Total Recall

Total Recall: Woody Allen's Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the Blue Jasmine director.

by | July 25, 2013 | Comments

Woody Allen

He’s never been a blockbuster filmmaker, but with more than a half century in Hollywood under his belt — and dozens of movies along the way — Woody Allen‘s consistently prolific output stands as a continuing testament to the ability of brainy, low-budget cinema to find an audience, even during an era in which superheroes, sequels, reboots, and remakes seem to exert an ever-stronger grip on the box office. Love him or hate him, Allen’s one of the few directors left who can film people sitting around talking and turn it into a wide release — and with his latest, Blue Jasmine, arriving in theaters this weekend, we knew now would be the perfect time to pay tribute by looking back at his best-reviewed efforts. Call your therapist, because it’s time for Total Recall, Woody Allen style!


10. Crimes and Misdemeanors

After suffering relatively lukewarm reviews for 1987’s September and 1988’s Another Woman, Allen enjoyed a rebound — and picked up a pair of Academy Award nominations — for 1989’s Crimes and Misdemeanors, which found him writing, directing, and starring alongside Martin Landau in a rather pensive drama that interweaves the stories of an adulterous opthalmalogist (Landau) and a struggling filmmaker (Allen) for whom love and romance are fraught with difficulty (or even danger). Calling it “A relative of Hannah and Her Sisters in its duplex structure and of The Purple Rose of Cairo in its bitter theme,” the Washington Post’s Rita Kempley bestowed praise befitting Crimes‘ parallel narrative, calling it “two movies in one, a blend of Allen’s satiric and pretentious dramatic styles.”


9. Midnight in Paris

While it would be inaccurate to say that Allen’s work went unappreciated during the 1990s and aughts, critical accolades were no longer in such ready supply, and his box-office profile — which never approached mega-blockbuster heights even during his 1970s and 1980s peak — lost more than a bit of its luster. But things turned around for 2011’s Midnight in Paris, a late-period smash that brought Allen some of the warmest reviews (and the highest grosses) of his career while telling the the fantasy-infused comedic tale of an ennui-addled screenwriter (Owen Wilson) who heads out for a melancholic walk on the streets of Paris and ends up taking much more of a journey than he bargained for. “Woody Allen seemed to have lost his fizz as a filmmaker of late,” observed Jason Best for Movie Talk, “and then he uncorked the sparkling Midnight in Paris, a comic fantasy with all the effervescence of vintage champagne.”


8. Bullets Over Broadway

One of Allen’s more critically successful late-period movies, 1994’s Bullets Over Broadway found him stepping completely behind the camera in order to tell the tale of a naive 1920s playwright (John Cusack) whose budding Broadway career threatens to derail itself almost before it’s begun, thanks to the cascading series of compromises forced when he accepts financial backing from a mobster who insists his talentless girlfriend (Jennifer Tilly) be given a role in the show. Sadly met with indifference at the box office, Bullets made a direct hit with critics like Edward Guthmann of the San Francisco Chronicle, who called it “Woody Allen at his best — a gem of a Broadway fable with a crafty premise, a raft of brilliant actors at the top of their form and a bouncy, just-for-pleasure attitude.”


7. Manhattan

Following the Oscar-winning Annie Hall, Allen reunited with Diane Keaton for their sixth collaboration, 1979’s Manhattan, the story of a neurotic TV writer caught in a(n admittedly unlikely-seeming) love triangle between a teenager (Mariel Hemingway) and an intellectual (Keaton). Adding another pair of Academy Award nominations to Allen’s growing stack (including one for Best Screenplay), it rounded out his 1970s hot streak with typically neurotic flair — and another round of unbridled love from critics like Joshua Rothkopf of Time Out New York, who wrote, “This is a deeply self-critical film about immaturity and the gift of real love. Many films can be said to put an epitaph on the decade, but few remain as relevant.”


