Critics Consensus

Independence Day: Resurgence Is More of the Same

Plus, Free State of Jones is well-meaning but uneven; The Shallows is nail-bitingly tense; and The Neon Demon is striking but shallow.

by | June 23, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a war of the worlds (Independence Day: Resurgence, starring Liam Hemsworth and Jeff Goldblum), an armed revolt (Free State of Jones, starring Matthew McConaughey and Gugu Mbatha-Raw), a shark attack (The Shallows, starring Blake Lively and Oscar Jaenada), and the cutthroat world of fashion (The Neon Demon, starring Elle Fanning and Christina Hendricks). What do the critics have to say?


Independence Day: Resurgence (2016) 30%

Roland Emmerich’s Independence Day was a lethally effective blast of sci-fi alien invasion thrills that redefined the summer blockbuster while launching Will Smith into full-on leading man status — and whetting its director’s appetite for decades of large-scale, CGI-enhanced cinematic destruction. He’s taken his time getting around to a sequel, but unfortunately, most reviews say the 20 years between chapters hasn’t done much in terms of seasoning the story; for better and for worse, Independence Day: Resurgence offers a straightforward second helping, and delivers essentially the same senses-rattling experience the director’s devotees have come to expect. It’s disappointing for those who wondered whether the passage of time (and the absence of Smith’s character) might add some genuine poignancy to the proceedings, but the critics are clear. If it’s alien invaders and global mayhem you’re after at the theater this weekend, Independence Day: Resurgence is clearly your best bet — just don’t expect more than high-energy spectacle


Free State of Jones (2016) 48%

Writer-director Gary Ross has delivered a number of distinctive, critically lauded hits over the years, and his latest effort, Free State of Jones, seemed like a safe bet for another: with a fact-based storyline promising epic Civil War action and a cast list that included Matthew McConaughey, Gugu Mbatha-Raw, and Keri Russell, it beckoned on the release schedule as an oasis from the usual summer fare. Alas, critics say that while Jones clearly has its heart in the right place, the end result is a surprising misfire that reduces real-life southern secessionist Newt Knight to a line item in a well-meaning lecture. It’s a story worth telling, and all the ingredients are there, but the reviews warn against entering this Free State.


The Shallows (2016) 78%

The Shallows stars Blake Lively as Nancy, a perky surfer who happens to be testing the waves at a secluded beach just as a hungry great white shark comes cruising by. It’s the type of setup that’s been used for many a bikini-clad ocean frightfest, often with less than compelling results — but the critics say this entry proves a happy exception to the genre rule, with tightly coiled thrills to match Lively’s strong central performance. The Shallows isn’t necessarily thought-provoking stuff, but as our British friends like to say, it does exactly what it says on the tin; if you’re in the mood to scream in the dark with strangers this weekend, check your local listings and proceed accordingly.


The Neon Demon (2016) 59%

Like Zack Snyder without the yen for comic book adaptations, Nicolas Winding Refn has a singular eye for composition and detail — and a growing reputation for too rarely putting that gift to good use. The Neon Demon adds another chapter to Refn’s frustrating story, with critics lining up to praise its hauntingly vivid imagery while pointing out that it’s also a narrative mess. Elle Fanning stars as Jesse, an aspiring model who moves to L.A. and finds herself in a viper’s nest of bad behavior — but what exactly Refn’s trying to accomplish with her story is lost in a swirl of beautiful yet ultimately inscrutable style. Hardcore fans may find watching Demon worth the effort; for the rest of us, re-watching Drive might be a better investment.


What’s New on TV

Greenleaf: Season 1 (2016) 81%

Immersed in a unique megachurch setting, Greenleaf is a juicy family soap bolstered by a provocative spirituality.


