Total Recall

10 Beloved TV Shows That Were Made Into Awful Movies

In this week's Total Recall, we look at some of the worst adaptations of popular TV series ever to hit the big screen.

by | October 21, 2015 | Comments

When Jem and the Holograms makes its truly outrageous way into theaters this weekend, it’ll add another entry to the long list of successful television shows that have been adapted for the big screen. Of course, just because a concept works as a series doesn’t mean it’ll pay off as a film — and although all of us here certainly wish nothing but the best for Jem and her pals on their cinematic adventures, we’re willing to concede the possibility that this will end up being another instance where a few things will be lost in translation. In that spirit, we’ve decided to dedicate this feature to some of the bumpier journeys hit shows have experienced on the way to the cineplex, so don’t touch that dial — it’s time for Total Recall!


Land of the Lost (2009) 26%

LandoftheLost

Will Ferrell, Danny McBride, and dinosaurs — plus a loose creative affiliation with one of the most beloved live-action Saturday morning serials of the 1970s. It’s a can’t-miss proposition, right? Universal certainly seemed to think so, given that the studio ponied up $100 million and a plum June release date for 2009’s Land of the Lost. Sadly, the result — which starred Ferrell as a nincompoop paleontologist who triggers a time warp and finds himself trapped in the distant past with a college student (Anna Friel) and a gift shop owner (McBride) — didn’t even try to recapture the low-budget magic of the original series, opting instead for a satirical approach that failed to resound with filmgoers and critics alike. “With his belligerent blankness and gawky aplomb, Ferrell has made me laugh as much as any comic of his generation, but he’s not doing anything fresh in Land of the Lost,” opined a disappointed Peter Rainer for the Christian Science Monitor.

Watch Trailer


Bewitched (2005) 24%

Bewitched

Bewitched was an undeniably silly show, but its high-concept premise — about a witch who falls for an ordinary guy and tries to fit in with his suburban existence — was used to address a wide variety of themes and topics during its eight-season run. Updating the show for the 21st century really could have been a good idea, particularly with Nicole Kidman and Will Ferrell in the lead and Nora Ephron writing, directing, and producing, but this is one case of the road to cinematic hell being paved with good intentions — not to mention a convoluted script that added an unnecessary meta layer to the whole thing. In this version of Bewitched, Ferrell plays a washed-up actor approached to star in a film adaptation of Bewitched… whose vain attempt to secure a nobody for a co-star leads him to unwittingly cast an actual witch. It’s the kind of self-consciously aware stuff that really needs to be clever in order to work; alas, cleverness proved to be in exceedingly short supply. “If it lost every bad idea, miscast actor, wasted performance, and botched scene,” predicted the A.V. Club’s Nathan Rabin, “nothing would be left but the end credits.”

Watch Trailer


The Beverly Hillbillies (1993) 22%

BeverlyHillbillies

A number of long-gone television shows were adapted for the big screen in the early 1990s, with wildly varying results; for every critical and commercial hit like The Brady Bunch Movie, there were a number of duds like… well, a few of the other films on this list, actually. Somewhere in the middle sat 1993’s The Beverly Hillbillies, director Penelope Spheeris’ rather inexplicable follow-up to her triumph with Wayne’s World the previous year — although the movie made money, it was a critical disaster, with review after review rejecting the film’s aggressive attempt to update the barn-broad cornpone humor of the hit series. While Spheeris enlisted a talented cast to portray the oil-rich Clampett clan, building a roster of stars that included Cloris Leachman, Lily Tomlin, Dabney Coleman, and Jim Varney, and the movie even worked in a clever cameo from original Beverly Hillbillies star Buddy Ebsen as his other iconic TV character, Barnaby Jones, it simply wasn’t enough to overcome the movie’s many creative flaws. “Four writers worked on the script,” noted the Chicago Reader’s Jonathan Rosenbaum. “They all should hang their heads in shame.”

