Five Favorite Films

Lily James' Five Favorite Films

The Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again star explains why people were so receptive to her feel-good summer hit.

by | October 23, 2018 | Comments

Jeff Spicer/Getty Images

(Photo by Jeff Spicer/Getty Images)

It takes someone special to fill Meryl Streep‘s shoes — or to plausibly play someone in whose shoes Queen Meryl will follow, eventually — but Lily James managed to charm audiences as Young Donna in the Certified Fresh summer hit Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again.

A decade after the film adaptation of the jukebox musical, Streep, Amanda Seyfried, and co. returned to the fictional Greek island of Kalokairi — Skopelos, Greece doubled for Kalokairi in the first movie but filming moved to Croatia in the second — for a film that ended up being both prequel and sequel to the original.

Here We Go Again tells the origin story of how Young Donna (James) met the three suitors who, in one summer of love, could’ve potentially fathered her daughter, Sophie (Seyfried). Colin Firth, Pierce Brosnan, and Stellan Skarsgård reprised their roles as Sophie’s potential hot dads, with Hugh Skinner, Jeremy Irvine, and Josh Dylan as their younger selves.

James, who grew up going to musicals with her family, never thought she’d star in one, let alone be featured on an international chart-topping album with Cher. (The Here We Go Again soundtrack hit No. 1 in eight countries, and No. 3 in the U.S.) Her next project is not a musical, per se, but is a music-influenced film from Richard Curtis.

When the actress caught up with Rotten Tomatoes ahead of the film’s home entertainment release — it’s available on streaming and Blu-ray now — she almost went with a list of her five favorite movie musicals. Instead, she discussed her Five Favorite Films of all time, her next projects, and the importance of feel-good movies.


Badlands (1973) 97%

Terrence Malick, Sissy Spacek — she’s out of this world and I just think that film’s so beautiful. I like the relationship and the whole visual world of it. I love that film. I can watch it again and again and again.

Titanic (1997) 89%

I love Titanic. It’s one of the first films I remember really being taken aback by. Any time I’m at home and if I see that film, whatever point it’s at, I have to watch it ’til the end. I got nodules on my voice and I realized I could do the ‘Jack. Jack. Jack. I’ll never let go, Jack.’ And I realized I could do it cause I’ve ruined my vocal chords and I could gain that talent, so there we go.

Grease (1978) 76%

I love musicals. I could just do my five favorite musicals, actually. Grease I had on cassette tape and I used to pause and rewind and write down the lyrics of the songs. Like “Hopelessly Devoted” — I’d pause it and then I’d write it down and then I’d play it and then I’d pause it and I’d write down the words so I could sing along. I used to write in my diary and spray perfume on it like Rizzo does when she sprays the perfume on the thing. I just, I knew every word. John Travolta is just — oh my God, doesn’t get any better.

Pretty Woman (1990) 64%

Julia Roberts is just everything. My mum was obsessed with Richard Gere, like literally obsessed. My mom introduced me to that film really early and I’m so glad she did. I love when [Roberts] goes into the shop and is like, “Big mistake. Huge. Huge.” I guess, in a way, now you think, “Oh, it’s like the Cinderella story and they probably wouldn’t even make that movie anymore; it’s not a strong message,” or whatever. But I think that’s just nonsense. It’s such an amazing film, and I think Richard Gere and Julia Roberts had this electric chemistry, and Julia Roberts is a goddess. I love the bit where she goes, “But when does it ever work for anyone? I mean, when? When?” Like, a man saving you from your destitute life. And Laura San Giacomo thinks about it and she goes, “You know, Cinde-f—ing-rella.”

The Deer Hunter (1978) 92%

That opening section at the wedding, it takes its time. Those movies at that time, I think, are some of the best movies in the world. I think it was the caliber of actors that existed then. Those actors, I think, are some of the greatest, and the type of filmmaking that happened then was something so special. It’s so character-based and story-led. None of the big blockbuster crap. Not that blockbusters are crap! But you know what I mean.


Rotten Tomatoes: You were debating between Pretty Woman and Notting Hill, and you wanted to give Notting Hill a shout-out.

I just worked with Richard Curtis and he is one of my favorite people on the planet. I think that he is a genius, and I thank god that he exists because he’s given us so much. I think that’s why I wanted to act, just to be a part of those kind of films, to be honest — those ones that are so heart-lifting and the joy and the comedy and the quirkiness of those movies.

RT: The Richard Curtis movie is a musical, right?

It’s actually not a musical. You’d think it would be ’cause it’s the music of the Beatles, but it’s not a musical. At all. I don’t even know what it is. It’s sort of its own genre. But I suppose it’s like a comedy-drama vibe. Hamish Patel is just out of this world. He sings a lot of Beatles but he’s pretty much the only one.

