Critics Consensus

Latest Smurfs Gives Critics the Blues

Plus, Going in Style is an unnecessary makeover, Brockmire is funny and compelling, and Your Name and Colossal are Certified Fresh.

by | April 6, 2017 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have miniature woodland critters with the blues (Smurfs: The Lost Village, featuring the voices of Demi Lovato and Rainn Wilson), retirees with an axe to grind (Going in Style, starring Morgan Freeman, Michael Caine, and Alan Arkin), and a married couple at a religious crossroads (The Case for Christ, starring Mike Vogel and Erika Christensen). What are the critics saying?


Smurfs: The Lost Village (2017) 40%


At this point, there are no surprises with the Smurfs — you’re either on board with the little blue creatures debuted by Belgian artist Peyo in 1958 or you find their antics insufferable, and never the twain shall meet. With that in mind, it’s worth noting that this weekend’s Smurfs: The Lost Village represents something of a departure from recent installments in the franchise, given that it’s an all-animation outing instead of the live-action/CGI hybrids of the previous trilogy, but the story remains substantially the same. On one side of the story, you’ve got the Smurfs happily smurfing along; on the other, you have their eternal nemesis, the wicked wizard Gargamel (voiced by Rainn Wilson). This adventure adds a few new narrative wrinkles, but as has been the case with recent Smurfs outings, critics aren’t impressed — whether it’s the rather mundane story or the middle-of-the-road animation, reviews identify no shortage of deficiencies for discerning family audiences. The next time you’re in urgent need of a cinematic babysitter, it might do in a pinch, but this Lost Village probably isn’t worth finding at a theater near you.


Going in Style (2017) 48%


If a movie offers a brilliant cast a too-rare opportunity to shine — but still ends up being somewhat less than compelling — should it still be celebrated on some level? That’s the question facing critics this weekend with Going in Style, which puts veteran talents Alan Arkin, Michael Caine, Morgan Freeman, and Ann-Margaret back in the spotlight for a loose remake of the somewhat forgotten 1979 dramedy of the same name. Like the original, which starred George Burns, Art Carney, and Lee Strasberg, the plot finds a trio of retirees plotting a robbery — but this time around, instead of just looking for one last adventure, our protagonists are righteously ticked off after being cheated out of their pensions by unscrupulous bankers. There’s an opportunity to justify this remake with a fresh timely perspective, in other words; alas, critics say director Zach Braff leaves it on the table — along with just about everything else that might have made the movie more than a painless passing diversion. That being said, the opportunity to watch these old pros work together might make Going in Style worth a watch… if only to let Hollywood know there’s still a demand for its stars’ services.


The Case for Christ (2017) 59%


An Easter-season dramatization of the real-life marital/spiritual crisis that engulfed journalist Lee Strobel after his wife experienced a religious awakening, The Case for Christ (starring Mike Vogel and Erika Christensen as the Strobels) purports to tell the tale of his unexpected journey upon setting out to debunk Christianity once and for all. We’d love to tell you what the critics have to say about all this, but unfortunately, the movie didn’t screen for them ahead of time — and you know what that means. Guess the Tomatometer!


What’s New on TV

Brockmire: Season 1 (2017) 94%

Brockmire insinuates itself as the series goes on, elevated by assured, compelling performances from Hank Azaria and Amanda Peet — and a raw humor all its own.


Prison Break: Season 5 (2017) 55%

Prison Break recaptures some of its old urgency in its return, but familiar faces and frenetic action aren’t enough to make up for a plot that manages to bore while beggaring belief.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Truman (2017) , about two old friends reconnecting under the specter of looming sadness, is Certified Fresh at 100 percent.
  • Alive and Kicking (2017) , a documentary look at the culture of swing dancing, is at 100 percent.
  • Your Name. (Kimi No Na Wa.) (2017) , an anime about two teens who suddenly swap bodies — and genders — is Certified Fresh at 97 percent.
  • Graduation (Bacalaureat) (2017) , about a father’s progressively more complicated efforts to ensure a bright academic future for his daughter, is Certified Fresh at 96 percent.
  • Their Finest (2017) , about a woman pressed into service writing propaganda movies for Britain during World War II, is at 92 percent.
  • The Transfiguration (2017) , about two alienated teens who form a potentially fraught bond, is at 86 percent.
  • SHOT!: The Psycho-Spiritual Mantra of Rock (2017) , a documentary look at the life and career of photographer Mick Rock, is at 86 percent.
  • The Void (2017) , about the supernatural chaos that erupts after a policeman discovers a dying man and rushes him to treatment, is at 80 percent.
  • Colossal (2017) , writer-director Nacho Vigalondo‘s balancing act between monster movie and addiction drama, is Certified Fresh at 76 percent.
  • All These Sleepless Nights (2017) , about the complications that develop between two friends during their school years in Warsaw, is at 75 percent.
  • i hate myself 🙂 (2017) , a self-reflexive documentary examining director Joanna Arnow‘s life and filmmaking process itself, is at 60 percent.
  • Gifted (2017) , starring Chris Evans as a man whose guardianship of his niece is threatened by the attention attracted by her prodigious intellect, is at 57 percent.
  • Aftermath (2017) , starring Arnold Schwarzenegger as a man struggling to come to terms with the sudden death of his wife and daughter, is at 40 percent.
  • The Ticket (2017) , starring Dan Stevens as a man whose life is upended in unexpected ways after he regains his eyesight, is at 39 percent.
  • Salt and Fire (2017) , a Werner Herzog drama about a hostage situation starring Michael Shannon and Gael García Bernal, is at 29 percent.
  • The Assignment (2017) , starring Michelle Rodriguez as a hitman who undergoes forced gender reassignment surgery at the hands of a vengeful doctor (Sigourney Weaver), is at 24 percent.
  • Mine (2017) , starring Armie Hammer as a soldier stranded alone in hostile territory after a mission goes violently awry, is at 19 percent.
  • Queen of the Desert (2017) , starring Nicole Kidman in a biopic about English explorer Gertrude Bell, is at 11 percent.

