Total Recall

Jared Leto's Best Movies

In this week's Total Recall, we take a look back at the most acclaimed work of the Suicide Squad star.

by | August 3, 2016 | Comments

This weekend, the movie everyone’s talking about is Suicide Squad — and while a number of cast members have earned critical applause for their efforts, it’s Jared Leto‘s turn as the Joker that we’ve all been waiting to see. In honor of that moment’s eagerly anticipated arrival, we’re dedicating this week’s feature to a fond look back at some of the brightest critical highlights from the Oscar-winning star’s career, and the results add up to one admirably eclectic journey. It’s time for Total Recall!

 Prefontaine (1997) 56%

Leto was still Jordan Catalano from My So-Called Life in a lot of filmgoers’ eyes when he scored the leading role in Prefontaine — but those who passed on director Steve James‘ biopic about the titular Olympic runner missed the opportunity to see the results of Leto’s Method dedication for the first time on the big screen. As he would with subsequent roles, Leto dove in completely, adopting Prefontaine’s voice and running style; the end result, coupled with an already-eerie physical similarity, went a long way toward proving he was more than just a pretty face. Alas, the rest of the movie didn’t quite live up to Leto’s efforts, and many critics dismissed Prefontaine as a TV-worthy hagiography — but it did have its fans, including Roger Ebert, who wrote, “Here is a sports movie in the tradition of the best sportswriting, where athletes are portrayed warts and all. You do not have to be nice to win races, but you have to be good.”

Watch Trailer

How to Make an American Quilt (1995) 63%

Fresh off My So-Called Life, Leto got his big-screen break with a supporting part in director Jocelyn Moorhouse‘s adaptation of the Whitney Otto novel How to Make an American Quilt. Starring Winona Ryder (with whom Leto would later share screen time in Girl, Interrupted), the movie offers an episodic look at the stories of a group of women who seek to soothe the nerves of a bride-to-be by sharing some hard-won wisdom from their own pasts. Leto’s role, as the hunky kid who engages in an interracial affair with his family’s servant, takes up a relatively brief portion of the movie — but it got him started at the movies, and played a part in a modest critical and commercial hit that, as the New York Times’ Caryn James wrote, “takes the makings of a limp ‘women’s weeper’ and as if by magic, spins them into gold.”

Watch Trailer

Lord of War (2005) 61%

How many chances does a guy get in life to play one half of a pair of arms-dealing brothers opposite Nicolas Cage? Leto got his opportunity with Lord of War, writer-director Andrew Niccol‘s 2005 war crime drama about a couple of crazy kids with a dream to make a bunch of money by selling lethal weapons to anyone with enough money to make the sale. The end result of years of research on Niccol’s part, it seethes with righteous anger without tipping over into didacticism — and offers Cage and Leto plenty of material to sink their dramatic teeth into, including an arc for Leto’s character that includes drug addiction in addition to morally reprehensible gun-running. “Niccol is no stranger to hot-button issues,” wrote Time Out’s Dave Calhoun, “but he outdoes his previous efforts by injecting this satire of war profiteering in the Halliburton age with a wicked arsenic wit.”

Watch Trailer

Mr. Nobody (2009) 68%

Leto’s fondness for projects lying off the beaten path was further reflected in Mr. Nobody, writer-director Jaco Van Dormael‘s sci-fi drama about a 118-year-old man whose memories send him back to three critical junctures in his long life — and send the viewer wandering along alternate timelines that might have resulted from different decisions along the way. The movie bowed in Venice in 2009 and didn’t make it to the States for another four years, the kind of delay that often suggests more than a few fundamental flaws in a film — yet while it wasn’t exactly rapturously received by critics, reviews outlined a picture whose charms outweighed its circular, meandering narrative. “Never mind that several characters seem to gain or lose British accents throughout the course of the film,” wrote the Washington Post’s Michael O’Sullivan. “The lack of continuity only enhances the sense of deliciously dizzying disequilibrium.”

