Critics Consensus

Now You See Me 2 Is all Smoke and Mirrors

Plus, Warcraft is a disappointing fantasy, and The Conjuring 2 is a spooky sequel.

by | June 9, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got rogue magicians (Now You See Me 2, starring Jesse Eisenberg and Mark Ruffalo), a Horde of Orcs (Warcraft, starring Ben Foster and Paula Patton), and paranormal investigators (The Conjuring 2, starring Vera Farmiga and Patrick Wilson). What do the critics have to say?


Now You See Me 2 (2016) 33%

Now You See Me didn’t exactly inspire critical adulation when it arrived in theaters in 2013, but it made a lot of money — so now we have Now You See Me 2, which reunites most of the original’s showy cast while adding a few new faces for another magical heist filled with twists, turns, and double-crosses. The problem, according to most critics, is the same one that dogged the original — namely, that the movie is more interested in giving the appearance of a busy caper than actually making sense. If it’s a talented onscreen assemblage you’re after, Now You See Me 2 offers this weekend’s biggest bang for your buck, but for genuine cinematic magic, the pundits suggest looking elsewhere.


Warcraft (2016) 28%

It isn’t often that the critical establishment even bothers to feign interest in a video game adaptation — but then, most video game adaptations don’t have Warcraft‘s pedigree. With director Duncan Jones at the helm, this fantasy saga threatened to deliver more than just another exercise in franchise-building; alas, instead of offering filmgoers an experience as enchanting as its source material, critics say the Warcraft movie is a hollow shell of CGI eye candy with a narrative void at its center. Although Jones gets credit for assembling an impressive visual spectacle, his efforts aren’t enough to compensate for subpar acting, dense mythology, and a plodding plot — and in the end, Warcraft is one more in a long line of game-to-film journeys ending with a critical walk of shame.


The Conjuring 2 (2016) 80%

Director James Wan gave horror enthusiasts a Certified Fresh surprise with 2013’s The Conjuring, which used chilling restraint to tell a terrifically creepy tale drawn from the archives of real-life paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren. More than $300 million later, Wan is back — along with stars Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga — to offer another dramatization of the Warrens’ ghostbusting exploits. Although most critics can’t help but point out that this stuff isn’t quite as scary the second time around, they’re also quick to admit that Wan remains a deft genre filmmaker, and while The Conjuring 2 is subject to the laws of diminishing returns suggested by its title, it’s still got its share of suitably nasty scares.


What’s New on TV

Outcast: Season 1 (2016) 80%

A cut above average summer fare, Outcast provides the genuine chills one should — but often can’t — expect from television horror.


Maya & Marty: Season 1 (2016) 38%

Maya & Marty is a safer, weekday version of Saturday Night Live with little to recommend it other than Maya Rudolph and Martin Short‘s admittedly considerable charms.


Feed the Beast: Season 1 (2016) 23%

Feed the Beast‘s visual appeal isn’t enough to make up for predictable plotting, convoluted dialogue and unlikable characters.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • James Bender

    Critics suck ass. They are always cruel, aloof, and think they know better than anyone what is an enjoyable film or not. They are useless. And they end up being wrong anyway when the film makes a lot of money and a high percentage of people like it.

  • Soaren

    Seems like a lot of critics aren’t able to grasp anything about Warcraft (not so surprising, all things considered), but the worldwide audience looks to be in a strong disagreement.