Watch Trailer


Wild Wild West (1999) 17%

WildWildWest2

Starting with 1995’s Bad Boys, Will Smith pretty much owned the box office for the back half of the decade, toplining an impressive string of hits that included Independence Day, Men in Black, and Enemy of the State. By 1999, he had nowhere to go but down — although no one expected him to take a tumble as fast and steep as the infamous Wild Wild West, a woeful would-be Western steampunk action-comedy that entered theaters positioned as the hit of the summer and instantly revealed itself to be just as ludicrously ungainly as the mechanized spider thing piloted by Kenneth Branagh in the final act. Based on the hit CBS series that was described as “James Bond on horseback” during its 1965-’69 run, the big-screen West aped some of the form of its predecessor (including its flights of technological fancy), but neglected to include a sensible storyline, memorable characters, or interesting dialogue; the result was one of the least-loved major releases of the year. He’d certainly go on to enjoy further cinematic successes, but after this, Hollywood understood it needed more than Will Smith and some killer special effects to cook up a hit. “Wild Wild West is a comedy dead zone,” decreed Roger Ebert. “You stare in disbelief as scenes flop and die. The movie is all concept and no content; the elaborate special effects are like watching money burn on the screen.”

Watch Trailer


I Spy (2002) 16%

ISpy

It broke new racial ground, but in terms of its concept, I Spy was pretty standard stuff — the secret agent adventures of an undercover tennis player (Robert Culp) and his trainer (Bill Cosby) as they traipsed around the world stopping bad guys. The secret of its Emmy-winning success was the abundant chemistry between Culp and Cosby — not to mention the sharp writing. All of the above was lost in translation when the show made its way to theaters in 2002, despite a small army of screenwriters and the star power of Owen Wilson and Eddie Murphy. The problem, according to Ed Park of the Village Voice: “Though ample time is spent mingling Murphy’s jabberjaw locutions and Wilson’s curveball spaciness, the film leaves only the bitter reek of a botched chemistry experiment.”

Watch Trailer


The Dukes of Hazzard (2005) 14%

DukezHazzard2

A thinly disguised spinoff of the 1975 film Moonrunners, the hit CBS series The Dukes of Hazzard was never regarded as, shall we say, particularly intelligent entertainment. It was harmlessly cheesy fun, the rootin’ tootin’ adventures of some good ol’ boys who never meant no harm and were just makin’ their way the only way they knew how — which was, unfortunately just a little bit more than the law would allow. In other words, it should have been relatively easy to make an entertaining Dukes movie in 2005, especially with an eclectic cast that included Seann William Scott, Johnny Knoxville, Burt Reynolds, and an exuberantly short-shorted Jessica Simpson. Alas, although it broke $100 million at the box office, the Dukes movie was lambasted by critics like Stephen Hunter of the Washington Post, who lamented it as “So loud, so long, so dumb.”

Watch Trailer


The Avengers (1998) 5%

Avengers1

Super-producer Jerry Weintraub has blockbuster powers beyond most mere mortals, but not even his magic box-office touch was enough to take a big-budget adaptation of the ‘60s British series The Avengers and turn it into a hit movie nearly 30 years after the show’s final airdate. It definitely wasn’t for lack of effort: Ralph Fiennes and Uma Thurman signed on to play secret agents John Steed and Emma Peel, while Sean Connery co-starred as the villainous weather-controlling madman Sir August de Wynter. But not even the finest cast could have altered the public’s indifference toward a movie based on a property many filmgoers were barely familiar with, and the project was also a fairly odd fit for director Jeremiah Chechik, whose previous credits included National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation. The result was a bruising flop whose failure helped speed Connery’s looming retirement and prompted David Bianculli of the New York Daily News to moan, “This Avengers film is so horrendously, painfully and thoroughly awful, it gives other cinematic clunkers like Ishtar and Howard the Duck a good name.”

Watch Trailer


The Mod Squad (1999) 3%

ModSquad1

During its 1968-73 run on ABC, The Mod Squad was not only a moderate hit, it could be argued that the show was actually important: with its hippies-solving-crimes formula and a focus on multicultural storylines, it helped make the counterculture safe for mainstream American audiences. But it was also very much a product of its time (example: the cringeworthy promo tagline “One White, One Black, One Blonde”), and when MGM decided to give the Squad a new look with 1999’s Scott Silver-directed movie, the results were disastrous. Despite an attractive cast led by Claire Danes, Giovanni Ribisi, and Omar Epps, the updated Mod Squad petered out at 4 percent on the Tomatometer, thanks to what the Palo Alto Weekly’s Jim Shelby called “a pristine example of incoherent storyline mixed with poor editing and limp writing.”

