Total Recall

Ian McKellen's 10 Best Movies

In this week's Total Recall, we count down the best-reviewed work of the Mr. Holmes star.

by | July 15, 2015 | Comments

He’s played Gandalf, Magneto, and Richard III — and this weekend, Sir Ian McKellen adds another household name to the long list of characters he’s brought to life. We’re talking, of course, about Mr. Holmes, director Bill Condon?s adaptation of the Mitch Cullin novel A Slight Trick of the Mind, in which legendary sleuth Sherlock Holmes putters through retirement while looking back on a case that’s dogged him for decades. In anticipation of seeing McKellen as Holmes, we decided to dedicate this week’s list to an appreciation of his fine filmography, including all the expected hits as well as a few surprises. It’s elementary — and it’s time for Total Recall!

10. The Ballad of Little Jo (1993) 76%

A grim, muddy Western with a feminist/revisionist slant, The Ballad of Little Jo finds writer-director Maggie Greenwald plunging viewers into the dirt-caked underbelly of a world in which an unattached woman (Suzy Amis) is liable to find herself kidnapped and sold into slavery before she’s so much as reached the outskirts of the city where her family has cast her out as punishment for having a baby out of wedlock. Unwilling to put up with the brutal treatment that seems to be her new lot in life, Josephine disguises herself in men’s clothing and becomes Little Jo, resident of the misleadingly named Ruby City — and lives undetected for years among a motley crew of thugs and reprobates that includes a violent alcoholic with a taste for ladies of the evening (McKellen). “It’s not hard to view The Ballad of Little Jo as an allegorical critique of sex and power and men’s-club values in America,” mused Stephen Holden for the New York Times. “In its disdain for those values, the film is as focused and cool-headed as the remarkable character whose story it tells.”

9. Jack & Sarah (1996) 74%

He’s chiefly known to a generation of filmgoers as Gandalf and Magneto, but before picking up roles in two of the most successful franchises in recent memory, McKellen could often be seen adding an expert splash of color to British arthouse pictures in supporting roles. Case in point: 1996’s Jack & Sarah, in which Richard E. Grant and Samantha Mathis star, respectively, as a single father grieving the death of his wife and the cute waitress he hires as his nanny. The movie’s superficial resemblance to any of the Hugh Grant rom-coms of the era wasn’t lost on critics, but neither were its many small charms — including McKellen as the friendly neighborhood alcoholic bum that Grant hires for additional domestic support. “Jack & Sarah is one of those romantic movies viewers know will end in a happy smooch,” admitted the San Francisco Chronicle’s Peter Stack. “What’s fine is the rush of amusing, heartrending humanity before it gets to the inevitable.”

8. The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit Trilogies
80% (Average Score)

Ian McKellen has appeared in dozens of films, television shows, and plays — and he’s still making more — but for a considerable number of filmgoers, he will always be Gandalf from Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit trilogies. And really, if you’re going to distill his life’s work into six films and a single role, that isn’t such a bad place to start. Although these movies definitely had their critical ups and downs, they brought J.R.R. Tolkien’s books to life with an overall artful blend of epic scope and wide-eyed wonder, and while McKellen may have played the noble wizard under layers of robes, hats, and hair, none of it — nor the increasing amounts of CGI spectacle — were enough to dull the depth of his portrayal of a character who could be gentle, imposing, or funny, sometimes all in the space of a single scene. As Bill Muller put it for the Arizona Republic, “Not only has Jackson boldly and faithfully brought J.R.R. Tolkien’s world to life, he’s created the most epic and sweeping fantasy adventure of all time.”

7. Cold Comfort Farm (1996) 83%

It took Cold Comfort Farm more than a year to make its journey from British television to American theaters, but for the most part, Stateside critics found the movie none the worse for wear; although John Schlesinger’s ensemble-driven adaptation of the Stella Gibbons novel — about an unflappable young woman (Kate Beckinsale) who heads to the country in order to live with relatives while discovering herself as a writer — was a fairly minor commercial success, it resonated strongly with critics who appreciated Schlesinger’s light touch and sterling cast, which included an array of wonderful supporting players that included McKellen, Stephen Fry, Joanna Lumley, and Rufus Sewell. “What could be more welcome,” wondered the Los Angeles Times’ Kevin Thomas, “than a classic English comedy, bristling with wit and hilarity and crammed with wonderful eccentrics?”