RT: Would you do more musicals? Clearly you grew up appreciating them.

It’s so funny. I kind of lost my love for them because I was so focused on acting, and I went to drama school and I realized that’s what I wanted to do. But then I think back on it, it’s so obvious. The Sound of Music, My Fair Lady, Cabaret, Grease — all these films were the films I literally grew up on and knew every word to. So, it’s obvious that is actually something in me that is my total passion and I kind of neglected it. Well, not neglected it — I just sort of forgot. And then doing it just feels so right.

And The Wizard of Oz and even, like, I know they’re not musicals, but the old Marilyn Monroe films where they sing, like Some Like it Hot. There’s something, I guess, in me. I would love to do Cabaret on stage.

RT: I think that one reason people loved Mamma Mia is because it’s nice to be reminded of the joy in life. Musicals are the embodiment of that.

Yeah. It’s abandon. It’s a sort of freedom of spirit. It’s a sense of humor. I think that’s why people love karaoke, right? Because most people, maybe they have to be drunk, but they like it because you get up, and suddenly you’re singing to a load of drunk people and you don’t care and you let your hair down. And I think musicals are like that, you know? It’s people going, “I’m gonna sing because words aren’t enough, because I’m that committed.” There’s an escapism, and it’s infectious.

RT: Did you ever think that you would be on an album with Cher?

The other person my mum was obsessed with was Cher. If I think of two people that my mum spoke about on a daily basis, it’s Richard Gere and Cher. So to be in a film on a soundtrack with Cher is just — I still can’t get my head ’round it. Cher gave each of us a necklace that says, like, “Dear Lily, Love Cher.” And Mamma Mia 2 on the back. It will be my most prized possession for the rest of my life. That’s my family heirloom, done.

RT: Have you just had ABBA songs stuck in your head for the past two years?

Yeah, pretty much. But that’s pretty much been my life anyway. My present since I was a kid and could only sit on my dad’s lap, he used to take me to the ballet. And he used to have to put, like, three pillows on my seat in the theater. I’d sit and I’d watch and I’d be in a pretty frock. That evolved into going to musicals, and every year we’d get on the train to London with my brothers who’d be like, “Ugh, for god’s sake.” They wouldn’t tell me where I was going, and my present was to go and see a musical, and I saw Mamma Mia.

RT: What do you think about the reception of the film this summer? People seemed to really embrace it.

I feel so proud. I love the film. There’s a lot of things about it that are really beautiful. It’s a film about loss and grief. I think it’s a film about mother-daughter friendship. There’s a lot in it that cuts deep, as well as just being a total laugh. It was cool, the reaction. I was traveling around Italy for a month and I met a girl on a train with a backpack and she said to me that it had really inspired her to go traveling. She was, like, 20. And people that say, “I’ve seen it three times.” “I saw it with my daughter.” It makes you feel good. I really love that.


Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again! is available to watch on DVD, Blu-ray and streaming.

