Critics Consensus

Aquaman Is See-Worthy

Plus, Mary Poppins Returns, Bumblebee, The Favourite, and Vanity Fair are Certified Fresh, but Second Act and Welcome to Marwen disappoint.

by | December 20, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got an origin story (Aquaman, starring Jason Momoa and Amber Heard), a magical visitor (Mary Poppins Returns, starring Emily Blunt and Lin-Manuel Miranda), a bug’s life (Bumblebee, starring Hailee Steinfeld and John Cena), an ad maven (Second Act, starring Jennifer Lopez and Leah Remini), a fantasy artist (Welcome to Marwen, starring Steve Carell and Leslie Mann), a royal rivalry (The Favourite, starring Emma Stone and Rachel Weisz), and another royal rivalry (Mary Queen of Scots, starring Saoirse Ronan and Margot Robbie). What are the critics saying?


Aquaman (2018) 65%

Aquaman may not be the coolest or most popular DC Comics character to find his way to the big screen, but if Jason Momoa has any say in the matter, the chracter’s reputation is about to change. In his first solo outing, the half human, half Atlantean prince must contend with not only a threat of war from his home kingdom but also an adversary with a personal vendetta. It’s a swirl of special effects and blockbuster action that critics say is appropriately super-sized and a welcome continuation of the fun, lighter tone of Wonder Woman, and it’s aided by a stellar cast that includes Amber Heard, Nicole Kidman, Willem Dafoe, and Patrick Wilson. That said, Aquaman‘s over-the-top antics may not be for everyone, and those in search of a decidedly less CGI-driven movie will almost certainly want to look elsewhere.


Mary Poppins Returns (2018) 79%

How do you follow up a celebrated classic movie musical featuring one of Hollywood’s favorite stars with over half a century’s worth of adoration lavished up on it? It certainly doesn’t hurt if you cast someone of, say, Emily Blunt’s caliber in the central role and recruit multiple Tony Award-winner Lin-Manuel Miranda to bring life to some of the big song-and-dance numbers. In Mary Poppins Returns, Blunt plays the magical nanny, who pays a visit to now grown-up Banks children Michael (Ben Whishaw) and Jane (Emily Mortimer) in order to impart a few more life lessons to Michael’s own three children. While it’s near impossible not to invite comparisons to the 1964 Julie Andrews original, critics say Emily Blunt is charming in the role, and Mary Poppins Returns succeeds in channeling its predecessor’s familiar magic to deliver a satisfying, whimsical adventure for the whole family.


Bumblebee (2018) 92%

The films of the Transformers franchise have never been critical darlings (the first is the highest-rated at 57%), but they’ve consistently made boatloads of money, so it wasn’t altogether surprising that, after five installments, Paramount decided it was time for a spinoff. The result is this week’s Bumblebee, a prequel story set in 1987 that recounts the fan-favorite sidekick’s first days on Earth as an Autobot scout tasked with setting up a base of operations. His efforts are thwarted by a pair of Decepticons, and suffering from amnesia, he befriends a teenager (Hailee Steinfeld) who helps him get his groove back. Directed by Travis Knight (Kubo and the Two Strings), Bumblebee has drawn the best reviews of the franchise from critics who say its focus on a smaller-scale story, its revamped retro character designs, and its emphasis on genuine emotion make it a series standout, and it’s already Certified Fresh.


Second Act (2018) 45%

If there’s any time of the year best-suited for wish fulfillment, it’s the holiday season, and if there’s any actress best-suited to play a working woman who overcomes unlikely odds on the way to success, it might be Jennifer Lopez. In Second Act, Lopez plays struggling retail manager Maya, who is mistakenly hired as a high-level marketing consultant and uses the opportunity to turn her life around. Unfortunately, while critics say Lopez is clearly committed to her role and the film aims for the heart with its feelgood message, it’s also suffers from unusual tonal shifts, an unfocused narrative, and shopworn platitudes. That said, it works as a bit of counterprogramming against the big-budget fare opening this week and might serve as a pleasant enough diversion for anyone who knows what they’re getting into.


Welcome to Marwen (2018) 34%

In 2000, a man named Mark Hogancamp was severely beaten outside of a bar and suffered a nine-day coma that left him with partial brain damage. Unable to recall much of his life before the incident, he found comfort in crafting a miniature World War II-era town in his back yard as a form of therapy. Hogancamp’s story came to public attention with the help of a photographer who discovered his work and the acclaimed 2010 documentary Marwencol, but this week, it gets the biopic treatment courtesy of director Robert Zemeckis and star Steve Carell, who plays Hogancamp himself. Mixing live-action with fantastical recreations of Hogancamp’s unique art, Welcome to Marwen follows the tragic events that resulted in Hogancamp’s condition and explores his relationships to the powerful women he depicts in his work. Unfortunately, critics say the film largely fails to comprehend why Hogancamp’s journey is so remarkable, choosing instead to lather on phony sentimentality and focus more on showcasing its spectacular effects than the human story at its core.


The Favourite (2018) 93%

In the first of two films based on true stories about regal squabbling that are expanding into wide release this week, we have Yorgos LanthimosThe Favourite. The film stars Olivia Colman as 18th century British monarch Queen Anne, Rachel Weisz as the Queen’s advisor and secret lover Sarah Churchill, and Emma Stone as Abigail Hill, the younger cousin of Sarah who schemes to repair her tarnished reputation by replacing Sarah as the Queen’s “favourite.” Critics say the performances from all three stars, as well as the razor-sharp writing from Deborah Davis and Tony McNamara, are stellar, and Lanthimos’ wry sense of humor fits perfectly into the perdiod setting and darkly comic history being depicted. It’s already won a number of awards heading into Oscar season, so don’t be surprised to see it when the nominations are announced.


