Critics Consensus

The Eyes of Tammy Faye Is Unfocused, but Jessica Chastain Is Riveting

Plus, Cry Macho is minor Eastwood, Copshop is surprisingly thrilling, Nightbooks is spooky family fun, and Y: The Last Man is a solid adaptation.

by | September 16, 2021 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got scandalous evangelists (The Eyes of Tammy Faye, starring Jessica Chastain and Andrew Garfield), a divisive road trip (Cry Macho, starring Clint Eastwood and Eduardo Minett), a lockdown showdown (Copshop, starring Gerard Butler and Frank Grillo), and a captive storyteller (Nightbooks, starring Winslow Fegley and Krysten Ritter). What are the critics saying?

During the 1970s and 1980s, televangelist couple Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker rose to prominence through the religious broadcasting network and real estate empire they built, before it all came tumbling down in a mess of scandals and criminal fraud in 1989. The 2000 documentary The Eyes of Tammy Faye chronicled the couple’s rise and fall in poignant fashion, and this week’s The Eyes of Tammy Faye seeks to dramatize the whole affair. Andrew Garfield and Jessica Chastain don heavy make-up and advanced prosthetics to play Jim and Tammy Faye in Michael Showalter’s (The Big Sick) new adaptation, focusing in particular on the latter’s journey and, at times, faithfully recreating scenes from the original documentary. While critics remain a little disappointed that Showalter and Co. chose not to explore their eccentric characters in more detail, the story is a fascinating one at its core, and the performances — especially from Chastain — are impressive enough to warrant a watch.

Cry Macho (2021)


Clint Eastwood has had some fun in recent years poking holes in the tough-guy persona that characterized much of his early career, and he continues that trend in Cry Macho. Eastwood stars as Mike Milo, an aging former rodeo star who is tasked by an ex-boss to retrieve — read: kidnap — his estranged son from his abusive mother in Mexico City and escort him back to Texas. When Mike arrives, he learns there’s more to the story than he was led to believe, and he and young Rafo (Eduardo Minett) — along with Rafo’s fighting rooster Macho — set out on a road trip that will change both their lives. Set in the late 1970s and based on the 1975 novel of the same name by the late N. Richard Nash, who also penned the first version of the script, Cry Macho sees Eastwood reuniting with writer Nick Schenk, and the film appropriately feels like a cross between two of their former projects, namely Gran Torino and The Mule. Critics are split on the film, however; some say the writing and the acting feel a little uncharacteristically clumsy, especially in the early going, while others say if you’re willing to stick it out, the film improves in its second half. You won’t likely find anything particularly fresh or inventive about the story or the storytelling, but there are some quiet, thoughtful moments peppered throughout the film, and Eastwood proves he can still throw a punch at the ripe old age of 91. You can catch this one in theaters or on HBO Max.

Copshop (2021)


You may think you’ve got Copshop all figured out just by seeing that it stars Gerard Butler and Frank Grillo — two tough guys whose filmographies are littered with cookie-cutter action flicks. Pair them with director Joe Carnahan (Narc, The Grey), though, and you may have a stylish, economically shot thriller on your hands. Grillo stars as con man Teddy Murretto, who thinks he’s outsmarted hitman Bob Viddick (Butler) by getting himself locked up in a small-town jail in Nevada. Unfortunately for Teddy, Viddick plays the same trick, and while the two quietly plot against each other in separate cells, another assassin (Toby Huss) arrives on the scene and throws everything into chaos. Critics say Copshop is a suitably old-fashioned action thriller that doesn’t reinvent the genre but does what it sets out to do pretty effectively, so if you’re looking for a cheeky, fast-paced showdown, you’re likely to have a pretty good time.

Nightbooks (2021)


The director of 2019’s Brightburn might not seem like an ideal fit for a spooky children’s film on Netflix, but David Yarovesky seems to have hit just the right tone with Nightbooks. Produced by Sam Raimi, the movie stars Winslow Fegley as Alex, a young boy with a gift for writing scary stories and Krysten Ritter as Natacha, the witch who imprisons him and demands he tell her a new story every night. In other words, yes, it’s like Goosebumps meets Arabian Nights, with a pre-teen R.L. Stine as Scheherazade. As goofy as that may sound, critics so far mostly say it’s a mix that works, with a potent blend of heart and horror that should thrill younger viewers. Granted, it’s a tad early for spooky Halloween content, but it’s on Netflix, which means you can rewatch it with the kids as many times as you want.

What’s New on TV

Y: The Last Man makes a few key updates to its source material and boasts a number of incredible performances, but this highly anticipated adaptation can’t help but feel like a bit of a letdown in a world full of dystopian realities.

