Critics Consensus

Logan Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Feud: Bette and Joan and When We Rise are also Certified Fresh, and Before I Fall is a smart teen drama.

by | March 2, 2017 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have Hugh Jackman unsheathing his claws for what may be the final time (Logan, co-starring Patrick Stewart), a teenage girl trapped in a time loop (Before I Fall, starring Zoey Deutch and Halston Sage), and a man in a spiritual crisis (The Shack, starring Sam Worthington and Octavia Spencer). What are the critics saying?


Logan (2017) 93%


For years, Wolverine fans have patiently waited for the character to go on a suitably grim and gory big-screen adventure. It looks like it took Hugh Jackman hanging up his claws to make it happen, but better late than never: Logan finally embraces the dark, unflinchingly violent side of Wolverine that’s helped make the cigar-chomping little berserker such a comics fan favorite over the last several decades. In what promises to be Jackman’s last outing in the role, he finds himself on a post-apocalyptic road trip of sorts with old mentor Professor X (Patrick Stewart, also retiring from the franchise), both men guarding one of the planet’s last few remaining mutants — a young girl (Dafne Keen) with the same retractable claws and boiling rage as our hero. Critics say Jackman and director James Mangold are sending this iteration of the character out on a powerful high note with Logan, which stands among not only the best of the X-Men movies but arguably the greatest in the superhero genre overall. Part family road trip movie, part hard-hitting action thriller, it should more than satisfy those long-suffering fans — and may even convert a few non-believers.


Before I Fall (2017) 65%


Based on Lauren Oliver’s 2010 YA bestseller, Before I Fall introduces viewers to Samantha Kingston (Zoey Deutch), a high school senior with a seemingly perfect life — one that unravels when she’s trapped in a time loop that forces her to relive the events of the day leading up to her death. Naturally, Samantha has some important lessons to learn, and the audience will learn them all along with her, right up through the heartwarming final act. It isn’t the subtlest of setups — critics have called Before I Fall a cross between a Nicholas Sparks weepie and Groundhog Day — but it all works well enough, enlivened by a strong performance from Deutch and a perspective that’s just different enough to set itself apart from every other young adult drama with a supernatural tinge. If you’re young and/or young at heart and seeking a satisfying cry this weekend, this seems like a pretty safe bet.

The Shack (2017) 21%


The “faith-based film” market still hasn’t quite come into its own as far as critics are concerned, but there’s no denying the genre’s come a long way over the last few years. This weekend’s The Shack, starring Sam Worthington as a man driven to a spiritual crossroads by soul-shattering tragedy, is the latest case in point: with a terrific cast rounded out by Octavia Spencer and Radha Mitchell, it’s obviously not cut from the same low-budget cloth these films were once known for. But rounding up great ingredients is only half the battle — a great movie needs to blend them successfully too, and critics say The Shack falls down on that front, losing its worthy message in a heap of rickety clichés and heavy-handed platitudes. Lukewarm critical buzz hasn’t always put much of a dent in the box office for these films, but if you’ve found yourself on the fence, you may want to reconsider paying a visit.

What’s New on TV

Feud: Bette and Joan (2017) 91%

While campy and sweetly indulgent, Feud: Bette and Joan provides poignant understanding of humanity, sorrow, and pain while breezily feeding inquisitive gossip-starved minds.


When We Rise: Miniseries (2016) 82%

When We Rise works as a well-meaning outreach project with a decent cast, even if the script’s ambitious reach slightly exceeds its grasp.


Taken: Season 1 (2017) 32%

Taken‘s cast hits the right notes, but overall, the series fails to deliver a compelling narrative distinguished from its source material.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Last Laugh (2017) , a documentary look at which subjects — if any — should be off-limits to comedians, is at 100 percent.
  • The Settlers (2017) , a documentary look at Israeli settlements in the West Bank, is at 100 percent.
  • Donald Cried (2017) , about the surreal odyssey that unravels after a man is forced to reconnect with his childhood neighbor, is at 91 percent.
  • Nakom (2017) , a Ghana-set drama about a med student called home to manage his family farm after the death of his father, is at 86 percent.
  • Apprentice (2017) , about a young Malaysian cop being groomed to assist the prison executioner who put his father to death, is at 86 percent.
  • Contemporary Color (2017) , a documentary about a 2015 event organized by David Byrne in tribute to the art of color guard performances, is at 82 percent.
  • Catfight (2017) , about the violent reunion between two former college friends (Anne Heche and Sandra Oh), is at 77 percent.
  • Headshot (2017) , an action thriller about an amnesiac who learns some shocking things about his past when he’s drawn into someone else’s fight for survival, is at 75 percent.
  • Lovesong (2017) , about the highs and lows of a long, complex friendship between two women, is at 74 percent.
  • Junction 48 (2017) , about the trials and tribulations of a Palestinian youth who aspires to a career in hip-hop, is at 71 percent.
  • Wolves (2017) , starring Michael Shannon as a man whose irresponsible lifestyle threatens to derail his teenage son’s ambitions, is at 44 percent.
  • The Human Surge (El auge del humano) (2017) , about a disaffected youth in Buenos Aires and his connections to other boys in the world, is at 44 percent.
  • Lavender (2017) , starring Abbie Cornish as a woman whose memory loss may be hiding some disturbing secrets, is at 42 percent.
  • The Last Word (2017) , starring Shirley MacLaine as a woman who enlists a reporter (Amanda Seyfried) to write her perfect obituary, is at 31 percent.
  • Table 19 (2017) , a comedy starring Anna Kendrick as a wedding guest who finds herself exiled to the misfits’ table, is at 16 percent.

