Total Recall

Total Recall: I Am Legend and the Work of Richard Matheson

We examine the film work of the cult novelist/screenwriter.

by | December 12, 2007 | Comments

This week, Will Smith plays a guy who discovers he’s the last man on earth in I Am Legend. So it’s a good time to take a look at the movie work of Richard Matheson, who penned the film’s source material.

Among sci-fi/thriller writers whose work has been adapted for the screen, Matheson’s name is less familiar than Stephen King‘s or Philip K. Dick‘s. But his novels and screenplays have cast a long shadow over the pulp medium. Like King, Matheson tells stories of regular people who find themselves in extraordinary situations. Though his novelization of I Am Legend has been made into a movie several times (as 1964’s The Last Man on Earth [91 percent] and 1971’s The Omega Man [62 percent]) and is probably his best-known work, Matheson has shown an aptitude for twisty horror, thoughtful sci-fi, and sweeping romance.

Duel (81 percent) is a perfect example of one of Matheson’s greatest strengths: The image of one man gradually coming to grips with inexplicable horror. While Terror at 20,000 Feet is docked points since it’s only a short (part of The Twilight Zone movie, 63 percent) and the details of I am Legend are always drastically changed for film, Duel remains as taut and efficient as it originally was in 1971. Representing Steven Spielberg‘s feature-length directorial debut, the film follows a traveling businessman (Dennis Weaver) who’s relentlessly pursued by a big rig and its never-seen driver. “Even without benefit of hindsight,” writes Janet Maslin of The New York Times, “Duel looks like the work of an unusually talented young director.”

Duel was made for the ABC network on a 10-day shooting schedule, but its success as a Sunday Movie of the Week prompted its theatrical release overseas, along with a limited run in the U.S. Spielberg shot three new sequences: the scene where Weaver tries to assist a stuck school bus as the big rig slowly creeps up on him, an equally compelling scene that has Weaver’s car slowly being nudged into an oncoming train, and one that has Weaver calling his family before being terrorized. The last scene is interesting for a few reasons. For one, it shows a strong father figure before Spielberg’s cynicism toward them crept into his work. And the scene’s sentimentality actually helps the movie overall: it grounds Weaver’s character into reality, in a movie that is otherwise a frightening existential pursuit across the California outback.


Duel theatrical trailer

After the considerable success the dramatic Robin Williams experienced in Good Will Hunting, Williams seemed determined to re-invent himself as dramedian at the end of the century. 1999’s Jakob the Liar was a box office bomb, along with Bicentennial Man and 1998’s What Dreams May Come (56 percent), though the latter two couldn’t be faulted for lacking ambition. Bicentennial Man plots out a robot’s 200-year long journey to become human, while What Dreams May Come is a metaphysical drama about a man who leaves Heaven and plumbs the depths of Hell to retrieve his recently deceased wife. Based on the Matheson novel of the same name, Williams overacts a bit (that’s what happens when Williams does drama without a beard), but the movie’s worth watching for its Oscar-winning depiction of Heaven. “[It’s] like an abstract painting,” Karen Hershenson of the Contra Costa Times writes about the film. “Full of vivid brushstrokes that hint at deeper meaning.”

Matheson has a long-standing reputation as a thinking man’s Stephen King, but he did occasionally dip into romantic melodrama. Along with What Dreams May Come, 1981’s Somewhere in Time (60 percent) is an odd romance starring Christopher Reeve who travels back in time to get it on with Jane Seymour. Adapted by Matheson from his novel, he writes “Somewhere in Time is the story of a love which transcends time, What Dreams May Come is the story of a love which transcends death. I feel that they represent the best writing I have done in the novel form.”


