Critics Consensus

Independence Day: Resurgence Is More of the Same

Plus, Free State of Jones is well-meaning but uneven; The Shallows is nail-bitingly tense; and The Neon Demon is striking but shallow.

by | June 23, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a war of the worlds (Independence Day: Resurgence, starring Liam Hemsworth and Jeff Goldblum), an armed revolt (Free State of Jones, starring Matthew McConaughey and Gugu Mbatha-Raw), a shark attack (The Shallows, starring Blake Lively and Oscar Jaenada), and the cutthroat world of fashion (The Neon Demon, starring Elle Fanning and Christina Hendricks). What do the critics have to say?


Independence Day: Resurgence (2016) 29%

Roland Emmerich’s Independence Day was a lethally effective blast of sci-fi alien invasion thrills that redefined the summer blockbuster while launching Will Smith into full-on leading man status — and whetting its director’s appetite for decades of large-scale, CGI-enhanced cinematic destruction. He’s taken his time getting around to a sequel, but unfortunately, most reviews say the 20 years between chapters hasn’t done much in terms of seasoning the story; for better and for worse, Independence Day: Resurgence offers a straightforward second helping, and delivers essentially the same senses-rattling experience the director’s devotees have come to expect. It’s disappointing for those who wondered whether the passage of time (and the absence of Smith’s character) might add some genuine poignancy to the proceedings, but the critics are clear. If it’s alien invaders and global mayhem you’re after at the theater this weekend, Independence Day: Resurgence is clearly your best bet — just don’t expect more than high-energy spectacle


Free State of Jones (2016) 46%

Writer-director Gary Ross has delivered a number of distinctive, critically lauded hits over the years, and his latest effort, Free State of Jones, seemed like a safe bet for another: with a fact-based storyline promising epic Civil War action and a cast list that included Matthew McConaughey, Gugu Mbatha-Raw, and Keri Russell, it beckoned on the release schedule as an oasis from the usual summer fare. Alas, critics say that while Jones clearly has its heart in the right place, the end result is a surprising misfire that reduces real-life southern secessionist Newt Knight to a line item in a well-meaning lecture. It’s a story worth telling, and all the ingredients are there, but the reviews warn against entering this Free State.


The Shallows (2016) 79%

The Shallows stars Blake Lively as Nancy, a perky surfer who happens to be testing the waves at a secluded beach just as a hungry great white shark comes cruising by. It’s the type of setup that’s been used for many a bikini-clad ocean frightfest, often with less than compelling results — but the critics say this entry proves a happy exception to the genre rule, with tightly coiled thrills to match Lively’s strong central performance. The Shallows isn’t necessarily thought-provoking stuff, but as our British friends like to say, it does exactly what it says on the tin; if you’re in the mood to scream in the dark with strangers this weekend, check your local listings and proceed accordingly.


The Neon Demon (2016) 59%

Like Zack Snyder without the yen for comic book adaptations, Nicolas Winding Refn has a singular eye for composition and detail — and a growing reputation for too rarely putting that gift to good use. The Neon Demon adds another chapter to Refn’s frustrating story, with critics lining up to praise its hauntingly vivid imagery while pointing out that it’s also a narrative mess. Elle Fanning stars as Jesse, an aspiring model who moves to L.A. and finds herself in a viper’s nest of bad behavior — but what exactly Refn’s trying to accomplish with her story is lost in a swirl of beautiful yet ultimately inscrutable style. Hardcore fans may find watching Demon worth the effort; for the rest of us, re-watching Drive might be a better investment.


What’s New on TV

Greenleaf: Season 1 (2016) 81%

Immersed in a unique megachurch setting, Greenleaf is a juicy family soap bolstered by a provocative spirituality.


American Gothic: Season 1 (2016) 58%

American Gothic may not be striving for much, yet it holds promise as a soapy, campy family murder-mystery that’s ultimately just engaging enough.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Hunt for the Wilderpeople (2016) , starring Sam Neill and Julian Dennison in a Certified Fresh dramedy about a 13-year-old and his curmudgeonly uncle who are forced to flee the authorities and hide out in the woods, is at 100 percent.
  • Nuts! (2016) , a documentary/animation hybrid about a Kansas doctor who claimed to have created a bizarre cure for male impotence, is at 100 percent.
  • Eat That Question: Frank Zappa in His Own Words (2016) , a documentary about the life and career of the virtuoso guitarist and celebrated non-conformist, is at 100 percent.
  • Breaking A Monster (2016) , a documentary about a preteen metal band and the viral fame that earned them a gig opening for Metallica, is at 100 percent.
  • T-Rex (2016) , T-Rex, a a documentary about a teenage Olympic boxing hopeful, is at 100 percent.
  • The Phenom (2016) , starring Johnny Simmons and Ethan Hawke in a drama about a pitching prospect with a troubled family life, is at 89 percent.
  • River (2016) , starring Rossif Sutherland as an American volunteer surgeon in Laos who stumbles into some very dark corners of the country, is at 88 percent.
  • Les Cowboys (2016) , a French Western starring François Damiens as a man consumed by a quest to find his missing daughter, is at 79 percent.
  • Wiener-Dog (2016) , a Todd Solondz ensemble comedy that connects four stories through the presence of its titular canine, is at 69 percent.
  • Swiss Army Man (2016) , starring Paul Dano as a shipwrecked man and Daniel Radcliffe as the gassy all-purpose corpse who might be his ticket back to civilization, is at 65 percent.

