Critics Consensus

Pacific Rim: Uprising Is Not That Good

Plus, Paul, Apostle of Christ is a holy mess, Sherlock Gnomes and Midnight Sun weren't screened for critics, and Unsane and Isle of Dogs are Certified Fresh.

by | March 22, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have mankind making one more last stand against one more giant monster invasion (Pacific Rim: Uprising, starring John Boyega, and Rinko Kikuchi), the return of cinema’s top-grossing animated gnomes (Sherlock Gnomes, featuring the voices of James McAvoy and Emily Blunt), star-crossed teen lovers (Midnight Sun, starring Bella Thorne and Patrick Schwarzenegger), Steven Soderbergh‘s smartphone thriller (Unsane, starring Claire Foy and Joshua Leonard), and a Bible hero in the hoosegow (Paul, Apostle of Christ, starring Jim Caviezel and James Faulkner). What are the critics saying?

Pacific Rim Uprising (2018) 44%

After you’ve racked up hundreds of millions in box office grosses by pitting giant robots against giant monsters, what’s your mandatory next move? A sequel, of course — and that leads us to Pacific Rim Uprising, which finds Steven S. DeKnight taking the reins from Pacific Rim director Guillermo del Toro for another round of large-scale mayhem with the fate of the human race hanging in the balance. While the original Rim wasn’t exactly a critical darling, reviews promised a cheerfully undemanding good time; unsurprisingly, Uprising delivers more of the CGI-fueled set pieces that drew crowds the first time around, with the added benefits of a pair of likeable leads in John Boyega and Cailee Spaeny. Unfortunately, none of that is enough to counter an unfortunate drift toward assembly-line action that lacks its predecessor’s signature del Toro quirk and leaves all that high-stakes, end-of-the-world drama feeling awfully loud and ordinary. On the other hand, it’s got giant robots and giant monsters punching each other into oblivion, so if you’re in the mood for that, everything else might not matter.

Sherlock Gnomes (2018) 27%

It took half a decade for Pacific Rim fans to get a sequel, but that’s nothing compared to the long wait endured by anyone who walked out of Gnomeo & Juliet hoping for a second installment. After seven long years, Sherlock Gnomes has arrived, reuniting members of the original voice cast (including James McAvoy, Emily Blunt, Michael Caine, and Ozzy Osbourne) for an adventure involving the titular detective (voiced by Johnny Depp), his ex-girlfriend (Mary J. Blige), and his fellow sleuth Gnome Watson (Chiwetel Ejiofor). Was it worth the wait? We wish we could tell you what the critics think, but reviews haven’t started posting yet, so we’ll all just have to wait and see. In the meantime, how about a round of Guess the Tomatgnometer?

Midnight Sun (2018) 22%

Ah, young love. Chances are you remember your teenage romances as being fairly ordinary, albeit occasionally melodramatic; in the movies, however, two fresh-faced teens can’t so much as smooch without life-threatening stakes rising up to thwart their hormones. Such is the case with Midnight Sun, starring Bella Thorne as Katie, a 17-year-old with a life-threatening allergy to the sun. She compensates by heading outside after dark, but when one fateful night finds her crossing paths with her neighbor crush (Patrick Schwarzenegger), it’s clear our lovebirds — and the audience — are headed for hankie-dampening heartache. By and large, this sort of thing tends not to play very well with critics, which is probably why Midnight Sun didn’t screen early for the scribes. Guess that Tomatometer!

Unsane (2018) 80%

For decades, Steven Soderbergh has been known as a filmmaker with an uncommon knack for using technical gimmickry in service of a solid story. That streak continues with his latest outing, Unsane, a mystery thriller about a young woman (Claire Foy) who’s institutionalized against her will and undergoes major trauma — perhaps real, perhaps imagined — while she’s locked up. It’s a straightforward enough story, but Soderbergh has told it in somewhat unusual fashion; instead of filming with the traditional array of professional gear, he opted to shoot the picture on the sly with an iPhone. Unsane isn’t the first mainstream release to be made this way — Sean Baker‘s Tangerine is another example of smartphone technology being brought to bear on modern filmmaking — but given the resources at Soderbergh’s command, this was clearly a creative choice not purely driven by financial need. For the most part, the reviews agree it’s a move that paid off here: the movie’s intimate aesthetic works well with the story, adding to the overall creepy tone and making it harder to draw the line between fantasy and reality. Like last year’s Logan Lucky, this is a project that’s left critics cheering the end of Soderbergh’s short-lived — and obviously premature — retirement.

