Total Recall

Total Recall: James McAvoy's Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the X-Men: First Class star.

by | June 1, 2011 | Comments

James McAvoy

Since breaking into the film business in the mid-1990s, James McAvoy has collected a pile of positive reviews and award nominations, and he’s done it while dividing his time between thoughtful independent fare (like The Last King of Scotland) and big-budget blockbusters (such as Wanted). But all that was merely a prelude for this weekend, when McAvoy suits up as the mighty (and decidedly wheelchair-free) Charles Xavier in X-Men: First Class. With a starring role in one of the summer’s most highly anticipated films under his belt, we thought it was about time to take a look at some of the brightest spots in McAvoy’s filmography, Total Recall style. Let’s get started!


10. Gnomeo and Juliet

In early 2011, McAvoy entered the world of family-friendly 3D CGI with Gnomeo & Juliet, in which squabbling clans of garden gnomes re-enact the classic Shakespeare tragedy to the strains of Elton John’s greatest hits. An odd blend, right down to a voice cast that included McAvoy, Michael Caine, Jason Statham, Ozzy Osbourne, and Hulk Hogan — but it got a smile out of critics like Film School Rejects’ Robert Levin, who called it “The greatest film ever made about living, breathing garden gnomes.”


9. Becoming Jane

Nobody did star-crossed love like Jane Austen, so it’s only fitting that, with 2007’s Becoming Jane, the endlessly screen-friendly author got to have a forbidden love affair of her own. The movie’s casual relationship with historical fact — not to mention Anne Hathaway’s unsteady accent in the starring role — was a source of consternation for some, but whatever its flaws, Jane gave audiences a peek at the unconsummated love that might have existed between Austen and the young lawyer Thomas Lefroy. Duane Dudek of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel was one of its supporters, calling it “An evocative portrait of an artistic temperament in defiance of propriety and of how, when such things are repressed, passion and personality are revealed in acts of private ritual and public performance.”


8. Wimbledon

Wimbledon really belonged to Paul Bettany and Kirsten Dunst, but McAvoy notched a scene-stealing supporting turn in this 2004 romantic comedy, playing Bettany’s obnoxiously funny brother (and getting some of the movie’s best lines in the process). Although filmgoers weren’t particularly interested in watching a love story blossom on the tennis court, most critics thought Wimbledon was a pretty good match — including Rick Kisonak of Film Threat, who wrote, “You aren’t likely to see a film with more warmth and good humor anytime soon, or one that does more to give feel good filmmaking a good name.”


7. Bright Young Things

Multi-hyphenate talent Stephen Fry made his directorial debut with this ensemble period drama, which adapts Evelyn Waugh’s novel Vile Bodies, about the exploits of well-to-do young Londoners during the 1920s, 1930s, and 1940s. Overstuffed to a fault, Bright Young Things alternately delighted and confounded critics who found it difficult to draw a common thread between its chaotic jumble of plots and an eclectic, unwieldy cast that included McAvoy, Michael Sheen, Jim Broadbent, Peter O’Toole, and Dan Aykroyd. “The episodic structure gets more unwieldy as the story progresses,” observed Steve Schneider of the Orlando Weekly, “but there’s still room for some rewarding dalliances.”


6. The Last Station

The last days of Leo Tolstoy may not seem like the most obvious inspiration for a movie, but what The Last Station lacks in marquee sparkle, it makes up in opportunities for its talented cast to showcase their prodigious gifts. McAvoy co-stars here as part of an impressive ensemble that includes Paul Giamatti, Helen Mirren, and Christopher Plummer, as the dying author whose legacy sparks the battle at the heart of the plot. Even for a low-budget independent feature, Station underperformed at the box office, failing to recoup its budget, but most critics thought it was worth a look. “If you come to this expecting the philosophical depth and psychological detail of Tolstoy’s work you’re sure to be disappointed,” wrote J.R. Jones of the Chicago Reader, “but as an actors’ romp it’s delectable.”


5. Wanted

McAvoy’s Everyman appeal came in handy for this adaptation of the Mark Millar comic book series, which follows the evolution of an office drone (McAvoy) who finds himself unexpectedly recruited by a shadowy network of assassins called The Fraternity (whose members include Angelina Jolie and Morgan Freeman). Thoroughly unhinged from reality, but bursting at the seams with eyebrow-raising action sequences, Wanted lived up to its title at the box office, where it raked in more than $340 million — and it didn’t do too badly with critics, either. Cole Smithey joined the chorus of applause for the film, writing, “You’ll come for the action; you’ll enjoy it more because of James McAvoy.”


4. The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe

McAvoy took a role among the star-studded supporting cast of this big-budget, family-friendly adaptation of the C.S. Lewis classic, appearing as Mr. Tumnus, a faun who leaves the court of the White Witch to fight with the friends of Aslan (voiced by Liam Neeson). It may not have afforded McAvoy the most screen time he’d ever seen, but it did give him an opportunity to be part of a $745 million blockbuster that brought a beloved book to the screen — and earned the approval of critics like the Atlantic City Weekly’s Lori Hoffman, who wrote, “The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe is a fable that captures a fully realized landscape of honor, love, sacrifice, betrayal and forgiveness.”


