Critics Consensus

The Gentlemen is Vintage Guy Ritchie

Plus, The Turning spins a twisty but unsatisfying tale, and Color out of Space and Zombi Child are Certified Fresh.

by | January 23, 2020 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a retiring kingpin (The Gentlemen, starring Matthew McConaughey and Hugh Grant) and a bedeviled babysitter (The Turning, starring Mackenzie Davis and Finn Wolfhard). What are the critics saying?


The Gentlemen (2020) 73%

Director Guy Ritchie has spent the past several years helming big-budget Hollywood projects like the Sherlock Holmes movies, The Man from U.N.C.L.E., 2017’s King Arthur: Legend of the Sword, and last year’s live-action remake of Disney’s Aladdin. But it’s worth remembering that he initially made a name for himself with sprawling crime capers led by ensemble casts, like Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels and Snatch. Much like Rian Johnson did recently with Knives Out, Ritchie returns to his roots this week with The Gentlemen, hoping to recapture the same magic that made him a studio darling. Matthew McConaughey leads the way as Michael “Mickey” Pearson, an American ex-pat in London who rules over a vast marijuana empire. When Mickey decides he wants to sell off his business and retire, a number of interested parties emerge, setting off a war of double-crosses as everyone struggles to get the upper hand. In other words, this is classic Guy Ritchie territory, and most critics say it’s a witty, entertaining, fast-paced comedy that benefits from some top-notch talent, particularly Hugh Grant and Colin Farrell at their scenery-chewing best. That said, Ritchie’s penchant for colorful language and tendency to play sordid situations for laughs — bestiality, casual and frequent racism, and a rape figure into the narrative here — aren’t for everyone, so it’s likely to shock anyone only familiar with his more mainstream fare.