American Gothic: Season 1 (2016) 58%

American Gothic may not be striving for much, yet it holds promise as a soapy, campy family murder-mystery that’s ultimately just engaging enough.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Hunt for the Wilderpeople (2016) , starring Sam Neill and Julian Dennison in a Certified Fresh dramedy about a 13-year-old and his curmudgeonly uncle who are forced to flee the authorities and hide out in the woods, is at 100 percent.
  • Nuts! (2016) , a documentary/animation hybrid about a Kansas doctor who claimed to have created a bizarre cure for male impotence, is at 100 percent.
  • Eat That Question: Frank Zappa in His Own Words (2016) , a documentary about the life and career of the virtuoso guitarist and celebrated non-conformist, is at 100 percent.
  • Breaking a Monster (2015) , a documentary about a preteen metal band and the viral fame that earned them a gig opening for Metallica, is at 100 percent.
  • T-Rex (2015) , T-Rex, a a documentary about a teenage Olympic boxing hopeful, is at 100 percent.
  • The Phenom (2016) , starring Johnny Simmons and Ethan Hawke in a drama about a pitching prospect with a troubled family life, is at 89 percent.
  • River (2015) , starring Rossif Sutherland as an American volunteer surgeon in Laos who stumbles into some very dark corners of the country, is at 88 percent.
  • The Cowboys (2015) , a French Western starring François Damiens as a man consumed by a quest to find his missing daughter, is at 79 percent.
  • Wiener-Dog (2016) , a Todd Solondz ensemble comedy that connects four stories through the presence of its titular canine, is at 69 percent.
  • Swiss Army Man (2016) , starring Paul Dano as a shipwrecked man and Daniel Radcliffe as the gassy all-purpose corpse who might be his ticket back to civilization, is at 65 percent.

