Total Recall

James Franco's 10 Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the director and star of The Disaster Artist.

by | November 29, 2017 | Comments

He’s a performance artist, published author, gala host, former soap star, college student, professor, and one of the most prolific film actors currently working in Hollywood. This week, James Franco is keeping busy as the director and star of The Disaster Artist, which dramatizes outsider hero Tommy Wiseau’s efforts to bring his infamous The Room to the big screen, so we decided now would be the perfect time to take a fond look back at some of the brightest critical highlights from Franco’s bustling career. From indie flicks to blockbusters, he’s been in just about every kind of picture — and we’re ranking them here while inviting you to rank your own favorites. It’s time for Total Recall!

1. Memoria (2016) 100%

(Photo by Monterey Media)

As if it weren’t enough that Memoria served as one of a whopping nine movies Franco released in 2016, it’s also based on a short story he wrote — all of which might make it sound like the vanity project to end all vanity projects, if not for the universally positive critical reception it earned during its limited release. Granted, at five reviews, we’re dealing with a limited sample size — at a certain point, Franco becomes too prolific even for people paid to watch the movies — but a rave is a rave, and this quiet character study about a troubled Bay Area teen earned its share, with its author’s supporting turn as a concerned teacher helping anchor the drama. “Despite clocking in at a scant 70 minutes,”  wrote Michael Rechtshaffen for the Los Angeles Times, “Memoria manages to make a hauntingly poetic impression.”

2. Milk (2008) 93%

(Photo by Focus Features)

Sean Penn rightly received most of the many accolades afforded this 2008 biopic of assassinated political activist Harvey Milk, but director Gus Van Sant wasn’t content to let his movie rest on its star’s performance — he rounded out the cast of Milk with a number of actors whose seamlessly committed performances helped make it one of the most lauded films of the year. Franco fills a supporting role here as Scott Smith, Milk’s onetime lover (and, eventually, the executor of his will), who moves to San Francisco with him during the first act and helps him start his political career. Franco’s work earned him an MTV Movie Awards nomination for Best Kiss — and helped inspire Tom Long of the Detroit News to write, “Progress is slow, but Harvey Milk was one of the first to set the wheels in motion. He more than deserves a movie this good.”

3. 127 Hours (2010) 93%

(Photo by Chuck Zlotnick/Fox Searchlight Pictures)
 By 2010, James Franco had been making movies for well over a decade, and had flirted with leading man status fairly early in his career, but it never really seemed to suit him — until Danny Boyle came along with 127 Hours. A dramatization of the horrible ordeal overcome by mountain climber Aron Ralston, who devised his own gruesome rescue from certain death after being pinned by a boulder during an expedition, 127 Hours gave Franco the opportunity to carry a movie on his own terms — and earned him some of the best reviews of his career, not to mention a pile of awards and a Best Actor Oscar nomination, in the process. Mike Scott of the Times-Picayune was just one of the many critics who loved the film, calling it “A masterful slice of four-star cinema, featuring an irresistible performance by James Franco, breathtaking cinematography, and the kind of deep, searching soul that is absent from so much of what comes out of Hollywood.”

4. The Spider-Man Franchise (82%)

(Photo by Columbia Pictures)

Long before Tom Holland swung into the MCU as Spider-Man, Tobey Maguire brought Marvel’s wall-crawler to the big screen in director Sam Raimi’s blockbuster trilogy — and Franco joined the core ensemble cast as Harry Osborn, Peter Parker’s best pal and the future Green Goblin. Harry’s tortured arc helped form the backbone of Raimi’s overarching narrative throughout the three films, and although Spider-Man 3 proved a dissatisfying low note for the end of this chapter in Spidey’s big-screen life, the movies together helped pave the way for the looming great golden age of superheroes at the box office; more importantly, as Mick LaSalle observed for the San Francisco Chronicle, they offered “Smart, fun entertainment made by people who took nothing for granted, including the audience.”

5. This Is the End (2013) 83%

(Photo by Suzanne Hanover/Sony Pictures)

If an actor is playing themselves in a movie, should it count as one of their best performances? More often than not, we’d say no — but we’re making an exception for the gloriously loopy This Is the End, in which some of Hollywood’s sharpest young talent play exaggerated (or straight up invented) versions of themselves against the backdrop of the apocalypse. The end of the world, naturally, is witnessed from Franco’s abode, where he’s hosting a house party (including Seth Rogen, Danny McBride, Jonah Hill, and Emma Watson) when things go haywire. The end result, while decidedly not for all tastes, hits its comedic targets far more often than it misses; as Dana Stevens observed for Slate, “This Is the End, true to its subject matter, is as funny as hell.”