Mary Queen of Scots (2018) 63%

Two weeks ago, when there were no new films opening in wide release, we chose to lead with a period drama that was only hitting 4 theaters. So of course it had choose the week when we had 6 other wide releases to expand. For those of you who missed it last time, Academy Award nominees Saoirse Ronan and Margot Robbie co-star as Mary Stuart and Queen Elizabeth I, respectively, in Mary Queen of Scots, which focuses on the former’s return to the Scottish throne and her challenge to the latter’s claim over Scotland. Critical reaction to the film has waned quite a bit since its initial release, but most still agree that its two celebrated young stars are consistently compelling to watch, even if it all doesn’t quite add up to the sum of its impressive parts. If you read about Mary Queen of Scots here two weeks ago and lamented the fact that it wasn’t playing near you, go and check again, and you may find yourself spending an evening with Ronan and Robbie.


What’s New on TV

Vanity Fair: Miniseries (2018) 89%

Olivia Cooke‘s brilliant portrayal of the feisty and scheming Becky Sharp in Vanity Fair makes this adaptation of Thackeray’s classic novel more relatable for a 21st century audience.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Cold War (Zimna wojna) (2018)Pawel Pawlikowski‘s romantic drama about a singer and a jazz musician living in 1950s Poland who fall in love and find their relationship tested by Cold War politics, is Certified Fresh at 93%.

Tag Cloud

Television Academy police drama New York Comic Con spanish language ABC Family Song of Ice and Fire Dark Horse Comics Family discovery Mary poppins The Witch serial killer hist VICE spy thriller Red Carpet YA Countdown Crackle docudrama Awards Tour PBS Star Wars Superheroe aliens Podcast OWN cops revenge Box Office jamie lee curtis Showtime Cartoon Network Women's History Month Universal Syfy History LGBT cats finale crossover transformers Binge Guide TLC GoT Teen science fiction ratings Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sony Pictures WarnerMedia elevated horror TBS Holidays Photos Calendar Star Trek talk show spinoff Nominations Arrowverse binge festivals Year in Review First Look President Musical technology NYCC Pirates animated Spring TV Amazon Prime 007 Western Character Guide Hulu spain tv talk Cannes 2017 Amazon Prime Video space NBC Emmys X-Men Spectrum Originals SundanceTV TCA 2017 DC streaming service Cosplay Mindy Kaling Film Festival 20th Century Fox Opinion dc Vudu Lifetime FXX anime Disney streaming service Stephen King streaming Kids & Family romance FX nature movies American Society of Cinematographers Walt Disney Pictures biography travel psycho E! miniseries Heroines Chernobyl CBS Video Games Rock Warner Bros. CNN blaxploitation GIFs adventure crime thriller USA Network comiccon robots politics SDCC justice league vampires disaster Adult Swim Starz crime theme song Comics on TV hispanic The CW Trophy Talk Toys Super Bowl zero dark thirty 2019 Horror 71st Emmy Awards Comic Book anthology Marvel Fall TV dceu Lucasfilm Paramount Network Epix medical drama Emmy Nominations See It Skip It Quiz composers Fantasy DirecTV dragons Freeform Marathons 45 Best and Worst cars RT21 Food Network AMC RT History VH1 Christmas DC Comics USA PaleyFest based on movie HBO Max Oscars facebook Action Musicals YouTube Red quibi DGA YouTube Premium stand-up comedy Disney Music zombies singing competition Rom-Com Set visit ITV Nickelodeon Reality E3 cults Thanksgiving Columbia Pictures Comedy dramedy Mudbound Tomatazos Infographic war south america casting historical drama children's TV WGN Polls and Games Sundance comic sitcom harry potter TNT Logo thriller Biopics Brie Larson TIFF Country MSNBC Captain marvel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt psychological thriller Acorn TV Watching Series true crime FOX foreign boxoffice Fox News Sneak Peek Rocky Paramount ghosts Sci-Fi IFC Winners DC Universe Nat Geo Shudder sequel SXSW Anna Paquin mockumentary Pixar strong female leads toy story Rocketman what to watch National Geographic political drama CBS All Access 2016 Bravo diversity ABC green book cinemax Winter TV award winner Awards Shondaland CW Seed Esquire mutant Peacock 2018 Ovation Comedy Central TruTV Mystery richard e. Grant LGBTQ Premiere Dates unscripted Trailer Film 24 frames social media Pet Sematary Tumblr Mary Poppins Returns Summer game of thrones adaptation San Diego Comic-Con teaser Schedule MCU Disney Channel latino witnail 21st Century Fox Netflix GLAAD series First Reviews Superheroes Trivia Writers Guild of America Animation Interview CMT 2015 Pride Month Apple TCA BBC America Ghostbusters HBO Drama El Rey Pop Spike Valentine's Day supernatural Masterpiece sports golden globes Election Elton John game show Black Mirror ESPN Extras APB television Lionsgate natural history Grammys Creative Arts Emmys The Arrangement period drama Amazon MTV Mary Tyler Moore kids crime drama TV spider-man Ellie Kemper Martial Arts Tarantino cooking Reality Competition video book IFC Films BBC BET zombie A&E TV Land Britbox Sundance Now TCM Certified Fresh doctor who