Critics Consensus

Dear Evan Hansen Misses the High Note

Plus, The Guilty is a solid thriller, and Netflix's Midnight Mass and Disney+'s Star Wars: Visions are both Certified Fresh.

by | September 23, 2021 | Comments

This weekend, we’ve got a musical misfire (Dear Evan Hansen, starring Ben Platt and Kaitlyn Dever), and an emergency call gone awry (The Guilty, starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Ethan Hawke), as well as a couple of hotly anticipated new streaming series. What are the critics saying?

Dear Evan Hansen (2021)


In a year chock full of musical adaptations, you’d think that one based on a multiple Tony Award-winner would be a sure thing… and you’d be wrong. Stephen Chbosky’s (The Perks of Being a WallflowerDear Evan Hansen, based on the 2016 Broadway musical of the same name, stars Ben Platt as the titular high school senior suffering from anxiety who’s been tasked by his therapist to write encouraging letters to himself. When a troubled classmate named Connor (Colton Ryan) nabs one of those letters, then later commits suicide, Connor’s parents believe Evan is the best friend they never knew their son had, and the misunderstanding quickly spirals out of Evan’s control. Critics say that the central premise of the story, which was already problematic on stage, is even more egregiously toxic now, and instead of embracing its inherent darkness, Chbosky and Co. insist upon wringing inspirational platitudes from it, much to the film’s detriment. The impressive cast also includes Kaitlyn Dever, Amy Adams, and Julianne Moore, and the musical numbers translate fairly well onto celluloid, but reviews say the whole enterprise feels a little tone deaf, which robs it of some of its power. It’s still probably worth a watch for fans of the original, but be prepared for a different experience here.

The Guilty (2021)


It’s usually a pretty risky proposition to center a film on a single actor in a single location, but fantastic results are possible (see: 2010’s Buried or 2013’s Locke). The latest to make the attempt is The Guilty — which is itself a direct remake of the 2018 Danish film of the same name. The new film, releasing in theaters this week and streaming on Netflix next week, is directed by Antoine Fuqua and stars Jake Gyllenhaal in the central role, Joe Baylor, an L.A. cop relegated to 9-1-1 dispatch duty who takes a call from a woman in the midst of a kidnapping. As Joe attempts to ascertain the woman’s whereabouts and get to the bottom of her story, he gradually learns that not everything is as it seems. Critics say The Guilty isn’t quite as gripping as its predecessor, but Antoine Fuqua knows his way around a tense, gritty thriller, and Jake Gyllenhaal brings his A-game to the table in a riveting performance that holds the film together.

What’s New on TV

An ambitious meditation on grief and faith that is as gorgeous as it is unsettling, Midnight Mass’s slow boil is a triumph of terror that will leave viewers shaking – and thinking – long after the credits roll.

Gorgeously animated and wildly creative, Visions is an eclectic, but wholly enjoyable collection of Star Wars stories that breathe new life into the galaxy.

