Total Recall

Jeff Daniels' 10 Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the Dumb and Dumber To star.

by | November 12, 2014 | Comments

Always an actor first and celebrity second, Jeff Daniels has appeared in scores of films over the last three decades and change without ever commanding a superstar level of attention — but as even a cursory glance at his filmography makes clear, he has a marvelous knack for choosing projects, one that extends to his work on the stage (where he’s earned a Tony nomination) and the small screen (where he won an Emmy for his work on The Newsroom). This weekend, Daniels reunites with his old pal Jim Carrey for the Dumb and Dumber sequel Dumb and Dumber To, and to celebrate, we’ve decided to turn our attention to his most critically beloved efforts. It’s time for Total Recall!

10. Fly Away Home 87%

Little kids and animals often trigger Cuteness Overload warnings for filmgoers over the PG-13 age barrier, and that can be especially true for sun-dappled dramas starring grizzled Hollywood veterans playing emotionally broken parents fumbling to reconnect with their children while also racing against time to solve some critical little kid/animal dilemma. Pretty much all of those boxes are ticked in 1996’s Fly Away Home, but the end result is affecting enough to tug a few strings in all but the hardest of hearts — due in large part to a pair of top-shelf performances from Jeff Daniels and Anna Paquin, starring here as a father-daughter duo who move beyond their painful past in order to save a flock of geese. Saying that the movie’s “tender beauty… goes well beyond what might be expected from a movie about things that hatch,” Janet Maslin of the New York Times applauded director Carroll Ballard for turning “a potentially treacly children’s film into an exhilarating ’90s fable” and added, “See it and you will never look at a down comforter in quite the same way.”

9. The Lookout 87%

Out of Sight and Get Shorty screenwriter Scott Frank made his directorial debut with The Lookout, starring Joseph Gordon-Levitt — then just beginning to demonstrate the knack for picking scripts that had helped him earn raves for Brick two years before — as a callow high school athlete whose foolishness leads to a catastrophic accident that turns his entire life upside down…and puts him in the path of a group of bad people who want to use him for their own nefarious ends. Co-starring Daniels as Gordon-Levitt’s blind roommate and Isla Fisher as the seductive, memorably named Luvlee Lemons, The Lookout didn’t have much of an impact at the box office, but it earned plenty of praise from critics like the AV Club’s Scott Tobias, who wrote that its “thriller elements could stand to be more surprising, but they’re ultimately in service of a better understanding of the characters. Usually, it’s the other way around.”

8. Something Wild 91%

It’s refreshing whenever an actor plays against type, but there’s also something to be said for a script that lets a star sit directly in his or her wheelhouse; for example, here’s Something Wild, in which Daniels plays a buttoned-down stockbroker who makes the fateful decision to accept a ride home from a vivacious stranger (Melanie Griffith), thus setting off a chain of events that finds him an unwilling participant in all manner of ill-advised hijinks — including fending off her enraged husband (Ray Liotta). Subversive, willfully quirky, and thoroughly well-acted, Wild earned applause for its stars as well as for director Jonathan Demme; as James Kendrick wrote for Q Network Film Desk, “The tones shift rampantly, which for some viewers can be disorienting and off-putting. But, if you’re in tune with Demme’s aesthetic, which usually runs counter to our cinematic intuition, it is a wild ride indeed.”

7. Terms of Endearment 78%

Daniels made his cinematic debut in Milos Forman’s 1981 epic Ragtime, but he got his first big break two years later in Terms of Endearment. Writer-director James L. Brooks, working from Larry McMurtry’s novel about the complicated lives and relationships of a mother (Shirley MacLaine) and daughter (Debra Winger), fashioned a critical and commercial sensation that grossed more than $100 million and picked up 11 Oscar nominations (winning five). While none of those trophies went to Daniels, he did earn positive notice for his supporting role as Winger’s rather scummy (and ridiculously named) husband, Flap Horton, and he was hardly alone among an almost uniformly praised cast; as John Ferguson so succinctly put it for Radio Times, “This is American mainstream movie-making at its best.”

6. The Purple Rose of Cairo 92%

After catching Hollywood’s eye in Terms of Endearment, Daniels wasted no time racking up further accolades, picking up a starring (and Golden Globe-nominated) role in Woody Allen’s The Purple Rose of Cairo. Starring Mia Farrow as a mousy waitress toiling her way through a fairly dismal marriage to a rough-tempered drunk (Danny Aiello), the movie offers its heroine an unexpected boost in the form of a movie character (Daniels) who steps out of the screen and into her life. (As she tells her sister, “I just met a wonderful man. He’s fictional, but you can’t have everything.”) Critics were similarly smitten. “To be blunt about it, The Purple Rose of Cairo is pure enchantment,” gushed Vincent Canby of the New York Times. “It’s a sweet, lyrically funny, multi- layered work that again demonstrates that Woody Allen is our premier film maker who, standing something over 5 feet tall in his sneakers, towers above all others.”