Tag Cloud

rotten television name the review Trophy Talk justice league blockbuster President cooking Sundance Now Marathons Amazon Prime Video breaking bad cinemax remakes Syfy psycho BBC America asian-american 20th Century Fox golden globes Martial Arts classics Acorn TV Interview BET Awards true crime Winners Grammys kids BBC One Bravo Television Critics Association cars sitcom Classic Film worst Amazon Studios Sneak Peek YA harry potter renewed TV shows concert cancelled TV shows Summer slashers 24 frames nbcuniversal crime Horror Pride Month Crackle New York Comic Con franchise canceled AMC TCA Awards Lifetime Christmas movies spinoff E! streaming space biography Lifetime BET Shudder south america dceu Creative Arts Emmys GoT festival Rocketman Crunchyroll Star Trek travel 2016 historical drama Hallmark Christmas movies Rom-Com dogs Apple Reality Baby Yoda Oscars Action ESPN Amazon toronto Netflix Christmas movies WGN strong female leads CNN The Arrangement directors Christmas singing competition Red Carpet jamie lee curtis Pop TV Pop Rocky Trailer obituary witnail free movies doctor who batman Warner Bros. Quiz ABC dragons Kids & Family BBC zombies Nat Geo The Purge hollywood Vudu best game show Sundance TV festivals NBC Women's History Month dramedy Sci-Fi Character Guide Rock APB Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Cosplay Mary poppins Disney streaming service Television Academy Trivia Captain marvel FX on Hulu halloween movie Walt Disney Pictures Masterpiece 2015 joker National Geographic Comics on TV reviews Spectrum Originals politics Marvel Studios ratings TCA Winter 2020 Holidays animated werewolf twilight docudrama Pirates cats Tarantino HBO History 2017 007 green book romantic comedy rotten movies we love Fantasy Emmys award winner Disney PlayStation serial killer Disney Plus HBO Max Turner Classic Movies Pixar Awards Tour natural history scary movies Premiere Dates 4/20 Disney+ Disney Plus Binge Guide video Apple TV+ criterion Mary Tyler Moore Cartoon Network series Marvel VH1 FXX indiana jones MSNBC 45 fast and furious psychological thriller GLAAD GIFs technology war cancelled television TLC comiccon chucky RT21 Academy Awards Shondaland science fiction anime Drama Schedule documentaries The CW Western Turner superhero Set visit Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt American Society of Cinematographers adaptation Brie Larson Black History Month mockumentary football documentary DC streaming service diversity Endgame OneApp cartoon dc Epix blaxploitation 71st Emmy Awards Musicals ITV Animation casting worst movies spanish language TruTV Comedy Esquire period drama Lionsgate The Walking Dead TV renewals 72 Emmy Awards foreign NYCC 2020 Emmy Nominations Family WarnerMedia stoner Discovery Channel Countdown Chernobyl latino Box Office elevated horror a nightmare on elm street miniseries LGBTQ YouTube Red Netflix what to watch hist Peacock vampires venice Toys Hulu Pet Sematary Watching Series scorecard video on demand Avengers comic Freeform discovery all-time Sundance reboot Extras canceled TV shows screen actors guild stop motion TV Hallmark Winter TV Certified Fresh Mystery Superheroe Infographic children's TV crossover medical drama sequel Thanksgiving spy thriller BAFTA X-Men facebook USA Network Adult Swim Travel Channel HBO Go VICE Mudbound Ellie Kemper Teen Tubi MTV cancelled TNT Ovation LGBT Food Network laika Super Bowl mutant Britbox Marvel Television Film satire disaster First Look Country anthology Calendar Cannes Amazon Prime Best and Worst Ghostbusters TV Land Lucasfilm The Witch See It Skip It 2019 Podcast emmy awards quibi Tomatazos YouTube DirecTV Fall TV spain comedies zero dark thirty Dark Horse Comics DGA dark Mary Poppins Returns crime thriller Funimation stand-up comedy San Diego Comic-Con FOX Paramount Network TCM Universal Fox News Nickelodeon supernatural films theme song CMT Comedy Central zombie Stephen King Heroines game of thrones Showtime cancelled TV series PBS sag awards Disney Channel Video Games talk show comics Logo news TIFF revenge Superheroes police drama based on movie political drama child's play aliens OWN Starz Apple TV Plus ABC Family screenings thriller Elton John Black Mirror CW Seed IFC Films Valentine's Day Arrowverse Polls and Games romance Film Festival finale USA cults versus crime drama mission: impossible SXSW First Reviews richard e. Grant Sony Pictures A&E Nominations RT History A24 nfl indie TCA 2017 social media christmas movies Hear Us Out Tumblr YouTube Premium Anna Paquin Paramount sports PaleyFest Awards TCA adventure TBS 21st Century Fox 2018 toy story Year in Review boxoffice Spike hispanic tv talk El Rey universal monsters CBS All Access cops independent MCU Holiday DC Universe robots Election CBS Photos movies SDCC FX Reality Competition teaser IFC Spring TV Columbia Pictures ghosts Writers Guild of America Musical die hard book SundanceTV binge Opinion spider-man VOD Comic Book unscripted Star Wars parents composers Biopics Mindy Kaling Music DC Comics nature critics E3 sequels Song of Ice and Fire transformers