Thumbnail image by Searchlight Pictures

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Paramount Brie Larson Chernobyl Amazon History GoT CNN vampires Character Guide mission: impossible Holiday Warner Bros. adaptation USA Spike slasher Chilling Adventures of Sabrina jurassic park 73rd Emmy Awards Sony Pictures critics Sci-Fi Calendar See It Skip It Awards Tour TCA Shudder deadpool Opinion christmas movies Podcast police drama PBS Syfy festivals classics Ghostbusters toy story cats adenture Comic Book 24 frames San Diego Comic-Con cars monster movies Musical TV renewals theme song Marvel Studios witnail Set visit sequel BBC America critic resources Arrowverse Pride Month Spectrum Originals Legendary dramedy Kids & Family war game of thrones spanish language cartoon Quiz Showtime PaleyFest LGBT Thanksgiving Avengers Tokyo Olympics Drama WGN dc genre award winner Writers Guild of America ESPN Amazon Studios movies Pixar Dark Horse Comics Pop Alien rotten Television Critics Association Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt children's TV Broadway YouTube TCA Awards stoner talk show Black Mirror joker anime Action superhero comic book movie Martial Arts superman comic Paramount Plus asian-american ViacomCBS blockbuster international Marvel Television Bravo Election E3 new zealand elevated horror sports japan Mary Tyler Moore DC Comics Family Creative Arts Emmys Red Carpet Song of Ice and Fire Star Trek Amazon Prime justice league Mary poppins Spring TV diversity vs. spy thriller green book DC Universe quibi hist Cosplay natural history Apple TV+ fresh IFC Year in Review Sundance Now VH1 The CW New York Comic Con American Society of Cinematographers Emmy Nominations facebook know your critic live event all-time Schedule Disney pirates of the caribbean CBS Winter TV Tumblr streaming movies zero dark thirty NYCC 45 Mindy Kaling james bond Infographic spain gangster TIFF lord of the rings 2017 dreamworks ghosts indie 90s kaiju basketball aliens AMC Plus heist movie technology OWN comic book movies MSNBC Rocketman rt archives king arthur Adult Swim sag awards zombies sequels romance Certified Fresh indiana jones singing competition hollywood Christmas sopranos DGA fast and furious Fox Searchlight E! free movies book CMT crossover emmy awards historical drama MCU SDCC TCA Winter 2020 films debate child's play Sneak Peek social media Fall TV 2019 supernatural Vudu suspense BAFTA Mary Poppins Returns nfl adventure The Walt Disney Company 2018 science fiction Starz A24 posters Summer The Purge Rocky japanese directors crime book adaptation mockumentary TV Land anthology Hallmark Christmas movies The Academy BBC One Paramount Network trailers animated Reality LGBTQ scary movies YouTube Red video on demand criterion screenings rt labs Walt Disney Pictures festival Hulu remakes documentary Pacific Islander new york marvel comics First Look Turner Classic Movies Stephen King thriller Heroines TCM godzilla President Teen new star wars movies VOD based on movie canceled Sundance TV medical drama hispanic miniseries period drama Acorn TV Trophy Talk Disney Plus HBO Go art house DirecTV Comedy Central scene in color black Exclusive Video reboot toronto psychological thriller First Reviews Crackle FX Musicals tv talk archives biography Animation mcc Nat Geo worst movies hispanic heritage month comiccon australia aapi docuseries Toys TLC cooking worst OneApp Premiere Dates Nickelodeon nature Holidays Food Network Reality Competition Box Office politics cancelled television Hallmark halloween Britbox Pop TV revenge Captain marvel Western CBS All Access Discovery Channel screen actors guild Peacock Elton John Marathons french cults ID space unscripted 20th Century Fox Valentine's Day Cartoon Network Logo die hard 2016 Watching Series Comics on TV docudrama romantic comedy Freeform 2020 Comic-Con@Home 2021 video doctor who stand-up comedy halloween tv Tarantino Photos GIFs werewolf obituary VICE cancelled TV series casting razzies blockbusters mutant scary foreign feel good FXX Lifetime Nominations Superheroe Ovation Masterpiece Apple streaming X-Men 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards National Geographic Neflix YA Funimation boxoffice golden globe awards Academy Awards TV movies kids saw ABC Signature best psycho Women's History Month Trivia ITV WarnerMedia Awards RT History batman Countdown TCA 2017 CW Seed Travel Channel Columbia Pictures Instagram Live golden globes 99% comedies Superheroes ABC stop motion telelvision political drama chucky what to watch TBS Disney streaming service Classic Film breaking bad cops reviews BET Awards FOX Baby Yoda jamie lee curtis Video Games YouTube Premium Netflix Christmas movies RT21 GLAAD 1990s cinemax Epix Ellie Kemper BBC Disney Channel marvel cinematic universe Star Wars transformers Pirates news Lucasfilm Amazon Prime Video ABC Family Horror HBO richard e. Grant SundanceTV canceled TV shows Music women twilight mob concert comics Polls and Games comic books A&E cancelled NBA italian dark dragons Tubi Film PlayStation Television Academy spanish composers 93rd Oscars series target young adult Winners Binge Guide football crime drama TNT 72 Emmy Awards movie Black History Month TV rom-coms a nightmare on elm street legend Anna Paquin robots Cannes game show live action Comedy FX on Hulu king kong Extras Tomatazos Mudbound Hear Us Out TV One The Witch BET dogs south america binge Netflix Country Image Comics Disney+ Disney Plus kong travel documentaries TruTV television Universal Super Bowl Trailer Interview serial killer HBO Max DC streaming service biopic parents spider-verse true crime Sundance Turner scorecard disaster strong female leads rotten movies we love NBC sitcom rt labs critics edition harry potter Marvel blaxploitation finale Lionsgate franchise universal monsters Crunchyroll Emmys hidden camera Wes Anderson dexter ratings Pet Sematary teaser SXSW crime thriller Universal Pictures 4/20 olympics high school Lifetime Christmas movies Rom-Com Fantasy Best and Worst prank Fox News nbcuniversal name the review Mystery 2015 71st Emmy Awards 21st Century Fox MTV slashers Endgame Rock The Walking Dead The Arrangement Esquire Oscars popular action-comedy discovery renewed TV shows APB IMDb TV wonder woman zombie AMC spider-man satire Grammys Biopics venice spinoff independent versus black comedy dceu boxing Apple TV Plus USA Network laika cancelled TV shows IFC Films 007 latino Shondaland royal family El Rey 2021 Film Festival