6. Mr. Holmes (2015) 88%


Take the big-budget action thrills of Robert Downey, Jr.’s Sherlock Holmes franchise, spin them 180 degrees, and age the master detective by 50 years or so, and you’ve got the basic outline for Mr. Holmes. Many of Holmes’ screen appearances over the years have focused on solving mysteries and defeating bad guys, but this elegiac adaptation of the Mitch Cullin novel A Slight Trick of the Mind is more interested in the man under the deerstalker hat, and how he confronts his greatest foe — the deleterious effects of advancing age — while leading a quiet beekeeper’s life in retirement and pondering a long-ago case he was never quite able to solve. While Holmes may strike fans of Sherlock’s peppier adventures as stubbornly slow, director Bill Condon’s deliberate pace yields its own rewards; as Bilge Ebiri wrote for Vulture, “It’s a gripping little tale, to be sure, but it’s more than that. Somewhere in its tangle of timelines, false starts, and red herrings is a great truth about the unsolvable mystery of the human soul.”

5. X-Men Franchise 87% (Average Score)

The original X-Men trilogy isn’t perfect, but there’s no arguing that it helped lay some crucial groundwork for the many superhero movies that followed. One of its strongest components has always been the cast, starting with the 2000 original, which united an impressive ensemble that included the perfectly chosen McKellen and Patrick Stewart as long-battling mutant frenemies Erik “Magneto” Lehnsherr and Charles “Professor X” Xavier. The battle between Xavier’s X-Men and Magneto’s Brotherhood of Evil Mutants fuels the action overlaying the sociopolitical subtext in the original trilogy — and when the franchise rebooted itself with 2011’s X-Men: First Class, taking the characters back to their origins, the Xavier/Lehnsherr friendship frayed before filmgoers’ eyes, with Michael Fassbender and James McAvoy stepping in for McKellen and Stewart. The series’ dual timelines merged for 2014’s X-Men: Days of Future Past, bringing McKellen and Stewart back into the fold while repairing the narrative damage wrought in the widely maligned X-Men 3: The Last Stand — an apparent swan song for both actors in the roles, and one that allowed them to exit on a high note. “X-Men: Days of Future Past is a thrilling, hey-what-if comic-book movie that hits just about every mark you’d reasonably want it to hit,” observed Deadspin’s Will Leitch. “It’s not easy to surprise in a blockbuster these days. It’s a rare treat to find one that even tries.”

4. Six Degrees of Separation (1993) 88%

The fascinating story of real-life con artist David Hampton formed the basis for Six Degrees of Separation, adapted from the John Guare play about a smooth-talking young man named Paul (Will Smith) who shows up on the doorstep of a wealthy New York couple (Donald Sutherland and Stockard Channing) and convinces them he’s not only friends with their college-age kids, but that he’s the son of Sidney Poitier. Before the night is out, he’s sleeping in their guest room — and before the closing credits roll, the extraordinary truth of Paul’s story is revealed. Bolstered by a deep bench of acting talent — Channing earned an Oscar nomination, and the stars were backed by supporting performances from a group that included McKellen, who makes an amusing appearance as a South African businessman — Separation won praise from critics like the Austin Chronicle’s Marjorie Baumgarten, who wrote, “The temporal experience of watching Six Degrees of Separation is one of absorption and intrigue.”

3. Scandal (1989) 91%

Scandal delves into one of the more titillating real-life stories in Britain’s history, and the marketing materials for the movie didn’t shy away from the movie’s more salacious elements. But first-time director Michael Caton-Jones had more on his mind than mere prurience when he sought to dramatize the peccadillo between former British Secretary of State for War John Profumo (McKellen) and a teenage call girl (Joanne Whalley) who was being pimped out by a prominent doctor (John Hurt); although the movie has its lighthearted moments, it’s really a fairly sober reconstruction of a fascinating series of events. “What makes this movie so absorbing is its heady celebration of London during this period, as well as a healthy enjoyment of the erotic elements,” wrote Jonathan Rosenbaum for the Chicago Reader, “demonstrating overall that good, trashy fun doesn’t necessarily entail dumbness or irresponsibility.”