6. Rise of the Planet of the Apes (2011) 82%

(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)
 While it would certainly be fair to say that the human actors have never been the Planet of the Apes franchise’s biggest draw — and that goes at least double for the recent prequel trilogy — it definitely helps to ground the drama if you’re working with actors who can bring the sci-fi saga’s more fantastical elements believably to life. With Rise of the Planet of the Apes, director Rupert Wyatt rounded up a talented flesh-and-blood ensemble that included John Lithgow, Brian Cox, Freida Pinto, and — as Will Rodman, the biologist whose quest for an Alzheimer’s cure unwittingly triggers the virus that sets the story in motion — James Franco. It all added up to a blockbuster that set the bar surprisingly high for its successors, and although Andy Serkis’ mo-cap work would deservedly come to define the trilogy, Franco helped lay the groundwork with an opening installment that the Minneapolis Star Tribune’s Colin Covert deemed “first-class entertainment, packed with clever, unsettling and even inspired ideas.”

7. Goat (2016) 79%

(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

In addition to taking a supporting role, Franco also donned his producer’s hat for Goat, a harrowing drama from director/co-writer Andrew Neel about a college freshman (Ben Schnetzer) whose efforts to fit in on campus include pledging his older brother’s fraternity — a fateful decision that soon goes violently wrong, further complicating a young life already shadowed by horrific violence. Like a good number of Franco’s film efforts, it was destined for limited release and aimed outside the mainstream, but for many of the critics who screened it, this hard-hitting coming-of-age story — distinguished by a scene-stealing turn from former pop idol Nick Jonas — proved difficult to shake. “This isn’t an easy film to watch,” admitted the Washington Post’s Stephanie Merry. “But it’s even harder to forget.”

8. Yosemite (2016) 77%

(Photo by Monterey Media)

One of several films drawing from Franco’s 2010 short story collection Palo Alto, this 2015 indie drama weaves together “Yosemite” and “Peter Parker,” a pair of stories from the book, to observe moments in the lives of three fifth-grade boys in 1985. As with other Palo Alto-derived movies, Franco produced and starred but didn’t write or direct; here, he handed the reins to writer-director Gabrielle Demeestere and appeared in one segment as Phil, a father taking a trip to the titular park with his son (Everett Meckler). While certainly not one of his more widely seen efforts, it ranks among his most satisfying for the majority of critics who reviewed it — including the Village Voice’s Alan Scherstuhl, who wrote, “Yosemite mines Franco’s fiction for its most vital quality: his unsentimental depiction of youthful insecurity, this time among fifth-graders.”

9. The Dead Girl (2006) 76%

(Photo by First Look International)
 It wasn’t seen by many people during its brief theatrical run, but this dark ensemble piece from writer/director Karen Moncrieff gave a strong stable of actors (including Franco, Brittany Murphy, Marcia Gay Harden, Josh Brolin, Toni Collette, and Kerry Washington) a chance to plumb the emotional depths of the mystery surrounding a woman’s grisly death. While far from Franco’s showiest role, his turn as a kind-hearted mortician helped anchor The Dead Girl’s unrelenting grimness with a small ray of something like hope — and helped move the Oregonian’s Shawn Levy to write, “Moncrieff manages to get beneath the skin of several of these characters, a nifty trick considering what a crowded world she’s created. In all, it’s a grueling, emotionally taxing, discomfiting film.”

10. In the Valley of Elah (2007) 73%

(Photo by Warner Bros. courtesy Everett Collection)

In this Paul Haggis drama, Franco took a supporting role alongside Jason Patric as one of two politely dismissive Army officers who interfere with the efforts of a grieving father (played by Tommy Lee Jones) to uncover the facts of his son’s gruesome murder. Though its Iraq War overtones didn’t do it many favors with audiences, and some critics felt Haggis took an excessively heavy-handed approach, most were able to appreciate In the Valley of Elah’s message — and the hard questions it asked in a time of war. “After the potent final image faded to black,” wrote Aisle Seat’s Mike McGranaghan, “I had that very special tingle I get when I know I’ve just seen a great movie.”