Tag Cloud

boxing Crunchyroll werewolf Comics on TV History nature BBC America Tumblr name the review Awards live event Mary poppins rotten movies we love chucky rotten 21st Century Fox sitcom Esquire halloween tv binge Extras legend spanish E! spider-verse travel police drama Rock Universal TCA Awards book movies cops vampires HBO dexter Tarantino E3 Character Guide reviews VICE ABC Family Television Academy Podcast parents sequels Western TV One new york Logo know your critic universal monsters Apple miniseries WGN Legendary Mudbound ID LGBTQ elevated horror Year in Review action-comedy suspense ratings basketball Pride Month adventure dark USA Network Women's History Month diversity A&E based on movie supernatural Vudu Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TCA cancelled transformers Sony Pictures Red Carpet Marvel Studios toronto die hard women Superheroes harry potter Winners stoner HBO Max AMC Spring TV WarnerMedia Anna Paquin jurassic park cartoon classics facebook Arrowverse singing competition Shondaland YouTube MSNBC GLAAD tv talk CBS All Access cancelled TV shows razzies ABC Signature Fox News scary worst NYCC streaming batman The Arrangement kaiju The CW APB free movies robots LGBT comic 73rd Emmy Awards Pet Sematary rt labs Nickelodeon 90s blockbuster space marvel comics Toys Marathons VOD mcc comics YA zombies comic book movies Paramount Plus dreamworks Exclusive Video trailers SXSW mob scorecard golden globes Britbox telelvision Tomatazos BBC One breaking bad FX on Hulu festivals PlayStation DGA reboot Academy Awards stand-up comedy biopic Lifetime 20th Century Fox cults criterion popular 007 composers Pop Summer Peacock Creative Arts Emmys Holidays TruTV The Witch El Rey laika Paramount aliens Mindy Kaling San Diego Comic-Con Oscars Disney streaming service crime DirecTV satire CNN joker Awards Tour television vs. series Sundance biography teaser TCM Countdown The Purge romance witnail Fantasy new star wars movies documentary Martial Arts australia Fox Searchlight Lionsgate Warner Bros. crime thriller superman Pirates 2021 dogs kong war Amazon Studios Ovation films art house news Elton John scary movies DC streaming service Paramount Network Mary Tyler Moore IFC Broadway Opinion sports dragons NBA period drama YouTube Red Schedule MTV spy thriller Cosplay Rom-Com live action TCA 2017 Song of Ice and Fire Captain marvel christmas movies Valentine's Day Ghostbusters foreign Set visit high school zero dark thirty Thanksgiving Pixar Tubi Disney Plus cooking quibi true crime BBC anime The Academy hispanic heritage month political drama TV movies documentaries 2016 Turner new zealand dc renewed TV shows streaming movies king kong movie Adult Swim Music Sundance Now MCU Cannes TV Land godzilla target Funimation Rocketman thriller medical drama Freeform TV renewals BET gangster versus crossover marvel cinematic universe USA spanish language deadpool french stop motion mockumentary Emmys Winter TV casting Video Games spider-man canceled TV shows Amazon Prime SundanceTV best Epix NBC Disney Neflix strong female leads Family superhero Emmy Nominations screen actors guild Musicals Country Starz Sundance TV Crackle Alien video on demand Pacific Islander BET Awards OneApp boxoffice 72 Emmy Awards Bravo Super Bowl award winner RT21 Animation Film indie Lucasfilm obituary directors venice revenge Sneak Peek Dark Horse Comics Grammys National Geographic olympics Baby Yoda festival Nat Geo Chernobyl cinemax ESPN social media franchise children's TV fresh child's play scene in color DC Comics Hear Us Out independent archives blaxploitation CW Seed finale rom-coms royal family Fall TV Horror Box Office south america Disney Channel Trailer comiccon Black Mirror black TBS Quiz emmy awards New York Comic Con Amazon Prime Video Comedy Central monster movies natural history PaleyFest A24 Amazon CBS genre comic books historical drama Universal Pictures richard e. Grant Star Wars FXX 2020 docudrama 2019 international TCA Winter 2020 Tokyo Olympics DC Universe disaster Star Trek technology a nightmare on elm street Watching Series SDCC Apple TV+ game show PBS unscripted discovery saw rt labs critics edition Superheroe pirates of the caribbean Holiday nbcuniversal slasher green book Musical Binge Guide kids Kids & Family docuseries Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Showtime Hallmark Marvel Television prank rt archives Comic Book The Walt Disney Company Interview japan See It Skip It theme song book adaptation X-Men canceled Apple TV Plus 2018 psychological thriller Image Comics slashers Nominations cancelled TV series Certified Fresh Biopics Christmas 45 spinoff black comedy BAFTA Wes Anderson Travel Channel nfl spain 99% italian HBO Go toy story Masterpiece young adult animated dceu Brie Larson FOX zombie asian-american mutant Rocky Reality screenings First Look Mystery 71st Emmy Awards football The Walking Dead Trivia sequel YouTube Premium Polls and Games indiana jones feel good First Reviews ITV Shudder 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Lifetime Christmas movies all-time Spectrum Originals psycho President Film Festival Walt Disney Pictures remakes king arthur serial killer IMDb TV ViacomCBS AMC Plus GoT hidden camera lord of the rings debate talk show IFC Films science fiction Teen golden globe awards Trophy Talk hispanic Comic-Con@Home 2021 ABC critic resources hist cats cars cancelled television Black History Month ghosts Avengers Best and Worst Classic Film fast and furious james bond comic book movie Netflix Christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns Marvel comedies Comedy sag awards VH1 Drama posters romantic comedy Premiere Dates Discovery Channel American Society of Cinematographers concert 4/20 Syfy Turner Classic Movies adenture Instagram Live crime drama Spike justice league TIFF critics 2015 Action 1990s twilight GIFs Heroines Infographic TNT Ellie Kemper sopranos 2017 TV Hallmark Christmas movies hollywood doctor who video politics CMT Election jamie lee curtis Television Critics Association latino Reality Competition worst movies halloween mission: impossible Writers Guild of America what to watch adaptation blockbusters aapi Food Network Cartoon Network Sci-Fi FX japanese heist movie Hulu Pop TV Columbia Pictures Netflix OWN Stephen King 24 frames Acorn TV Disney+ Disney Plus Photos anthology Endgame wonder woman dramedy game of thrones RT History Calendar 93rd Oscars TLC