Tag Cloud

TCA 2017 RT21 Action PaleyFest binge Grammys sequel Summer casting NYCC TNT CBS All Access TIFF Heroines Comic Book National Geographic FX Pride Month Schedule book Drama Spike series Animation award winner quibi Writers Guild of America Holidays President 2016 Sneak Peek boxoffice Apple Infographic war VICE Britbox true crime elevated horror Photos historical drama disaster Awards Tour Tomatazos Mindy Kaling Disney justice league Acorn TV transformers adventure Ovation Amazon golden globes stand-up comedy richard e. Grant Interview Shudder 21st Century Fox Rom-Com singing competition sitcom E! Box Office HBO Max Rocketman Reality Competition discovery zombie Universal Ellie Kemper ABC Family PBS science fiction game of thrones Logo cooking Tumblr romance Biopics HBO IFC Films Mary poppins finale Trophy Talk south america The Arrangement dc cops Christmas Adult Swim Super Bowl X-Men Nickelodeon Thanksgiving VH1 technology spinoff Emmy Nominations zero dark thirty Video Games Shondaland New York Comic Con DirecTV LGBTQ Character Guide Captain marvel composers Year in Review USA Network OWN Film BBC America revenge SundanceTV serial killer Horror DC streaming service Pixar Peacock CW Seed The Witch Fox News Mudbound First Look TV Land Awards Star Trek Paramount Network Martial Arts SDCC Country El Rey spy thriller Superheroe 2017 Musical Teen Binge Guide Freeform Sony Pictures See It Skip It Nat Geo Food Network WarnerMedia YA Warner Bros. Certified Fresh mutant festivals 007 The CW docudrama latino Creative Arts Emmys nature teaser spanish language hist San Diego Comic-Con Syfy adaptation crime thriller Lifetime video Spectrum Originals crime drama History Spring TV facebook Chernobyl strong female leads Winners Fantasy psycho 2015 talk show DC Universe Sundance 20th Century Fox Nominations foreign Arrowverse anthology First Reviews medical drama Lucasfilm Countdown 71st Emmy Awards Marathons tv talk CNN space natural history Dark Horse Comics Television Academy Calendar A&E Epix Western social media Podcast Reality cults Starz doctor who AMC cinemax ITV E3 TruTV Pop mockumentary Amazon Prime Video USA Trivia streaming CBS Kids & Family FOX Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt blaxploitation police drama Cannes television animated Lionsgate Netflix Mary Tyler Moore Musicals Set visit what to watch Polls and Games game show WGN travel Showtime Stephen King hispanic politics Watching Series political drama 24 frames Premiere Dates dragons TV Marvel comic ESPN Vudu Esquire Valentine's Day ratings diversity cars Cartoon Network NBC Winter TV Rock Rocky children's TV Paramount Comics on TV dceu Sci-Fi Bravo Columbia Pictures Black Mirror American Society of Cinematographers comiccon YouTube Premium crime Film Festival toy story based on movie Extras IFC Emmys Brie Larson Disney Channel cats Mary Poppins Returns TCA Crackle Amazon Prime Song of Ice and Fire Cosplay Comedy Hulu RT History aliens MSNBC Quiz 2018 Superheroes BET Oscars Trailer 45 biography jamie lee curtis Masterpiece witnail ABC theme song 2019 Opinion green book GIFs Best and Worst Tarantino GLAAD CMT thriller Ghostbusters FXX ghosts psychological thriller Music Toys unscripted MCU Women's History Month zombies LGBT APB Family robots TBS harry potter GoT Elton John TCM Red Carpet Sundance Now DC Comics movies Mystery BBC dramedy DGA TLC period drama vampires YouTube Red Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pet Sematary spider-man Walt Disney Pictures spain anime sports Election Anna Paquin miniseries Fall TV SXSW MTV Star Wars Pirates kids Comedy Central supernatural Disney streaming service crossover