Hear Us Out

Hear Us Out: You've Totally Underrated AVP: Alien vs. Predator

This interplanetary crossover has flaws, sure, but it also has an ass-kicking hero, plenty of gore, and deepens both franchises' lores.

by | September 10, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by © 20th Century Fox)

Just like you at home, we at Rotten Tomatoes – the writers and staffers who bring you the site’s original content – don’t always agree with the Tomatometer verdict. (Just check out our list of Rotten movies we love.) Enter AVP: Alien vs. Predator: The 2004 sci-fi thriller so nice they named it twice, sitting pretty with a 20% Tomatometer score and 39% Audience Score. Critics felt it was toothless and scare-free, while YOU felt it bungled the Alien franchise’s far-future continuity. And pretty much everyone thought the AVP-colon business in the title was just stupid. But, looking back – more fondly than we expected – as we near the release of Shane Black’s The Predator, we’ve come to a strange realization: AVP is actually pretty good.

No, really. AVP: Alien vs. Predator ­– our levels of respect are such that we will use the full name! – is almost criminally underrated. It has a great cast, a fantastic set-up, and more than enough action and fan-service for a nerdgasmic experience, if you’re a fan of either franchise. And it is, without a doubt, better than some of its contemporaries. Don’t believe us? Read on for some reasons why you should revisit it sometime.


AVP: Alien vs. Predator borrowed heavily from the Dark Horse-published comic of the same name, which featured Machiko Noguchi, human protagonist-turned-Predator protégé. She would go on to be a series staple and fan-favorite character.

Sanaa Lathan is fantastic in the film as Alexa “Lex” Woods, a mountaineer and environmental technician who is, in many ways, modeled after Noguchi. Woods is a pragmatic and resourceful guide for the Weyland Industries expedition to a Predator temple. She is the definition of “cooler heads prevailing” when among her scientist cohorts, but she has no trouble mixing it up with the Aliens and Predators – so much so that the Predator Scar takes her as an apprentice and eventually uses Alien blood to brand her with a warrior’s mark, rendering her an honorary Predator. So cool.

Lathan brings great physicality to the role, using a spear and shield crafted from an Alien’s carapace to fight an Alien Queen. More, Lathan’s screen time with Scar displays her impressive range as an actor (yes, we did just say that in a piece about Alien vs. Predator) – her initial horror develops into curiosity, admiration, empathy, compassion, and remorse in a way that others might render mawkish. She’s a fantastic character, and – attention, Shane Black, if you’re gearing up for a sequel – we’d love to see her return to the series.


In AVP, we see Lance Henriksen as Charles Bishop Weyland, CEO of the company, and are given a sense of what drives the company’s achievements in exploration, satellite communication, and robotics: legacy. Weyland is obsessed with creating something of lasting value and leaving his mark on society, a trait that would continue to define the company after its merger with the Yutani Corporation. What’s more, even though Ridley Scott’s Prometheus and Alien: Covenant strip the company’s backstory from the canon, they still maintain the motivation of legacy and creation.

AVP adds a ton to the canon. The discoveries made in AVP: Alien vs. Predator explain the Weyland-Yutani Corporation’s knowledge of and interest in the Alien race. Henriksen’s casting as Weyland implies that the company used human proxies for their androids, which suggests that the second Bishop in Alien 3 is also an android and possibly an unwitting one. Where so many prequels sully the continuities with rehashed plots or silly contrivances, AVP deepens the existing lore – especially that of Weyland Industries – without detracting from previous films.


By 2004, Aliens and Predators were a pop-cultural institution, with endless comics, video games, and action figures. In effect, they’d become as recognizable as chattier horror fixtures like Freddy Krueger (the Predators even have some choice one-liners in their films). A comic book and video game enthusiast himself, director Paul W.S. Anderson played into the idea of character in AVP by enriching the warring races’ personalities.

The Predators are presented as an imperialistic race of hunters on a sacred rite of passage – and more importantly, they’re rookies: They’re reckless, arrogant, and underestimate their opponents, leading to their demise. Each Predator is given just enough personality to be distinctive: Celtic, their wizened leader; Chopper, who specializes in wrist blades; Scar, who wields a Frisbee-sized Shuriken and befriends Woods; and Elder, who demonstrates an uncharacteristic understanding and empathy for its race.

The Aliens get a special character in the form of Grid, an Alien who barely survived a Predator’s Netgun. Named for the markings left by the net, Grid becomes the Predators’ nemesis, leading a pack of Aliens on the hunt for their hunters like the head of a brutal posse. Even the Alien Queen, previously depicted as a vengeful mother in Aliens and a tender one in Alien Resurrection, is given new dimensions, coming across as starvation-maddened and berserk, bent purely on feeding.


AVP knew what it had to deliver for fans: shared continuity and a victory lap for the series, just as Freddy vs. Jason had been tasked to do earlier, and the Avengers would have to do later. The whole point of AVP is to pay off the set-ups in previous films (the Alien trophy in Predator 2 and implications of Weyland-Yutani in the Alien series), and to blend the Alien franchise’s horror with the Predator franchise’s action. It does those things and more by touching upon every previously established idea in both franchises and pushing them further. And holy nerdgasm, those fight scenes – you get your money’s worth.