Watch Trailer


McHale's Navy (1997) 3%

MchalesNavy3

The McHale’s Navy TV series was so successful that midway through its run, it spawned a 1964 theatrical effort that managed to sell tickets despite the obvious fact that it was little more than a 90-minute episode of the show. Thirty years later, none of the above should have indicated to any rational person that the world was waiting for a goofy McHale’s update starring Tom Arnold, Tim Curry, and David Alan Grier, but that’s still what we got in 1997. Fresh off the Mighty Morphin Power Rangers movie and in the midst of a banner year that also included the Tim Allen/Kirstie Alley vehicle For Richer or Poorer, director Bryan Spicer assembled an alleged comedy following the exploits of the original McHale’s son (played by Arnold) who’s drawn out of retirement in order to combat the world’s second-best terrorist (Curry). The finished product, as Liam Lacy decreed for the Globe and Mail, was “A useless movie. Not funny, suspenseful, moving or even offensive enough to want to torpedo. Just devoid of any conceivable value.”

Watch Trailer


Car 54, Where Are You? (1994) 0%

Car54WhereAreYou

It’s hardly remembered as a TV classic today, but Car 54, Where Are You? was an Emmy-winning hit during its two-season run on NBC from 1961-’63, and its premise — centering on the goofy misadventures of a pair of Bronx cops (played by Joe E. Ross and Fred Gwynne) — should have been fairly easy to bring to the big screen. Unfortunately, something unfunny happened along the way, and Tapeheads director Bill Fishman’s adaptation was doomed well before it even arrived in theaters. In fact, the movie version of Car 54 — with David “Buster Poindexter” Johansen and future Scrubs star John C. McGinley subbing in for Ross and Gwynne — moldered in the studio’s vault for years before finally puttering into cineplexes in 1994. Ultimately, it needn’t have bothered; despite appearances from original stars Al Lews and Nipsey Russell, the results proved a thoroughly misbegotten effort to update the show’s campy laughs. “Some movies are so bad they warrant special attention,” warned the Chicago Tribune’s Jim Petrakis. “Car 54, Where Are You is one of them.”

Watch Trailer

  • TomNewYorker

    I actulley liked
    Land Of The Lost, Bewitched, Beverly Hillbillies & Dukes Of Hazzards.

    My 10 Worst Movies based on Tv Shows are
    1-The Avengers
    2-Wild Wild West
    3-The Last Airbender
    4-Barney’s Great Adventure
    5-Car 54: Where Are You
    6-Thje Box
    7-I Spy
    8-Lost In Space
    9-McHale’s Navy
    10-The Mod Squad

    My 10 Favorite Movies based on Tv Shows are
    1-Starsky & Hutch
    2-South Park: Bigger, Longer Uncut
    3-21 Jump Street
    4-Charlie’s Angels
    5-Mission Impossible
    6-The Dukes Of Hazzards
    7-Crocodile Hunter: Collison Course
    8-Scooby Doo
    9-The Equalizer
    10-Land Of The Lost

    • skywalkr2

      Glad to meet another person that enjoys Starsky and Hutch. I knew there had to be another person out there.

      • Brian

        Starsky and Hutch was enjoyable.

      • Starsky and Hutch was good.

    • Tbear

      The Fugitive – easily the best movie based on a TV show
      The Brady Bunch Movie – honorable mention, here’s to being meta

    • Lost In Space is a very Good movie 🙂

      • MK Ozzie

        Watch the television show… IT… the show… staying true to the characters and how they inter-related, could have been made into a great movie. The movie was good,,, for those who didn’t grow up watching the show; but then WHY make a movie BASED on a beloved TV show if you’re going to make major changes to the story line and / or characters personalities and behavior, If it wasn’t called “Lost In Space” and different names for the characters… I would have liked it.
        What would be great is to redo the show, even the movie. Modernize… fine… but stick to the basic formula we all loved, example:
        Guy Williams, as “John Robinson”, just epitomized all the best in a man… strong & tall with amazing looks, wonderful husband & father, even tempered, thoughtful and considerate in every situation; NOT a reactionary… all this, WHILE being a scientist, explorer & leader of the “expedition”. There was no lack of attention or respect from “John Robinson” for any family or other member of their group, just the opposite.
        The movie must have been made by those who’d never watched, or had forgotten, the essence of the inter-relationships of the group…. just so very disappointing…. you can catch re-runs on HULU.