2. Gods and Monsters (1998) 96%

Long before they collaborated on Mr. Holmes, McKellen and director Bill Condon offered filmgoers a glimpse into the final days of another public figure — albeit a real-life one — in Gods and Monsters, a thoughtful attempt to imagine what might have led up to the death of Frankenstein director James Whale. McKellen’s performance as Whale drew the lion’s share of Monsters‘ acclaim, although pundits were also impressed with the rest of the cast (including Brendan Fraser and Lynn Redgrave), and fairly stunned by Condon’s evolution from Candyman: Farewell to the Flesh to prestige drama. “Gods and Monsters has been capably made in all regards,” wrote Janet Maslin for the New York Times. “What especially elevates it is the razor-sharp cleverness of Mr. McKellen’s performance, which brings unusual fullness and feeling to a most unusual man.”

1. Richard III (1995) 96%

Richard III found McKellen collaborating with director Richard Loncraine, collaborating onscreen and off in order to transplant Shakespeare’s play into a fascist nightmare version of 1930s England. The duo’s script took some liberties with the source material, both with the updated setting and its streamlined cast of characters; for example, Robert Downey, Jr. appears as Earl Rivers, an amalgamation of three roles from the play. At the heart of it all, however, McKellen anchored his Richard III with a mesmerizing performance in the title role, ensuring that even if it wasn’t the same story viewers remembered, it remained a gripping exploration of the same timeless themes. “Richard III is the kind of movie that earns the right to interpret the bard’s ideas through alternate perspectives,” argued Cinemaphile’s David Keyes, “because it does so without sacrificing its core values or integrity.”