The Turning (2020) 12%

Henry James’ classic novella The Turn of the Screw is one of the most famous examples of open-ended gothic horror, and it’s been the subject of classroom debates ever since it was first published in 1898. So it’s fitting that it has seen numerous screen adaptations, many of which offer different interpretations of what exactly the story communicates. The latest is this week’s The Turning, brought to us courtesy of director Floria Sigismondi (The Runaways, Marvel’s DaredevilThe Handmaid’s Tale), who updates the story for a 1990s setting, and critics say it’s unnecessary and unnecessarily frustrating. Mackenzie Davis stars as Kate, the new nanny to orphaned high-society siblings Miles (Finn Wolfhard) and Flora Fairchild (Brooklynn Prince), who live on a large, spooky estate in Maine in the care of their maid. Kate quickly discovers that neither the children nor the house is quite normal, and when mysterious things begin to happen, she finds herself ill-equipped to make sense of any of it. Unfortunately, the critics largely also failed to make much sense of the film, which fails to generate much dread from its repeated images of creepy doll faces and ghostly specters in the distance en route to a baffling climax. James’ original story is clearly meant to inspire discussion, but The Turning isn’t likely to spark much other than bewilderment and maybe a little regret.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • I Wish I Knew (Hai shang chuan qi) (2020)Jia Zhangke’s documentary portrait of Shanghai and its remarkable history, is at 100%.
  • Color Out of Space (2020) , starring Nicolas Cage in an adaptation of the H.P. Lovecraft short story of the same title, about the effects of a meteorite on a family living in rural Massachusetts, is Certified Fresh at 87%.
  • Zombi Child (2020) , following two parallel stories about a sugar plantation worker in 1962 Haiti and his granddaughter, who attends a boarding school in present-day France, is Certified Fresh at 87%.
  • The Last Full Measure (2020) , featuring a star-studded cast in a based-on-true-events drama about a Pentagon staffer’s investigation of a Medal of Honor request for a Vietnam War hero, is at 63%.
  • Quezon's Game (2020) , a drama about former Filipino President Manuel Quezon’s efforts to rescue Jews during the Holocaust, is at 29%.
  • John Henry (2020) , starring Terry Crews as a former gang member who turns to vigilante justice when he encounters two children on the run from the leader of the gang he left, is at 0%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Opinion ITV OneApp zero dark thirty serial killer 20th Century Fox TruTV Tubi Creative Arts Emmys joker Premiere Dates Ellie Kemper Horror History NYCC Song of Ice and Fire crime thriller justice league crossover Mindy Kaling festivals The Witch crime stand-up comedy Writers Guild of America Watching Series sitcom Extras Comedy Emmy Nominations 2018 The Arrangement ghosts YA Lucasfilm biography foreign YouTube Elton John Disney adventure Epix technology E! Spectrum Originals Hallmark TIFF PaleyFest finale ABC Ovation Pop romance Cosplay hist Holiday Amazon Prime Video sequel Lifetime Warner Bros. Christmas Super Bowl Arrowverse Disney streaming service richard e. Grant Valentine's Day Pirates Reality Election harry potter Shudder TV Land strong female leads 2015 robots movie CBS All Access Bravo medical drama Nat Geo See It Skip It children's TV Masterpiece PBS Fox News SundanceTV canceled TV shows TV Classic Film Comedy Central latino Lifetime Christmas movies Amazon werewolf Universal 71st Emmy Awards The CW TNT HBO boxoffice 007 Grammys IFC Films Infographic BET streaming canceled supernatural OWN Certified Fresh FOX BBC Amazon Prime Western reboot Countdown directors Crackle christmas movies Vudu comics Set visit Music Summer 2020 revenge Emmys Apple GIFs quibi Star Wars free movies Teen Trophy Talk Stephen King Film theme song psychological thriller Disney Plus Rocketman Adult Swim batman travel Captain marvel mutant kids cancelled TV shows based on movie book Schedule APB A24 Sony Pictures First Reviews Baby Yoda Netflix Christmas movies Columbia Pictures Pride Month San Diego Comic-Con RT21 Hallmark Christmas movies witnail Country Paramount Network jamie lee curtis Logo indie doctor who game show Paramount Amazon Studios teaser X-Men Showtime science fiction MCU cartoon golden globes Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Walt Disney Pictures Pet Sematary 24 frames MTV renewed TV shows anthology Starz casting video dc cancelled TV series 45 FX spy thriller Box Office period drama Fall TV screen actors guild comiccon GLAAD war Fantasy Marathons adaptation 2016 TCA documentary Year in Review Musical Television Academy Oscars Binge Guide nature elevated horror Mary poppins slashers Animation Peacock breaking bad Food Network screenings dramedy BBC America Film Festival spider-man A&E natural history transformers RT History cats Endgame award winner DC streaming service Turner Classic Movies Polls and Games Turner LGBTQ Marvel Television Dark Horse Comics DirecTV police drama historical drama versus El Rey Trivia YouTube Premium SDCC DC Comics Sundance spanish language facebook Mystery dragons Mary Poppins Returns 21st Century Fox Sundance TV VH1 discovery Spike Disney+ Disney Plus Tumblr Kids & Family ESPN Mudbound GoT spain singing competition VICE American Society of Cinematographers Comics on TV Mary Tyler Moore what to watch television CBS CW Seed E3 Britbox President Syfy Biopics New York Comic Con Trailer Tarantino vampires Brie Larson Podcast name the review HBO Max cops SXSW diversity Comic Book Interview south america sag awards cars Superheroe The Purge comic Heroines USA aliens ABC Family Marvel Studios miniseries Pixar WGN halloween Cannes Drama Acorn TV political drama toy story politics Family Winners social media First Look Character Guide Rocky Action Reality Competition Awards Tour Women's History Month Rom-Com Toys Avengers Thanksgiving psycho TBS movies Discovery Channel Awards zombies Martial Arts Spring TV cults Holidays independent Calendar cooking FXX Chilling Adventures of Sabrina blockbuster zombie 2017 Nickelodeon YouTube Red Apple TV Plus dceu series green book Esquire anime Sundance Now IFC crime drama LGBT Red Carpet TV renewals Apple TV+ Black Mirror Best and Worst Shondaland romantic comedy cinemax CNN Musicals Chernobyl Lionsgate Superheroes CMT docudrama Academy Awards Cartoon Network unscripted DGA Freeform Crunchyroll Sci-Fi dogs AMC 2019 Ghostbusters true crime Rock hispanic Disney Channel Photos TCA Winter 2020 cancelled television MSNBC thriller disaster Netflix USA Network tv talk Nominations Star Trek sports TCA 2017 rotten movies we love National Geographic binge TCM NBC Quiz Sneak Peek Anna Paquin blaxploitation animated WarnerMedia talk show Video Games cancelled Hulu ratings composers The Walking Dead Winter TV DC Universe spinoff space Marvel Tomatazos TLC game of thrones mockumentary