Know Your Critic

Know Your Critic: Leonard Maltin, Film Critic and Historian

Maltin talks favorite films, reflects on his celebrated career, and teases his new film review-centric game, “King of Movies.”

by | July 23, 2020 | Comments

Warner Bros. Pictures, Twentieth Century Fox, and Newmarket Film Group

(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures, Twentieth Century Fox, and Newmarket Film Group)

Know Your Critic” is a column in which we interview Tomatometer-approved critics about their screening and reviewing habits, pet peeves, and personal favorites.

Before Leonard Maltin became known as the iconic critic and historian that he is, he was a movie-loving teenager, putting together a fanzine called Film Fan Monthly. He wrote for Variety, TV Guide, and other major publications, eventually becoming Entertainment Tonight’s broadcast movie critic – a position he held for 30 years. Starting in 1969, he compiled lists of every year’s must-see movies – Leonard Maltin’s Movie Guide published annually or biannually until 2014. He’s written a dozen books, been the president of the Los Angeles Film Critics Association, and taught at USC’s School of Cinematic Arts. And now he’s a game… really.

Maltin’s most devoted fans and fellow cinephiles have put together a game in his honor: “King of Movies.” The objective? To be Leonard Maltin in the most convincing fashion. Players pull a movie title from a deck of cards, along with a genuine Maltin review of the title, then must review the film in Maltin’s signature style, attempting to trick a player into thinking Maltin wrote it himself. It’s basically “pick the real Maltin review,” and will be available to purchase from Mondo.

“The idea is to fool the other players that you’ve written an authentic writeup for a movie they’ve never heard of,” Maltin told Rotten Tomatoes in an interview.

In his storied and celebrated career, Maltin is most proud of “surviving,” he says – “and that’s not a flippant answer.”

Leonard Maltin is a film critic and historian. He currently publishes at leonardmaltin.com.


What do you consider required viewing?

Charlie Chaplin. No further explanation. To me, so much begins with Charlie Chaplin.

Citizen Kane, Singin’ in the Rain, Seven Samurai, La Strada, I could go on and on and on.

What is the hardest review that you’ve ever written?

The Mel Gibson movie, The Passion of the Christ. Because I went to a screening, and directly from that screening to our studio, and had to write and deliver a review without having more than a half hour to digest the film and organize my thoughts.

Is there something that’s Rotten on the Tomatometer, but you’d defend it to the ends of the Earth?

I actually wrote about this one in the book, Rotten Movies We Love. It’s called Bela Lugosi Meets a Brooklyn Gorilla. And by any objective standards, it’s indefensible, but I love it.

What are you most proud of in your career so far?

I feel very fortunate that I came along when I did – which is to say long before the Internet – when you could still make a name or stake yourself a spot on the landscape through old-fashioned means, self-publishing the fanzine as I did, being generously plugged or promoted by other publications and building a reputation, and then publishing books that were actually distributed widely in stores around the country and not just limited to specialty presses.

My first couple of books – I met a lot of people who say that mine was the first movie book they ever bought when they were in their teens, because they only cost a dollar-and-a-half, and they were on sale at the local drug store or Woolworth’s or card and gift shop in the days before the malling of America and rise of the bookstore chains.

Timing in life is crucial – and luck. The challenge for anyone starting today is cutting through all the clutter.


Can you give us the rundown on your new King of Movies game?

Well, there are people who were devotees and remain devotees of my annual movie guide for years, in some cases for decades. One of them is Tim League, the co-founder of Alamo Drafthouse. He and one of his cohorts, Ant Timpson, used to play this game where they would try to devise phony write-ups of movies, because especially when writing about older, more formulaic Hollywood movies, there was identifiable rhythm and style to the writing. So they started to challenge each other and friends of theirs.

They’ve now institutionalized this as a game. I played it with them a couple of times, and I’ve done a couple of test runs of the final game. Some people really get it. Some people fall into the rhythm of those write-ups, and they can be very persuasive.

What makes a Leonard Maltin review a Leonard Maltin review?

Well, none of the better qualities are part of this game. Rapier wit and incisive storytelling in capsule form are not the hallmarks of these reviews. It’s the formula – the formulaic descriptions of films that really come out on top in the game.

Is there anyone that you think could “beat” you at your own game?

Well, yes, theoretically. But I did it for so long, I have an unfair advantage.


Warner Bros. Pictures

(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

What is your favorite classic film?

Casablanca.

Is there a movie that you’ve watched more than any other?

Casablanca.

Can you guesstimate how many times you’ve seen it?

No, I really can’t. Certainly 20 to 25 times.

What do you think is the biggest misconception about critics?

We’re lucky to get paid for what we do. And that is also a truism.