5. Arachnophobia 92%

Frank Marshall (backed here by his longtime production partner Steven Spielberg) made his directorial debut with this affectionate, cheerfully creepy tribute to classic Hollywood creature features, in which a deadly breed of spider terrorizes a small town whose residents include a lunatic exterminator (John Goodman) and, of course, a doctor with the titular phobia (Jeff Daniels). “That sound you hear in the background is the ‘ugh!’ heard round the world,” chuckled Janet Maslin of the New York Times, adding, “luckily, Arachnophobia will also be generating its share of boisterous, nervous laughter.”

4. Speed 94%

After Die Hard blew up at the box office, action movies where the setting served as a sort of co-star became a wildly popular trend — to the point where, when Keanu Reeves starred in 1994’s Speed as an LAPD officer trapped on a moving bus that a maniac (Dennis Hopper) has loaded with explosives, it seemed safe to assume that it was just one more of the “Die Hard on a _____” movies that had clogged the cineplex for the past several years. Happily, this one proved a sleekly thrilling exception to the rule, both at the box office — where it racked up more than $350 million worldwide — and among critics, who applauded director Jan de Bont’s lean production, the movie’s uncommonly intelligent screenplay (given an instrumental polish by Joss Whedon), and a terrific cast that also included Sandra Bullock, Alan Ruck, and as Keanu’s steadfast partner, Jeff Daniels. Calling it “clean, delirious, and, yes, speedy,” the New Yorker’s Anthony Lane deemed it “the best big-vehicle-in-peril movie since Clouzot’s The Wages of Fear.”

3. The Squid and the Whale 92%

Round up all the characters in every Noah Baumbach movie, and you’d have yourself a room full of some fairly messed up individuals. Case in point: 2005’s The Squid and the Whale, starring Daniels and Laura Linney as a husband and wife whose messily splintering marriage throws shards that wound their two sons (played by Jesse Eisenberg and Owen Kline) — not that either of the parents seem willing or able to put a stop to their selfish behavior. Like many of Baumbach’s films, Squid puts the viewer in the company of narcissists and misanthropes, but it’s also a piercingly honest look at the ways in which we deal with disappointment when our lives — and our loved ones — let us down. As Roger Ebert put it, “The Squid and the Whale is essentially about how we grow up by absorbing what is useful in our parents and forgiving what is not.”

2. Good Night, and Good Luck 93%

For his directorial follow-up to Confessions of a Dangerous Mind, George Clooney decided to dramatize Senator Joseph McCarthy’s Communist witch hunt — specifically from the viewpoint of CBS News, where legendary anchor Edward R. Murrow (David Strathairn) engaged in a public war of wills against McCarthy while trying to temper the mass hysteria wrought by his adversary’s rabid insistence that all levels of American life had been infiltrated by the Red Menace. Rounded out by a stellar supporting cast (including Daniels as CBS News director Sig Mickelson), Good Night, and Good Luck. earned an impressive six Academy Award nominations — as well as our own Golden Tomato for Best Reviewed Film of 2005 in Limited Release. “By its end,” enthused Movie Mezzanine’s Sam Fragoso, “Good Night, and Good Luck evolves into a prophetic vision of how television and film can be used to illuminate or insulate, educate or entertain.”

1. Looper 93%

A large part of Jeff Daniels’ considerable screen appeal has always been his ability to project an unassuming everyman aura, but acting opposite Joseph Gordon-Levitt seems to bring out the oddball in him: After stealing every scene he was in as Gordon-Levitt’s roommate in The Lookout, Daniels proceeded to do the same in Looper, injecting writer-director Rian Johnson’s thought-provoking sci-fi thriller with a madcap blast of energy as the sociopathic (and perversely likable) mob boss who orders Levitt’s hit man character to kill…well, we don’t want to spoil the fun if you haven’t already seen the movie. Point is, Looper is a lot of fun, not least because of Daniels’ performance, as well as what Deadspin’s Will Leitch called “A wildly entertaining film that isn’t content with science and cinematic tricks. It desires, and achieves, much more.”

