Total Recall

Faye Dunaway's 10 Best Movies

In this week's Total Recall, we look at the best-reviewed work of the star of The Bye Bye Man.

by | January 11, 2017 | Comments

After retreating from the spotlight for a few years, Faye Dunaway is having something of a moment: aside from a recurring role in Amazon’s Hand of God, the Oscar-winning star has wrapped a handful of new films — including this weekend’s The Bye Bye Man. In celebration of her overdue return to the big screen, we decided to take a fond look back at some of the many critical highlights from Ms. Dunaway’s distinguished career, and you know what that means: it’s time for Total Recall!

10. Barfly (1987) 79%


After spending a few years in England and focusing on television work in the mid-1980s, Dunaway returned to Hollywood in search of film roles — and found a doozy in Barfly, a semi-autobiographical drama written by Charles Bukowski about a perpetually sozzled writer (Mickey Rourke) whose self-destructive habits put him in the path of a fellow alcoholic (Dunaway) who happens to share a past with his usual bartender/sparring partner (Frank Stallone). It’s far from the cheeriest entry in her filmography, but it offered the chance to dig into a dramatic role Dunaway had been looking for; as Roger Ebert wrote, “The dialogue scenes between Rourke and Dunaway in this movie are never less than a pleasure… Rourke and Dunaway take their characters as opportunities to stretch as actors, to take chances and do extreme things.”

9. The Thomas Crown Affair (1968) 72%


Dunaway quickly parlayed her breakthrough performance in Bonnie and Clyde into another classic: The Thomas Crown Affair, Norman Jewison’s heist picture starring Steve McQueen as a wealthy businessman who plans high-stakes robberies as a lark. As the insurance investigator who figures out Crown’s misdeeds — but of course finds herself drawn to him anyway — Dunaway proved herself a leading lady who could stand toe to toe with one of the era’s most effortlessly cool superstars. As James Rocchi argued for Netflix, “Caper films don’t come much better.”

8. The Three Musketeers (1973) 87%


Left at loose ends with his idea for an action-comedy retelling of The Three Musketeers after plans for the Beatles to star fell through, director Richard Lester rounded up a showy cast — including Oliver Reed, Charlton Heston, Raquel Welch, Richard Chamberlain, Christopher Lee, and of course Faye Dunaway — to tell the story, which proved so sprawling that he ended up filming two movies’ worth of footage, cutting it in half, and releasing the results six months apart. In the U.S., The Three Musketeers and The Four Musketeers both arrived in 1974, performing respectably at the box office and earning praise from critics along the way; while Dunaway’s appearance as the wickedly seductive Milady de Winter was hardly one of the more progressive roles on her résumé, it’s all part of the movies’ swashbuckling good time. Deeming it “The finest rendering of Dumas’ tale to date,” eFilmCritic’s Brian Mckay called it “A perfect blend of comedy, romance, and no-holds-barred swashbuckling adventure,” and added, “The cast is phenomenally good.”

7. Three Days of the Condor (1975) 88%


Dunaway was on a major roll in the mid-1970s, surging on the strength of a career comeback that included Chinatown, the Musketeers movies, and The Towering Inferno. Also among her hits during the period: Three Days of the Condor, a Robert Redford-led spy thriller that draws on the paranoia of the era to tell the story of a CIA analyst who fights back against a shadowy government conspiracy while hiding out in the apartment of a woman (Dunaway) he essentially kidnaps in desperation. In some ways, it’s inescapably an artifact of its era, but it remains fundamentally sound — a suitably tense affair, steered by director Sydney Pollack’s deft hand, that stands among the era’s better entries in the genre. “At its best moments,” wrote Vincent Canby of the New York Times, “Three Days of the Condor creates without effort or editorializing that sense of isolation — that far remove from reality — within which super-government agencies can operate with such heedless immunity.”

