Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Age of Adaline is Charming But Uneven

Plus, Little Boy is earnest but corny, Ex Machina is Certified Fresh, and Orphan Black is as mind-bending as ever.

by | April 23, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an immortal twentysomething (The Age of Adaline, starring Blake Lively and Michiel Huisman), a spirited child (Little Boy, starring Emily Watson and Jakob Salvati), and an intelligent robot (Ex Machina, starring Alicia Vikander and Domhnall Gleeson). What do the critics have to say?

The Age of Adaline


Depending on who you are, The Age of Adaline is the kind of movie that’s sure to elicit either tears or groans. Critics say that while this magic realist romantic fantasy boasts stellar production values and strong performances from Blake Lively and Harrison Ford, its tonal and narrative inconsistencies keep it from fully cohering. Lively stars as the title character, who, through a supernatural occurrence, has remained 29 for nearly a century. In order to keep her secret, she’s lived a mostly solitary life, but a love-struck suitor unwittingly brings Adaline’s strange state of being to light. The pundits say that if you’re willing to go with it, The Age of Adaline casts a bittersweet spell — though it may be a bit too saccharine for some tastes.

Little Boy


Little Boy is a well-meaning, warm-hearted tale about the dangers of prejudice and the power of faith. Unfortunately, critics say it’s also hopelessly corny, heavy-handed, and dramatically dull, despite the best efforts of a top-notch cast. When his father is taken as a prisoner of war while fighting in the Pacific, seven-year-old Pepper Busbee (Jakob Salvati) is beside himself with heartache. Refusing to give up hope, the oft-bullied Pepper sets out to will his father home through a combination of faith and good deeds. The pundits say Little Boy is earnest but predictable, hammering home its message without an ounce of subtlety. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Watson’s best-reviewed movies, and watch our video interview with Salvati and co-star Michael Rapaport.)

Ex Machina


A psychological thriller for an age of runaway technological advancement, critics say Ex Machina is thoughtful, chilling science fiction with a breakout performance from Alicia Vikander. Domhnall Gleeson stars as a computer wiz who’s tasked by his company’s reclusive CEO with testing the artificial intelligence of a remarkably lifelike robot (Vikander); in doing so, our hero begins to question the nature and limits of humanity. Critics say the Certified Fresh Ex Machina is visually striking, emotionally resonant, and deeply unsettling.

What’s On TV:

Season three of Orphan Black (82 percent) lures viewers into an expanded series mythology while continuing to highlight Tatiana Maslany’s multiple standout performances.

Building upon a strong season opener, “The House of Black and White” (96 percent) increases the intensity by calling upon some major characters to make some tough decisions.

The Forecast” (88 percent) points the way toward the Mad Men finale with typically sharp storytelling and a renewed focus on the show’s female characters — and concern for Don’s future.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Women's History Month Awards finale cops Amazon Prime Sundance FOX comics Marvel Television USA Network romantic comedy richard e. Grant christmas movies thriller Sundance Now TCM E! Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Marvel Emmys Box Office Martial Arts indie Trailer kids CMT war Epix batman Paramount Cartoon Network Cosplay Vudu doctor who Ovation VICE Rock Mary Tyler Moore Musicals Amazon Prime Video serial killer BBC America Spectrum Originals Lifetime Christmas movies AMC cancelled TV shows SDCC Premiere Dates Anna Paquin Disney Channel discovery GLAAD The CW spanish language DC streaming service Tomatazos social media comic PaleyFest ABC ESPN Netflix Christmas movies Pride Month Mystery 2016 dceu game of thrones animated vampires BBC Set visit composers GIFs festivals politics zombie Lucasfilm sitcom National Geographic YA Disney streaming service Dark Horse Comics Star Trek SXSW Disney+ Disney Plus period drama ITV Disney biography independent RT History Showtime Animation canceled Pixar teaser Toys TCA 2017 Cannes sequel hist anthology Best and Worst crime aliens witnail TLC OWN Reality Fox News Reality Competition Arrowverse cancelled TV series streaming spain Countdown New York Comic Con political drama Pop 2017 24 frames robots children's TV werewolf medical drama Character Guide Hallmark Christmas movies TIFF IFC movies TBS book ratings Christmas Peacock screenings VH1 TV Land revenge Holidays YouTube Bravo TNT Music Turner Turner Classic Movies ABC Family cancelled television Mary poppins cartoon Polls and Games quibi television Lifetime facebook Classic Film Paramount Network First Look Apple casting HBO singing competition harry potter The Arrangement Captain marvel Super Bowl Spring TV science fiction green book rotten movies we love Biopics Superheroe A&E Apple TV Plus 45 disaster cooking halloween History YouTube Red LGBT Certified Fresh travel RT21 technology Interview Superheroes WGN Nat Geo Adult Swim Comic Book Chernobyl justice league Year in Review American Society of Cinematographers NYCC mockumentary Shudder Fantasy The Witch cinemax Comics on TV mutant Binge Guide Infographic Thanksgiving CW Seed diversity Stephen King police drama DC Universe theme song YouTube Premium zero dark thirty foreign Netflix Elton John DirecTV Comedy Central Winners The Purge Britbox Red Carpet dc ghosts Spike DGA docudrama elevated horror San Diego Comic-Con Logo APB nature CNN Sci-Fi psycho anime Crunchyroll video stand-up comedy spider-man romance Disney Plus Mindy Kaling toy story USA LGBTQ Marathons Quiz Trivia joker Acorn TV BET Extras talk show Walt Disney Pictures Amazon Lionsgate PBS Film Grammys MCU versus Pirates Sneak Peek Hallmark Marvel Studios Apple TV+ Star Wars boxoffice Horror Drama Food Network Rocky IFC Films MSNBC WarnerMedia 2018 SundanceTV binge CBS All Access supernatural TV Calendar based on movie Starz south america Black Mirror free movies Mary Poppins Returns Musical Rocketman Schedule See It Skip It natural history Warner Bros. Freeform Pet Sematary Nickelodeon Hulu Heroines series A24 Election Awards Tour Summer golden globes HBO Max Tarantino Song of Ice and Fire sports TruTV Columbia Pictures cats Tumblr Ghostbusters Oscars 007 canceled TV shows dramedy Universal Family true crime Television Academy spy thriller X-Men President Syfy 2019 slashers Trophy Talk Winter TV tv talk E3 Masterpiece latino miniseries Kids & Family NBC psychological thriller cancelled 2015 TCA Holiday Brie Larson Podcast 21st Century Fox GoT Opinion Shondaland Watching Series crossover Action what to watch Emmy Nominations Film Festival FX zombies Creative Arts Emmys CBS hispanic El Rey The Walking Dead 71st Emmy Awards strong female leads renewed TV shows blockbuster Writers Guild of America adaptation unscripted cults Esquire First Reviews Mudbound Sony Pictures 20th Century Fox jamie lee curtis TV renewals FXX award winner transformers spinoff Comedy Ellie Kemper Rom-Com space historical drama dragons cars game show adventure Country comiccon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Western Crackle crime thriller Valentine's Day Fall TV Photos Nominations breaking bad MTV DC Comics Video Games blaxploitation Teen crime drama