Tag Cloud

Elton John Hallmark Baby Yoda 93rd Oscars critic resources Hallmark Christmas movies travel Sneak Peek theme song directors Esquire Interview WarnerMedia anime Disney Plus razzies Set visit OWN ghosts Pacific Islander quibi spanish IFC ABC Family scary screenings Amazon Prime Video toy story First Look Infographic dark 2021 USA anthology series CMT medical drama dogs Freeform doctor who CNN talk show 2016 HBO Emmys new york cooking franchise streaming Marvel TCA 2017 Paramount Network singing competition halloween tv kaiju cults comedies psychological thriller Epix Animation spider-man Biopics superman movies saw OneApp basketball TIFF feel good The Walt Disney Company Podcast E! strong female leads royal family a nightmare on elm street women rt archives LGBTQ Star Wars Tokyo Olympics A24 target National Geographic reviews revenge Country docudrama space Amazon Studios screen actors guild laika comic christmas movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt MCU venice Shondaland Broadway classics asian-american jurassic park cats kong AMC supernatural period drama RT21 godzilla El Rey hist Horror technology Tubi universal monsters Masterpiece golden globes LGBT Walt Disney Pictures miniseries marvel comics black versus Apple TLC IFC Films serial killer ABC harry potter Endgame critics name the review 2020 Amazon Prime Superheroes ITV Ovation adaptation debate festival Marathons Cannes Red Carpet trailers Mary Poppins Returns Reality BBC psycho criterion football stoner Cosplay Film disaster vampires Comedy Central Comic Book cinemax deadpool dexter high school Comic-Con@Home 2021 fresh Creative Arts Emmys Disney streaming service blockbusters Western animated witnail thriller Ellie Kemper zombies green book book adaptation Valentine's Day DC Comics social media Universal Pictures canceled TV shows APB Polls and Games documentaries Lifetime Christmas movies cancelled Quiz Awards golden globe awards 71st Emmy Awards Warner Bros. spy thriller USA Network award winner VH1 PBS zero dark thirty Food Network TV movies Binge Guide Classic Film monster movies SDCC GLAAD Star Trek biography chucky concert Rom-Com slashers video Trivia mcc science fiction wonder woman king arthur Best and Worst Alien Spike American Society of Cinematographers toronto FXX SXSW dceu BET Awards breaking bad Netflix Christmas movies YouTube crime drama Stephen King worst movies Television Academy facebook art house superhero japanese PlayStation Paramount ViacomCBS italian Sundance TV Song of Ice and Fire pirates of the caribbean child's play mutant romantic comedy Pet Sematary Extras emmy awards Captain marvel 24 frames Sundance Now The CW TV renewals historical drama war ABC Signature NBC french DGA political drama binge popular The Arrangement james bond boxing Legendary aapi Sci-Fi SundanceTV Drama Anna Paquin Holiday children's TV Peacock game of thrones 2018 BAFTA stop motion Dark Horse Comics Emmy Nominations scorecard twilight Marvel Studios Exclusive Video Countdown Rocketman First Reviews Hear Us Out video on demand 007 Logo Martial Arts YA discovery slasher Box Office olympics gangster dramedy hispanic WGN See It Skip It police drama HBO Go crime thriller Rock parents aliens robots IMDb TV GoT E3 Wes Anderson Musical 2019 VOD Election Pop spain DC Universe Hulu suspense die hard spider-verse sopranos action-comedy composers unscripted obituary what to watch BBC America hidden camera young adult TV Land Tarantino all-time The Walking Dead Bravo based on movie President comics tv talk marvel cinematic universe Showtime mission: impossible VICE Amazon Oscars Chernobyl Reality Competition Discovery Channel Fox News Pirates scene in color HBO Max finale blockbuster independent The Witch free movies documentary Cartoon Network posters Marvel Television worst cancelled television 4/20 TCA Film Festival Trophy Talk canceled renewed TV shows Syfy AMC Plus Disney satire Opinion sequels scary movies blaxploitation mockumentary The Purge Turner Video Games Lifetime TruTV GIFs new star wars movies reboot Ghostbusters book TCA Awards 2015 Heroines cancelled TV series true crime Music Avengers Black History Month History Winter TV telelvision 2017 dreamworks nfl elevated horror Tumblr TBS genre Black Mirror game show DC streaming service werewolf Apple TV+ casting nature 45 73rd Emmy Awards 21st Century Fox live action cartoon Musicals MTV Tomatazos Family Brie Larson Photos Fall TV sitcom dragons Travel Channel Instagram Live justice league Crunchyroll know your critic diversity 72 Emmy Awards cancelled TV shows joker remakes 1990s adenture Adult Swim international sequel nbcuniversal Action richard e. Grant Netflix sag awards 90s TCM stand-up comedy romance Mindy Kaling Watching Series New York Comic Con 20th Century Fox dc sports Mudbound TNT San Diego Comic-Con adventure Sundance rotten Britbox 99% Awards Tour Summer FX Rocky TV YouTube Red lord of the rings BBC One ESPN Pop TV cops batman cars spanish language comic book movie TV One NYCC Premiere Dates Fantasy indie Columbia Pictures ratings Fox Searchlight Kids & Family Television Critics Association Super Bowl politics Mary Tyler Moore PaleyFest BET FX on Hulu Crackle X-Men 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Spectrum Originals Holidays Mary poppins NBA Neflix black comedy crossover teaser Sony Pictures jamie lee curtis live event Women's History Month mob DirecTV Nickelodeon Winners south america Arrowverse Trailer YouTube Premium television Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Writers Guild of America prank Pride Month foreign Pixar hispanic heritage month crime CBS MSNBC Grammys Academy Awards archives Universal rom-coms indiana jones movie Disney Channel A&E comiccon Shudder rt labs critics edition spinoff FOX Year in Review Thanksgiving biopic hollywood Disney+ Disney Plus Paramount Plus Certified Fresh Christmas The Academy rotten movies we love ID Starz Schedule news CW Seed new zealand Comics on TV comic books rt labs latino TCA Winter 2020 fast and furious Lucasfilm heist movie Turner Classic Movies festivals Vudu transformers Apple TV Plus streaming movies Nominations Toys Funimation RT History australia docuseries Superheroe kids Spring TV king kong comic book movies Image Comics Mystery Teen vs. Acorn TV Character Guide Nat Geo japan Comedy halloween boxoffice legend Calendar zombie Lionsgate films CBS All Access best natural history