Tag Cloud

Photos Box Office unscripted Countdown PBS Mary Poppins Returns Animation period drama vampires CW Seed NYCC Amazon Prime Video TIFF YouTube Red First Look cinemax SundanceTV Apple TCM TLC Summer Comedy Central Pop thriller Nat Geo 007 Dark Horse Comics casting witnail The CW social media YA Ellie Kemper zero dark thirty Red Carpet Superheroe comic supernatural The Arrangement Mystery AMC Vudu IFC Films Trivia historical drama sports romance CBS All Access Music GoT police drama spanish language nature OWN Set visit quibi RT History Marathons Pet Sematary natural history talk show zombie Winter TV DGA ITV Lifetime Tumblr Superheroes revenge SXSW Tomatazos Heroines sequel Mary Tyler Moore Black Mirror psycho toy story RT21 Lionsgate theme song teaser doctor who National Geographic Thanksgiving harry potter foreign cops ABC TNT Toys singing competition space Extras VICE science fiction sitcom FX Film Food Network richard e. Grant game of thrones composers tv talk BBC Reality Competition transformers Infographic 2018 LGBT cats Musical Rom-Com Oscars Paramount aliens south america HBO Horror Lucasfilm zombies X-Men USA Network YouTube Premium green book Star Trek Christmas TCA Stephen King Star Wars disaster 24 frames Rock Family Cosplay elevated horror Sundance ESPN Esquire Marvel festivals Binge Guide cults Grammys Elton John miniseries Premiere Dates San Diego Comic-Con Kids & Family facebook Creative Arts Emmys Opinion Sci-Fi Emmy Nominations Pride Month finale crossover El Rey kids 21st Century Fox Calendar Teen 20th Century Fox Universal comiccon Country Song of Ice and Fire dramedy Valentine's Day anthology binge GIFs President Warner Bros. Crackle Trailer Super Bowl 45 Rocketman anime Fall TV Fox News Netflix Best and Worst APB Columbia Pictures Bravo psychological thriller Chernobyl Year in Review Comic Book MTV strong female leads hist Ghostbusters animated FXX Character Guide DC Universe Awards HBO Max PaleyFest political drama Britbox Podcast Sony Pictures war Cannes hispanic First Reviews movies FOX Election Anna Paquin Watching Series 2015 series Spring TV Showtime Quiz Amazon ABC Family 2016 Logo Shudder mockumentary discovery Polls and Games adventure Video Games serial killer based on movie Spectrum Originals Certified Fresh Pirates golden globes CMT Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Amazon Prime 2019 Sundance Now ghosts Shondaland SDCC biography true crime Ovation Spike Rocky A&E Disney spinoff Western Disney streaming service streaming crime thriller technology Nominations American Society of Cinematographers Drama Women's History Month game show E3 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Interview Tarantino crime drama boxoffice politics medical drama cooking 2017 TV Land NBC Winners Writers Guild of America VH1 Action DC streaming service dragons Trophy Talk Cartoon Network Walt Disney Pictures stand-up comedy Syfy Fantasy Holidays GLAAD Schedule Masterpiece mutant latino children's TV TruTV award winner LGBTQ CNN robots Awards Tour Film Festival USA Reality Hulu MSNBC crime ratings Adult Swim DirecTV Sneak Peek spider-man travel Comics on TV BBC America television diversity Martial Arts New York Comic Con jamie lee curtis BET dceu Mary poppins adaptation book IFC docudrama E! Emmys TBS Musicals Comedy Pixar spy thriller spain Freeform Paramount Network dc Arrowverse Mindy Kaling Brie Larson TCA 2017 what to watch Disney Channel WGN Captain marvel Nickelodeon History justice league Epix DC Comics Starz MCU See It Skip It Acorn TV cars CBS blaxploitation The Witch TV Mudbound WarnerMedia Biopics