6. Arizona Dream (1992) 87%


Filmed in 1991, Emir Kusturica’s Arizona Dream languished in limbo for two years before it was released in Europe — and it didn’t reach American shores until the following September, at which point it grossed a little over $100,000 in limited release. It seems like a pretty harsh fate for a movie featuring Johnny Depp, Jerry Lewis, and Faye Dunaway, but if you’ve ever seen Dream, you know it is not, to put it mildly, the type of film Hollywood studios were made to promote. The story of a fish tagger (Depp) who believes he can see the fishes’ dreams, it’s over two hours of absurdist comedy, packed with symbolism-laden dream sequences and oddball characters like Dunaway’s Elaine, a woman who aspires to build a flying machine, and her daughter Grace, a turtle-obsessed young woman played by Lili Taylor. Even the critics that enjoyed it used words like “peculiar,” “odd,” and “bizarre” to describe Dream; as Janet Maslin of the New York Times wrote, “Even at its full length, showing off a more seductive rhythm and the buoyant humanism that is this director’s calling card, it remains as ripe a subject for therapy as for criticism.”

5. Bonnie and Clyde (1967) 89%


Dunaway’s first screen role, opposite Anthony Quinn in The Happening, presaged a period in which she had to fight her way out of an undesirable contract — but it was her work in that movie that attracted the attention of director Arthur Penn, who ended up casting her in his classic biographical gangster drama Bonnie and Clyde. Starring Dunaway as Bonnie Parker opposite Warren Beatty’s Clyde Barrow, the movie exploded into an Oscar-winning smash, with both stars earning Oscar nominations under a cloud of violent controversy that’s continued to shadow its legacy for decades. To some, it represents a glorification of violence that panders to some of humanity’s worst instincts; to others, it’s a thrilling breath of fresh cinematic air. “Bonnie and Clyde is the most excitingly American American movie since The Manchurian Candidate,” wrote the New Yorker’s Pauline Kael. “The audience is alive to it.”

4. Voyage of the Damned (1976) 83%


Given its crowded cast and the era in which it was released, 1976’s Voyage of the Damned might look like one of the star-studded disaster movies that were in vogue at the time; instead, however, it’s a fact-based drama about an ocean liner full of Jewish refugees who sailed to Cuba in 1939 in the vain (and ultimately fraudulent) hopes of being accepted as refugees from the Nazi regime. Understandably overshadowed in Dunaway’s career by Network, which was released during the same year, it nevertheless proved a critical success, with PopMatters’ J.C. Maçek III later reflecting, “There is no Indiana Jones to save the day and no pat Hollywood ending to revise history. Voyage of the Damned is unquestionably a serious drama and treats its subject matter with the dignity that it should.”

3. Network (1976) 92%


Much as many of our favorite television pundits like to argue that we’re living in one of the medium’s great golden ages, there’s no denying that wide swaths of the dial have been abandoned and given over to lowest-common-denominator fare. But long before anyone started worrying about trashy talk shows or “reality” TV, screenwriter Paddy Chayevsky had an inkling of the dystopian landscape looming on the horizon — and the result was 1976’s Network, a bitingly bitter satire about a veteran news anchor (Peter Finch) whose unorthodox response to being fired serves as the unintended catalyst for a new era of ever-more-provocative nightly news, whipped into a ratings frenzy by a rather unscrupulous exec (Dunaway, who earned her third Best Actress Oscar nomination and first win). “One would assume that a 1976 film about network television would feel dated today,” admitted Forrest Hartman of the Reno Gazette-Journal, “but director Sidney Lumet and screenwriter Paddy Chayefsky had such a fine concept that Network seems downright contemporary.”

2. Little Big Man (1970) 96%


Dunaway suffered through a string of duds after making The Thomas Crown Affair, but enjoyed a rebound of sorts with 1970’s Little Big Man — albeit in a supporting role she reportedly only accepted as a favor to director Arthur Penn. However she got involved, the movie — an adaptation of the Thomas Berger novel about the incredible life story of the world’s oldest man — was a critical and commercial hit that reaped awards and nominations for star Dustin Hoffman as well as actor Chief Dan George. Dunaway’s performance as a sexually frustrated preacher’s wife whose arc ends with a cheeky tribute to Hoffman’s work in The Graduate may not have called for the heaviest dramatic lifting she’s done in her career, but it offered a rare opportunity to flash her comedic chops onscreen. The end result, wrote Scott Weinberg for eFilmCritic, is “Easily one of the most entertaining (and presently overlooked) Westerns of the early 1970s.”

