Critics Consensus

Bridget Jones's Baby Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Blair Witch is less than spellbinding, Snowden is timely but muted, and American Horror Story offers an intriguing twist.

by | September 15, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have a pair of very belated, very different sequels (Bridget Jones’s Baby, starring Renée Zellweger and Colin Firth; and Blair Witch, starring James Allen McCune and Callie Hernandez), a ripped-from-the-headlines Oliver Stone drama (Snowden, starring Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Shailene Woodley), and a concert movie (Hillsong – Let Hope Rise). What are the critics saying? Let’s take a look.


Bridget Jones's Baby (2016) 77%

Bridget Jones’s Diary made rom-com magic out of Helen Fielding‘s bestselling novel in 2001, but the sequel, 2004’s Bridget Jones: The Edge of Reason, failed to produce similar results. It might have seemed safe to assume we’d seen the last of Ms. Jones on the big screen, but lo and behold, all these years later, she’s back with Bridget Jones’s Baby. Reviews describe a third installment that delivers pretty much what fans would expect; although Hugh Grant has departed the cast, Renee Zellweger remains as charming as ever as Bridget, and Colin Firth is back for another appearance as her longtime squeeze (and potential baby daddy) Mark Darcy. Critics say this is the rare threequel that, while somewhat safe and fairly predictable, remains a surprising return to form over its predecessor — and may even be the best Bridget of the bunch.


Blair Witch (2016) 35%

Speaking of sequels to long-ago movies, here’s Blair Witch, a follow-up to the 1999 found-footage horror hit that eschews the side road taken by 2000’s ill-received Book of Shadows in favor of taking audiences back where they started. Which, in a nutshell, is the problem: Instead of taking the Blair Witch mythology in any substantially new or extra-terrifying directions, director Adam Wingard (working from a script by his frequent collaborator Simon Barrett) seems mostly content to settle for a loose rehash of the original story. Although the end results are still good for some jolts, and Blair Witch does manage to add a few wrinkles to the familiar narrative, critics say you can safely wait to watch this one in the dark from the comfort of your own home.


Snowden (2016) 61%

Oliver Stone is certainly no stranger to political filmmaking; in fact, his filmography contains some of Hollywood’s more provocative — and widely acclaimed — cinematic statements on American history and current events. But looking to the headlines isn’t always enough to guarantee an Oscar contender from Stone; in recent years, fact-based efforts such as World Trade Center and W. have fallen short of the lofty standard set by achievements like Platoon and Born on the Fourth of July. Unfortunately, critics say this weekend’s Snowden follows that downward slope, giving the fascinating story of the titular whistleblower (played by Joseph Gordon-Levitt) a curiously muted dramatization that critics say is well-acted and topical, but occasionally too slackly paced. If it’s a great Snowden film you’re in the mood for, try checking out the Citizenfour documentary this weekend — but if you’re holding out for the next great Oliver Stone production, you might be a little disappointed.


Hillsong - Let Hope Rise (2016) 60%

They may not be household names yet, but the members of Australian contemporary worship band Hillsong UNITED have cracked the Billboard Top 10 with each of their last two albums — and now they’re getting their documentary due with Hillsong — Let Hope Rise, which purports to capture their “on-stage energy and off-stage hearts” while bringing new meaning to the phrase “theatrical worship experience.” Unfortunately, we can’t really speak to their success in that mission, because critics don’t seem to be rushing out to see it. As of this writing, Let Hope Rise has a pair of reviews, and they’re evenly split. Go on and Guess the Tomatometer!


What’s Hot on TV

High Maintenance: Season 1 (2016) 94%

Dreamlike, poignant, and often funny, High Maintenance successfully transitions from the web to the small screen thanks to sharp writing and an excellent cast.


American Horror Story: Roanoke (2016) 78%

Season six of American Horror Story takes a surprising turn away from prior AHS formats, revisiting the deliberate pace of earlier seasons on a spookier, smaller scale, even if the true-crime format feels overdone.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Beatles: Eight Days a Week - The Touring Years (2016) , a Ron Howard documentary offering a new look at the titular period in the Fab Four’s history, is at 97 percent.
  • Miss Stevens (2016) , about a teacher whose inner turmoil dovetails with her chaperoning duties on a weekend school trip, is at 92 percent.
  • Command and Control (2016) , a documentary that raises questions about the stewardship of America’s nuclear weapons program, is at 92 percent.
  • Operation Avalanche (2016) , a Cold War thriller about a pair of CIA agents trying to root out a mole in NASA’s space program, is at 74 percent.
  • Tanna (2016) , the reality-inspired story of young South Pacific lovers caught in the middle of a tribal war, is at 73 percent.
  • Mr. Church (2016) , starring Eddie Murphy in a rare dramatic role as a chef who proves a fateful addition to a household in their time of need, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

police drama Star Trek TIFF justice league American Society of Cinematographers Holidays GoT Awards TruTV Acorn TV HBO Rock Thanksgiving talk show IFC Interview ESPN See It Skip It singing competition travel boxoffice Trivia SundanceTV Adult Swim Hulu MTV The Arrangement TCA 2017 aliens Video Games TBS Mindy Kaling Action Dark Horse Comics Grammys Comedy zombie Set visit Lionsgate Cosplay Countdown 2016 24 frames TCM Best and Worst DC Universe Comedy Central Trailer thriller 007 Country golden globes Pixar Mary Tyler Moore romance war SDCC VICE ABC Family Tumblr Reality Competition ITV vampires medical drama BET Spike Election Sneak Peek AMC 2015 VH1 Showtime Watching Series CBS All Access Christmas Paramount Network Winners Reality sitcom OWN Biopics MSNBC Esquire social media E3 historical drama Oscars based on movie Nominations TV Emmys Marvel Universal Rom-Com psycho dc dceu CMT Britbox Sundance Now Star Wars FOX harry potter period drama 2017 cooking First Look Freeform Summer TCA docudrama spy thriller Tomatazos GIFs crime drama Musicals BBC America Teen Box Office Starz Character Guide A&E Martial Arts TNT Kids & Family Red Carpet Opinion crime thriller Amazon DC Comics Polls and Games serial killer X-Men 21st Century Fox El Rey DirecTV E! Year in Review Calendar PBS LGBTQ Masterpiece supernatural USA Network political drama History diversity Creative Arts Emmys Infographic CNN Musical Netflix Fantasy Logo 45 ratings ABC cats Podcast Super Bowl Lifetime science fiction Certified Fresh comiccon sports what to watch The CW cinemax dramedy Horror Writers Guild of America Disney Channel Warner Bros. Valentine's Day Sundance transformers Music Premiere Dates Cartoon Network Photos TV Land politics Crackle Extras Drama Fox News Disney Toys FXX Rocky Pop Pirates crime Nat Geo Ghostbusters Winter TV APB FX Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Syfy Sci-Fi Western CBS Paramount NBC Comic Book WGN adventure cops NYCC Nickelodeon Schedule Marathons BBC USA RT History binge Animation TLC biography Spring TV Mystery PaleyFest Bravo Ellie Kemper composers discovery Superheroes President GLAAD Fall TV technology Food Network YA