Paul, Apostle of Christ (2018) 46%

Easter Sunday is right around the corner, which makes this weekend a perfectly fine time for a faith-based drama — and writer-director Andrew Hyatt is here to oblige with Paul, Apostle of Christ, a look at the last days of the titular biblical figure (played by James Faulkner) as he reflects on his life while awaiting execution in the prisons of Roman emperor Nero. While serving his sentence, he’s visited in his cell by Luke (Passion of the Christ vet Jim Caviezel), who vows to record Paul’s story — and we all know how that turned out. Of course, as Rogue One proved, knowing how a story ends doesn’t necessarily make it any less enjoyable as long as it’s well told; unfortunately, critics say that’s where Paul stumbles, focusing on a section of its subject’s life that’s overall ill-suited to explore the movie’s desired themes in a truly meaningful or compelling way. For filmgoers who are in the mood for a Bible story at the cinema, it might still be worth the price of a ticket, but all in all, this looks like an example of the book being better than the movie.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

Television Academy crime drama Interview Cosplay tv talk Turner Classic Movies adventure award winner Superheroes cancelled TV series Writers Guild of America sequel joker Anna Paquin TBS DC Universe zombies elevated horror TIFF dramedy See It Skip It Captain marvel Sci-Fi BET dceu cartoon Winter TV historical drama Family vampires American Society of Cinematographers VICE PaleyFest Lucasfilm Marathons 2016 Adult Swim romantic comedy President Year in Review Binge Guide breaking bad Pirates Comics on TV Musicals TCA The Witch animated Spike Netflix sitcom IFC Films Universal YouTube romance The CW Oscars 71st Emmy Awards cars Rom-Com GoT ABC Family Spring TV E! A24 travel richard e. Grant Extras Turner Pet Sematary anthology halloween Epix indie disaster Amazon Prime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina comics canceled TV shows christmas movies Sundance Now Lifetime Fox News ghosts Ovation Red Carpet Freeform Pop History Tomatazos police drama Sony Pictures Set visit TruTV Comic Book spider-man kids jamie lee curtis VH1 diversity First Look foreign Animation casting Mary poppins OWN Heroines Horror DirecTV CMT streaming Quiz Watching Series facebook singing competition USA Network south america Pixar LGBT Warner Bros. 45 Western TCM Emmys LGBTQ spy thriller supernatural Super Bowl Film Festival Hallmark Paramount The Arrangement boxoffice video 007 Trophy Talk Sneak Peek sports 2018 based on movie Holiday Biopics Rock Disney Plus talk show San Diego Comic-Con discovery ABC game of thrones Disney MSNBC cats Spectrum Originals composers cancelled Rocketman Lifetime Christmas movies NYCC Black Mirror SundanceTV BBC Walt Disney Pictures AMC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comic YouTube Red Brie Larson quibi versus political drama TV Land Grammys SDCC 20th Century Fox strong female leads canceled Chernobyl Lionsgate Shudder series CBS politics Starz cancelled television Country Mindy Kaling period drama Apple robots NBC Trivia The Walking Dead Logo Countdown anime Music Pride Month zero dark thirty WarnerMedia CW Seed Paramount Network natural history Summer cooking Disney Channel comiccon CBS All Access X-Men Crackle APB Esquire crime blaxploitation Box Office Stephen King Kids & Family technology Election Polls and Games Disney streaming service Cannes Ellie Kemper Showtime Bravo harry potter USA Comedy Central Reality Competition screenings Shondaland TCA 2017 Marvel Studios cults latino Premiere Dates Schedule DC Comics movies crossover E3 National Geographic Britbox FXX YA RT History A&E mutant crime thriller toy story IFC independent Amazon cinemax RT21 book Reality Rocky Star Trek psycho Dark Horse Comics Apple TV+ Ghostbusters Superheroe werewolf serial killer Video Games Fantasy teaser Martial Arts Crunchyroll 2017 Nominations Cartoon Network rotten movies we love psychological thriller Thanksgiving DC streaming service PBS Creative Arts Emmys what to watch TV golden globes 21st Century Fox hist First Reviews stand-up comedy Vudu Holidays doctor who Christmas Podcast binge Winners Mudbound HBO WGN cops Peacock HBO Max ITV Netflix Christmas movies MTV Food Network 24 frames Elton John GLAAD social media Film Hallmark Christmas movies theme song Women's History Month zombie unscripted medical drama Awards Calendar Syfy Marvel Television ratings children's TV 2015 Columbia Pictures Sundance blockbuster Nat Geo Star Wars SXSW hispanic Drama cancelled TV shows Toys ESPN Action TLC Tumblr aliens justice league TV renewals true crime GIFs Fall TV BBC America TNT dragons adaptation renewed TV shows Apple TV Plus Tarantino spinoff Comedy FX CNN Nickelodeon festivals Marvel television Hulu biography Certified Fresh El Rey FOX Mystery Amazon Prime Video Masterpiece Trailer Opinion MCU mockumentary Emmy Nominations war Photos game show Arrowverse Character Guide free movies nature finale transformers space Awards Tour batman spain slashers YouTube Premium DGA Teen Best and Worst The Purge Infographic Acorn TV witnail Disney+ Disney Plus Classic Film revenge green book 2019 miniseries Mary Poppins Returns Valentine's Day spanish language docudrama dc science fiction Mary Tyler Moore Song of Ice and Fire Musical thriller New York Comic Con