Critics Consensus

Ford v Ferrari Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Charlie's Angels is fun but a little flat, The Good Liar is a bit too predictable, and Atlantics, Waves, and The Report are also all Certified Fresh.

by | November 14, 2019 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a racing rivalry (Ford v Ferrari, starring Matt Damon and Christian Bale), angelic agents (Charlie’s Angels, starring Kristen Stewart and Naomi Scott), and conniving conman (The Good Liar, starring Helen Mirren and Ian McKellen). What are the critics saying?


Ford v Ferrari (2019) 92%

Director James Mangold is no stranger to the Oscars, his most recent film Logan having earned him a Best Adapted Screenplay nomination, and he looks poised to make some noise again at the next ceremony with his latest film, Ford v Ferrari. The last time Mangold took on a story based on true events — the 2005 Johnny Cash biopic Walk the Line, specifically — the end result was five Academy Award nominations, and based on the reception to Ford v Ferrari so far, it’s not out of the question to assume more nominations are in the cards. Matt Damon and Christian Bale star as legendary car designer Carroll Shelby and British racecar driver and engineer Ken Miles, respectively, who were hired by the Ford Motor Company after its president, Henry Ford II, felt slighted by Ferrari owner Enzo Ferrari pulling out of a business deal between the two companies. Shelby and Miles’ mission? To develop and race a car that would defeat Scuderia Ferrari in the 24 Hours of Le Mans race in 1966. Critics say Ford v Ferrari not only delivers on the pulse-pounding action on the race track but also serves up outstanding performances from Damon, Bale, and their supporting cast, as well as a crowd-pleasing story infused with plenty of human intrigue. Even if you aren’t an auto enthusiast, this is likely to be a satisfying drama that maybe doesn’t take many risks but hits almost all the right notes.


Charlie's Angels (2019) 52%

Elizabeth Banks did a pretty respectable job when she made her feature directorial debut with Pitch Perfect 2 in 2015, so for her sophomore effort, she decided to help revive and reinvent a classic franchise with similar female bonding themes. Charlie’s Angels began as a television series back in the mid- to late-1970s and found new life in a pair of cheeky, early 2000s action flicks starring Cameron Diaz, Lucy Liu, and Drew Barrymore — both revolved around a trio of female agents who specialized in investigation and espionage and were commanded by a mysterious man named Charlie. In this modern update, the angels (or would-be angel, in one case) are played by Kristen Stewart, Ella Balinska, and Naomi Scott, and they comprise just one team of many around the world who all take orders from various “Bosleys” — their own is played by Banks herself. When one of the trio discovers the company she works for is developing a potentially dangerous technology, she unwittingly stumbles upon a conspiracy that the Angels must work to unravel. Critics say Charlie’s Angels is an earnest effort from all involved, with a particularly sprightly performance from Kristen Stewart, but it’s also a little disappointingly rote, as far as action fare goes, and it doesn’t make the greatest case for why it was revived. That said, it’s energetic, breezy, and appropriately cheeky, even if it is formulaic, and it may be just fun enough to pass the time for most.


