Critics Consensus

Night School Feels A Little Like Detention

Plus, Smallfoot is a pleasant surprise, Little Women fails to set itself apart, and The Old Man & the Gun is Certified Fresh.

by | September 27, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have education after dark (Night School, starring Kevin Hart and Tiffany Haddish), not large ladies (Little Women, starring Lea Thompson), an abominable singing snowman (Smallfoot, featuring the voices of Channing Tatum and Common), and a horror-ble Halloween (Hell Fest, starring Amy Forsyth and Reign Edwards). What are the critics saying?


Night School (2018) 28%

Being funny often seems like it comes naturally to certain people, but making great comedy is deceptively difficult, and what looks like surefire hilarity on paper — like, for instance, teaming up two of Hollywood’s biggest laugh-getters — often adds up to a disappointing dud. Comedy is more like alchemy than addition, and as our latest example, here’s Night School, starring Tiffany Haddish and Kevin Hart in the ostensibly humorous story of a high school dropout who belatedly goes back to get his GED after his life is turned upside down. Both stars are very funny, with hit comedies to prove it; unfortunately, critics say School‘s scattered screenplay is more of a collection of set pieces than an actual story, and without any real investment in the characters, the chuckles are tough to come by. Of course with all this talent in one place, sparks are bound to fly on at least a couple of occasions, and Haddish and Hart are ably supported by a talented ensemble that includes Taran Killam, Mary Lynn Rajskub, and Rob Riggle; it’s just that it doesn’t add up to much more than a movie that leaves you wishing these stars had been brought together for a comedy that wasn’t (ahem) strictly remedial.


Smallfoot (2018) 75%

For a guy whose marquee idol looks could have easily led him down a far less interesting path, Channing Tatum has consistently demonstrated an admirable willingness to try just about anything onscreen, along with an impressive ability to jump from acclaimed lower-profile releases to mainstream hits. He’s at it again with this weekend’s Smallfoot, an animated outing about a yeti whose discovery of a human ends up throwing his community into upheaval. Rounded out by supporting work from Common, LeBron James, Zendaya, and Danny DeVito, this family-friendly feature — did we mention it’s also a musical? — might look pretty odd on paper, but critics say it’s actually well worth seeking out for families in the mood for a fun night out at the movies. If the results still end up falling a bit shy of the bar set by some of Warner Bros. Animation’s more illustrious competitors, audiences can still expect a solidly entertaining adventure for younger viewers — and all of us can clearly still expect the unexpected from Mr. Tatum.


Little Women (2018) 33%

Hollywood certainly seems to have gotten a lot more remake-prone in recent years, but as film buffs are fully aware, studios have been dipping into the vaults for properties to revisit pretty much all along — and as a result, certain stories have been filmed more times than most of us can count. No, we aren’t talking about A Star Is Born — not yet, anyway. Instead, this is all leading up to the latest Little Women, which adapts the classic Louisa May Alcott novel by bringing the plot into the present. It’s a somewhat novel twist for an oft-told tale, and it isn’t hard to root for any picture that gives Lea Thompson a leading role; unfortunately, critics say none of it goes far enough to justify this particular version of a story many people have already seen. Reviews describe a movie whose sincerity is admirable and whose themes remain as resonant as ever, but one that’s also ultimately more of a creative exhuming than a fresh spin. It’s a bummer for fans of heartfelt female-centric drama, but on the bright side, there are plenty of other Little Women to watch already — and Greta Gerwig is bringing yet another one to audiences next year.