6. Annie Hall

The word “iconic” gets thrown around a lot more often than it should, but this movie fits the description — a film that so perfectly expresses its creative principals’ gifts that when you say “Woody Allen and Diane Keaton,” the picture that leaps to mind for most film fans is a black-and-white still from Annie Hall. Keaton’s career was already well on its way in 1977, but her performance here rocketed her into Hollywood’s upper echelon, earning her a Best Actress Oscar and heaps of critical accolades for a performance of a character who’d form the (often misunderstood) template for countless quirky-but-lovable leading ladies in subsequent rom-coms, and she wasn’t the only one who enjoyed recognition for the film; Allen picked up a pair of Oscars of his own (for Best Director and Best Original Screenplay), as well as heaps of praise from critics like TIME’s Richard Schickel, who observed, “Personal as the story he is telling may be, what separates this film from Allen’s own past work and most other recent comedy is its general believability.”


5. Love and Death

The second in a string of Woody Allen/Diane Keaton movies that started with Sleeper and included Annie Hall, 1975’s Love and Death found the duo starring in a satire on Russian literature that used the story of a reluctant war hero (Allen) and his equally reluctant bride (Keaton) to offer a cockeyed, tightly scripted take on Tolstoy, Dostoyevsky, and Eisenstein, melding satirical philosophical debates with visual homages only a film buff could truly love — and became one of the more unlikely hits of the 1970s in the process. As Vincent Canby argued for the New York Times, “Besides being one of Woody’s most consistently witty films, Love and Death marks a couple of other advances for Mr. Allen as a filmmaker and for Miss Keaton as a wickedly funny comedienne.”


4. Zelig

Allen’s early years found him bringing his unique style and sense of humor to bear on a wide variety of mediums and genres, from sci-fi to Russian lit. With 1983’s Zelig, Allen delivered a suitably smart, poignant take on the mockumentary format, using his screenplay’s nominal focus — the life of a fictional ardent conformist named Leonard Zelig — to offer more of the subtly intelligent commentary on modern American life that his audiences had come to expect. Arguably more interesting, however, were the techniques Allen employed to insert Zelig into a series of historical situations, from batting practice with Babe Ruth to the Nuremberg rally with Adolf Hitler; among its many award recognitions was a BAFTA nomination for Best Special Visual Effects. As for the film itself, Peter Bradshaw of the Guardian echoed the sentiments of many of his colleagues when he deemed it “A masterpiece: a brilliant, even passionate historical pastiche, a superbly pregnant meditation on American society and individuality, and an eerie fantasy that will live in your dreams.”


3. Broadway Danny Rose

Slight, quirky, and wry, 1984’s Broadway Danny Rose is vintage Woody Allen, in terms of form as well as function. While it starts from an absurdly broad premise, following the hapless adventures of a borderline incompetent talent agent (Allen) whose clients have little talent to speak of, there’s a sweet, somewhat sober message underneath all the shenanigans, with a final act that underscores the value of loyalty and forgiveness — even in the face of violent mobsters and opportunistic lounge singers. While Broadway‘s rather modest narrative scope was matched by middling box office grosses, it earned substantial admiration from critics like Janet Maslin of the New York Times, who called it “one of Mr. Allen’s more modest films but also one of his very best” and enthused, “Mr. Allen works with such speed and confidence these days that a brief, swift film like this one can have all the texture and substance of his more complicated work.”


2. Sleeper

After the impressive commercial performance of 1972’s Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sex* (*But Were Afraid to Ask), Allen opted for a follow-up with a somewhat larger scale: Sleeper, a futuristic comedy about a health food store owner (Allen) who’s cryogenically frozen after dying during a gall bladder operation, thawed out 200 years later, and becomes an unlikely leader in a resistance movement — while falling in love with the woman who briefly thought he was a robot (Diane Keaton). Billed as a “nostalgic look at the future,” Sleeper offered a humorous counterpoint to the dry sci-fi epics of the day, predicting (sadly accurately, some would argue) that technological advancement wouldn’t be able to stem the rising tide of pure human foolishness. Mused Filmcritic’s Christopher Null, “Pound for pound and minute for minute, Sleeper may just have more laughs in it than any other Woody Allen movie.”