Tag Cloud

San Diego Comic-Con biopic SDCC Mystery Interview cooking comedies Baby Yoda satire movie video on demand stoner Food Network TCM disaster streaming movies politics franchise new york FX on Hulu harry potter Endgame Women's History Month Nat Geo OneApp FX Calendar DC Universe screen actors guild Television Academy documentary remakes Comics on TV TNT Marvel 73rd Emmy Awards concert Starz SundanceTV First Look high school comiccon CW Seed comic anime Showtime TIFF Comic Book Walt Disney Pictures Classic Film IFC Films zombie 99% ViacomCBS Acorn TV Mary Tyler Moore scene in color NYCC Marathons Infographic canceled TV shows 2020 Photos Comedy kaiju TCA telelvision science fiction prank Brie Larson Captain marvel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt docudrama YA Anna Paquin aapi slashers adenture Amazon Prime Video 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Syfy anthology cats TCA 2017 cancelled animated Grammys Warner Bros. ghosts Mudbound joker kids rt archives Lucasfilm Polls and Games rom-coms Amazon aliens Mindy Kaling mutant Spring TV wonder woman Shudder green book TBS Tumblr Hallmark dc WGN universal monsters 2017 action-comedy Red Carpet VICE children's TV Awards Tour Fox Searchlight news 2018 DGA worst Apple TV+ sports Travel Channel TV movies thriller finale NBA Winners Disney Creative Arts Emmys Musical pirates of the caribbean Action international documentaries spanish 2015 romance fresh Masterpiece CMT crime teaser TV LGBTQ dark robots Mary poppins versus independent space hist Discovery Channel Watching Series Disney streaming service Lifetime Christmas movies Turner Classic Movies jurassic park south america 71st Emmy Awards rotten australia hidden camera Sundance TV 90s spanish language vampires Cannes First Reviews die hard cancelled TV shows GIFs rt labs Reality The Academy Animation Trivia SXSW live action blockbuster Apple TV Plus Amazon Prime movies Film Festival toy story sag awards Crackle Star Wars National Geographic Extras Television Critics Association spain TCA Awards FOX TV Land comic book movie Fox News name the review screenings adventure toronto docuseries child's play award winner Funimation Holidays Academy Awards royal family YouTube Bravo spy thriller singing competition TLC Netflix Christmas movies HBO AMC Adult Swim TV One dragons latino book adaptation adaptation 1990s E3 Pop TV cancelled TV series See It Skip It 20th Century Fox festival feel good based on movie golden globes king arthur posters Heroines best foreign critics Sci-Fi Vudu talk show CBS All Access LGBT Britbox USA dceu golden globe awards Character Guide Pride Month Pixar superhero 4/20 mcc nfl Super Bowl japanese Marvel Television indiana jones GoT Exclusive Video psychological thriller A&E facebook nbcuniversal binge BBC America Tarantino Legendary Musicals The Walking Dead Esquire Ghostbusters 2019 ESPN all-time unscripted TCA Winter 2020 Pirates tv talk TruTV Binge Guide Superheroes blaxploitation Nominations Spike serial killer Podcast VH1 IFC 93rd Oscars young adult kong suspense Trailer President DC Comics BET Awards 21st Century Fox Winter TV emmy awards black American Society of Cinematographers Certified Fresh trailers Quiz Shondaland Election new zealand 007 natural history casting social media strong female leads historical drama Paramount Plus mission: impossible reviews Box Office YouTube Premium Crunchyroll Chernobyl Arrowverse political drama ABC Signature Disney+ Disney Plus Disney Plus godzilla cinemax razzies japan Paramount Network The Walt Disney Company YouTube Red 24 frames Opinion james bond spider-man Peacock Lifetime spinoff Biopics breaking bad Teen italian Sundance Now witnail Year in Review Logo Film archives deadpool MSNBC debate RT History richard e. Grant Song of Ice and Fire Drama Horror miniseries discovery psycho Martial Arts Pacific Islander RT21 The Arrangement Star Trek Image Comics a nightmare on elm street A24 Epix Valentine's Day Sony Pictures 2021 laika Family indie asian-american crossover basketball MCU PlayStation DirecTV ratings hispanic Black Mirror VOD period drama 72 Emmy Awards NBC USA Network crime thriller festivals halloween tv Emmy Nominations PaleyFest Sneak Peek CNN Rocketman Music olympics Western video composers cops doctor who Apple dogs hollywood Premiere Dates Toys true crime king kong criterion X-Men Christmas scorecard Sundance theme song parents sequels transformers rotten movies we love Wes Anderson zero dark thirty marvel comics Video Games Holiday Pet Sematary know your critic cults FXX television dramedy Tokyo Olympics Tubi elevated horror Rom-Com revenge CBS Alien twilight Cartoon Network chucky Universal Awards El Rey Fantasy BET Stephen King marvel cinematic universe MTV stand-up comedy HBO Max comics Superheroe book HBO Go Comedy Central obituary nature Dark Horse Comics romantic comedy Spectrum Originals sitcom Black History Month WarnerMedia batman Lionsgate rt labs critics edition renewed TV shows Kids & Family what to watch zombies Thanksgiving Amazon Studios monster movies stop motion Tomatazos Countdown scary movies Emmys 45 free movies Broadway BAFTA reboot Marvel Studios technology popular Disney Channel Schedule Hear Us Out Comic-Con@Home 2021 superman films Trophy Talk ABC Family directors Best and Worst The Purge boxoffice classics french hispanic heritage month Turner cars OWN Avengers saw halloween New York Comic Con ID supernatural 2016 Fall TV Writers Guild of America dexter women travel diversity werewolf target christmas movies gangster Set visit Rock sequel Country Columbia Pictures slasher mockumentary heist movie legend fast and furious medical drama cartoon boxing Chilling Adventures of Sabrina game show Ellie Kemper game of thrones Cosplay jamie lee curtis BBC Mary Poppins Returns Ovation Reality Competition war crime drama comic books Hallmark Christmas movies BBC One Summer new star wars movies ABC critic resources TV renewals Nickelodeon Freeform Hulu streaming quibi blockbusters The Witch police drama canceled comic book movies The CW APB Paramount Elton John football ITV venice PBS DC streaming service E! Oscars justice league biography Netflix worst movies Rocky GLAAD History lord of the rings Pop cancelled television series