More importantly, AVP knows what its audience needs. It’s a message flick – really. Its plot is about the nature of hubris: The human characters explore the Antarctic for forbidden knowledge and are slaughtered for it; the Predators are arrogant enough to believe they can control the Aliens, and things go just as well for them. Anderson presents all of these Aesopian morals without compromising his comic book-styled, action-horror adventure.

Which makes it better than Prometheus and Alien: Covenant.


We know the Tomatometer would say different (AVP is Rotten, the other guys are Fresh), but hear us out.

All three films are riffs on H.P. Lovecraft’s At the Mountains of Madness, a story where humans travel to a newly discovered cradle of civilization intending to learn the secrets of the gods. There, they find that the gods fashioned and exploited a slave race, which later rose up to slay them. Humanity now must flee from the emancipated slave race. The films are, in terms of story structure, very similar.

The difference is in the execution. AVP knows that it’s a pulpy camp-fest and leans into it, reimagining Madness with fun and consistent characters, consistent tone, and clear cause-and-effect. Prometheus and Alien: Covenant want to be prestige genre pieces but are stuffed with characters whose personalities and sense of logic fluctuate from scene to scene as wildly as the film’s tone shifts from horror to camp to philosophy class. And whereas AVP gets to the action, the other flicks’ narratives spend too much time rehashing and over-explaining series elements better left to the imagination.

In embracing the schlock and horror, and eschewing any pretentions of being high art, AVP wins the battle of Aliens vs Predator vs Promethus vs Covenant.

Agree? Disagree? In space, no one can hear you scream, but we can sure hear you sound off in the comments!

Tag Cloud

DGA MTV medical drama IFC Films Star Trek sitcom Walt Disney Pictures PaleyFest golden globes Spike spain Stephen King binge Calendar Syfy Kids & Family Thanksgiving aliens BBC America Starz talk show psychological thriller facebook Musicals green book Lucasfilm Shudder Interview Heroines police drama Family FX Rocketman composers Amazon kids teaser Song of Ice and Fire Mudbound Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Black Mirror game of thrones Awards Mindy Kaling TIFF DC Universe cults witnail GoT discovery Mary Poppins Returns Creative Arts Emmys Video Games Premiere Dates Tumblr Year in Review Adult Swim Musical The Arrangement Biopics Bravo Horror History south america anthology Peacock hist dramedy elevated horror Cartoon Network Writers Guild of America Quiz ABC Family SXSW CNN TruTV Sundance Now strong female leads Emmy Nominations robots SundanceTV YouTube Premium spanish language CBS All Access ABC cinemax supernatural richard e. Grant American Society of Cinematographers Arrowverse Mary poppins Schedule zombies psycho TCA Pet Sematary Comic Book Martial Arts crime based on movie 2018 Netflix Trophy Talk vampires science fiction romance streaming Television Academy First Look Mystery Oscars sports Dark Horse Comics Ghostbusters stand-up comedy NYCC Nat Geo RT History mutant Esquire New York Comic Con zombie NBC Tomatazos Lionsgate Super Bowl Fox News Rock Rocky CMT award winner sequel doctor who LGBTQ Sundance Comedy Central TBS MSNBC 20th Century Fox Pixar 2019 VICE children's TV Podcast Britbox Film TNT movies foreign FOX television Reality unscripted Drama TV comic APB book Comedy spy thriller Western Showtime Acorn TV finale GLAAD Valentine's Day Fantasy Extras Ovation Christmas Sci-Fi crime thriller HBO Max tv talk Infographic Certified Fresh See It Skip It natural history IFC Vudu comiccon boxoffice Trivia crime drama Cannes Toys Winners diversity Action TLC TCM TCA 2017 MCU Epix HBO crossover RT21 politics Disney streaming service technology disaster blaxploitation cats Watching Series Superheroe San Diego Comic-Con E3 A&E game show anime Star Wars spinoff Pop Teen Tarantino Awards Tour Spectrum Originals Red Carpet Freeform 71st Emmy Awards SDCC period drama Box Office Animation AMC Logo Binge Guide Universal revenge FXX Photos transformers political drama jamie lee curtis Election ITV Nominations Opinion Winter TV spider-man Disney Channel war space latino zero dark thirty CBS 2017 Crackle social media Brie Larson Marvel dceu E! miniseries OWN PBS Countdown Amazon Prime ghosts Best and Worst cops 2016 Disney Chernobyl serial killer Ellie Kemper Marathons President DC Comics cooking travel Elton John Music ESPN video theme song Paramount Network Holidays Food Network Trailer harry potter Fall TV Sneak Peek Emmys singing competition Spring TV thriller casting USA Network BET Columbia Pictures Superheroes dragons LGBT BBC VH1 Country TV Land Paramount historical drama animated GIFs Mary Tyler Moore Rom-Com Reality Competition Pirates Amazon Prime Video The Witch Women's History Month Polls and Games X-Men DirecTV true crime Warner Bros. Captain marvel Lifetime quibi hispanic adventure 2015 dc CW Seed National Geographic The CW Summer docudrama First Reviews YouTube Red 007 justice league Character Guide mockumentary DC streaming service Masterpiece toy story nature Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt what to watch USA festivals biography WarnerMedia Shondaland Nickelodeon adaptation Comics on TV 45 Grammys Film Festival Sony Pictures cars El Rey 21st Century Fox Apple Cosplay ratings Pride Month Anna Paquin YA Set visit WGN 24 frames Hulu series