Watch Trailer

American Psycho (2000) 69%

It took nine years, but Bret Easton Ellis’ controversial 1991 novel got the big-screen treatment with this adaptation, which cast Christian Bale as the loathsome, status-obsessed serial killer Patrick Bateman, Reese Witherspoon as his equally shallow girlfriend, and Leto as a smarmy co-worker whose superior business card sets off the movie’s killing spree. Though many of the cultural touchstones described in the book had faded by the time American Psycho reached the screen, its central observations — and the consumer culture that produced them — remained as timely as ever. Its torrent of generally unappealing behavior and horrific violence make Psycho an unpleasant film, but one that, in the words of Time’s Richard Corliss, “needs to be seen and appreciated, like a serpent in a glass cage.”

Watch Trailer

Panic Room (2002) 76%

A claustrophobic thriller with the heart of a B movie, Panic Room found director David Fincher wielding a stellar cast (including Jodie Foster, Forest Whitaker, and a young Kristen Stewart) and dropping them in the middle of a tightly wound, tension-filled storyline. Panic sets in almost immediately, with single parent Meg Altman (Foster) and her daughter Sarah (Stewart) spending their first night in the huge Manhattan brownstone Meg has just purchased; what Meg and Sarah don’t know is that their new home contains some very valuable hidden treasure — as well as a trio of very bad men (including the skin-crawling Dwight Yoakam and a mysteriously cornrowed Leto) who will stop at nothing to steal it. Ultimately, Panic Room is mostly just a nail-biter — albeit one assembled with uncommon flair. “This is just a big, dumb, commercial suspenser,” admitted Empire’s Caroline Westbrook, “but it’s one of the best for ages, reminding us that it is still possible to make a high-quality piece of popcorn entertainment.”

Watch Trailer

The Thin Red Line (1998) 81%

Marking director Terrence Malick’s return from a 20-year absence and featuring the work of a stellar ensemble cast that included Leto, Woody Harrelson, Adrien Brody, George Clooney, John Cusack, and Sean Penn, The Thin Red Line was the film buff event of 1998. Even with a 170-minute running time, there wasn’t enough Line to go around — in fact, during all the whittling between its five-hour first cut and the theatrical version, Malick excised entire performances by Martin Sheen, Gary Oldman, Billy Bob Thornton, Viggo Mortensen and others, meaning that even if Leto’s performance as Second Lieutenant Floyd Whyte isn’t his biggest role, it’s really saying something that it ended up in the movie at all. And for most critics, there was no arguing with the end result; as Norman Green wrote for, “It wrestles with complexity, speaks to us in poetry, weaves multiple narrative strands into a tapestry, opens the festering wounds of war and gazes inside without blinking.”

Watch Trailer

Requiem for a Dream (2000) 79%

Like the Hubert Selby, Jr. novel from which it’s adapted, Darren Aronofsky‘s Requiem for a Dream is certainly not for everyone. An unflinching look at the misery of addiction, Requiem follows the hellish descents of a widow named Sara Goldfarb (Ellen Burstyn), her son Harry (Jared Leto), his girlfriend Marion (Jennifer Connelly), and Harry’s friend Tyrone (Marlon Wayans). After 102 minutes, all four characters have been pretty well run through the wringer; Burstyn winds up institutionalized, Leto loses an arm, Wayans has to go cold turkey in a jail cell — and Connelly crosses paths with Big Tim, played with thoroughly skeevy elan by Keith David. Good taste prevents us from getting into the exact nature of their relationship; suffice it to say that Connelly’s character arc demonstrates that some people will do just about anything to get their fix, and David’s performance reminds us that other people will stoop at nothing to take advantage of an addict. “Never have we been taken this close to the edge, and never have the characters teetering over it elicited so much sympathy,” wrote Eugene Novikov of Film Blather. ” Requiem is difficult to watch, but it richly rewards those who stay with it.”