Hell Fest (2018) 40%

A man, a plan, a… carnival full of screaming teens? For a number of film fans, these are all the basic ingredients you need for a killer horror movie, and this weekend’s Hell Fest has them all present and accounted for. Directed by Gregory Plotkin, whose genre bona fides include helming Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension and editing Get Out, this slasher outing imagines the inevitably gory chaos that might unravel if a serial killer decided to indulge his darkest desires at a Halloween theme park. It’s a slick enough setup, and it’s undeniably promising that the cast includes Candyman and Final Destination vet Tony Todd, but as for the actual movie itself, we still don’t have a verdict, because Hell Fest didn’t screen for critics. While we wait for those reviews to start coming in, lay your best guesses on us with a round of Guess the Tomatometer.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Free Solo (2018) , a documentary about free climber Alex Honnold’s attempt to scale El Capitan, is at 100%.
  • MATANGI/MAYA/M.I.A. (2018) , a documentary about the life and career of musician and activist M.I.A., is at 88%.
  • The Old Man & the Gun (2018) , starring Robert Redford and Sissy Spacek in a drama based on the exploits of real-life convict Forrest Tucker, is Certified Fresh at 88%.
  • All About Nina (2018) , starring Mary Elizabeth Winstead as a woman juggling the demands of her personal life and her career, is at 85%.
  • Bad Reputation (2018) , a documentary about pioneering rocker Joan Jett, is at 85%.
  • Monsters and Men (2018) , a drama tracing the fallout of a police killing — and the choices facing a man who filmed it — is at 80%.
  • 306 Hollywood (2018) , a documentary about a pair of siblings sorting through their grandmother’s voluminous belongings after her passing, is at 78%.
  • Scaffolding (2018) , in which a young man nearing the end of high school faces some pivotal decisions, is at 71%.
  • Black '47 (2018) , a period piece about a former soldier’s struggles to aid his countrymen during Ireland’s Great Famine, is at 69%.
  • Summer '03 (2018) , starring Joey King as a teenager whose coming-of-age journey starts with her grandmother’s blunt dying words, is at 55%.
  • At First Light (2018) , about a teenage girl who develops supernatural abilities after a brush with unexplained phenomena, is at 50%.

Tag Cloud

A&E thriller blaxploitation IFC Creative Arts Emmys SDCC singing competition San Diego Comic-Con Britbox Nominations Winter TV AMC cults cops discovery CNN Mary Tyler Moore Nat Geo DC Universe Adult Swim Marathons GLAAD Extras SXSW Set visit Animation USA Network Pixar Song of Ice and Fire Video Games Sci-Fi Lionsgate Summer Showtime Biopics harry potter TruTV 007 TIFF Reality Competition Lucasfilm Comedy CW Seed Starz Polls and Games medical drama zombie composers MTV Drama FXX TCA YouTube Red 2017 TV TLC BET WGN sitcom comiccon YA crime Winners Comedy Central President Calendar CBS Toys robots E3 science fiction 2016 Cosplay Ghostbusters anime dramedy ITV Disney Channel El Rey Martial Arts DirecTV Columbia Pictures Rocky docudrama doctor who Trivia ESPN Mindy Kaling MSNBC supernatural TCM Photos social media NYCC Oscars political drama boxoffice History SundanceTV romance IFC Films dceu Opinion 24 frames crossover Musical jamie lee curtis 21st Century Fox Warner Bros. DC Comics BBC NBC Dark Horse Comics Disney vampires Masterpiece Cartoon Network justice league FOX PBS Thanksgiving Best and Worst serial killer historical drama RT History sports Paramount Infographic hist Pop cats Pirates what to watch Schedule Epix unscripted Lifetime Musicals VH1 Election Star Wars Podcast Year in Review Awards Bravo Rom-Com dc CBS All Access Ovation talk show Food Network spy thriller technology Premiere Dates based on movie binge DC streaming service Action finale Christmas Fantasy Amazon Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TBS ABC GIFs E! TV Land Spring TV Walt Disney Pictures Emmys Hulu 2015 Reality Syfy Paramount Network Sundance See It Skip It Western politics BBC America psycho Nickelodeon Marvel Fall TV The CW 20th Century Fox Spike X-Men Kids & Family Interview ABC Family golden globes Music Sneak Peek Country Countdown TNT Character Guide Holidays Teen YouTube Premium Shudder CMT Universal crime drama period drama Super Bowl Mystery Netflix HBO USA Box Office OWN Freeform Watching Series Rock transformers Fox News Esquire National Geographic aliens crime thriller Superheroes VICE Shondaland Star Trek Trailer travel Acorn TV Valentine's Day LGBTQ Certified Fresh TCA 2017 Superheroe PaleyFest biography Logo Apple adventure Sundance Now diversity Writers Guild of America ratings 45 Tumblr First Look war Red Carpet Sony Pictures festivals Tomatazos Ellie Kemper Comic Book zombies American Society of Cinematographers cooking Comics on TV The Arrangement FX New York Comic Con police drama Horror cinemax mutant GoT APB Crackle streaming Grammys