scream Queens fails to satisfy.” Well it certainly satisfies me, and I’m an avid horror fan. I don’t think whoever wrote that consensus took into account that the show is a parody of teen horror tropes, and it does it brilliantly.

  • MasterGeek

    I would have rated a couple of them higher (Life in Pieces and Limitless), but otherwise this seems pretty accurate to me. Our favorite new shows are at the top (Ash vs. Evil Dead, Supergirl, and Grinder). I have really been meaning to check out Master of None.

  • hyraxx

    I am shocked Supergirl rated this high. Plot seems forced in some areas. Especially the anger episode.

    Plus Dean Cain is a fucking piece of shit. Her sis is ugly and annoying. And they unnecessarily changed jimmy from historically nerdy to sexy. And they are making her out to be too weak. Too many near death experiences even without kryptonite.

    That all being said, still a good show.

  • Supergirl?????? Thats just not true!!!! That show was/is worse than anything in the top 20.

  • Micah Mahaffey

    Where’s Doctor Who? I can’t take this list seriously… It was a 100% positive rating on rotten tomatoes and this last season was spectacular!

  • Phil

    So happy that my 2 favorite new shows this year, Supergirl and Ash Vs Evil Dead are both in the top 3. I might have to give Master of None a shot just cause it was the only show that beat them on this list, lol.

  • Brent

    Saw maybe four of these shows — cannot recall. Supergirl is enjoyed and we watch every episode; overrated here though. Blindspot is great! Quantico is a stinking pile of crap; well, that’s strong; it is just sucky vacuuous non-entertainment.

Tag Cloud

Song of Ice and Fire Film Festival 2017 Rocketman Turner finale Holidays Rock Photos cancelled TV series sports Premiere Dates RT History mission: impossible Trailer 4/20 45 crime drama Nominations Western OneApp aliens Spike docudrama Family cancelled television streaming nbcuniversal composers Winners Country cancelled TV shows Winter TV 007 versus hollywood History animated A24 richard e. Grant FXX Pop social media Comedy Central Toys 2016 WarnerMedia comic police drama christmas movies documentary Mary poppins Set visit news Hallmark doctor who Tubi Discovery Channel Avengers Star Trek Disney Plus Sundance Now rotten Year in Review PBS Showtime IFC Films historical drama VICE Marvel Television Disney Ghostbusters Reality Competition New York Comic Con Logo crossover Britbox Bravo Chernobyl Walt Disney Pictures all-time scary movies south america ABC dramedy Classic Film Ellie Kemper Adult Swim jamie lee curtis X-Men Election Turner Classic Movies Hulu RT21 biography ghosts E3 spy thriller universal monsters dragons blockbuster sitcom BET Awards National Geographic Awards theme song Academy Awards Best and Worst comiccon CBS All Access GLAAD indiana jones Nat Geo LGBTQ directors franchise Pirates renewed TV shows batman anime hist comedies science fiction Writers Guild of America cartoon Syfy satire series Reality SDCC Lifetime CNN Lucasfilm what to watch Black Mirror unscripted thriller Musicals Crunchyroll YouTube Premium Animation TIFF nature Paramount NBC a nightmare on elm street Opinion romantic comedy diversity 72 Emmy Awards Television Academy 2018 reviews Thanksgiving Marvel Studios toy story ESPN Women's History Month singing competition Dark Horse Comics superhero USA Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt criterion asian-american DC Comics Fox News CMT Amazon Studios Shondaland 2019 Stephen King Extras TCA Winter 2020 space talk show Disney+ Disney Plus anthology toronto teaser Tarantino medical drama BBC 24 frames Sneak Peek war Chilling Adventures of Sabrina indie Apple American Society of Cinematographers quibi Elton John witnail Mudbound based on movie FX festivals Pet Sematary Action The Witch Amazon Prime Video cults E! Character Guide stand-up comedy Heroines ABC Family nfl Nickelodeon Cannes Starz Fall TV Watching Series sequel Baby Yoda cooking politics TCA Awards supernatural political drama Paramount Network remakes Christmas Grammys spain parents DC streaming service obituary Lionsgate Mystery cars sequels die hard Podcast casting FOX DC Universe Fantasy cops PlayStation Mindy Kaling Emmys psychological thriller YouTube Drama elevated horror Emmy Nominations name the review Television Critics Association Tumblr DirecTV dark screenings golden globes green book PaleyFest zombie Star Wars venice SundanceTV BBC America Holiday Oscars ratings Apple TV+ CW Seed foreign serial killer Anna Paquin chucky scorecard zero dark thirty HBO Max USA Network screen actors guild Sundance TV BBC One Cosplay adaptation Apple TV Plus sag awards Red Carpet transformers TLC tv talk Sony Pictures latino revenge festival Comics on TV Vudu YouTube Red Crackle President Sci-Fi 21st Century Fox The CW SXSW hispanic travel zombies movie free movies San Diego Comic-Con crime binge game show Film TCA 2017 Pop TV Black History Month robots ITV Schedule Infographic discovery halloween IFC Disney streaming service Superheroe Acorn TV Trophy Talk Mary Tyler Moore Kids & Family video cinemax fast and furious Amazon Prime Netflix Christmas movies psycho Peacock BET MSNBC period drama TCM APB VH1 GIFs book Music worst movies GoT TV Land children's TV Esquire miniseries Horror Summer adventure blaxploitation Columbia Pictures DGA werewolf Martial Arts 2020 spider-man concert Shudder The Walking Dead Endgame Arrowverse Awards Tour Superheroes Captain marvel YA harry potter HBO Go Box Office FX on Hulu dceu Travel Channel laika boxoffice Marvel BAFTA Masterpiece Polls and Games MTV See It Skip It TNT rotten movies we love Freeform 20th Century Fox Warner Bros. Super Bowl Food Network Trivia justice league Pride Month independent breaking bad movies Video Games Universal Certified Fresh documentaries mutant Ovation VOD true crime slashers worst award winner Epix video on demand romance TV renewals CBS LGBT First Reviews Biopics kids First Look NYCC best Creative Arts Emmys facebook MCU TBS Netflix Disney Channel Spring TV Rocky Teen films canceled TV shows 2015 comics game of thrones stoner television Calendar Brie Larson dc crime thriller Marathons reboot El Rey Hallmark Christmas movies Hear Us Out Comedy natural history Mary Poppins Returns The Arrangement classics TruTV joker Lifetime Christmas movies Tomatazos disaster Comic Book cats child's play Sundance TV technology Amazon spanish language 71st Emmy Awards Musical mockumentary stop motion HBO TCA Binge Guide Interview Cartoon Network Spectrum Originals Countdown spinoff WGN Rom-Com Valentine's Day Pixar A&E Quiz The Purge cancelled strong female leads critics dogs Funimation football AMC OWN emmy awards vampires twilight canceled