Critics Consensus

The Light Between Oceans Is Beautiful but Uneven

Plus, Morgan fails to live up to its premise, and You're the Worst is Certified Fresh.

by | September 1, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a pair of lighthouse-dwelling impromptu parents (The Light Between Oceans, starring Michael Fassbender and Alicia Vikander) and a synthetic humanoid facing off against a corporate consultant with the power to order its extinction (Morgan, starring Anya Taylor-Joy and Kate Mara). What do the critics have to say?


The Light Between Oceans (2016) 61%

Nothing quite heralds the arrival of the fall season at the box office like a prestige drama — you know, the kind that comes with beautiful, sad-looking stars and a classy serif font on the poster. This year, just in time for Labor Day, we’ve got The Light Between Oceans, writer-director Derek Cianfrance‘s adaptation of the M.L. Stedman bestseller about a couple (Michael Fassbender and Alicia Vikander) whose marriage is haunted by his painful past and their shared grief over not being able to have a child — until a boat washes up on the shore of their lighthouse with a dead man and a baby inside. That discovery sets up a sumptuously filmed old-fashioned weepie that reviews describe as lovely to look at and undeniably effective, albeit also fairly chilly and dark. It seems likely we’ll see more satisfying dramas this season, but if you’re looking to get your cry on this weekend, the critics say you can safely head toward The Light Between Oceans.


Morgan (2016) 37%

Luke Scott, son of Ridley, makes his directorial debut with this weekend’s Morgan, a sci-fi thriller about a lab-grown organism (Anya Taylor-Joy) whose potentially lethal powers prompt a visit from a consultant (Kate Mara) sent to assess whether “she” should be terminated. It’s a premise with a number of intriguing possibilities, some of which have been examined by the elder Scott with powerful results (see: Blade Runner), but unfortunately, critics say Morgan isn’t really interested in exploring enough of them. Reviews describe the end result as a fairly boilerplate action picture whose standard set pieces aren’t nearly enough to cover the hole where a truly intelligent narrative might have fit, and although it’s still fairly painless as these things go, you might just be better off waiting for the rental.


What’s Hot on TV

You're the Worst: Season 3 (2016) 100%

You’re the Worst continues to chart serious territory with intelligence, heart, and noxious wit in its third season, even as the anti-rom-com’s damaged narcissist protagonists slowly start to get over themselves.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • White Girl (2016) , writer-director Elizabeth Wood’s provocative (and semi-autobiographical) look at a young woman’s descent into New York City’s underbelly, is at 71 percent.
  • Zoom (2015) , a trio of interlinked dramedies about artists from different disciplines, is at 69 percent.
  • Antibirth (2016) , starring Natasha Lyonne as a hard-partying woman who finds herself potentially impregnated through highly unusual means, is at 53 percent.
  • Kickboxer: Vengeance (2016) , a new installment in the venerable series that hails the return of original star Jean-Claude Van Damme, is at 50 percent.
  • Skiptrace (2016) , a Renny Harlin action-adventure starring Jackie Chan and Johnny Knoxville, is at 31 percent.
  • Yoga Hosers (2016) , Kevin Smith‘s Tusk spinoff about a pair of teenage convenience store clerks caught in a supernatural conflict, is at 22 percent.