3. Atonement

Director Joe Wright turned Ian McEwen’s bestselling novel into an Academy Award-winning film with this 2007 adaptation, starring Saoirse Ronan and Keira Knightley as Briony and Cecilia Tallis, a pair of sisters living in 1930s England whose relationship is forever altered after Briony makes an impetuous (and false) allegation against Cecilia’s boyfriend (McAvoy). Offering war, teary-eyed romance, and period sweep, Atonement instantly marked Ronan as one to watch, and although a substantial number of critics felt it didn’t match the power of the book, most thought it came close enough, and the Orlando Sentinel’s Roger Moore went so far as to call it “A film that instantly joins the ranks of the great screen romances.”


2. The Last King of Scotland

It’s often said that the greatest trick the devil ever played was convincing the world he didn’t exist, but sometimes we can convince ourselves even if we can see the devil staring right at us. That’s the moral of The Last King of Scotland, the story of a Scottish doctor (McAvoy) who finds himself seduced by the charisma and opulent wealth of Ugandan dictator Idi Amin (Forest Whitaker), rationalizing the regime’s horrific brutality until it’s impossible to ignore — and almost impossible to escape. McAvoy took home a Best Supporting Actor BAFTA nomination for his work, Whitaker netted the Best Actor Oscar, and the film earned unqualified praise from critics like Heather Huntington of ReelzChannel, who wrote, “This isn’t just a moral cause movie for New Yorker-reading smartypants to brag to their friends that they saw to show how in-the-know they are. The Last King of Scotland deserves every good thing that has been said about it, and then some.”


1. Starter for 10

Screenwriter David Nicholls adapted his own novel for this low-key 2006 coming-of-age dramedy, which follows a British university student (McAvoy) as he struggles to reconcile his college life with his working-class roots — and tries to choose between a pair of impossibly beautiful love interests (Alice Eve and Rebecca Hall). While certainly built with familiar ingredients, Starter for 10 earned critical praise for its sweetly sentimental tone, funny script, and likable cast; as Michael Szymanski wrote for, it’s “Pure feel-good romantic nostalgia, whether you lived in 1980’s London or not.”

In case you were wondering, here are McAvoy’s top 10 movies according RT users’ scores:

1. Rory O’Shea Was Here — 88%

2. The Last King of Scotland — 87%

3. Atonement — 79%

4. Becoming Jane — 75%

5. Penelope — 74%

6. Wanted — 72%

7. The Conspirator — 69%

8. The Last Station — 65%

9. Starter for 10 — 64%

10. Bright Young Things — 63%

Take a look through McAvoy’s complete filmography, as well as the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out the reviews for X-Men: First Class.

Finally, here’s McAvoy in his movie debut — 1995’s The Near Room (NSFW — language):

