Critics Consensus

The Light Between Oceans Is Beautiful but Uneven

Plus, Morgan fails to live up to its premise, and You're the Worst is Certified Fresh.

by | September 1, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a pair of lighthouse-dwelling impromptu parents (The Light Between Oceans, starring Michael Fassbender and Alicia Vikander) and a synthetic humanoid facing off against a corporate consultant with the power to order its extinction (Morgan, starring Anya Taylor-Joy and Kate Mara). What do the critics have to say?


The Light Between Oceans (2016) 62%

Nothing quite heralds the arrival of the fall season at the box office like a prestige drama — you know, the kind that comes with beautiful, sad-looking stars and a classy serif font on the poster. This year, just in time for Labor Day, we’ve got The Light Between Oceans, writer-director Derek Cianfrance‘s adaptation of the M.L. Stedman bestseller about a couple (Michael Fassbender and Alicia Vikander) whose marriage is haunted by his painful past and their shared grief over not being able to have a child — until a boat washes up on the shore of their lighthouse with a dead man and a baby inside. That discovery sets up a sumptuously filmed old-fashioned weepie that reviews describe as lovely to look at and undeniably effective, albeit also fairly chilly and dark. It seems likely we’ll see more satisfying dramas this season, but if you’re looking to get your cry on this weekend, the critics say you can safely head toward The Light Between Oceans.


Morgan (2016) 37%

Luke Scott, son of Ridley, makes his directorial debut with this weekend’s Morgan, a sci-fi thriller about a lab-grown organism (Anya Taylor-Joy) whose potentially lethal powers prompt a visit from a consultant (Kate Mara) sent to assess whether “she” should be terminated. It’s a premise with a number of intriguing possibilities, some of which have been examined by the elder Scott with powerful results (see: Blade Runner), but unfortunately, critics say Morgan isn’t really interested in exploring enough of them. Reviews describe the end result as a fairly boilerplate action picture whose standard set pieces aren’t nearly enough to cover the hole where a truly intelligent narrative might have fit, and although it’s still fairly painless as these things go, you might just be better off waiting for the rental.


What’s Hot on TV

You're the Worst: Season 3 (2016) 100%

You’re the Worst continues to chart serious territory with intelligence, heart, and noxious wit in its third season, even as the anti-rom-com’s damaged narcissist protagonists slowly start to get over themselves.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • White Girl (2016) , writer-director Elizabeth Wood’s provocative (and semi-autobiographical) look at a young woman’s descent into New York City’s underbelly, is at 71 percent.
  • Zoom (2015) , a trio of interlinked dramedies about artists from different disciplines, is at 69 percent.
  • Antibirth (2016) , starring Natasha Lyonne as a hard-partying woman who finds herself potentially impregnated through highly unusual means, is at 53 percent.
  • Kickboxer: Vengeance (2016) , a new installment in the venerable series that hails the return of original star Jean-Claude Van Damme, is at 50 percent.
  • Skiptrace (2016) , a Renny Harlin action-adventure starring Jackie Chan and Johnny Knoxville, is at 31 percent.
  • Yoga Hosers (2016) , Kevin Smith‘s Tusk spinoff about a pair of teenage convenience store clerks caught in a supernatural conflict, is at 22 percent.

