Critics Consensus

The Gentlemen is Vintage Guy Ritchie

Plus, The Turning spins a twisty but unsatisfying tale, and Color out of Space and Zombi Child are Certified Fresh.

by | January 23, 2020 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a retiring kingpin (The Gentlemen, starring Matthew McConaughey and Hugh Grant) and a bedeviled babysitter (The Turning, starring Mackenzie Davis and Finn Wolfhard). What are the critics saying?


The Gentlemen (2020) 75%

Director Guy Ritchie has spent the past several years helming big-budget Hollywood projects like the Sherlock Holmes movies, The Man from U.N.C.L.E., 2017’s King Arthur: Legend of the Sword, and last year’s live-action remake of Disney’s Aladdin. But it’s worth remembering that he initially made a name for himself with sprawling crime capers led by ensemble casts, like Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels and Snatch. Much like Rian Johnson did recently with Knives Out, Ritchie returns to his roots this week with The Gentlemen, hoping to recapture the same magic that made him a studio darling. Matthew McConaughey leads the way as Michael “Mickey” Pearson, an American ex-pat in London who rules over a vast marijuana empire. When Mickey decides he wants to sell off his business and retire, a number of interested parties emerge, setting off a war of double-crosses as everyone struggles to get the upper hand. In other words, this is classic Guy Ritchie territory, and most critics say it’s a witty, entertaining, fast-paced comedy that benefits from some top-notch talent, particularly Hugh Grant and Colin Farrell at their scenery-chewing best. That said, Ritchie’s penchant for colorful language and tendency to play sordid situations for laughs — bestiality, casual and frequent racism, and a rape figure into the narrative here — aren’t for everyone, so it’s likely to shock anyone only familiar with his more mainstream fare.


The Turning (2020) 13%

Henry James’ classic novella The Turn of the Screw is one of the most famous examples of open-ended gothic horror, and it’s been the subject of classroom debates ever since it was first published in 1898. So it’s fitting that it has seen numerous screen adaptations, many of which offer different interpretations of what exactly the story communicates. The latest is this week’s The Turning, brought to us courtesy of director Floria Sigismondi (The Runaways, Marvel’s DaredevilThe Handmaid’s Tale), who updates the story for a 1990s setting, and critics say it’s unnecessary and unnecessarily frustrating. Mackenzie Davis stars as Kate, the new nanny to orphaned high-society siblings Miles (Finn Wolfhard) and Flora Fairchild (Brooklynn Prince), who live on a large, spooky estate in Maine in the care of their maid. Kate quickly discovers that neither the children nor the house is quite normal, and when mysterious things begin to happen, she finds herself ill-equipped to make sense of any of it. Unfortunately, the critics largely also failed to make much sense of the film, which fails to generate much dread from its repeated images of creepy doll faces and ghostly specters in the distance en route to a baffling climax. James’ original story is clearly meant to inspire discussion, but The Turning isn’t likely to spark much other than bewilderment and maybe a little regret.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • I Wish I Knew (2010)Jia Zhangke’s documentary portrait of Shanghai and its remarkable history, is at 100%.
  • Color Out of Space (2019) , starring Nicolas Cage in an adaptation of the H.P. Lovecraft short story of the same title, about the effects of a meteorite on a family living in rural Massachusetts, is Certified Fresh at 87%.
  • Zombi Child (2019) , following two parallel stories about a sugar plantation worker in 1962 Haiti and his granddaughter, who attends a boarding school in present-day France, is Certified Fresh at 87%.
  • The Last Full Measure (2019) , featuring a star-studded cast in a based-on-true-events drama about a Pentagon staffer’s investigation of a Medal of Honor request for a Vietnam War hero, is at 63%.
  • Quezon's Game (2018) , a drama about former Filipino President Manuel Quezon’s efforts to rescue Jews during the Holocaust, is at 29%.
  • John Henry (2020) , starring Terry Crews as a former gang member who turns to vigilante justice when he encounters two children on the run from the leader of the gang he left, is at 0%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