Watch Trailer

Fight Club (1999) 79%

Yes, we are going to talk about Fight Club. Initially rejected by critics and ignored by audiences, director David Fincher’s third feature steadily built a cult following on DVD; these days, it’s widely regarded as one of the best films of the ‘90s, which not only helped reaffirm Fincher as a director of stylishly thoughtful fare, but established the Hollywood bona fides of author Chuck Palahniuk, from whose novel the movie was adapted. The plot follows the eager descent of a nameless protagonist (Edward Norton) into the anti-establishment crusade of Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt), who organizes the titular underground brawling network whose participants include the ill-fated Angel Face (Leto). On a deeper level, the story functions as a bloody, black-humored indictment of consumer culture, but more importantly, in the words of ReelView’s James Berardinelli, “Fight Club is a memorable and superior motion picture — a rare movie that does not abandon insight in its quest to jolt the viewer.”

Watch Trailer

Dallas Buyers Club (2013) 92%

Nothing screams “for your consideration” like an actor physically transforming himself for a role, to the point that it’s become something of a signal for filmgoers cynical enough to be suspicious of a star’s motivations when taking a part. But as often as not, that commitment pays off; just ask Jared Leto, whose rather frightening pre-shooting regimen included dropping more than 40 pounds to portray Rayon, the transgender HIV-positive woman whose story lends a poignant anchor to Jean-Marc Vallée‘s fact-based Dallas Buyers Club. Academy voters ultimately honored the movie with six nominations — three of which it won, including Best Actor for Matthew McConaughey and Best Supporting Actor for Leto. “Dallas Buyers Club represents the best of what independent film on a limited budget can achieve,” wrote Rex Reed for the New York Observer. “Powerful, enlightening and not to be missed.”