Yeah, we are lucky. We’re not digging ditches, we’re not doing manual labor, but we get paid to watch bad movies. I found out particularly when I started getting recognized from being on television and people would stop me and say, “You got the best job in the world.” I said, “Well, it’s a great job, but you know, some days it feels like a job.” Then people’s eyes glaze over. When you get paid to watch movies, no one wants to hear complaints, and I get that.

What do you think makes a good movie?

They say a smart person can hold two opposing thoughts in their mind at the same time. On the one hand, I’m tempted to say originality and freshness, and yet there’s some movies I like a lot, very good movies, that follow a ritual for a genre and wind up being really good.


What is your preferred seat in a movie theater?

Aisle seat, midway down the aisle.

What is your favorite screening snack?

Popcorn. No butter.

When reviewing, do you go in cold?

The only way I go. I actually studiously avoid reading or seeing anything about a movie. I don’t even watch the trailers. The less I know about a movie going in, the better experience I have.

Are you pro- or anti- note-taking?

Neither. There are times when note-taking is crucial. I don’t write lengthy reviews, so I find as long as I log-in either that night or the next morning when I get home, that does it for me.

What is your personal record for most movies watched in a day?

Seven. May I add with an asterisk: That was the day I discovered definitively that it’s not the eyes that go first, it’s the tush.

What’s your favorite film from your childhood?

Oh gosh, so many. No one has ever asked me that.

At age seven, my parents took me to see a film called The Golden Age of Comedy, which was a compilation of great moments from silent film comedies with Laurel and Hardy and Charlie Chaplin and others. I even remembered the theater where I saw it in Manhattan, and it literally changed my life.


Twentieth Century Fox

(Photo by Twentieth Century Fox)

Who is an actor or director or a screenwriter whose work you always love?

Alexander Payne. He is an original – he and his frequent writing partner, Jim Taylor. Their films aren’t like anybody else’s. They deal in social satire, which very few people even approach, because it’s such a difficult genre.

Who are some under-the-radar directors or a screenwriters that you think more people should know about?

Well, yes. I guess it depends on how you define that radar. Kelly Reichardt, her latest film, First Cow, is the best movie I’ve seen this year. Nicole Holofcener, huge fan; Jeff Nichols, an underappreciated talent; Debra Granik, so many. They’re not exactly newcomers, but they ought to be more celebrated than they are.

Is there someone in your life who isn’t a critic, whose opinion you admire?

Well, my wife and daughter, who are critics, only they don’t get paid for it. I respect their opinions, both of them.

Can you think of a recent movie where you may have disagreed with either of them?

Oh gosh. My daughter and her husband weren’t engaged by Spike Lee‘s Da 5 Bloods. My wife and I just thought it was terrific.


Who are some up-and-coming critics that you want people to check out?

I deal so much with classic and vintage films. I’ve been very impressed with two young-ish writers and essayists on the scene. One is Imogen Sara Smith, the other is Farran Smith Nehme.

They’re both freelancers, and they’re employed quite a bit by the Criterion Collection. I’ve seen them both on camera and doing commentary tracks and writing wonderfully eloquent essays for Criterion booklets as well. They’re whip smart, and I’m very impressed with both of them.

Do you have advice for critics who are still finding their voice?

Keep at it. Experience is the best teacher, and getting feedback is hugely important too.


Leonard Maltin is a film critic and historian. He currently publishes at leonardmaltin.com.