target GIFs Countdown E3 hist spider-verse Elton John Fantasy Amazon Prime Video MSNBC Pop Masterpiece concert HBO Go Discovery Channel Travel Channel vs. TCA Awards ESPN dexter new york Fall TV international Disney Channel book adaptation natural history Disney Plus Mudbound transformers historical drama Sneak Peek Calendar cancelled sag awards YouTube Premium supernatural golden globes latino serial killer remakes Academy Awards Extras Superheroes cancelled TV shows BBC America Endgame Spring TV Shondaland films reboot Certified Fresh technology Disney+ Disney Plus History Rom-Com Country MTV TBS what to watch Tubi Amazon Prime slashers Universal Pictures witnail Cosplay worst movies Musical aapi AMC halloween tv Superheroe comics The Walking Dead sequel CNN Classic Film live action Rock feel good nbcuniversal football Comic-Con@Home 2021 royal family 2016 japan satire versus Image Comics Alien game show romance Esquire tv talk criterion Holidays obituary Epix TV renewals 93rd Oscars cancelled TV series FX on Hulu Nominations hollywood 1990s FXX Mary poppins stoner zombie 2019 Hulu Year in Review Prime Video crime adventure canceled TV shows TruTV First Look Holiday Music best dogs franchise archives true crime Starz Instagram Live Tomatazos monster movies dragons President New York Comic Con Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt composers Nickelodeon cartoon talk show children's TV NBA BAFTA Heroines BBC One social media jamie lee curtis blaxploitation Quiz documentaries werewolf TCA 2017 72 Emmy Awards Trophy Talk AMC Plus ABC Family Arrowverse art house SundanceTV Oscars TV One critic resources Awards breaking bad mcc italian X-Men 2020 Biopics Schedule Infographic parents know your critic Tags: Comedy Sony Pictures BET chucky comic book movies WGN Watching Series The Witch Adult Swim james bond movies LGBTQ Legendary DC Comics Pet Sematary Women's History Month comiccon Nat Geo Premiere Dates DGA series 73rd Emmy Awards binge science fiction Summer Warner Bros. dramedy streaming movies dceu foreign dc twilight San Diego Comic-Con OWN DirecTV discovery comic books The CW Family CMT Comic Book ViacomCBS stop motion 90s comic child's play ID Spike slasher HBO Max YouTube Red Columbia Pictures Ghostbusters debate sports The Walt Disney Company DC Universe Paramount Network green book spy thriller TLC Grammys 21st Century Fox joker Comedy ghosts Action Tumblr cooking nature docuseries Marvel Character Guide sopranos south america screen actors guild anime mutant OneApp heist movie Polls and Games Marvel Television TV movies travel 2021 singing competition comedies razzies asian-american toy story gangster posters all-time diversity Christmas quibi legend harry potter toronto critics cancelled television king kong politics WarnerMedia TCM name the review cars Box Office Fox News video SDCC Red Carpet Tarantino Pacific Islander elevated horror crime drama spain new star wars movies Syfy Mary Poppins Returns The Academy based on movie Sci-Fi Crunchyroll Hollywood Foreign Press Association reviews saw Film Festival blockbuster 99% black 4/20 a nightmare on elm street ABC Signature Brie Larson IFC Films golden globe awards rom-coms Apple TV Plus halloween Lifetime miniseries romantic comedy Avengers 71st Emmy Awards batman new zealand spinoff period drama VOD Kids & Family Funimation Set visit rt labs A24 festival cults Winter TV justice league disaster Amazon kids Musicals Marathons Walt Disney Pictures crime thriller die hard VH1 richard e. Grant suspense Neflix CBS All Access universal monsters Trailer Awards Tour CBS Britbox lord of the rings Television Critics Association Baby Yoda 79th Golden Globes Awards news FX El Rey award winner police drama documentary TV Land deadpool french women japanese zero dark thirty CW Seed free movies National Geographic high school fresh thriller godzilla Chilling Adventures of Sabrina young adult Opinion classics scary movies USA Sundance TV docudrama scene in color HBO 24 frames Pride Month directors dark Super Bowl Apple TV+ indie rt archives finale spanish Exclusive Video kong marvel cinematic universe GoT DC streaming service Freeform TCA Winter 2020 Logo Winners emmy awards Mystery streaming MCU Martial Arts boxoffice indiana jones Marvel Studios Toys Captain marvel Cannes Writers Guild of America war laika TIFF Stephen King blockbusters The Purge hidden camera Netflix comic book movie Mindy Kaling renewed TV shows Broadway Pirates Pop TV Trivia 2017 Lifetime Christmas movies genre worst sitcom crossover boxing Ellie Kemper Turner Classic Movies Showtime Hallmark Valentine's Day Emmy Nominations sequels Apple NYCC Anna Paquin 007 Hear Us Out telelvision Drama Rocky Acorn TV independent scary Shudder Peacock APB Reality Competition video on demand king arthur TCA Crackle Comedy Central Election pirates of the caribbean anthology See It Skip It Netflix Christmas movies E! robots Television Academy cinemax hispanic Animation rt labs critics edition HFPA USA Network RT History Paramount Black Mirror mission: impossible Bravo Food Network festivals Disney streaming service space unscripted spider-man SXSW Mary Tyler Moore psychological thriller NBC basketball Black History Month action-comedy book YouTube rotten movies we love prank VICE The Arrangement Amazon Studios 45 BET Awards Creative Arts Emmys 2015 Horror RT21 leaderboard superman Dark Horse Comics First Reviews facebook PBS IFC fast and furious Song of Ice and Fire kaiju Spectrum Originals Emmys Interview Fox Searchlight American Society of Cinematographers Disney olympics Pixar Sundance Now trailers jurassic park adenture dreamworks ITV Cartoon Network casting Lionsgate Universal TV Fargo Thanksgiving Lucasfilm psycho Turner ABC Star Wars IMDb TV Comics on TV A&E zombies biography Sundance revenge biopic rotten animated superhero TNT spanish language LGBT doctor who 20th Century Fox canceled marvel comics strong female leads FOX YA popular Photos GLAAD scorecard trophy Video Games Film vampires PaleyFest television nfl screenings political drama BBC Chernobyl game of thrones mob aliens Best and Worst Teen teaser Western wonder woman Binge Guide 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 2018 movie Paramount Plus christmas movies australia Ovation live event Hallmark Christmas movies PlayStation Tokyo Olympics Star Trek Wes Anderson theme song medical drama mockumentary hispanic heritage month ratings Podcast black comedy Rocketman Reality cops venice cats stand-up comedy adaptation Vudu