Watch Trailer

Tag Cloud

classics Focus Features trailers franchise Discovery Channel BBC America Brie Larson 73rd Emmy Awards Hallmark Christmas movies crime drama TCA 2017 CNN Nominations Disney obi wan adaptation Song of Ice and Fire archives TV Land supernatural Apple TV+ breaking bad YouTube films Arrowverse thriller Superheroes space 2015 YouTube Premium Broadway live action critic resources animated Paramount Network true crime Horror Family Peacock posters Elton John adenture President disaster fast and furious period drama feel good obituary golden globe awards new star wars movies book adaptation Sundance TV Extras sag awards BBC One Opinion The Purge hidden camera Food Network The Academy Amazon Prime Film Festival prank First Reviews Best Director Lucasfilm Infographic transformers Quiz South by Southwest Film Festival Walt Disney Pictures Fox News Exclusive Video Musical Cosplay halloween miniseries french romantic comedy social media Polls and Games Rocky Amazon Prime Video Black History Month dogs popular hist critics CMT Captain marvel biography New York Comic Con adventure El Rey sports rt archives Calendar rom-coms Lifetime women boxoffice TruTV Classic Film trophy hispanic mob Paramount Pictures dc 71st Emmy Awards Disney Plus scorecard discovery singing competition AMC best halloween tv Cartoon Network ghosts Amazon Super Bowl FX on Hulu spy thriller Certified Fresh new york TBS blockbusters video on demand leaderboard Lionsgate Set visit Spectrum Originals directors Pride Month Music dexter Shondaland what to watch stoner HBO Comedy high school venice nature theme song Epix mockumentary black comedy james bond video Turner Classic Movies war Dark Horse Comics OWN harry potter foreign Chernobyl Red Carpet Universal Pictures Turner target debate lord of the rings Academy Awards scary movies Interview rotten movies we love PBS game show Disney streaming service children's TV Emmys political drama Rock Best Picture child's play 99% Anna Paquin Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Warner Bros. TCA name the review award winner SDCC Reality Ovation Avengers dark travel Rom-Com Drama elevated horror Funimation wonder woman broadcast Disney Channel strong female leads DC streaming service laika Mary poppins cancelled TV shows Pop king arthur Reality Competition SundanceTV dragons werewolf rt labs critics edition royal family Video Games worst movies festival movies Holidays Writers Guild of America CW Seed docuseries 93rd Oscars tv talk international renewed TV shows festivals satire vampires all-time golden globes AMC Plus batman A24 Martial Arts dreamworks Nickelodeon PlayStation Showtime finale The Walt Disney Company mcc TV One anime asian-american blockbuster Fargo zombie Trivia rt labs comics saw Winter TV Paramount Plus 94th Oscars television gangster OneApp Disney+ Disney Plus Women's History Month First Look slashers Esquire Starz Tags: Comedy suspense sequel Character Guide comic book movies Winners VOD sequels GIFs Animation Acorn TV natural history Tumblr Paramount dceu Binge Guide boxing Election Premiere Dates FOX free movies dramedy christmas movies E! 45 robots book live event Mary Poppins Returns nfl chucky police drama jamie lee curtis ratings Teen RT History IFC spanish language scary Marvel Television Star Trek Pop TV superhero zombies USA A&E Instagram Live streaming movies Logo new zealand cats composers Netflix Oscar comic books National Geographic canceled 90s documentaries DGA anthology based on movie monster movies cancelled television Awards Tour American Society of Cinematographers ABC Family comic screen actors guild Biopics Hallmark Podcast Sneak Peek Sci-Fi WGN Adult Swim cars australia stop motion ESPN See It Skip It MCU Fall TV Television Academy psychological thriller crime 2016 APB toy story italian summer TV preview 4/20 Amazon Studios indie 24 frames aapi Marvel Mary Tyler Moore cinemax TIFF 2018 Valentine's Day Photos Comedy Central legend HBO Go Mindy Kaling Apple TV Plus FX comiccon Schedule jurassic park Hulu Cannes 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards GoT marvel cinematic universe doctor who concert godzilla Hollywood Foreign Press Association kids NBA japanese kaiju Sony Pictures TCA Winter 2020 telelvision know your critic biopic Spike genre scene in color 2019 hollywood TNT Summer TCA Awards Marvel Studios Universal olympics Wes Anderson Comic-Con@Home 2021 CBS All Access Syfy spinoff TV renewals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Box Office black The CW action-comedy docudrama casting Western cops CBS universal monsters science fiction zero dark thirty art house Pirates MGM south america The Witch Ghostbusters Musicals ITV streamig USA Network Mystery serial killer kong TCM spanish Countdown blaxploitation X-Men Masterpiece Pixar diversity Trophy Talk Nat Geo Lifetime Christmas movies Toys Fox Searchlight Thanksgiving Apple spain football unscripted Crunchyroll YA Freeform San Diego Comic-Con worst PaleyFest Tubi green book Vudu facebook streaming japan sitcom ID Star Wars witnail teaser movie Ellie Kemper Alien Television Critics Association criterion DC Comics Mudbound IMDb TV RT21 BAFTA Pet Sematary MSNBC Neflix E3 Pacific Islander ViacomCBS reviews Emmy Nominations joker Baby Yoda Spring TV Shudder MTV cancelled TV series GLAAD comic book movie reboot The Walking Dead Best Actress Marathons mission: impossible 20th Century Fox Tomatazos LGBT hispanic heritage month 79th Golden Globes Awards remakes Country Sundance spider-verse nbcuniversal VH1 mutant Best Actor 1990s politics 2017 BBC crossover Crackle Fantasy SXSW 2022 romance revenge DC Universe 2021 medical drama NYCC talk show HFPA basketball BET fresh twilight binge YouTube Red Heroines TV FXX DirecTV Holiday news rotten WarnerMedia documentary vs. Columbia Pictures ABC aliens Legendary TLC TV movies Trailer Bravo spider-man justice league latino crime thriller a nightmare on elm street Kids & Family 007 cults cartoon Comics on TV Stephen King king kong The Arrangement Hear Us Out historical drama slasher deadpool cooking quibi screenings Christmas Rocketman Film toronto Best and Worst Creative Arts Emmys Comic Book parents indiana jones Tokyo Olympics LGBTQ young adult IFC Films canceled TV shows summer TV marvel comics pirates of the caribbean Tarantino Black Mirror NBC BET Awards comedies 2020 Endgame series Grammys emmy awards die hard Action Netflix Christmas movies 72 Emmy Awards History independent Prime Video cancelled Awards versus Oscars SXSW psycho Travel Channel game of thrones Superheroe Sundance Now ABC Signature VICE Watching Series summer preview heist movie Image Comics Year in Review stand-up comedy Britbox HBO Max superman sopranos technology 21st Century Fox razzies richard e. Grant