Critics Consensus

Alita: Battle Angel Is Style over Substance... but the Style Is Killer

Plus, Isn't It Romantic is moderately clever, Happy Death Day 2U is fairly fun, and Doom Patrol and Umbrella Academy keep superheroes interesting.

by | February 14, 2019 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got an amnesiac android (Alita: Battle Angel, starring Rosa Salazar and Christoph Waltz), a meta rom-com (Isn’t It Romantic, starring Rebel Wilson and Liam Hemsworth), and a sequel we’ve seen before… or have we (Happy Death Day 2U, starring Jessica Rothe and Israel Broussard)? What are the critics saying?


Alita: Battle Angel (2019) 61%

The Japanese cyberpunk manga Battle Angel Alita began publication back in 1990, and when James Cameron got wind of it (via Guillermo del Toro, no less), he became instantly fascinated by it and began development on it as a passion project. Ultimately, after years of delays, Cameron found himself occupied by Avatar and its sequels, so he handed the reins over to Robert Rodriguez. The film centers on a scientist (Christoph Waltz) who discovers a deactivated cyborg (played in motion-capture by Rosa Salazar) in a junkyard and gives her a new body, only to realize her previous function was much more lethal. Alita: Battle Angel has impressed critics with its groundbreaking, immersive special effects — par for the course with any film produced by James Cameron — but it takes some of its narrative cues from better films that have come before. It’s an eye-popping theater experience, to be sure, and if that’s what you’re looking for, Alita delivers enough entertainment value to keep you in your seat. Just don’t expect to be blown away — or even particularly engaged — by its story.


Isn't It Romantic (2019) 70%

The danger in making a film that aims to be a genre takedown is that it can easily fall prey to the same cliches it’s attempting to ridicule, resulting in a final product that feels disingenuous and sometimes phony. In other words, it’s an incredibly risky proposition, and according to the reviews, this week’s Isn’t It Romantic just manages to pull it off, mostly thanks to its star, Rebel Wilson. The story follows a cynical architect who wakes up from a mugging encounter to discover that she has become the star of her own romantic comedy. Critics say the meta narrative, while not entirely fresh, still offers a few surprises and clever gags, and Wilson lights up the screen as the unwilling protagonist of her own love story. It doesn’t have much of a story outside of its initial high-concept premise, and it’s perhaps not as smart as it thinks it is, but you could definitely do worse for a Valentine’s date movie.


Happy Death Day 2U (2019) 71%

In 2017, Universal and Blumhouse mixed the trappings of a classic slasher film with the déjà vu antics of Groundhog Day and achieved surprisingly effective results, so this week we get a return trip through the time loop with a slightly different twist. Jessica Rothe reprises her role as college student Tree Gelbman once again finds herself reliving the same day over and over again. Only thing is, this time around, the person responsible for her death in the first film is also murdered here, which means there’s a new killer on the loose. Critics say Happy Death Day 2U isn’t quite as much fun as the original — as the Arizona Republic’s Bill Goodykoontz writes, “a movie can only be a pleasant surprise once” — and it gets a little bogged down in trying to explain why what’s happening is happening, but it still packs some bloody thrills and hearty chuckles for the horror-comedy aficionados among us.


What’s New on TV

Doom Patrol: Season 1 (2019) 96%

DC Universe finds breakout material in this iteration of Doom Patrol thanks to a fully committed cast and the writing’s faith in weirdness.


The Umbrella Academy: Season 1 (2019) 76%

The Umbrella Academy unfurls an imaginative yarn with furtive emotion and an exceptionally compelling ensemble, but the series’ dour sensibility often clashes with its splashy genre trappings.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Hotel by the River (2018) , Hong Sang-soo‘s drama about a dying man who retreats to a hotel and meets two women, is at 94%.
  • Birds of Passage (2018) , a crime drama about an indigenous Wayúu man in 1970s Colombia who enters the illicit drug trade to support his family, is Certified Fresh at 91%.
  • Fighting With My Family (2019) , starring Florence Pugh and Nick Frost in Stephen Merchant‘s comedic look at the ascent of wrestling superstar Paige, is at 91%.
  • Sorry Angel (2018) , a 1990s-set romance about a writer with AIDS who meets and falls in love with a young filmmaker, is at 88%.
  • Ruben Brandt, Collector (2018) , an animated film about a troubled man who embarks on a crime spree as a means of therapy, is at 83%.
  • Mega Time Squad (2018) , about a petty criminal who steals an ancient time-travel device and discovers how dangerous it is, is at 75%.
  • Donnybrook (2018) , which follows three characters in a no-holds-barred underground cage-fighting tournament, is at 48%.
  • Patrick the Pug (2018) , about a struggling young woman who is gifted a spoiled pug, is at 36%.