Thumbnail image by Universal Pictures

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

new york new zealand aliens know your critic FX Nominations Star Trek Pixar art house Awards rt archives Premiere Dates Chernobyl true crime period drama Mudbound zombie Crackle remakes Avengers Animation OneApp hidden camera 21st Century Fox marvel cinematic universe 72 Emmy Awards psychological thriller Tubi Elton John Reality Competition 90s women Acorn TV Fox News spinoff batman Martial Arts NBC Sci-Fi The Academy anthology supernatural Polls and Games Podcast 2020 Mystery cooking Lionsgate hollywood The Witch slashers blaxploitation Pirates Hallmark Christmas movies MTV Lucasfilm Marvel golden globe awards all-time 71st Emmy Awards Reality award winner Family Schedule godzilla Comic-Con@Home 2021 New York Comic Con Lifetime live event FOX adenture PBS YouTube Red The Arrangement Holidays SDCC Video Games 2015 Sneak Peek dark DC streaming service video on demand Marathons mutant canceled TV shows deadpool Mary poppins First Reviews 93rd Oscars Columbia Pictures action-comedy San Diego Comic-Con finale elevated horror high school Funimation festivals rotten cancelled TV series Summer E3 posters blockbusters FXX wonder woman Countdown TruTV Food Network Pop Nickelodeon Classic Film TLC Starz PaleyFest discovery anime Black History Month natural history space mob ABC Family Character Guide doctor who 2016 Ovation cartoon The Walt Disney Company mission: impossible Amazon Prime Video foreign slasher Music Chilling Adventures of Sabrina renewed TV shows Comic Book 20th Century Fox Election HBO Max political drama razzies streaming archives medical drama Esquire obituary Vudu Spring TV dexter worst AMC Plus Tokyo Olympics Red Carpet gangster Emmys indie witnail hist Mary Poppins Returns blockbuster LGBT screenings BET zombies reviews TCA Awards CNN halloween miniseries dragons sag awards Writers Guild of America scorecard Heroines Trailer LGBTQ 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Country toronto VH1 scene in color Women's History Month unscripted popular book adaptation screen actors guild pirates of the caribbean Tomatazos toy story Musicals 45 satire Rom-Com Brie Larson sopranos Trophy Talk twilight adaptation jurassic park Box Office Winners Britbox 1990s Interview Oscars Toys Apple TV+ adventure boxoffice thriller E! classics TCM ViacomCBS directors DGA Rock based on movie south america critics trailers versus vs. composers psycho a nightmare on elm street prank facebook rt labs critics edition children's TV stand-up comedy hispanic heritage month james bond kids jamie lee curtis dogs WGN hispanic IFC Films DC Universe olympics Spectrum Originals television Netflix tv talk latino Showtime Film Pet Sematary Holiday HBO Go nfl die hard comics talk show breaking bad strong female leads Sundance comiccon 2018 Horror SundanceTV docudrama TNT ABC Signature Hulu First Look book harry potter revenge USA Hallmark sequel 4/20 Kids & Family spanish Spike Television Academy Fantasy superman Ellie Kemper docuseries Thanksgiving documentaries 2019 The Purge game of thrones Shudder ratings Trivia American Society of Cinematographers 2021 Instagram Live Universal cops legend franchise TCA 2017 technology TIFF romance Tumblr Tarantino A24 TBS Opinion CBS Travel Channel comic books biopic Apple aapi YouTube Binge Guide football 24 frames australia king arthur Rocketman Captain marvel crime Netflix Christmas movies A&E CW Seed international WarnerMedia joker Year in Review APB Valentine's Day cats streaming movies animated Extras transformers festival justice league Photos richard e. Grant Amazon Studios japanese TCA Winter 2020 game show GLAAD zero dark thirty comic book movies Ghostbusters crime drama italian Turner free movies cancelled television YouTube Premium sports Hear Us Out worst movies The Walking Dead Warner Bros. green book independent Freeform singing competition criterion National Geographic comic basketball feel good NYCC PlayStation Comedy venice Comics on TV Quiz Infographic Walt Disney Pictures El Rey documentary TV One YA binge TV movies boxing theme song new star wars movies indiana jones reboot TV BAFTA IFC Sundance TV spanish language black IMDb TV young adult Apple TV Plus Peacock AMC Epix Marvel Studios Image Comics Creative Arts Emmys Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VOD Broadway quibi nbcuniversal BBC cinemax war GIFs Turner Classic Movies mockumentary crime thriller MSNBC Western 99% ID DC Comics ghosts monster movies scary movies Neflix rom-coms NBA teaser Certified Fresh Best and Worst lord of the rings Awards Tour spy thriller Black Mirror Cosplay sequels Disney streaming service Disney Legendary Adult Swim Mindy Kaling Crunchyroll best Super Bowl biography science fiction Biopics movie canceled cults Academy Awards Sundance Now nature Fall TV Comedy Central RT History series TCA DirecTV Exclusive Video police drama Fox Searchlight Paramount Plus royal family halloween tv Song of Ice and Fire movies The CW asian-american stop motion dramedy Alien Mary Tyler Moore Endgame black comedy social media Watching Series robots scary casting Pop TV chucky Teen Drama Shondaland Amazon disaster Cannes comedies Emmy Nominations kong Baby Yoda Set visit crossover Amazon Prime name the review Superheroe japan sitcom RT21 Film Festival FX on Hulu cars Lifetime Christmas movies Christmas cancelled See It Skip It mcc films cancelled TV shows Anna Paquin spider-man Masterpiece romantic comedy ITV golden globes werewolf telelvision Syfy Universal Pictures Musical Marvel Television king kong debate Disney Plus Sony Pictures spain MCU X-Men CBS All Access historical drama CMT live action Logo Superheroes christmas movies BBC One VICE Wes Anderson Dark Horse Comics Calendar SXSW Grammys USA Network concert diversity dc TV renewals spider-verse rt labs Disney Channel Rocky vampires french BBC America President Paramount Network GoT heist movie travel History video stoner comic book movie Star Wars 2017 Bravo HBO TV Land Stephen King 007 Disney+ Disney Plus kaiju Pacific Islander news dreamworks critic resources Paramount Discovery Channel child's play emmy awards BET Awards serial killer laika ESPN fresh dceu Television Critics Association Cartoon Network fast and furious genre universal monsters politics 73rd Emmy Awards OWN Action Pride Month Winter TV suspense Nat Geo target marvel comics ABC parents what to watch rotten movies we love saw Arrowverse superhero