Tag Cloud

pirates of the caribbean Sundance TV marvel comics jurassic park Marathons asian-american aapi TV movies spinoff hollywood Lucasfilm sequels game show Cannes Starz comiccon italian canceled TV shows Film Festival TCA Awards A24 lord of the rings TruTV TCM new york golden globes BBC One American Society of Cinematographers PBS First Reviews Trivia crime boxoffice Video Games HBO Max award winner DC Universe Alien sequel Creative Arts Emmys Pacific Islander scorecard venice CW Seed video on demand children's TV tv talk dreamworks king kong anthology Fox News ITV 2016 japan scene in color Star Wars CBS All Access Infographic joker thriller GIFs Masterpiece Kids & Family Holidays TCA OneApp Epix Baby Yoda kaiju heist movie Tokyo Olympics superhero Opinion YouTube Syfy 2018 ABC Stephen King political drama AMC Plus stoner El Rey Character Guide President Marvel Television biography Lionsgate travel psychological thriller high school TV Land Emmys Musical comic book movie james bond transformers Turner HBO justice league nature CBS First Look The Walt Disney Company fast and furious kids zero dark thirty disaster hidden camera DC Comics television cops Freeform war Disney Channel die hard BBC America AMC art house romance 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards DGA foreign 24 frames parents movies dogs Travel Channel docudrama name the review spain green book live event rom-coms 72 Emmy Awards Valentine's Day A&E Family video Superheroe Super Bowl San Diego Comic-Con Comic Book nfl crime drama Brie Larson Biopics crossover space Summer Disney streaming service comic Rocketman National Geographic Photos Comedy 73rd Emmy Awards Discovery Channel VICE 1990s adventure 2020 jamie lee curtis rt archives doctor who screenings spanish TIFF Ellie Kemper biopic LGBTQ Mary Tyler Moore comic books fresh Dark Horse Comics football FX on Hulu spanish language VH1 spider-man natural history razzies Cartoon Network facebook 2015 comic book movies Elton John Television Critics Association monster movies 99% Adult Swim feel good nbcuniversal 93rd Oscars Superheroes sitcom Mary Poppins Returns dramedy Heroines Comic-Con@Home 2021 book Esquire posters 71st Emmy Awards Hallmark Christmas movies classics Disney 45 2021 revenge Spike serial killer Apple TV+ Universal technology kong Disney Plus french Spectrum Originals Drama Animation PaleyFest OWN ratings reboot BAFTA Pop TV Mudbound theme song animated SDCC concert RT History scary stand-up comedy Food Network cats vampires Anna Paquin PlayStation Shondaland Thanksgiving genre Rock CMT japanese TV One Pride Month Apple TV Plus Amazon universal monsters Exclusive Video Black Mirror SundanceTV Song of Ice and Fire anime The Academy Academy Awards Red Carpet Pop Sneak Peek breaking bad reviews Spring TV Captain marvel DC streaming service black comedy X-Men Wes Anderson documentaries Amazon Studios Paramount Plus worst movies History Vudu quibi a nightmare on elm street comics werewolf Hulu Britbox cults MCU Crackle HBO Go vs. BBC cancelled television Hear Us Out diversity wonder woman south america legend archives Country Walt Disney Pictures social media know your critic Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Instagram Live Set visit blockbuster zombies MSNBC Pirates Best and Worst Disney+ Disney Plus 4/20 singing competition discovery cartoon Interview Trailer MTV BET streaming movies toy story TLC TCA Winter 2020 teaser Ghostbusters Cosplay rt labs critics edition Horror australia Hallmark Premiere Dates Broadway witnail cinemax Mystery indiana jones Bravo 007 ID Comedy Central Pixar Sundance Now slashers Mindy Kaling Sundance Nickelodeon sports cancelled TV shows mcc Universal Pictures streaming 20th Century Fox E! New York Comic Con adenture strong female leads rotten movies we love Martial Arts Tumblr target medical drama zombie Paramount Teen YouTube Premium TBS NBA hispanic heritage month Grammys new zealand basketball police drama composers rotten Action Netflix Christmas movies BET Awards Sci-Fi Television Academy The Walking Dead saw all-time cancelled TV series psycho Holiday films richard e. Grant festivals dragons Polls and Games remakes Star Trek worst Classic Film mutant Film deadpool science fiction gangster Western independent Sony Pictures WarnerMedia Arrowverse Music Marvel binge Lifetime Christmas movies Fantasy Countdown Toys godzilla batman GLAAD satire Pet Sematary politics 2017 GoT chucky directors Turner Classic Movies trailers adaptation The Witch Neflix king arthur YA CNN TV renewals dceu talk show comedies sopranos Calendar hist mockumentary screen actors guild blaxploitation emmy awards international news aliens ghosts unscripted rt labs dc DirecTV live action renewed TV shows halloween VOD free movies Rom-Com Warner Bros. Fox Searchlight toronto versus supernatural IFC Films critic resources Extras historical drama Nominations Quiz festival USA hispanic E3 Lifetime Chernobyl FXX elevated horror FX Trophy Talk spy thriller debate WGN Podcast Acorn TV APB IMDb TV slasher TV YouTube Red 90s period drama latino boxing laika Apple crime thriller cars halloween tv Writers Guild of America game of thrones SXSW new star wars movies Rocky stop motion RT21 mob miniseries dark Endgame Emmy Nominations popular based on movie book adaptation suspense Winter TV mission: impossible critics cooking canceled action-comedy prank LGBT dexter NYCC casting finale robots Binge Guide NBC The CW black young adult Awards Tour Marvel Studios Year in Review Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt The Purge Fall TV Election See It Skip It 21st Century Fox Legendary IFC Shudder 2019 ESPN TCA 2017 superman olympics Nat Geo true crime harry potter Showtime Women's History Month indie Awards Columbia Pictures series Tomatazos Certified Fresh child's play sag awards Mary poppins Christmas Black History Month TNT Oscars Amazon Prime Video ABC Family ABC Signature Avengers Box Office marvel cinematic universe spider-verse Tubi FOX Netflix Schedule Tarantino USA Network Paramount Network Winners Comics on TV movie golden globe awards docuseries romantic comedy Funimation best scary movies blockbusters The Arrangement Ovation cancelled Peacock christmas movies franchise Reality Competition women criterion twilight ViacomCBS Watching Series Musicals Crunchyroll Logo telelvision royal family Image Comics documentary Amazon Prime what to watch obituary Reality