Tag Cloud

Neflix Starz MCU Apple TV Plus Opinion spider-man trailers Binge Guide diversity Nickelodeon Trailer Comic-Con@Home 2021 Oscar Hollywood Foreign Press Association The Academy AMC vs. rotten series sitcom video boxing Song of Ice and Fire dramedy 2016 new zealand Animation Comics on TV spanish language Lionsgate Rock BET Awards festivals CBS All Access chucky leaderboard canceled latino aapi news movie royal family Music blockbusters supernatural toy story anthology Lifetime game of thrones miniseries child's play Mary poppins spain boxoffice stop motion spy thriller all-time cancelled TV series Cosplay YouTube DirecTV New York Comic Con game show witnail renewed TV shows heist movie Winter TV Rocketman scary movies CMT Action Universal rt labs critics edition 24 frames Anna Paquin name the review Pixar rotten movies we love DC streaming service Chernobyl toronto 72 Emmy Awards ITV TLC scorecard Logo ratings comics FX Schedule Apple El Rey A&E Legendary hispanic heritage month comiccon Amazon Studios spinoff period drama Tubi psycho Disney Plus E3 documentaries Disney+ Disney Plus Super Bowl popular reviews Family quibi dceu National Geographic blaxploitation Sneak Peek SDCC Disney streaming service slasher godzilla 90s Interview young adult nfl police drama binge nature revenge 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards casting Comedy Central satire History TV Land Election Nominations E! king kong Television Academy Best and Worst GIFs NBC Tomatazos cancelled TV shows cinemax marvel cinematic universe HBO Max Photos Shondaland summer preview Fox Searchlight cancelled television First Look thriller 45 wonder woman Superheroe See It Skip It Ellie Kemper Video Games sequel technology Esquire FX on Hulu high school robots debate 007 Black History Month composers BBC target reboot talk show Pop TV MTV Red Carpet Character Guide crime TNT Best Director stoner IMDb TV action-comedy comic dreamworks WGN Netflix NBA saw scene in color docuseries zombie Film Festival streaming japanese Creative Arts Emmys Tags: Comedy social media Discovery Channel Acorn TV TCA Shudder Podcast travel ghosts ID TV renewals elevated horror ABC GoT Baby Yoda Travel Channel dexter Kids & Family halloween tv USA Grammys OneApp mockumentary HFPA basketball 2019 Epix aliens PaleyFest Amazon biopic Fargo rt archives 99% cooking adenture Black Mirror singing competition Teen what to watch book mutant Academy Awards black comedy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Spectrum Originals Musical richard e. Grant Masterpiece BBC One Box Office legend Fantasy cars movies best Biopics CW Seed stand-up comedy blockbuster finale Oscars NYCC dragons Paramount Plus IFC indiana jones San Diego Comic-Con Sundance Exclusive Video science fiction Classic Film james bond YA screenings Set visit Netflix Christmas movies Columbia Pictures serial killer television The Walking Dead breaking bad Food Network Western Comedy hispanic Mystery disaster sequels VICE TV One ABC Family obituary Cannes obi wan ViacomCBS docudrama remakes 2015 theme song parents Endgame kong Television Critics Association new york Elton John 2017 TBS DGA true crime Vudu medical drama South by Southwest Film Festival classics cops children's TV Fox News Trivia 2021 Warner Bros. spanish Pirates The Walt Disney Company RT History Apple TV+ 93rd Oscars Superheroes Turner Classic Movies crime drama comedies TCA Winter 2020 politics Image Comics superman asian-american PBS zero dark thirty Hallmark Christmas movies Sundance TV razzies Broadway 2018 WarnerMedia psychological thriller mission: impossible MSNBC TV movies streaming movies fast and furious YouTube Red The Arrangement Certified Fresh Mary Poppins Returns adventure south america 2020 ESPN Crunchyroll Ghostbusters zombies comic books Brie Larson Reality Watching Series Thanksgiving crossover The Witch vampires Captain marvel Prime Video Sony Pictures emmy awards Tarantino pirates of the caribbean The CW Heroines festival TCA 2017 Paramount Pictures prank book adaptation worst Mudbound mcc free movies Pop gangster die hard streamig Tokyo Olympics Nat Geo VOD Hulu Lucasfilm Freeform Hallmark TCM cults The Purge Best Actress Dark Horse Comics ABC Signature Writers Guild of America Women's History Month batman YouTube Premium suspense BAFTA cartoon First Reviews Marvel Television Toys comic book movie TruTV olympics Cartoon Network jamie lee curtis sports Showtime Marathons cancelled Polls and Games live event 20th Century Fox Comic Book dark strong female leads Universal Pictures hidden camera Britbox Horror Infographic Peacock fresh SundanceTV natural history films Winners art house dogs Marvel Arrowverse marvel comics harry potter video on demand USA Network Disney Channel Sundance Now directors Extras Crackle Turner HBO christmas movies Awards Tour documentary halloween feel good Countdown universal monsters Focus Features Pacific Islander SXSW 2022 green book Holidays crime thriller DC Comics international scary GLAAD CNN laika Martial Arts black Best Picture war critic resources 21st Century Fox hollywood versus live action sag awards Rom-Com french women Lifetime Christmas movies SXSW Amazon Prime Video TIFF comic book movies Pride Month Reality Competition award winner summer TV CBS facebook kaiju slashers critics Emmy Nominations animated OWN BBC America Ovation FXX Syfy BET canceled TV shows Wes Anderson LGBT Paramount Sci-Fi President tv talk Rocky golden globes space screen actors guild hist DC Universe Drama Year in Review rt labs Film jurassic park Spring TV Quiz VH1 werewolf twilight rom-coms unscripted australia RT21 summer TV preview Tumblr Premiere Dates telelvision FOX deadpool Bravo Avengers know your critic football Emmys X-Men cats Trophy Talk 73rd Emmy Awards MGM criterion genre Stephen King Adult Swim superhero foreign Hear Us Out dc political drama nbcuniversal sopranos lord of the rings golden globe awards Mindy Kaling PlayStation 4/20 Paramount Network mob Summer worst movies justice league teaser Valentine's Day based on movie kids joker 94th Oscars Pet Sematary doctor who LGBTQ TCA Awards Amazon Prime IFC Films Star Trek franchise independent venice Best Actor a nightmare on elm street 71st Emmy Awards American Society of Cinematographers Marvel Studios Instagram Live romance HBO Go romantic comedy Mary Tyler Moore concert Star Wars Alien TV historical drama new star wars movies anime Awards italian king arthur adaptation Fall TV Calendar APB Funimation 1990s A24 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Walt Disney Pictures AMC Plus posters spider-verse monster movies archives indie discovery transformers Disney Christmas Holiday trophy Country Musicals biography Spike 79th Golden Globes Awards japan