Finally, here’s Daniels putting in a plug for his home state:

Tag Cloud

Spring TV VICE Sneak Peek Ellie Kemper FX on Hulu Captain marvel laika miniseries AMC Awards Tour President crime drama First Look Creative Arts Emmys Cartoon Network doctor who Sundance MTV Syfy Super Bowl spinoff 20th Century Fox Turner Classic Movies Discovery Channel Teen Christmas Tomatazos Shondaland south america christmas movies TCM medical drama Heroines ESPN cancelled television Chilling Adventures of Sabrina best adaptation Holiday screen actors guild comics stoner BBC America parents CMT strong female leads facebook boxoffice stop motion Masterpiece vampires Premiere Dates Stephen King WarnerMedia Holidays Shudder remakes Pet Sematary cooking Rock zero dark thirty Apple TV Plus Interview Mystery jamie lee curtis witnail latino Oscars Fantasy Starz hispanic green book Extras Amazon Prime Chernobyl Superheroe book Country movie The Purge BET CBS DC Comics TV Land Classic Film Apple TV+ NYCC satire FX Film sequels fast and furious Summer Women's History Month kids streaming Acorn TV BET Awards APB stand-up comedy Winter TV richard e. Grant rotten movies we love MSNBC scary movies Pixar teaser 2016 indiana jones The CW DC streaming service worst 2019 Sundance Now Cannes spy thriller YouTube Premium Comedy Esquire talk show 2017 psychological thriller crime thriller Disney Channel X-Men cancelled TV series Cosplay adventure comiccon anthology sitcom Ghostbusters serial killer reviews Spike Opinion Schedule CW Seed werewolf superhero Musicals Hear Us Out TV renewals YA A&E VOD Black Mirror casting Warner Bros. mutant Lucasfilm zombie die hard Fox News binge Pop TV Brie Larson Hallmark nfl Rocky Lionsgate Year in Review Dark Horse Comics Biopics PaleyFest Marvel Studios Awards cancelled video on demand Anna Paquin rotten science fiction OneApp Netflix mission: impossible spanish language Paramount Rom-Com Sci-Fi Box Office concert GoT harry potter National Geographic Red Carpet Funimation San Diego Comic-Con Trophy Talk psycho Tubi The Walking Dead VH1 Watching Series cartoon TCA Winter 2020 Elton John Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Amazon Prime Video Comedy Central classics Winners golden globes blockbuster LGBTQ Reality Martial Arts Film Festival Freeform Kids & Family Amazon Studios festival sag awards Pop Tarantino TV directors Horror Song of Ice and Fire composers Epix Netflix Christmas movies Writers Guild of America Mary Tyler Moore Certified Fresh Lifetime E! Nat Geo theme song social media singing competition versus Countdown Comic Book 21st Century Fox 72 Emmy Awards DC Universe Infographic Video Games Rocketman Drama revenge toy story Arrowverse 2018 Grammys Lifetime Christmas movies Television Critics Association crossover Comics on TV DGA festivals what to watch unscripted free movies comic cults cinemax FOX Star Trek crime emmy awards war Toys TruTV HBO Max Valentine's Day TCA 2017 worst movies Turner Star Wars Disney Plus police drama Amazon RT21 The Arrangement nature Sundance TV HBO Go Walt Disney Pictures documentary History HBO Academy Awards ghosts Animation justice league Britbox chucky WGN Character Guide Quiz travel screenings Fall TV foreign Spectrum Originals space RT History Family series 45 Reality Competition obituary IFC Films biography Baby Yoda ABC 24 frames LGBT FXX The Witch historical drama nbcuniversal Black History Month movies halloween independent Photos Paramount Network venice Food Network Trivia canceled TV shows Disney Emmys Nominations hist SundanceTV See It Skip It 007 PlayStation thriller diversity football Logo Apple Thanksgiving Sony Pictures renewed TV shows USA Podcast dragons Marathons discovery award winner Marvel E3 Musical New York Comic Con joker Tumblr IFC video dramedy toronto A24 sequel 71st Emmy Awards Marvel Television Disney+ Disney Plus CNN Hallmark Christmas movies Pirates universal monsters disaster Travel Channel a nightmare on elm street Endgame politics dark natural history Mudbound romance TIFF robots OWN El Rey USA Network Mary poppins SDCC critics YouTube Red dogs GIFs criterion ABC Family Superheroes political drama Mindy Kaling cancelled TV shows NBC Columbia Pictures television asian-american Avengers Peacock romantic comedy Western scorecard slashers Ovation based on movie BBC One Action Hulu hollywood Binge Guide TLC game of thrones elevated horror news twilight technology DirecTV BAFTA SXSW name the review Polls and Games canceled children's TV documentaries Calendar GLAAD breaking bad Music period drama indie Election Trailer transformers PBS Emmy Nominations sports Disney streaming service Mary Poppins Returns TBS American Society of Cinematographers docudrama spain Nickelodeon Universal Showtime child's play Adult Swim ITV 4/20 Best and Worst Television Academy quibi batman mockumentary CBS All Access Set visit TCA Awards animated Bravo TCA cats cops comedies YouTube ratings blaxploitation tv talk true crime game show all-time First Reviews Crunchyroll supernatural anime dceu spider-man dc MCU cars 2015 2020 finale BBC TNT zombies films franchise aliens Crackle Pride Month Vudu reboot