Critics Consensus

Alita: Battle Angel Is Style over Substance... but the Style Is Killer

Plus, Isn't It Romantic is moderately clever, Happy Death Day 2U is fairly fun, and Doom Patrol and Umbrella Academy keep superheroes interesting.

by | February 14, 2019 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got an amnesiac android (Alita: Battle Angel, starring Rosa Salazar and Christoph Waltz), a meta rom-com (Isn’t It Romantic, starring Rebel Wilson and Liam Hemsworth), and a sequel we’ve seen before… or have we (Happy Death Day 2U, starring Jessica Rothe and Israel Broussard)? What are the critics saying?


Alita: Battle Angel (2019) 60%

The Japanese cyberpunk manga Battle Angel Alita began publication back in 1990, and when James Cameron got wind of it (via Guillermo del Toro, no less), he became instantly fascinated by it and began development on it as a passion project. Ultimately, after years of delays, Cameron found himself occupied by Avatar and its sequels, so he handed the reins over to Robert Rodriguez. The film centers on a scientist (Christoph Waltz) who discovers a deactivated cyborg (played in motion-capture by Rosa Salazar) in a junkyard and gives her a new body, only to realize her previous function was much more lethal. Alita: Battle Angel has impressed critics with its groundbreaking, immersive special effects — par for the course with any film produced by James Cameron — but it takes some of its narrative cues from better films that have come before. It’s an eye-popping theater experience, to be sure, and if that’s what you’re looking for, Alita delivers enough entertainment value to keep you in your seat. Just don’t expect to be blown away — or even particularly engaged — by its story.


Isn't It Romantic (2019) 69%

The danger in making a film that aims to be a genre takedown is that it can easily fall prey to the same cliches it’s attempting to ridicule, resulting in a final product that feels disingenuous and sometimes phony. In other words, it’s an incredibly risky proposition, and according to the reviews, this week’s Isn’t It Romantic just manages to pull it off, mostly thanks to its star, Rebel Wilson. The story follows a cynical architect who wakes up from a mugging encounter to discover that she has become the star of her own romantic comedy. Critics say the meta narrative, while not entirely fresh, still offers a few surprises and clever gags, and Wilson lights up the screen as the unwilling protagonist of her own love story. It doesn’t have much of a story outside of its initial high-concept premise, and it’s perhaps not as smart as it thinks it is, but you could definitely do worse for a Valentine’s date movie.


Happy Death Day 2U (2019) 69%

In 2017, Universal and Blumhouse mixed the trappings of a classic slasher film with the déjà vu antics of Groundhog Day and achieved surprisingly effective results, so this week we get a return trip through the time loop with a slightly different twist. Jessica Rothe reprises her role as college student Tree Gelbman once again finds herself reliving the same day over and over again. Only thing is, this time around, the person responsible for her death in the first film is also murdered here, which means there’s a new killer on the loose. Critics say Happy Death Day 2U isn’t quite as much fun as the original — as the Arizona Republic’s Bill Goodykoontz writes, “a movie can only be a pleasant surprise once” — and it gets a little bogged down in trying to explain why what’s happening is happening, but it still packs some bloody thrills and hearty chuckles for the horror-comedy aficionados among us.


What’s New on TV

Doom Patrol: Season 1 (2019) 95%

DC Universe finds breakout material in this iteration of Doom Patrol thanks to a fully committed cast and the writing’s faith in weirdness.


The Umbrella Academy: Season 1 (2019) 77%

The Umbrella Academy unfurls an imaginative yarn with furtive emotion and an exceptionally compelling ensemble, but the series’ dour sensibility often clashes with its splashy genre trappings.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

space Quiz SDCC comiccon Brie Larson Ellie Kemper Rocky Interview disaster blaxploitation Cannes Vudu Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt GIFs Apple Superheroes Fox News Sony Pictures what to watch 2015 Black Mirror Pet Sematary Western VICE Mary Tyler Moore Marathons Calendar aliens dramedy Columbia Pictures nature YouTube Premium Awards political drama mockumentary Nickelodeon Schedule war E! sports streaming History cinemax mutant MTV Music BBC America TNT Winners The CW Food Network cats composers 45 Rock singing competition Mary Poppins Returns IFC comic Biopics period drama PaleyFest 2016 Super Bowl HBO DGA discovery Rom-Com Thanksgiving theme song RT21 green book supernatural Toys Character Guide Superheroe Tumblr Emmys Spike biography Bravo television Creative Arts Emmys teaser FOX DC Comics Mindy Kaling IFC Films TIFF vampires Marvel Acorn TV Infographic CBS Rocketman Ghostbusters Awards Tour Amazon adventure harry potter golden globes USA travel cops Heroines Netflix El Rey Cosplay The Witch Oscars A&E festivals transformers Freeform Drama unscripted Britbox LGBTQ miniseries crime drama based on movie facebook ratings Logo Nominations OWN First Look Comics on TV Ovation Teen ABC Family Countdown Fall TV Animation romance Martial Arts TruTV TBS docudrama adaptation Paramount Network technology CBS All Access VH1 Best and Worst Reality 2017 Extras Elton John doctor who Kids & Family Sundance Star Trek MCU DC streaming service historical drama Photos Pirates finale Walt Disney Pictures spider-man Mystery serial killer TLC Shondaland X-Men FX NYCC thriller dc The Arrangement social media Certified Fresh DirecTV Lifetime ESPN Grammys Disney Channel Paramount Women's History Month 2018 20th Century Fox SundanceTV spy thriller Election zero dark thirty Premiere Dates Set visit Comedy President Disney sequel Box Office Anna Paquin award winner Trivia Film Festival Esquire true crime DC Universe zombies Polls and Games Mary poppins richard e. Grant YouTube Red APB cults PBS See It Skip It dceu strong female leads police drama anthology Syfy psychological thriller medical drama WGN FXX Starz boxoffice science fiction NBC Horror Warner Bros. 007 TV Land Adult Swim 21st Century Fox CW Seed GLAAD TCA crime Captain marvel Summer TCA 2017 justice league CNN Musical Lionsgate TCM New York Comic Con Song of Ice and Fire cooking CMT talk show Red Carpet Dark Horse Comics Pixar Trailer crossover YA Nat Geo American Society of Cinematographers Trophy Talk Podcast Masterpiece elevated horror Reality Competition binge Showtime Spring TV witnail Star Wars Comic Book crime thriller Amazon Prime sitcom hist Year in Review Writers Guild of America Comedy Central Hulu Winter TV USA Network psycho Tarantino AMC Tomatazos MSNBC politics Watching Series National Geographic Video Games casting Spectrum Originals diversity Fantasy Sneak Peek natural history dragons Mudbound GoT Crackle anime Opinion Stephen King E3 Universal 2019 BBC SXSW jamie lee curtis Action Chilling Adventures of Sabrina robots 24 frames Christmas Epix Sundance Now Holidays TV Country zombie Valentine's Day Musicals Lucasfilm ABC RT History San Diego Comic-Con Shudder Pop Cartoon Network ITV BET Sci-Fi