  • Aimee Cooper

    The Mod Squad was more than a “moderate” hit; it was a major hit, that teens embraced eagerly. Exciting, heartbreaking, and truly groundbreaking, it showed how three lost souls came together as a family, and faced injustices in the world head-on. They took on issues from abortion to war, drugs to cults; that was something you just didn’t see yet in other shows. Every kid either wanted to be Linc or Pete, and lord knows, every girl wanted to be Julie. But the movie version was bloody awful, because, among other things, the characters were unrecognizable. They turned Pete, who was James Dean-like, passionate yet confused as to his place in the world, into a clown. The original Linc fought for racial understanding, and Julie was “a bird with a broken wing”, almost too gentle and kind for the world around her. In the movie she was a kung-fu brat. If you are going to do a movie version of a beloved show, drama or comedy, than pay it some respect, or don’t do it at all.

  • cristina willigs

    jem is a trainwreck and will bomb hard cause it has nothing to do with the cartoon, and will bomb harder than any bad adaptation before cause it has NOTHING to do with the 80s cartoon, so how much the people producing this garbage is paying everybody to make fair reviews??

    • But it’s at 23% right now…

      • cristina willigs

        im sure they are using a bot, cause last night teatres were full of empty chairs

        • Jim222001

          At RogerEbert.com a critic gave it ***. I have no idea why.

  • Vits/Vicente Torres

    1/10: LAND OF THE LOST; I SPY; DUKES OF HAZZARD; MOD SQUAD
    3/10: WILD WILD WEST
    6/10: BEWITCHED

  • Grokenstein

    Josie and the Pussycats (technically a comic book but was much more popular as a cartoon) missed the cut with its 53% Tomatometer, but yeah…that one should’ve been sent to outer space.

  • Daniel Crowley

    So apparently Avatar isn’t a Tv show, and Shyamalan’s movie wasn’t bad enough to be on this list.

    • Charles Ranier

      THERE IS NO LAST AIRBENDER MOVIE, IT NEVER HAPPENED, LALALALALA I CAN’T HEAR YOU

    • Vits/Vicente Torres

      I think they wanted to focus on modern movies based on old shows.

      • Tura Satana

        It doesn’t say so anywhere – but indeed they are all old shows. Wait, where is Dark Shadows?

        • Vits/Vicente Torres

          DARK SHADOWS’ rating isn’t low enough.

    • Thomas

      Avatar is a cartoon for kids. It doesn’t count.

      • Thomas

        Then again, it did win Worst Picture in 2010, so I suppose it does count.

      • Daniel Crowley

        It’s a TV Show.

      • So was Jem and the Holograms, but that was the example in the lead-in paragraph.

  • I actually do like the Beverly Hillbillies movie, the rest I agree are awful, however.

  • CD

    Should be “based on”. Never ever use “off of”, in any context.

  • Jim222001

    I liked Land of the Lost. It deserves higher ratings due to some good laughs. Lost in Space was worse and isn’t on the list.

  • memu

    Where’s “The Last Airbender”?

  • Tura Satana

    That’s Bruce Campbell! “McHale’s update starring Tom Arnold, Tim Curry, and David Alan Grier,” says the text. Starring BRUUUUCE and some other dudes you might have heard of, like Tim Curry, surely? I may have to see this turd now…

    • EB

      And French Stewart is in that photo too. Still, I too would absolutely list Bruce Campbell above all the others mentioned.

  • I like more ” LAND OF THE LOST – WILD WILD WEST “

  • Matthew W

    Millions of stories to told on film and the crap they make is movies from tv shows.

