Critics Consensus

Ghost in the Shell Looks Great, but Rings Hollow

Plus, The Boss Baby isn't a bundle of joy, and Harlots is Certified Fresh.

by | March 30, 2017 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have Scarlett Johansson in the future (Ghost in the Shell, co-starring Michael Pitt) and Alec Baldwin in a diaper (The Boss Baby, with voice work from Steve Buscemi). What are the critics saying?


Ghost in the Shell (2017) 44%


Scarlett Johansson has convincingly kicked butt in more than one action movie, and the enduring popularity of the Ghost in the Shell media franchise has long since ably demonstrated its story’s appeal. Put the two together, and what do you have? A gorgeous techno-thriller with committed work from its leading lady — but one that, like its protagonist, isn’t quite what it was in its original incarnation. As the Major, a machine-enhanced law enforcement officer whose mind has been transplanted from a ruined flesh-and-blood body, Johansson acquits herself admirably enough that many critics are willing to look past the accusations of whitewashing that dogged the production; more troublesome, however, is the live-action Ghost‘s inability or unwillingness to satisfyingly deal with the story’s many intriguing philosophical questions. Instead, viewers are left with some solid acting and loads of cool special effects — fine for a fun night out, but still something of a disappointment in the context of the source material.


The Boss Baby (2017) 52%


America loves to laugh at talking toddlers, and — as millions of 30 Rock fans are still happy to attest — Alec Baldwin can be a pretty funny guy. So The Boss Baby, which puts Baldwin’s voice inside its pint-sized protagonist, should be a safe bet, right? Unfortunately, as we’ve seen all too often in this space, what looks great on paper can be a painful ordeal on the screen, and critics say this movie — inspired by Marla Frazee’s board book of the same name — offers yet another example. The premise, just fine for a short story, suffers from being stretched to feature length, and screenwriter Michael McCullers fills the gap with all the scatological humor one might fear from a 3D animated movie about a baby with a briefcase. The youngsters in your life will probably want to see it — and they might very well laugh themselves silly — but the reviews point to a nominally kid-friendly film with little to offer older chaperones.


What’s New on TV

Harlots: Season 1 (2017) 95%

Harlots uses its titillating subject matter to draw the viewer into a deeper drama about the intersection of survival, business, and family.


Imaginary Mary: Season 1 (2017) 25%

Imaginary Mary‘s appealing cast is canceled out by uninspired material and a ridiculous premise whose deficiencies are compounded by an unfunny, ill-advised CGI creature.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • David Lynch: The Art Life (2017) , a documentary profile of the director and his art, is at 100 percent.
  • Karl Marx City (2017) , which finds filmmaker Petra Epperlein taking a look back at her childhood in East Germany — and her father’s suicide — is at 93 percent.
  • All This Panic (2017) , a documentary look at the lives of young women in Brooklyn, is at 91 percent.
  • The Blackcoat's Daughter (February) (2017) , in which a pair of boarding school students are stalked by an evil presence, is at 74 percent.
  • God Knows Where I Am (2017) , a documentary look at the tragic aftermath of a woman’s mental illness, is at 67 percent.
  • Carrie Pilby (2017) , starring Nathan Lane as a psychiatrist trying to nudge a young genius (Bel Powley) out of her shell, is at 64 percent.
  • Here Alone (2017) , about three people drawn together in the wake of a catastrophic epidemic, is at 63 percent.
  • The Zookeeper's Wife (2017) , starring Jessica Chastain in a fact-based drama about Nazi-occupied Poland during World War II, is at 56 percent.
  • Cezanne and I (Cézanne et Moi) (2017) , a dramatization of the real-life friendship between painter Paul Cézanne and writer Emile Zola, is at 50 percent.
  • Live Cargo (2017) , about a couple whose escape to the Bahamas is nowhere near as idyllic as they’d planned, is at 38 percent.
  • Despite The Falling Snow (2017) , about a Cold War spy who falls for her Communist quarry, is at 11 percent.

Tag Cloud

Spring TV BBC Schedule Grammys Ellie Kemper The CW Character Guide comiccon composers Ghostbusters aliens History harry potter American Society of Cinematographers Photos AMC Polls and Games Syfy cops IFC 2016 CBS Writers Guild of America Disney Channel E! Lionsgate Comedy Central DC Comics Food Network Trailer Tomatazos Action DirecTV Infographic cinemax psycho Lifetime Trivia GIFs Biopics 007 Hulu historical drama TBS crime thriller Paramount Summer OWN WGN USA Rocky thriller TNT Fox News political drama Winter TV PaleyFest Mystery TV Land 2017 discovery sitcom technology FX Dark Horse Comics GLAAD Nat Geo period drama Watching Series MSNBC Nominations Sundance Emmys HBO Reality Competition adventure boxoffice Pop biography Superheroes VICE Universal A&E Premiere Dates Marvel war Best and Worst GoT Cartoon Network Reality Nickelodeon Podcast Comic Book Esquire TruTV Box Office Amazon Tumblr Marathons travel SundanceTV ESPN Logo Thanksgiving Video Games Fantasy Certified Fresh TCA Disney NYCC 24 frames FOX Pirates APB talk show Red Carpet Awards ABC Family NBC Oscars FXX TLC cats Star Trek Freeform vampires Kids & Family Horror singing competition Set visit Rom-Com RT History Crackle Sci-Fi Netflix Interview CMT E3 Starz MTV serial killer DC Universe Election based on movie Year in Review Calendar crime Bravo Super Bowl PBS sports SDCC Comedy politics Martial Arts crime drama Showtime 2015 docudrama TCM CNN TV The Arrangement diversity President Opinion ABC Drama social media Musical dramedy 45 El Rey Musicals Toys Fall TV Mary Tyler Moore Teen BBC America Star Wars Winners LGBTQ Rock First Look transformers Valentine's Day science fiction Adult Swim Sneak Peek supernatural ITV VH1 romance CBS All Access Holidays zombie Warner Bros. cooking Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Cosplay Music Mindy Kaling TCA 2017 Extras what to watch BET police drama YA Country Masterpiece X-Men TIFF Animation Countdown