Tag Cloud

natural history cars psychological thriller hist Oscars Marvel Television Crackle The Purge TruTV PlayStation screen actors guild unscripted screenings Shondaland crime drama National Geographic Logo Summer HBO Max Mary poppins documentaries YA CNN TCA Rocky nature Martial Arts Emmys 45 Song of Ice and Fire Musical best PaleyFest sag awards zombie TCA Awards SDCC Masterpiece Podcast zero dark thirty Paramount Network TV renewals 2015 Turner fast and furious Sneak Peek The CW science fiction TCA 2017 LGBTQ Family golden globes composers Music Nickelodeon YouTube Premium thriller Elton John streaming TLC WGN richard e. Grant romance all-time Video Games asian-american kids werewolf Funimation Christmas RT History OWN cats Pet Sematary animated cartoon Columbia Pictures FXX mockumentary christmas movies technology sequel Television Academy USA Ovation VH1 DC streaming service Sci-Fi emmy awards Best and Worst twilight franchise Nat Geo docudrama Hulu Mystery Horror Schedule game show The Walking Dead DC Comics award winner GoT Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Lifetime Christmas movies PBS quibi TNT based on movie AMC free movies DGA Reality Competition what to watch Character Guide Apple TV+ Marathons E! Syfy Marvel Studios laika talk show Lionsgate jamie lee curtis satire canceled TV shows finale mission: impossible MTV Anna Paquin theme song Pixar cults Nominations elevated horror medical drama CW Seed critics Tubi Classic Film Kids & Family TCM anthology spain binge Infographic criterion singing competition adventure YouTube Photos toy story Tarantino dark boxoffice New York Comic Con joker Grammys Awards Hear Us Out BBC America name the review Creative Arts Emmys WarnerMedia dogs TBS Reality hollywood Trophy Talk BBC cancelled TV shows casting space BET Awards Lucasfilm Esquire news Extras ratings serial killer Paramount Starz Super Bowl BBC One spinoff blockbuster spy thriller Western LGBT Drama festivals Sundance Now breaking bad Television Critics Association biography Stephen King Comics on TV harry potter crime blaxploitation robots Netflix Christmas movies Valentine's Day 4/20 Food Network RT21 APB Avengers ABC Family comics directors Sundance Comic Book Pride Month Countdown American Society of Cinematographers A&E YouTube Red Interview Chilling Adventures of Sabrina mutant police drama Disney video on demand Walt Disney Pictures discovery Travel Channel Calendar Trivia Discovery Channel FX on Hulu witnail worst facebook war Marvel Winter TV Netflix Watching Series period drama Superheroes Amazon Baby Yoda true crime Bravo Captain marvel Emmy Nominations Vudu Fox News IFC Films nbcuniversal Biopics batman children's TV Lifetime Chernobyl spider-man Britbox spanish language adaptation OneApp revenge Adult Swim Mary Tyler Moore Writers Guild of America ghosts Opinion NYCC social media psycho President MCU Amazon Prime Video political drama Cannes slashers Disney+ Disney Plus 2020 Hallmark NBC book scary movies Film Festival FX 20th Century Fox Fall TV Cosplay rotten die hard ITV Toys GIFs Brie Larson Black History Month documentary Endgame superhero halloween Tumblr renewed TV shows Sony Pictures video Academy Awards Apple TV Plus vampires Animation Comedy Central indie cancelled TV series Apple Warner Bros. GLAAD stoner Binge Guide El Rey cancelled television Musicals cooking USA Network CMT Mindy Kaling The Arrangement X-Men Star Wars Crunchyroll comic 2018 dramedy transformers Rom-Com Spring TV San Diego Comic-Con Disney Channel Spectrum Originals History Superheroe Awards Tour Universal 007 Star Trek chucky Box Office dc television CBS Winners anime Country Freeform comiccon series Ellie Kemper Amazon Prime Epix TCA Winter 2020 Tomatazos Holiday Pop politics Pop TV 2019 2016 SundanceTV Arrowverse CBS All Access VOD teaser 72 Emmy Awards BAFTA DC Universe Action independent a nightmare on elm street 2017 Turner Classic Movies First Reviews Mary Poppins Returns Premiere Dates FOX IFC 24 frames dceu miniseries green book A24 Red Carpet Thanksgiving sitcom romantic comedy Heroines Mudbound Disney streaming service Certified Fresh foreign SXSW sports reboot stop motion MSNBC Sundance TV Disney Plus disaster DirecTV HBO Go Film Hallmark Christmas movies First Look obituary Set visit game of thrones Acorn TV justice league Women's History Month Pirates crossover movie doctor who films The Witch Comedy TIFF Trailer TV Land cops aliens Polls and Games Quiz strong female leads 71st Emmy Awards ESPN Rock classics cancelled Teen TV Black Mirror VICE Ghostbusters ABC Peacock cinemax sequels indiana jones hispanic canceled Amazon Studios Spike Election Dark Horse Comics Rocketman comedies latino south america versus movies stand-up comedy rotten movies we love dragons Shudder child's play parents Cartoon Network reviews tv talk universal monsters supernatural See It Skip It 21st Century Fox travel concert crime thriller diversity BET Fantasy E3 Year in Review historical drama Showtime zombies HBO Holidays