Tag Cloud

diversity Arrowverse dogs dragons Podcast Holiday Set visit Esquire Amazon Prime Video harry potter Disney Pixar Election TruTV Fox News Ellie Kemper television Adult Swim canceled TV shows Mystery blaxploitation National Geographic Peacock Emmy Nominations 2018 HBO sitcom President USA crime thriller 2017 witnail reviews HBO Max Film Festival universal monsters TBS singing competition Comedy Central Fall TV renewed TV shows GoT USA Network Disney+ Disney Plus free movies The Witch TIFF psycho MCU Thanksgiving indie halloween doctor who Mary Poppins Returns Mudbound dramedy Women's History Month latino NBC game show jamie lee curtis ABC Family TV renewals miniseries Awards Marvel CBS police drama justice league spider-man Marvel Studios casting sag awards binge quibi Hulu versus Biopics Comic Book zero dark thirty Marathons docudrama TV festivals MTV cancelled television sports PBS Tubi Extras Best and Worst serial killer Disney Plus richard e. Grant SDCC The CW rotten movies we love 2015 Warner Bros. Musical Showtime Academy Awards VH1 DGA APB cults FOX Super Bowl Discovery Channel Sneak Peek screenings Binge Guide San Diego Comic-Con Tomatazos period drama Crackle TV Land Writers Guild of America Disney Channel independent Comedy Acorn TV Superheroes Hallmark Nominations CNN Christmas Star Trek Polls and Games Western YouTube Premium Nickelodeon Universal cops Watching Series GLAAD Reality Apple 2016 CBS All Access Funimation green book streaming Cannes adaptation Comics on TV A&E foreign Crunchyroll war Syfy Endgame Country Lucasfilm Black History Month First Reviews Lifetime discovery IFC Stephen King TCM ESPN Heroines Quiz spanish language Rocketman slashers WGN canceled Song of Ice and Fire Starz Ghostbusters kids historical drama Dark Horse Comics Toys Sci-Fi mockumentary christmas movies thriller The Arrangement Action El Rey romantic comedy ITV FXX Calendar Trophy Talk social media Family what to watch Video Games Walt Disney Pictures space Food Network adventure reboot Sundance Now TNT 24 frames cars spain Pop TV E3 animated Musicals MSNBC 2019 aliens unscripted award winner Netflix Christmas movies Pet Sematary 007 E! Drama Rocky SXSW Kids & Family A24 Television Academy IFC Films RT21 breaking bad Classic Film disaster scary movies Infographic finale YouTube Red Tarantino political drama Lionsgate Teen cartoon New York Comic Con blockbuster FX on Hulu Paramount Box Office 45 book Horror Paramount Network Animation strong female leads TCA Turner Classic Movies tv talk dceu TCA 2017 BET vampires Lifetime Christmas movies Apple TV+ Mary Tyler Moore cinemax TCA Winter 2020 Columbia Pictures Vudu talk show golden globes Winners franchise First Look anime zombie The Walking Dead composers revenge Marvel Television theme song Spring TV Apple TV Plus Travel Channel RT History Freeform nature Reality Competition X-Men DC streaming service comic spy thriller Pop Masterpiece movie movies comiccon Bravo biography 20th Century Fox WarnerMedia boxoffice Sundance joker LGBT Rom-Com technology PaleyFest Disney streaming service crime LGBTQ Ovation Logo Holidays batman Turner documentary FX Year in Review Shondaland OneApp BBC directors Music History DC Universe Emmys 71st Emmy Awards Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Elton John Anna Paquin children's TV 2020 cancelled TV shows true crime Photos werewolf politics dc Brie Larson Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt zombies screen actors guild Cartoon Network cats Shudder Interview Fantasy Grammys Superheroe Captain marvel Star Wars DirecTV mutant Awards Tour Opinion Tumblr AMC crime drama Nat Geo Red Carpet transformers comics ABC Mary poppins natural history cooking Netflix Rock spinoff Amazon Prime ghosts Mindy Kaling facebook Amazon supernatural Spectrum Originals series BBC America Character Guide Epix hispanic Chernobyl crossover YouTube teaser SundanceTV ratings Pride Month NYCC American Society of Cinematographers Trailer game of thrones Hallmark Christmas movies elevated horror GIFs south america cancelled Creative Arts Emmys psychological thriller Oscars sequel Sony Pictures 21st Century Fox Countdown medical drama OWN Martial Arts Summer The Purge travel Premiere Dates TLC Sundance TV CMT robots Winter TV cancelled TV series Certified Fresh YA stand-up comedy Schedule video Avengers based on movie Trivia DC Comics Cosplay name the review Amazon Studios Film See It Skip It anthology science fiction Valentine's Day Baby Yoda romance Pirates VICE Black Mirror toy story hist CW Seed Spike Britbox