1. Husbands and Wives

The perils of romance, the wisdom of long-term commitment, and the foibles of the modern American male — they’re all themes that will be quite familiar to anyone who’s seen more than a couple of Allen’s films (let alone any of those inspired by his work). So it’s saying something that 1992’s Husbands and Wives was greeted with such critical acclaim, despite the fact that its sad portrait of two turbulently self-destructing marriages looked a lot like Allen pictures previous. Although Husbands‘ theatrical release was overshadowed by the messy end of the real-life relationship between Allen and his long-term muse Mia Farrow (who co-stars here as his dissatisfied wife), dooming it to disappointing grosses, it found favor with critics like Entertainment Weekly’s Owen Gleiberman, who — while admitting that it was “less a drama than a series of overly chewed-on observations” — argued, “as Woody’s angst-a-thons go, this one is singularly lively and well acted.”

In case you were wondering, here are Allen’s top 10 movies according RT users’ scores:

1. Annie Hall — 91%
2. Manhattan — 91%
3. Crimes and Misdemeanors — 89%
4. Hannah and Her Sisters — 88%
5. Love and Death — 88%
6. Zelig — 86%
7. The Purple Rose of Cairo — 85%
8. Husbands and Wives — 84%
9. Midnight in Paris — 82%
10. Radio Days — 82%

Take a look through Allen’s complete filmography, as well as the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out the reviews for Blue Jasmine.

Finally, here’s the Woodman doing standup on British TV in 1965:

