Critics Consensus

The Light Between Oceans Is Beautiful but Uneven

Plus, Morgan fails to live up to its premise, and You're the Worst is Certified Fresh.

by | September 1, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a pair of lighthouse-dwelling impromptu parents (The Light Between Oceans, starring Michael Fassbender and Alicia Vikander) and a synthetic humanoid facing off against a corporate consultant with the power to order its extinction (Morgan, starring Anya Taylor-Joy and Kate Mara). What do the critics have to say?


The Light Between Oceans (2016) 61%

Nothing quite heralds the arrival of the fall season at the box office like a prestige drama — you know, the kind that comes with beautiful, sad-looking stars and a classy serif font on the poster. This year, just in time for Labor Day, we’ve got The Light Between Oceans, writer-director Derek Cianfrance‘s adaptation of the M.L. Stedman bestseller about a couple (Michael Fassbender and Alicia Vikander) whose marriage is haunted by his painful past and their shared grief over not being able to have a child — until a boat washes up on the shore of their lighthouse with a dead man and a baby inside. That discovery sets up a sumptuously filmed old-fashioned weepie that reviews describe as lovely to look at and undeniably effective, albeit also fairly chilly and dark. It seems likely we’ll see more satisfying dramas this season, but if you’re looking to get your cry on this weekend, the critics say you can safely head toward The Light Between Oceans.


Morgan (2016) 37%

Luke Scott, son of Ridley, makes his directorial debut with this weekend’s Morgan, a sci-fi thriller about a lab-grown organism (Anya Taylor-Joy) whose potentially lethal powers prompt a visit from a consultant (Kate Mara) sent to assess whether “she” should be terminated. It’s a premise with a number of intriguing possibilities, some of which have been examined by the elder Scott with powerful results (see: Blade Runner), but unfortunately, critics say Morgan isn’t really interested in exploring enough of them. Reviews describe the end result as a fairly boilerplate action picture whose standard set pieces aren’t nearly enough to cover the hole where a truly intelligent narrative might have fit, and although it’s still fairly painless as these things go, you might just be better off waiting for the rental.


What’s Hot on TV

You're the Worst: Season 3 (2016) 100%

You’re the Worst continues to chart serious territory with intelligence, heart, and noxious wit in its third season, even as the anti-rom-com’s damaged narcissist protagonists slowly start to get over themselves.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • White Girl (2016) , writer-director Elizabeth Wood’s provocative (and semi-autobiographical) look at a young woman’s descent into New York City’s underbelly, is at 71 percent.
  • Zoom (2016) , a trio of interlinked dramedies about artists from different disciplines, is at 69 percent.
  • Antibirth (2016) , starring Natasha Lyonne as a hard-partying woman who finds herself potentially impregnated through highly unusual means, is at 53 percent.
  • Kickboxer: Vengeance (2016) , a new installment in the venerable series that hails the return of original star Jean-Claude Van Damme, is at 50 percent.
  • Skiptrace (2016) , a Renny Harlin action-adventure starring Jackie Chan and Johnny Knoxville, is at 31 percent.
  • Yoga Hosers (2016) , Kevin Smith‘s Tusk spinoff about a pair of teenage convenience store clerks caught in a supernatural conflict, is at 22 percent.

Tag Cloud

television comiccon transformers Calendar Trophy Talk 45 war Sundance Now San Diego Comic-Con blaxploitation Podcast The Arrangement PaleyFest TCM aliens Polls and Games Paramount binge E3 Oscars spy thriller Summer Super Bowl Trivia TV Land cops CNN Nominations OWN Certified Fresh Logo YouTube Premium Pop Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cinemax Mary poppins Opinion Extras 2018 thriller anime NBC Marvel Crackle award winner based on movie serial killer Apple Mary Poppins Returns Warner Bros. ESPN biography adventure 007 zombies Esquire Walt Disney Pictures Grammys Pirates justice league DC streaming service police drama FOX E! technology Rock BBC Star Wars Character Guide Music crime drama FX Ellie Kemper Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DirecTV Winners cats dceu docudrama Watching Series cults Reality Nickelodeon Video Games finale Christmas golden globes Acorn TV Pixar WGN Tomatazos TBS TCA 2017 Netflix Musicals DC Universe science fiction talk show CBS All Access supernatural IFC Bravo President Cosplay Box Office CBS 2015 MSNBC Emmys Fantasy Epix diversity Animation National Geographic LGBTQ Biopics Fall TV boxoffice Interview Comic Book USA Network 24 frames vampires Writers Guild of America Comics on TV Sci-Fi Disney TV Trailer Superheroe cooking Mystery Horror PBS Universal period drama hist robots TruTV DC Comics First Look CW Seed Sundance Lifetime crime thriller GLAAD travel Food Network YA ABC Winter TV Rocky VH1 streaming ratings Fox News BET what to watch MTV APB romance Awards Tour mutant Spring TV Action political drama 2016 Tumblr Nat Geo SDCC BBC America medical drama Kids & Family Amazon 20th Century Fox New York Comic Con 2019 unscripted YouTube Red comic Countdown Disney Channel Adult Swim sports dc Marathons Western Teen festivals Country Thanksgiving El Rey X-Men crime zombie doctor who Showtime Masterpiece Comedy Central GoT politics Starz singing competition discovery Photos Cartoon Network harry potter TNT Drama Comedy Premiere Dates NYCC Mindy Kaling Shudder Ghostbusters social media IFC Films American Society of Cinematographers Holidays Mary Tyler Moore Awards spider-man Red Carpet SXSW green book VICE ABC Family Columbia Pictures Election Set visit Dark Horse Comics Schedule Sony Pictures Valentine's Day Year in Review Britbox Ovation Martial Arts ITV USA 2017 dramedy Creative Arts Emmys jamie lee curtis Quiz Shondaland Spike AMC TCA Lionsgate Sneak Peek RT History sitcom Rom-Com CMT Best and Worst composers Musical TLC See It Skip It psycho Paramount Network Lucasfilm Hulu Syfy GIFs The CW HBO 21st Century Fox historical drama FXX A&E Toys Star Trek History Superheroes TIFF crossover Reality Competition Infographic Freeform SundanceTV Song of Ice and Fire