Scene from What Dreams May Come

Matheson’s work has also blended everyday life with the supernatural to disquieting effect; an excellent example is the underrated Stir of Echoes (69 percent). This ghost story, based upon Matheson’s 1958 novel, had the misfortune of being released around the same time as, and sharing similar elements with, The Sixth Sense, but it stands on its own as a creepy, achingly poignant document of a solid, average guy’s descent into madness. Kevin Bacon plays Tom, a phone company employee and amateur musician, who’s not very happy with the routine his life has fallen into. On a lark at a neighborhood party, Tom convinces his sister-in-law (Illeana Douglas) to hypnotize him. Soon after, he experiences a series of troubling visions: the spectral presence of a teenage girl seems to be trying to communicate with him, and he finds he has strange powers that help him tap into the spirit world. Even more disturbing is the fact that his young son seems to be experiencing the same things with even greater clarity. As Tom pieces things together, he discovers the spirits may be giving him the clues to solving a murder.

Some of the Echoes‘ supernatural elements may not tie together seamlessly, and the ending doesn’t quite do justice to the deliciously sharp setup. But Stir of Echoes is still worlds richer than many horror flicks. It draws much of its power from its well-developed sense of place; one gets the sense that the characters have lived on the same block and breathed the same air for a long time, which adds heft to the horrifying things taking place around them. There are a number of seemingly mundane moments that throb with an undercurrent of terror. And Bacon is excellent as a decent family man who has become obsessed with the strange visions in his head. “Stir of Echoes gives a classic ghost story extra zip by insisting on the reality of the characters and their place,” wrote Susan Stark of the Detroit News.