The Good Liar (2019) 65%

Ian McKellen and Helen Mirren are two of modern cinema’s most celebrated and revered actors, so it may surprise some to learn that, between their extensive resumes, they have yet to share the screen together. That all changes this week with The Good Liar, a twisty, dramatic thriller that critics say doesn’t quite live up to the talents of its two esteemed stars. McKellen plays a veteran conman who sets his sights on a wealthy widower (Mirren) and inserts himself into her life. As he dodges her suspicious grandson, the elder pair grow closer, but his past threatens to catch up with him and bring the whole scheme crashing down. Critics say The Good Liar, directed by Bill Condon (Beauty and the BeastMr. Holmes), just misses the mark; though both McKellen and Mirren are magnetic on screen, the story twists itself into impossible knots in its efforts to squeeze intrigue out of what amounts to a fairly basic premise, and the end result may be a little difficult for some viewers to swallow. Though it sports all the trappings of a classic mystery, it only halfway meets its ambitious goals and ends up feeling like a pulpier take on better-executed films.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Mickey and the Bear (2019) , a drama about a young woman seeking independence from her Iraq War veteran father, is at 100%.
  • Recorder: The Marion Stokes Project (2019) , a documentary about the woman who recorded her television around the clock for over 30 years, is at 100%.
  • Everybody's Everything (2019) , a documentary about the life of rapper Lil Peep, who died at 21 years old from a drug overdose, is at 100%.
  • White Snake (2019) , an animated film about a young woman with amnesia who uncovers a supernatural conspiracy as she strives to recover her memory, is at 100%.
  • Atlantics (2019) , a romantic mystery about a young Senegalese woman’s relationship to a disgruntled construction worker who may be the only survivor of a boat crash, is at Certified Fresh at 96%.
  • Scandalous: The Untold Story of the National Enquirer (2019) , a documentary about the notorious tabloid and its questionable practices over the years, is at 93%.
  • I Lost My Body (2019) , an animated French film about a disembodied hand who journeys to reunite with its body, is at 92%.
  • Waves (2019) , starring Sterling K. Brown and Kelvin Harrison Jr. in Trey Edward Shults‘ drama about a Florida family’s trials and tribulations, is Certified Fresh at 89%.
  • The Hottest August (2019) , a documentary portrait of New York City over the course of an entire month, specifically August of 2017, is at 86%.
  • The Report (2019) , starring Adam Driver in Scott Z. Burns‘ dramatization of the release of the report detailing the U.S. government’s use of torture following 9/11, is Certified Fresh at 84%.
  • The Shed (2019) , a horror film about a teenager who discovers a vampire hiding out in his abusive grandfather’s tool shed, is at 71%.
  • The Warrior Queen of Jhansi (2019) , a historical action film about a female general in 19th century India who became a feminist icon, is at 10%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Nat Geo Captain marvel Disney+ Disney Plus travel Thanksgiving ITV children's TV TBS serial killer Martial Arts cults Fall TV HBO TNT Oscars Sony Pictures discovery crossover crime thriller crime drama christmas movies Photos FX El Rey PaleyFest book MTV Lionsgate Columbia Pictures green book The Arrangement Hallmark Christmas movies zombies BBC YouTube Red quibi cancelled what to watch ratings Superheroes harry potter Endgame Bravo MSNBC miniseries screenings unscripted movies Certified Fresh cats nature FXX game of thrones 007 Apple TV+ Biopics Red Carpet Marvel Valentine's Day Ellie Kemper Family Podcast Elton John casting Dark Horse Comics First Reviews BBC America X-Men versus Comedy VICE Women's History Month Universal Crunchyroll rotten movies we love richard e. Grant cooking Pet Sematary GLAAD mockumentary aliens Tomatazos Shudder Trailer golden globes dragons A24 Nickelodeon Freeform Film Netflix period drama Summer Marathons Vudu police drama Election Lucasfilm spain Lifetime Christmas movies psychological thriller IFC cinemax NYCC festivals Polls and Games Mystery thriller Country Showtime WarnerMedia foreign Western CW Seed Premiere Dates politics Teen Netflix Christmas movies comic Pop Emmys jamie lee curtis Turner Marvel Television Emmy Nominations Hulu Turner Classic Movies social media Cannes 20th Century Fox NBC supernatural Amazon Prime TIFF spy thriller Writers Guild of America Interview vampires zero dark thirty Paramount Mindy Kaling facebook cops screen actors guild See It Skip It crime blockbuster Musicals canceled TV shows San Diego Comic-Con First Look IFC Films Opinion Toys Film Festival Rocketman 2016 Paramount Network hist talk show series television cancelled television Sci-Fi E3 award winner Logo Grammys blaxploitation Box Office Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cars Stephen King slashers Best and Worst Disney Channel WGN finale Awards Trivia Schedule 21st Century Fox robots Spectrum Originals boxoffice cartoon true crime Creative Arts Emmys Extras Rom-Com Mudbound Starz justice league SDCC breaking bad A&E Christmas Masterpiece Chernobyl 24 frames free movies Winners anthology Sundance Now composers zombie kids natural history TCA 2017 Watching Series ghosts Fox News Ghostbusters canceled dc Super Bowl teaser Walt Disney Pictures cancelled TV shows American Society of Cinematographers Comic Book Rock Sneak Peek Infographic Acorn TV DC streaming service cancelled TV series Mary Poppins Returns comiccon Heroines indie E! Superheroe YouTube FOX The CW SXSW APB Amazon Prime Video Britbox science fiction latino Calendar romance LGBTQ Amazon New York Comic Con Hallmark spanish language Food Network OWN Brie Larson The Witch Year in Review adaptation Ovation name the review President Character Guide werewolf toy story Kids & Family Comedy Central adventure Video Games TV renewals Sundance binge technology Esquire strong female leads Star Trek renewed TV shows halloween Mary poppins Quiz Shondaland DC Universe doctor who stand-up comedy Holiday Musical Syfy based on movie Pride Month witnail TCM AMC Adult Swim Star Wars CMT Television Academy USA Network space 2019 Song of Ice and Fire DC Comics TLC CNN Trophy Talk hispanic Winter TV YouTube Premium spider-man joker independent revenge spinoff Tumblr National Geographic Binge Guide Crackle Comics on TV Drama psycho Tarantino Peacock TruTV Music Countdown dramedy Mary Tyler Moore game show sitcom ESPN Spike Disney Horror historical drama war 2018 Reality Competition DGA Arrowverse Apple TV Plus DirecTV GoT transformers CBS USA Disney streaming service Reality 71st Emmy Awards diversity 2017 Animation Anna Paquin TV Land Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt docudrama animated SundanceTV Lifetime Disney Plus 2015 RT21 tv talk romantic comedy Pirates mutant Nominations comics The Purge ABC sports sag awards elevated horror TCA LGBT 2020 YA Warner Bros. Action singing competition CBS All Access anime Spring TV RT History Cartoon Network Apple Set visit PBS Rocky Epix disaster 45 HBO Max Pixar ABC Family medical drama Awards Tour TV Marvel Studios Black Mirror theme song MCU The Walking Dead biography south america political drama sequel Holidays VH1 BET History batman Cosplay Avengers Classic Film streaming video GIFs dceu Fantasy