Tag Cloud

TCM 24 frames Animation Rocketman crossover golden globes scary movies cancelled australia NBA VH1 Disney Channel Best and Worst The Academy scene in color Sneak Peek ViacomCBS razzies sequel Grammys Premiere Dates Ovation Warner Bros. french El Rey Vudu social media Superheroe stand-up comedy Mary Tyler Moore sopranos unscripted 2017 Tomatazos Disney Plus Exclusive Video zero dark thirty History travel Nominations Hollywood Foreign Press Association Epix Trailer facebook Schedule feel good dogs harry potter telelvision Watching Series Crackle 21st Century Fox series Cosplay genre worst movies debate X-Men Neflix SXSW Stephen King mcc suspense spy thriller 20th Century Fox See It Skip It VICE war stoner true crime blaxploitation rotten IFC medical drama richard e. Grant FX festival biopic biography MTV Emmy Nominations comiccon slasher nature technology book E3 YA Ghostbusters TNT aapi PaleyFest Star Trek DC Comics zombie finale Syfy Christmas Turner composers robots Emmys doctor who Pride Month Cartoon Network BBC CBS All Access crime thriller Pacific Islander Elton John Amazon Prime Star Wars talk show Musicals 72 Emmy Awards Kids & Family Paramount Network pirates of the caribbean Pixar Box Office heist movie APB blockbuster trophy hist young adult USA Network universal monsters Lifetime Christmas movies new star wars movies mob YouTube Premium Prime Video olympics Red Carpet legend rt labs Lucasfilm kids worst HBO Go NBC San Diego Comic-Con sports 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards all-time Musical hispanic heritage month cinemax spider-verse Broadway Avengers MCU revenge football Chilling Adventures of Sabrina President Chernobyl children's TV zombies Tarantino LGBT king kong elevated horror Paramount Plus Fantasy HBO Max hollywood basketball classics Comedy Central Ellie Kemper monster movies Image Comics VOD adenture game show TV One Columbia Pictures child's play crime drama superman The CW popular what to watch blockbusters Toys Opinion HFPA Music Captain marvel BBC One Pop Podcast live action Anna Paquin Holiday quibi Sundance Now Dark Horse Comics The Arrangement IFC Films Video Games joker Paramount CMT deadpool ghosts Classic Film marvel comics miniseries Film SundanceTV discovery ABC Family concert police drama docuseries period drama Travel Channel Fall TV Academy Awards natural history Fox Searchlight scorecard criterion adventure TCA critics satire Esquire Shudder godzilla Disney+ Disney Plus Mudbound BET Election Martial Arts 79th Golden Globes Awards Masterpiece BET Awards Hallmark Spectrum Originals a nightmare on elm street Universal Pictures game of thrones FOX BBC America vs. Comic-Con@Home 2021 romance comic books Countdown Netflix Crunchyroll video tv talk A&E kaiju films E! dceu batman Logo target FXX toy story space Family SDCC PBS nbcuniversal stop motion ABC Mindy Kaling Fox News Apple TV+ Mary poppins Funimation asian-american DGA ITV animated werewolf Tubi halloween tv aliens best Rom-Com American Society of Cinematographers 2015 international Adult Swim Certified Fresh Binge Guide Disney streaming service GoT psycho video on demand casting kong diversity canceled Winter TV supernatural award winner OneApp laika Horror Hallmark Christmas movies Lifetime comic book movies 71st Emmy Awards Freeform Universal women art house Marvel Studios 2016 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt remakes Britbox new zealand streaming movies anime saw GLAAD Heroines Superheroes Marvel Television Baby Yoda science fiction LGBTQ transformers TV movies cats Brie Larson black Hulu Calendar thriller comedies latino free movies FX on Hulu prank WGN political drama disaster HBO screen actors guild NYCC Black History Month justice league Sony Pictures documentary docudrama wonder woman Acorn TV mockumentary cancelled television 4/20 Rocky Pet Sematary sag awards Turner Classic Movies Spike AMC 2019 comics jamie lee curtis AMC Plus cooking Amazon Studios 007 sequels Holidays versus rom-coms Legendary Food Network posters CNN dexter Nickelodeon Alien rotten movies we love television chucky breaking bad Trivia Song of Ice and Fire nfl cancelled TV shows franchise live event Writers Guild of America Hear Us Out Apple TV renewals spanish Infographic comic book movie royal family black comedy Winners Awards Tour 2021 Black Mirror Starz Television Critics Association Tokyo Olympics gangster green book italian Television Academy A24 Walt Disney Pictures DC Universe Peacock TLC christmas movies Action Mary Poppins Returns rt archives YouTube jurassic park news trailers rt labs critics edition Women's History Month Fargo Super Bowl The Walt Disney Company new york RT21 Film Festival Amazon Prime Video festivals cartoon RT History YouTube Red twilight Endgame GIFs boxoffice singing competition book adaptation OWN cops Summer The Walking Dead romantic comedy high school 93rd Oscars Wes Anderson Teen ratings TruTV Set visit 2020 toronto independent crime canceled TV shows Country Valentine's Day lord of the rings The Witch golden globe awards Reality Oscars Marathons New York Comic Con Year in Review USA directors mission: impossible die hard 90s movie dragons Creative Arts Emmys Pop TV emmy awards 99% Netflix Christmas movies hidden camera ESPN slashers TV south america streaming ID Quiz spanish language theme song 1990s indie Comics on TV DirecTV ABC Signature Discovery Channel Sci-Fi TV Land Nat Geo fresh superhero cults First Look binge Mystery indiana jones Bravo based on movie Pirates Reality Competition Thanksgiving dreamworks Awards Disney parents witnail Shondaland serial killer movies Cannes spinoff TBS Sundance Comic Book reboot TCA Winter 2020 73rd Emmy Awards hispanic TCA 2017 Marvel james bond 45 leaderboard teaser dc comic Arrowverse renewed TV shows TIFF Instagram Live halloween The Purge mutant foreign Biopics vampires Sundance TV Spring TV IMDb TV Lionsgate scary marvel cinematic universe critic resources dark MSNBC action-comedy Character Guide Apple TV Plus king arthur dramedy obituary cancelled TV series japanese BAFTA CW Seed know your critic Tags: Comedy archives Amazon Polls and Games spain sitcom screenings 2018 cars Showtime strong female leads Tumblr National Geographic adaptation fast and furious Drama First Reviews Extras Interview CBS venice spider-man Rock Western Photos Trophy Talk historical drama Comedy anthology psychological thriller politics boxing name the review PlayStation documentaries DC streaming service japan WarnerMedia reviews TCA Awards