Scene from Stir of Echoes

Tag Cloud

Vudu serial killer hispanic heritage month prank American Society of Cinematographers ratings batman Opinion indiana jones Dark Horse Comics movie Disney streaming service criterion debate dexter Sundance E! vs. animated Toys DC streaming service Marvel monster movies social media Endgame video on demand YouTube Lionsgate BBC comedies war RT History scary sag awards TruTV diversity Lifetime Star Wars TV renewals Superheroe ABC See It Skip It sports new york Legendary Tubi slasher emmy awards Trailer TV Land singing competition The Purge Sneak Peek Comic Book Drama marvel cinematic universe Musical scene in color series australia Tokyo Olympics TCA 2017 90s concert casting comics Syfy 94th Oscars canceled Comics on TV VH1 aapi First Reviews Amazon Prime Video ITV IFC Columbia Pictures Peacock 2017 Grammys stand-up comedy doctor who comiccon E3 99% mob Anna Paquin BAFTA free movies YouTube Premium The Witch FX HBO Go summer preview thriller Video Games Red Carpet Ghostbusters jamie lee curtis Universal Pictures Pop TV classics Starz comic book movies rt labs italian high school Mystery Amazon Prime unscripted Crunchyroll CBS All Access Disney Channel 45 basketball based on movie BBC America slashers aliens Awards Tour Rock miniseries 2018 sopranos The Academy Amazon Studios X-Men adaptation FXX USA Funimation documentary IMDb TV target harry potter japan stoner DC Universe Horror teaser Rocky Walt Disney Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina legend worst movies popular universal monsters Action biopic El Rey Comedy Central Broadway Emmys Holiday new star wars movies elevated horror Fox Searchlight posters Emmy Nominations robots romantic comedy Britbox Heroines superman toronto spanish nfl cancelled Black Mirror Music Epix summer TV preview 21st Century Fox independent Nominations travel dc Sundance TV all-time TLC CBS Set visit black adventure New York Comic Con obituary A&E 93rd Oscars rotten movies we love rotten Travel Channel Avengers TIFF Spike Polls and Games Extras Universal scene in color film series 71st Emmy Awards The Walt Disney Company Cartoon Network Turner Masterpiece Shudder Sony die hard Academy Awards MCU 79th Golden Globes Awards latino BET Awards trophy Apple TV Plus spain WarnerMedia Valentine's Day Paramount Pictures jurassic park Brie Larson Mary poppins young adult 007 series laika zero dark thirty Baby Yoda canceled TV shows target scene in color worst Spectrum Originals Superheroes Tarantino game show 72 Emmy Awards Crackle twilight Captain marvel scary movies HFPA Summer directors Winter TV Fall TV Comedy 2020 richard e. Grant IFC Films composers GLAAD DGA BET ABC Signature anime PBS natural history Hollywood Foreign Press Association discovery Elton John Super Bowl vampires cancelled TV series sequels Pop Instagram Live know your critic justice league dreamworks CW Seed remakes Netflix RT21 Stephen King SXSW Exclusive Video Martial Arts spinoff Countdown critic resources Best Actor Schedule lord of the rings Tumblr comic werewolf Paramount Family 20th Century Fox YouTube Red dramedy Rom-Com cults kong Warner Bros. trailers 4/20 Cosplay LGBTQ cooking psychological thriller spy thriller hollywood mission: impossible Hallmark medical drama streaming movies critics streamig Shondaland Calendar Creative Arts Emmys South by Southwest Film Festival Television Academy mutant Tags: Comedy Alien Star Wars Celebration french Teen Apple 73rd Emmy Awards Country Mary Tyler Moore Oscar 2016 women Lucasfilm dogs japanese blaxploitation television hidden camera San Diego Comic-Con green book BBC One royal family Mudbound golden globe awards MGM TV movies nature Image Comics Winners feel good Song of Ice and Fire Chernobyl heist movie Paramount Network king kong Wes Anderson PlayStation new zealand Comic-Con@Home 2021 christmas movies reboot Bravo Biopics Holidays Indigenous genre halloween 1990s ghosts black comedy best Amazon science fiction Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt pirates of the caribbean Film Festival GIFs live action boxoffice Disney docudrama The CW Sony Pictures Fantasy sequel TCM Focus Features movies Infographic godzilla supernatural renewed TV shows Interview VICE USA Network ESPN TV One Native Trophy Talk franchise DC Comics Tomatazos parents book Animation breaking bad Nat Geo blockbusters political drama WGN AMC Plus Musicals ABC Family Character Guide boxing YA Election Food Network Marathons Lifetime Christmas movies Awards VOD 2019 adenture Pirates scene in color reviews saw binge what to watch romance transformers Adult Swim TCA Awards video children's TV LGBT indie crime drama Best Picture finale DirecTV Mindy Kaling CMT witnail rt labs critics edition Binge Guide Spring TV The Walking Dead Esquire name the review ID theme song disaster facebook Kids & Family Sundance Now game of thrones SundanceTV crossover broadcast Neflix cancelled TV shows action-comedy Trivia NYCC crime thriller cars Writers Guild of America football 2015 Quiz strong female leads asian-american Best Director Star Trek versus joker screen actors guild Arrowverse Disney Plus suspense razzies Apple TV+ NBC Prime Video hispanic true crime Fargo Reality Competition quibi Netflix Christmas movies First Look TCA Winter 2020 The Arrangement a nightmare on elm street Television Critics Association chucky A24 telelvision Fox News foreign 2021 History cats CNN book adaptation Hear Us Out Geeked Week revenge toy story MSNBC cancelled television streaming ViacomCBS festivals satire leaderboard space dragons President superhero Ellie Kemper gangster Pacific Islander crime king arthur Western cinemax Pet Sematary obi wan anthology Cannes Podcast child's play police drama historical drama rt archives 24 frames tv talk Classic Film 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards interviews deadpool screenings Premiere Dates spanish language comic book movie talk show Black History Month Nickelodeon Rocketman Year in Review olympics fresh Best and Worst marvel comics spider-man venice south america Marvel Television Discovery Channel blockbuster PaleyFest spider-verse Photos live event nbcuniversal Certified Fresh biography Hulu comic books Women's History Month TCA TV Thanksgiving kaiju OneApp Paramount Plus National Geographic Watching Series Turner Classic Movies dark SXSW 2022 FX on Hulu Freeform Box Office Acorn TV kids psycho NBA Pixar technology hist Hallmark Christmas movies james bond HBO Max FOX art house golden globes Logo Sci-Fi Disney+ Disney Plus Pride Month period drama politics Film stop motion international news SDCC AMC fast and furious GoT zombie TNT festival archives zombies rom-coms Reality sitcom Marvel Studios Ovation OWN APB Oscars summer TV halloween tv films mockumentary documentaries MTV Best Actress TBS mcc Mary Poppins Returns cartoon cops award winner dceu wonder woman Christmas Showtime HBO scorecard docuseries