Critics Consensus

Maleficent: Mistress of Evil Misses on Magnificence

Plus, Zombieland: Double Tap is worth the second dip. See what the critics are saying about this week's movies!

by and | October 17, 2019 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a misunderstood sorceress (Maleficent: Mistress of Evil, starring Angelina Jolie and Elle Fanning) and apocalypse survivors (Zombieland: Double Tap, starring Jesse Eisenberg and Emma Stone). What are the critics saying?

Maleficent: Mistress of Evil (2019) 40%

Disney’s efforts to reinterpret their classic animated films as live-action fare have been a little hit-or-miss with critics, as we saw as recently as this past summer, but they still do pretty well at the box office. This was the case when the current remake trend kicked off with 2010’s Alice in Wonderland and continued with the studio’s next effort, 2014’s Maleficent, which only scored 53% on the Tomatometer but made over $750 million and became Angelina Jolie’s highest-grossing movie ever. It’s unclear if this week’s follow-up, Maleficent: Mistress of Evil, will be as big of a commercial success, but critics say it’s about on par with its predecessor. This time around, Jolie’s titular misunderstood Disney villain finds herself at odds with her goddaughter Princess Aurora’s (Elle Fanning) future in-laws, who seek to separate the worlds of human and fairies for good. Co-stars Imelda Staunton, Sam Riley, and Juno Temple all return to reprise their roles, joined by newcomers Michelle Pfeiffer, Chiwetel Ejiofor, and Ed Skrein, and critics say they do admirable work with the material. But the fact remains that the storytelling feels rather perfunctory, and the film makes only feeble attempts to grapple with some of the weightier themes it evokes. The visuals are as spectacular as they were the first time around, and Jolie and Pfeiffer in particular are fun to watch, but this may please only the biggest fans of Maleficent’s recent realignment as someone to root for.

Zombieland: Double Tap (2019) 69%

It’s been 10 years since the end of the long-running Zombieland saga, which had seen its empire rise to one movie, and one failed Amazon pilot. But the media landscape has changed a lot in the intervening decade: The Walking Dead premiered, Resident Evil games got bad, and then good again, and Brad Pitt solved World War Z. Frankly, we are up to here with zombies. And just as the dead keep coming back in some half-baked metaphor, so too does a quality comedy sequel script rise to the top in this biz, insisting to be given life. Woody HarrelsonJesse EisenbergEmma Stone, and Abigail Breslin are back reprising their geographically-named zombie slayer roles, who have all moved into the White House and transformed it into an impregnable fortress. But when love’s many splendored machinations threaten to tear the group asunder, it’s back on the road for more misadventures, involving powered-up undead, doppelganger crews, Rosario Dawson as an Elvis-loving hotel proprietress, and Zoey Deutch’s scene-stealing ditz. Critics can be tough on comedies, especially their sequels, but here’s one zombie follow-up that works, even if it’s got less teeth in its bite. Zombieland: Double Tap has the creative “survival rules” graphics. It’s got splatter, and it’s got slapstick. The chemistry between the four leads is just as top-shelf as in the first, but the expanded cast is push-and-pull. Some new characters not only get the laughs but also reveal new dimensions in the established crew, while others detract from the flow of the film. Nearly unanimous is praise for Deutch, as the improbable survivor Madison, with some calling her a comedy revelation. Also on everyone critic’s mind: Stick around during those credits. It’s a doozy.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

A&E Valentine's Day casting Lifetime History LGBTQ composers cars spider-man Disney streaming service series Tomatazos jamie lee curtis cooking medical drama Watching Series Tumblr police drama The Witch Amazon CBS comiccon DC Universe television Rom-Com social media Star Trek robots Logo psycho renewed TV shows The CW NYCC Nominations werewolf See It Skip It true crime TruTV romantic comedy Oscars Certified Fresh First Reviews halloween doctor who Pop Writers Guild of America cops TCA 2017 harry potter Ellie Kemper Brie Larson FXX BBC YouTube Red Lionsgate book golden globes Action miniseries Women's History Month elevated horror Premiere Dates sequel Hulu Countdown spy thriller slashers RT History The Arrangement latino Crunchyroll cartoon Winners singing competition Sundance Summer Horror Apple TLC Warner Bros. Mary Tyler Moore Disney Channel X-Men cancelled television Disney Plus GIFs cancelled TV series 45 zombie Toys Spectrum Originals Television Academy Nickelodeon Superheroe video green book Extras Turner docudrama vampires Song of Ice and Fire hist sitcom crossover OWN Bravo Musical animated Universal nature mutant TV stand-up comedy BBC America NBC what to watch Paramount Opinion SundanceTV Awards Tour YA TBS Nat Geo Marvel Television historical drama adventure Shudder dragons anthology Interview CW Seed Cartoon Network witnail 2017 cinemax Character Guide WGN The Walking Dead Emmy Nominations American Society of Cinematographers spinoff SDCC cancelled USA Britbox supernatural El Rey Stephen King travel Kids & Family political drama Mudbound VH1 Pixar Mindy Kaling binge USA Network PBS thriller ghosts Sneak Peek Disney FOX Pirates Family WarnerMedia Arrowverse E3 Captain marvel Rocketman President Thanksgiving ABC disaster Dark Horse Comics The Purge First Look Classic Film independent ratings Musicals free movies Year in Review Epix TCM ESPN talk show tv talk Adult Swim revenge Amazon Prime Video Mary poppins Pet Sematary facebook teaser blockbuster APB Fantasy Elton John VICE Amazon Prime Comedy Central Mystery Spike Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Disney+ Disney Plus Marvel Studios RT21 Lucasfilm comic blaxploitation Binge Guide crime drama E! Teen Polls and Games Martial Arts Cosplay Showtime foreign FX Cannes Marathons SXSW Shondaland Schedule TV Land award winner cults mockumentary Starz Turner Classic Movies Comedy HBO Max CBS All Access National Geographic Peacock anime ITV TNT BET sports hispanic zero dark thirty Grammys dramedy Animation Red Carpet crime thriller justice league Rocky politics DC streaming service 007 2015 Trophy Talk Film Festival Comic Book batman 20th Century Fox cancelled TV shows Apple TV+ biography Reality A24 Comics on TV Vudu HBO Trailer Walt Disney Pictures Freeform Quiz toy story streaming unscripted children's TV Creative Arts Emmys Trivia Esquire 2019 dceu Black Mirror Syfy Election Sundance Now game of thrones Sci-Fi joker Crackle breaking bad theme song GoT Winter TV 2018 based on movie zombies Star Wars San Diego Comic-Con Sony Pictures MTV romance science fiction Netflix AMC Chernobyl Columbia Pictures discovery canceled TV shows cats strong female leads YouTube Paramount Network Superheroes ABC Family IFC Films Mary Poppins Returns IFC Infographic indie finale 24 frames Holidays Pride Month DGA richard e. Grant Ghostbusters war Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DC Comics MSNBC period drama 71st Emmy Awards MCU Drama canceled Photos transformers space Music natural history spanish language Reality Competition Acorn TV 2016 Tarantino movies Heroines Film Rock serial killer technology Video Games kids TCA south america Western Super Bowl Anna Paquin CNN Apple TV Plus Biopics Podcast game show spain Christmas Marvel boxoffice PaleyFest Best and Worst LGBT festivals 21st Century Fox diversity New York Comic Con Set visit Box Office crime Spring TV Calendar YouTube Premium Food Network versus psychological thriller Awards adaptation CMT Fall TV dc DirecTV Masterpiece aliens Emmys Country GLAAD quibi TV renewals Ovation Fox News TIFF