Tag Cloud

93rd Oscars Hear Us Out Paramount Network Reality Competition cancelled Holiday 99% all-time Starz LGBTQ Broadway cancelled TV series name the review 4/20 remakes screen actors guild cartoon stand-up comedy Baby Yoda laika streaming movies Dark Horse Comics slasher 2019 summer TV preview hidden camera Amazon Prime sopranos indie finale Masterpiece 2015 Action rt archives Disney+ Disney Plus Extras spanish Arrowverse 21st Century Fox Columbia Pictures Black Mirror Mary Tyler Moore Television Critics Association robots Rom-Com criterion gangster Tomatazos parents saw Election facebook Comic Book CW Seed TCA 2017 posters latino sequel aapi anthology Travel Channel what to watch dceu Classic Film YA best canceled psychological thriller award winner football spanish language Sony Pictures Christmas 90s Rocketman Netflix Disney Channel NBC ratings Academy Awards 73rd Emmy Awards 71st Emmy Awards Hollywood Foreign Press Association IFC Films transformers adventure biopic Pacific Islander TV renewals 1990s Thanksgiving adaptation dogs YouTube Red satire mob popular scary psycho PBS spinoff Instagram Live blockbusters BBC America new york comic book movies BET Awards Awards Tour stop motion Peacock mission: impossible Emmy Nominations golden globe awards Food Network french First Reviews SXSW 2022 TruTV Mindy Kaling Western Trailer El Rey cancelled TV shows rotten rt labs wonder woman Quiz Red Carpet Teen TBS National Geographic franchise Year in Review Funimation boxing toy story ITV reboot vs. Marathons high school Star Wars USA Network Fox News DGA Adult Swim thriller DC Universe genre razzies south america Bravo FX on Hulu Comedy Central olympics Apple TV+ kids Cartoon Network book Apple trailers a nightmare on elm street 79th Golden Globes Awards Hallmark Christmas movies Video Games supernatural social media disaster BBC Marvel Studios SXSW Musicals foreign nbcuniversal casting Nominations festival fresh women australia game show Lucasfilm Schedule TV archives game of thrones Mudbound 94th Oscars AMC Plus Cosplay indiana jones Fall TV Chernobyl scorecard Turner Classic Movies spy thriller Netflix Christmas movies Toys Podcast TV Land OWN police drama Spring TV NBA The Arrangement breaking bad comiccon movie true crime canceled TV shows king arthur 24 frames RT History Marvel Television leaderboard Opinion Wes Anderson Infographic Universal Marvel scene in color See It Skip It Sundance Now 72 Emmy Awards Britbox scary movies VICE doctor who Oscars Polls and Games FX Fargo spain Comic-Con@Home 2021 Trivia movies series Crunchyroll Film Festival Elton John kong E! singing competition Martial Arts ID summer TV technology mutant A&E Mystery 2017 superhero war richard e. Grant blaxploitation vampires Country composers batman teaser IMDb TV rotten movies we love Image Comics 2020 venice art house hist Disney streaming service cinemax The Witch Film Women's History Month LGBT TNT elevated horror Sundance TV dreamworks 45 Alien sports MSNBC kaiju target Super Bowl Pirates crime new star wars movies SDCC blockbuster Fox Searchlight IFC DC streaming service debate adenture Oscar Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Tags: Comedy cults Discovery Channel suspense Acorn TV independent 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards cancelled television cooking Comics on TV golden globes king kong FOX Writers Guild of America universal monsters godzilla X-Men Universal Pictures ABC Family Set visit Ellie Kemper Tumblr discovery pirates of the caribbean The Walking Dead marvel cinematic universe Syfy GoT PaleyFest Spike critic resources asian-american Epix Amazon Prime Video emmy awards Kids & Family new zealand marvel comics tv talk fast and furious know your critic MCU period drama aliens Binge Guide harry potter documentaries dexter 007 VOD book adaptation Ovation natural history miniseries Family young adult mcc Horror Disney Plus festivals romance DirecTV SundanceTV video mockumentary RT21 TLC HBO Max prank Anna Paquin Turner Walt Disney Pictures New York Comic Con Mary poppins ABC Signature space streamig stoner classics cars child's play summer preview 2018 hispanic heritage month DC Comics Pixar films news The CW Emmys christmas movies justice league diversity Exclusive Video video on demand nfl Song of Ice and Fire action-comedy live event Endgame spider-verse anime CBS reviews rt labs critics edition Heroines Winners ABC directors Holidays cops Brie Larson Fantasy werewolf Crackle Warner Bros. YouTube Premium Photos political drama Valentine's Day unscripted spider-man based on movie crossover jamie lee curtis Neflix biography 2021 Summer Nickelodeon Best and Worst HBO zombies Hulu historical drama BET Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt slashers nature basketball Lifetime Christmas movies Rocky quibi documentary Box Office TV movies revenge deadpool South by Southwest Film Festival Tarantino Best Director comic Logo Avengers romantic comedy Premiere Dates APB sequels Calendar international dramedy trophy japan WarnerMedia royal family Superheroes screenings OneApp cats Sci-Fi children's TV A24 President ViacomCBS TIFF WGN CMT Animation obi wan streaming dark Freeform History TCM MTV strong female leads Showtime GIFs ghosts feel good Disney binge die hard Black History Month monster movies animated italian science fiction TV One CNN Mary Poppins Returns Reality Certified Fresh docudrama dc Rock toronto Star Trek zero dark thirty rom-coms japanese E3 Captain marvel Musical concert Watching Series lord of the rings Shudder Television Academy Shondaland heist movie TCA Winter 2020 Sundance live action politics halloween obituary telelvision docuseries Amazon Studios ESPN AMC Comedy black Pet Sematary free movies comic books Countdown 20th Century Fox TCA Prime Video witnail joker twilight james bond 2016 First Look travel Drama legend serial killer Spectrum Originals comedies The Purge Tokyo Olympics Grammys renewed TV shows medical drama superman Trophy Talk BAFTA boxoffice TCA Awards HBO Go Paramount Plus talk show Apple TV Plus Best Actress hispanic crime thriller FXX zombie Interview hollywood Winter TV YouTube Tubi The Academy Best Picture halloween tv VH1 theme song green book Creative Arts Emmys MGM Nat Geo Esquire Pop TV Lionsgate NYCC BBC One Awards Stephen King Sneak Peek Best Actor GLAAD worst chucky Hallmark Paramount Vudu PlayStation dragons television versus CBS All Access Lifetime Character Guide jurassic park San Diego Comic-Con worst movies Biopics crime drama comics Legendary Cannes Pop sitcom black comedy HFPA Superheroe Amazon Music sag awards comic book movie Ghostbusters USA Pride Month American Society of Cinematographers critics The Walt Disney Company