Tag Cloud

SXSW blaxploitation Brie Larson Marvel Disney docudrama Musicals doctor who Peacock monster movies all-time Lionsgate aapi kids Rock italian HBO Go stoner travel VICE CBS All Access golden globes cancelled TV shows Trailer politics Disney Plus worst movies series Fox News Marvel Television heist movie Pet Sematary true crime werewolf sequel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt streaming movies reboot Spike BET Awards Emmy Nominations fast and furious dark book Certified Fresh crime Ovation obituary Mystery Adult Swim YouTube Fox Searchlight saw criterion scorecard FXX Vudu psycho indiana jones 2017 Christmas movie Classic Film RT21 Thanksgiving best revenge canceled emmy awards IFC Films Western technology a nightmare on elm street video 4/20 VH1 Disney+ Disney Plus BBC One WGN TNT American Society of Cinematographers Masterpiece spy thriller Lucasfilm Spectrum Originals Grammys directors talk show TCA Shondaland CMT TV Land cinemax MTV anthology diversity PBS breaking bad Trophy Talk 21st Century Fox Amazon Prime Video 2019 ESPN MCU Countdown Schedule documentaries space indie Film Wes Anderson dc Teen Holidays children's TV basketball cancelled television Disney Channel target HBO Max reviews Premiere Dates high school marvel cinematic universe APB See It Skip It sports supernatural Biopics Sundance TV comic batman golden globe awards Pride Month streaming Lifetime Christmas movies TBS Nickelodeon 72 Emmy Awards cults political drama wonder woman Paramount Plus Star Trek zombie razzies spinoff unscripted halloween tv rotten movies we love Infographic E! 2016 popular Song of Ice and Fire police drama superman AMC black Family VOD Pop TV Pirates sequels godzilla LGBTQ DC Universe football teaser independent adenture deadpool RT History worst YA 1990s Best and Worst LGBT name the review superhero GIFs Valentine's Day Pixar thriller japan television Broadway dceu spider-man pirates of the caribbean french king arthur Writers Guild of America Apple kaiju Stephen King festivals australia binge Year in Review Drama crossover 20th Century Fox slashers Walt Disney Pictures Acorn TV Sony Pictures ID venice vampires olympics king kong Endgame sag awards Tubi cartoon Superheroes Amazon Prime Avengers Polls and Games Baby Yoda elevated horror President Universal Cartoon Network TIFF jamie lee curtis women comic books Emmys HBO Character Guide Discovery Channel nature ABC concert TLC 93rd Oscars Hulu Netflix Christmas movies Awards Tour Comic Book quibi PaleyFest 2018 History miniseries Crackle strong female leads anime Hallmark Creative Arts Emmys Comics on TV Quiz X-Men Cosplay Star Wars Fall TV OneApp comiccon Mary poppins richard e. Grant 45 ABC Family dogs canceled TV shows Summer joker ratings Comedy Marvel Studios Hear Us Out Musical Rom-Com Oscars screen actors guild zero dark thirty NBC Apple TV+ festival trailers Paramount Warner Bros. OWN Columbia Pictures Lifetime serial killer Women's History Month Television Academy halloween SundanceTV TV One comics telelvision Hallmark Christmas movies natural history Country zombies game of thrones The Walt Disney Company Amazon Studios Cannes Chernobyl Funimation war Amazon BAFTA Captain marvel Pop rom-coms ITV IFC documentary cancelled Alien scene in color GoT 90s live action stop motion game show 2015 new zealand Reality Competition Trivia Food Network fresh National Geographic transformers romantic comedy TruTV Disney streaming service renewed TV shows boxoffice historical drama Turner Classic Movies award winner robots Anna Paquin Election jurassic park Logo Spring TV new star wars movies classics chucky cooking 71st Emmy Awards Heroines TCA Winter 2020 First Reviews DC streaming service twilight critics Black History Month remakes know your critic Turner spanish language Image Comics Martial Arts Britbox universal monsters ghosts crime drama NYCC Binge Guide christmas movies Super Bowl 007 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Travel Channel archives south america USA Network Tokyo Olympics FX 2020 PlayStation Exclusive Video BBC Horror Sneak Peek rotten New York Comic Con romance A&E discovery Comic-Con@Home 2021 free movies mission: impossible crime thriller adaptation disaster foreign Arrowverse Nominations Red Carpet cops The Walking Dead Tumblr tv talk NBA franchise Extras Apple TV Plus TCM Pacific Islander Kids & Family Epix Comedy Central Legendary period drama biography Sundance Now facebook social media based on movie The Purge Tarantino international Superheroe Ghostbusters james bond Television Critics Association YouTube Premium boxing GLAAD medical drama 2021 justice league CNN psychological thriller Film Festival Winners cars Holiday Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Academy TCA Awards Mary Poppins Returns BET TV TV renewals Marathons Winter TV comedies japanese Video Games sitcom Shudder 99% singing competition Mudbound Elton John legend Crunchyroll satire films science fiction kong Black Mirror scary movies Starz WarnerMedia Bravo child's play nfl nbcuniversal Box Office Mary Tyler Moore Syfy Music stand-up comedy mutant Calendar ViacomCBS adventure what to watch FOX hist Animation Photos dramedy latino San Diego Comic-Con TCA 2017 MSNBC Esquire dragons hispanic green book animated DC Comics The CW finale toronto hidden camera docuseries asian-american book adaptation Freeform The Witch Mindy Kaling composers Showtime witnail die hard spanish FX on Hulu Set visit BBC America versus A24 Interview USA Nat Geo SDCC Podcast toy story Sci-Fi YouTube Red Rocketman blockbusters 24 frames CBS Fantasy harry potter news cancelled TV series Tomatazos cats blockbuster E3 ABC Signature new york CW Seed spain theme song laika video on demand The Arrangement hollywood Reality Action DGA mockumentary rt archives Toys Rocky parents lord of the rings Paramount Network suspense El Rey Ellie Kemper screenings DirecTV Dark Horse Comics Academy Awards First Look Netflix Sundance Opinion TV movies movies Watching Series aliens prank Awards casting