1. Chinatown (1974) 99%


In a filmography dotted with triumphs as significant as Rosemary’s Baby and The Pianist, it takes a truly special film to top them all — and 1974’s Chinatown is not only Roman Polanski’s personal best, it’s one of the most highly regarded films of all time. Starring Jack Nicholson as the duped-but-determined gumshoe Jake Gittes and Dunaway as the femme fatale Evelyn Mulwray — both nominated for Oscars — Chinatown explored an oft-forgotten chapter in Los Angeles’ history while bringing film noir back to brilliant life for the 1970s. Though plans for a trilogy were scuttled after the sequel, The Two Jakes, flopped in 1990, Chinatown more than stands on its own; Robert Towne’s script bustles with twists and double-crosses, and the cast, from Nicholson to Dunaway and John Huston, is impeccable. “This film,” crowed the Observer’s Philip French, “is flawless.”

Tag Cloud

Discovery Channel hist Thanksgiving worst blockbusters Fall TV reviews jamie lee curtis aliens war Creative Arts Emmys Musicals blaxploitation 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Martial Arts zombie laika Alien Apple TV Plus elevated horror Sundance Now 94th Oscars reboot Freeform Sneak Peek Anna Paquin Grammys all-time Pop TV stop motion strong female leads Pacific Islander spinoff Nat Geo football Marathons spanish language docuseries Avengers American Society of Cinematographers debate rom-coms IFC HFPA First Reviews singing competition criterion book adaptation Infographic movie Starz CMT toy story obi wan FX composers vampires Logo Epix Prime Video christmas movies E! ABC Family video on demand independent ID Mary Poppins Returns Fantasy Lucasfilm Endgame Image Comics diversity Teen DirecTV Television Critics Association action-comedy Marvel Television Pop El Rey Western TCA Winter 2020 President MGM MCU San Diego Comic-Con free movies RT21 rt labs critics edition monster movies suspense Heroines Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt CBS All Access comics Comedy The Walt Disney Company dceu sequels thriller marvel cinematic universe halloween fresh disaster mutant TV movies transformers james bond binge HBO Funimation TCM Apple dc comic book movies joker breaking bad Sundance Marvel crime supernatural mission: impossible HBO Go Crunchyroll Netflix Disney streaming service Opinion Disney Plus satire adventure Amazon Prime australia robots LGBT lord of the rings godzilla medical drama young adult Cannes Star Wars NYCC Sci-Fi FXX Film Amazon mob LGBTQ hidden camera Year in Review Sony Pictures hollywood razzies Ghostbusters cars National Geographic dexter miniseries Apple TV+ Classic Film critic resources TCA 2017 BBC America rt archives latino YA zero dark thirty 24 frames MSNBC 72 Emmy Awards Turner gangster TLC politics animated ratings basketball Quiz Mindy Kaling The Walking Dead festival south america italian franchise AMC Plus X-Men cancelled TV shows name the review YouTube Premium First Look Fox Searchlight mockumentary asian-american GIFs Music Britbox blockbuster discovery royal family trailers kong Brie Larson USA Network Pirates Box Office aapi Animation kaiju Christmas rt labs WGN talk show book scorecard crime thriller Reality historical drama stand-up comedy theme song Hollywood Foreign Press Association WarnerMedia Chilling Adventures of Sabrina streaming movies A&E legend Lifetime Christmas movies Best Actress crossover award winner HBO Max Watching Series ITV spider-man ViacomCBS The Purge cooking Women's History Month deadpool japan cancelled television Best and Worst Song of Ice and Fire RT History zombies olympics Country TV renewals Captain marvel technology ABC heist movie TruTV comic Esquire IMDb TV feel good Star Trek Cartoon Network VOD TIFF chucky Showtime a nightmare