  • Radknight

    ‘Land of the Lost’ wasn’t *that* bad. A lot of silly/funny parts to cover the bad such as most of what Chaka got up to. A well deserved 26% but not so bad as to specifically list it here.

  • bicyclebill

    “Bewitched” (the TV show) was actually based in part on a 1942 movie, “I Married a Witch” which starred Frederic March, Veronica Lake, and Susan Hayward.  So the original movie prompted a TV show which in turn prompted a second movie, thus completing the circle.

    -“BB”-

Tag Cloud

American Society of Cinematographers Heroines President Spring TV Polls and Games Fall TV TIFF thriller teaser medical drama Trailer adaptation political drama Netflix Emmy Nominations miniseries 2019 DC streaming service Pride Month Ghostbusters Awards Tour casting Tarantino History Musical aliens 20th Century Fox golden globes psychological thriller dceu Action Opinion APB Lucasfilm Rock VICE Walt Disney Pictures Set visit Reality SundanceTV San Diego Comic-Con Elton John supernatural spinoff Comics on TV nature crime thriller Martial Arts Food Network jamie lee curtis E! sequel Election Starz Logo Valentine's Day Video Games Song of Ice and Fire Film Festival Mystery Red Carpet Warner Bros. The Witch Freeform Hulu New York Comic Con DC Comics Thanksgiving Cannes Disney Channel CBS All Access The Arrangement theme song docudrama animated YouTube Red AMC sports Comedy Central science fiction RT21 Western cats PBS VH1 Awards Country 45 Showtime SDCC Drama WGN Podcast Stephen King Spectrum Originals Star Wars cinemax TCM mockumentary Paramount facebook Universal cooking adventure Best and Worst First Look Emmys 2018 Crackle FX IFC Films biography El Rey zombie based on movie GLAAD Anna Paquin Brie Larson CMT Amazon Prime psycho travel Certified Fresh Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Paramount Network game show Reality Competition Cosplay Pop Winter TV Comedy Toys Nickelodeon Character Guide diversity Sneak Peek Shudder Photos WarnerMedia comic USA Black Mirror TBS X-Men Biopics Oscars justice league romance true crime Mary Poppins Returns Sony Pictures FXX Vudu USA Network Rom-Com Trophy Talk RT History 2017 technology Extras HBO Max Trivia dc Musicals BBC richard e. Grant Music serial killer spy thriller Pixar Masterpiece unscripted period drama Fox News PaleyFest DirecTV TCA YA cops Ellie Kemper Acorn TV sitcom Countdown CBS doctor who Star Trek BBC America disaster Epix Marathons Sci-Fi Women's History Month Super Bowl YouTube Premium FOX Amazon Columbia Pictures Sundance Now ratings TNT space Premiere Dates anime spider-man talk show NBC Nominations E3 Cartoon Network 21st Century Fox crime witnail SXSW strong female leads Shondaland MCU war TCA 2017 TV Land Quiz Mary Tyler Moore GoT Mary poppins Syfy vampires DC Universe award winner Christmas toy story robots Pirates Summer festivals LGBTQ politics The CW Apple streaming ESPN Mindy Kaling Animation Superheroe ABC Family Esquire IFC HBO Teen Grammys BET MTV crossover hist Spike Bravo social media dramedy Calendar LGBT Creative Arts Emmys A&E finale cults MSNBC National Geographic Tomatazos comiccon 2016 ABC Interview composers Marvel police drama Infographic CNN DGA singing competition mutant Rocky harry potter Year in Review Sundance transformers blaxploitation Captain marvel Winners TruTV Britbox Adult Swim Kids & Family ITV elevated horror historical drama television Tumblr what to watch Lionsgate Ovation Holidays Comic Book binge 007 discovery natural history Lifetime 2015 See It Skip It zero dark thirty TLC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pet Sematary Chernobyl boxoffice OWN TV Box Office GIFs Fantasy Dark Horse Comics NYCC Rocketman Superheroes Watching Series Horror green book crime drama 24 frames anthology Writers Guild of America Disney CW Seed Nat Geo dragons Mudbound zombies Schedule