Tag Cloud

talk show ITV genre 2015 Wes Anderson war IFC critics cancelled television crime thriller Tokyo Olympics HBO Go Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt leaderboard comics MCU New York Comic Con period drama Spectrum Originals sag awards Peacock Mudbound disaster Calendar adventure Binge Guide festival sequel nbcuniversal australia Brie Larson halloween CBS All Access thriller slasher SXSW 2022 travel Podcast wonder woman MSNBC DC Comics Amazon Prime Video Pirates TCA Winter 2020 high school foreign Academy Awards Trophy Talk slashers ABC Signature Film BBC One Musicals First Reviews Infographic USA Network black harry potter cancelled TV shows BAFTA Alien Photos Cartoon Network obituary book stoner Character Guide Arrowverse mcc king arthur interviews mutant new star wars movies archives legend Emmys target scene in color TLC The Academy Classic Film zero dark thirty LGBT SXSW movies Nat Geo Captain marvel Black Mirror South by Southwest Film Festival BET rotten Mary Poppins Returns royal family PBS cartoon Family international scary movies italian Watching Series Fall TV cars FX on Hulu joker rt labs critics edition 2017 Pop TV 94th Oscars Fargo American Society of Cinematographers japan Tarantino screenings IMDb TV Sundance TV social media Pacific Islander justice league Valentine's Day Emmy Nominations saw Box Office trailers comic book movies superman Musical teaser marvel comics X-Men OneApp Comedy Ghostbusters toy story doctor who Shondaland Showtime biography PaleyFest 2018 diversity A&E Marathons RT History GIFs sitcom Amazon Studios HFPA anime superhero cults transformers VOD japanese cats Stephen King films Year in Review Star Trek comedies YouTube Premium target Tomatazos Teen BBC Reality blaxploitation versus rom-coms police drama GoT Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cops rt archives new york AMC spider-man remakes Syfy VICE TCA Awards summer TV laika TV movies IFC Films golden globe awards Comic-Con@Home 2021 obi wan Food Network dark Horror game show DC Universe natural history Creative Arts Emmys strong female leads medical drama reboot Hallmark Christmas movies Disney streaming service Martial Arts festivals San Diego Comic-Con serial killer true crime Thanksgiving DirecTV Superheroes Paramount Pictures ghosts 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Hollywood Foreign Press Association Fox News Best Picture History live event ESPN 1990s Opinion space 24 frames Hallmark Best and Worst green book satire The CW christmas movies Neflix Logo robots cancelled TV series romance telelvision mission: impossible hollywood Focus Features Mary poppins Country CBS The Purge crime south america Schedule ID scary spider-verse Sony Trivia zombies Oscars 79th Golden Globes Awards Marvel Studios ABC Family universal monsters YouTube Red VH1 Summer young adult ratings pirates of the caribbean 2019 french discovery Travel Channel Paramount dceu 007 Cosplay Holiday Chernobyl Marvel Amazon Prime spinoff revenge The Walking Dead popular sequels feel good YA science fiction scorecard deadpool aliens canceled TV shows summer TV preview Best Actress The Arrangement kong political drama based on movie Mystery Legendary Television Critics Association MGM supernatural halloween tv Pop Cannes witnail Song of Ice and Fire adenture NBA President olympics scene in color film series Sundance Now spain indie Indigenous comic books spanish marvel cinematic universe Discovery Channel book adaptation 2020 Television Academy batman Image Comics Comic Book Superheroe game of thrones Spike Crunchyroll Nickelodeon hispanic historical drama canceled venice basketball HBO Max ABC Prime Video Turner miniseries boxoffice comic book movie Awards boxing documentaries adaptation Comedy Central TCM classics Ovation Bravo TruTV elevated horror singing competition vs. die hard parents Tubi suspense Interview Fantasy HBO TIFF Election First Look Lionsgate finale politics zombie golden globes indiana jones 99% Paramount Network Comics on TV Baby Yoda worst movies Sony Pictures quibi all-time Broadway Biopics dexter Winter TV Tags: Comedy Trailer dragons women documentary werewolf USA A24 movie free movies prank franchise TBS Britbox fast and furious FX critic resources Best Actor hist twilight concert 93rd Oscars Tumblr crime drama Rocketman blockbuster mob broadcast NYCC docudrama stand-up comedy award winner Rocky nfl CNN debate Star Wars Celebration APB a nightmare on elm street Animation Exclusive Video FOX jurassic park fresh Rock Star Wars SundanceTV aapi video on demand Super Bowl Acorn TV 2016 YouTube DGA Heroines james bond facebook Starz Polls and Games dreamworks posters Action Extras TV Land composers TV One Instagram Live Video Games godzilla Dark Horse Comics 21st Century Fox Sundance theme song Western Warner Bros. Turner Classic Movies news blockbusters The Walt Disney Company Reality Competition child's play summer preview Certified Fresh asian-american 4/20 Shudder series rt labs heist movie Black History Month LGBTQ gangster sopranos reviews Apple TV+ latino Esquire Women's History Month 72 Emmy Awards Winners El Rey kaiju mockumentary know your critic Marvel Television Apple TV Plus Best Director tv talk E! screen actors guild Universal Pictures Epix AMC Plus animated Masterpiece toronto Christmas romantic comedy Mindy Kaling cooking breaking bad 2021 children's TV Countdown 90s new zealand live action lord of the rings streaming movies video GLAAD Kids & Family Apple Drama NBC Vudu 71st Emmy Awards renewed TV shows Freeform criterion Writers Guild of America OWN name the review chucky Music Lucasfilm Quiz Lifetime Christmas movies king kong Toys Disney Channel RT21 73rd Emmy Awards dc Oscar Funimation Walt Disney Pictures cancelled vampires Paramount Plus Netflix Christmas movies docuseries unscripted Awards Tour TV renewals Film Festival Adult Swim WGN monster movies FXX Endgame Sci-Fi Mary Tyler Moore jamie lee curtis hidden camera Premiere Dates action-comedy cinemax Amazon technology Lifetime spanish language Native Columbia Pictures TV The Witch sports crossover Red Carpet Ellie Kemper Hulu comiccon See It Skip It directors Pet Sematary CW Seed ViacomCBS dramedy PlayStation TCA Set visit Pixar Anna Paquin Disney+ Disney Plus biopic best Elton John Spring TV Crackle comic television Holidays art house TCA 2017 Fox Searchlight rotten movies we love National Geographic anthology SDCC CMT Hear Us Out binge black comedy richard e. Grant casting Pride Month Rom-Com trophy psycho WarnerMedia Disney streaming hispanic heritage month what to watch razzies DC streaming service psychological thriller E3 scene in color Nominations BET Awards Netflix MTV nature Grammys 45 TNT streamig Avengers independent scene in color series kids dogs Universal worst stop motion Geeked Week BBC America football emmy awards spy thriller Disney Plus 20th Century Fox Sneak Peek