on elm street Elton John Spring TV Tomatazos New York Comic Con Emmy Nominations biopic Holiday 99% Rock The Academy Podcast slasher classics BET Awards directors Hear Us Out Best Actor Walt Disney Pictures Video Games Fox News Mudbound Comics on TV child's play twilight Action Schedule Extras pirates of the caribbean casting Sundance TV Fargo genre TV political drama A24 Netflix Christmas movies revenge wonder woman 45 universal monsters facebook comiccon adenture Paramount Plus Disney Channel Black History Month CBS 2019 Winter TV Pixar Comedy Central anime Lionsgate Mary Tyler Moore FX on Hulu Comic-Con@Home 2021 Tarantino Oscar adaptation Trivia SDCC Best Picture Tumblr documentary PlayStation TV Land cancelled scary movies art house VH1 documentaries CW Seed screen actors guild remakes Horror leaderboard Disney 2020 live event Nickelodeon high school psychological thriller Rocketman Awards renewed TV shows werewolf spanish spider-verse harry potter BAFTA VICE MTV NBA Polls and Games crime drama BBC One romance concert dramedy Arrowverse Red Carpet kids space Hallmark Film Festival indie YouTube jurassic park golden globes canceled Best Director DGA streaming hispanic heritage month Countdown scary OWN 73rd Emmy Awards obituary Shondaland DC Comics festivals emmy awards The Arrangement telelvision Mystery based on movie 93rd Oscars scene in color Summer 20th Century Fox dogs versus Crackle IFC Films dark Marvel Studios Columbia Pictures golden globe awards Winners ghosts period drama boxing game show slashers true crime streamig Family Hallmark Christmas movies Instagram Live critics Universal Academy Awards video women Turner Classic Movies Binge Guide 2021 game of thrones screenings USA Travel Channel indiana jones Tokyo Olympics Comic Book Universal Pictures Vudu spain cults Ovation Super Bowl Lifetime Chernobyl FOX Superheroes 2018 toronto new star wars movies boxoffice worst movies Adult Swim Black Mirror TNT GoT See It Skip It Paramount Network know your critic sports Disney+ Disney Plus halloween tv cops dreamworks 2016 serial killer Character Guide Masterpiece doctor who Bravo Tags: Comedy TBS finale vs. Broadway Peacock cats Stephen King sag awards ESPN YouTube Red AMC rotten venice Pet Sematary TCA Awards foreign Tubi SundanceTV 71st Emmy Awards Cosplay Biopics NBC parents what to watch CNN sequel 21st Century Fox SXSW Pride Month die hard Rocky Toys new york black comedy Superheroe live action Spike green book biography popular television Paramount DC streaming service travel nbcuniversal Musical The CW Photos saw quibi science fiction cartoon APB mcc BET unscripted posters 90s 007 marvel comics canceled TV shows PBS Drama stoner Baby Yoda OneApp Trailer anthology GLAAD Certified Fresh Dark Horse Comics king kong Wes Anderson comic books social media teaser nature Election Oscars comic book movie 1990s target japanese Awards Tour Interview rotten movies we love TV One nfl 2015 sopranos dragons Holidays romantic comedy Valentine's Day psycho new zealand justice league Hulu TCA natural history Trophy Talk docudrama police drama batman news DC Universe Syfy ABC Signature 79th Golden Globes Awards french Set visit films Calendar cancelled TV series BBC children's TV Exclusive Video trophy Reality Competition black Television Academy Neflix hispanic richard e. Grant witnail cinemax archives Shudder Legendary The Witch 4/20 tv talk movies Mary poppins Nominations prank spy thriller Acorn TV Rom-Com Ellie Kemper Spectrum Originals king arthur international South by Southwest Film Festival Food Network Warner Bros. Amazon Prime Video History superhero Kids & Family Writers Guild of America comedies fast and furious Premiere Dates 2017 PaleyFest series superman Emmys sitcom best SXSW 2022 E3 Amazon Studios