Critics Consensus

RT Critical Consensus: "Doom" Gloom, "Country" Sounds Sweet

by | October 20, 2005 | Comments

This week at the movies brings stories of marines on Mars ("Doom"), iron miners fighting the man ("North Country"), little girls who love horses ("Dreamer: Inspired By a True Story"), and questions of human identity ("Stay"). Which of these films will score with critics?

"Doom," the video game, was nirvana for button-mashers. It took the simplest concept in the world of gaming – shooting aliens with big guns – and drove it home with a kaleidoscope of sensory pleasures. But video games and movies work on our senses in different ways, and "Doom," the movie, is – perhaps unsurprisingly – far from the revolutionary masterstroke of its source material. Granted, the source was not an Iris Murdoch novel. The film stars The Rock as a marine investigating strange goings-on at a research facility on Mars; naturally, things eventually get blowed up real good. While some critics say it’s not all that bad, others say it’s just big and loud. At 27 percent, the scribes are pressing the reset button, but its makers should take heart in the fact that it’s one of the best-reviewed video game adaptations of all time.

John Lennon once said, "A working class hero is something to be." That’s a sentiment the makers of "North Country" feel will resonate in these ambiguous political times. Charlize Theron stars as an iron miner who speaks out against hazardous working conditions and sexual harassment. Critics say that while "North Country" has its flaws, it’s an inspiring and passionate underdog story. At 64 percent, critics say this is one beautiful "Country."

A family-friendly tale of a little girl, her father, a horse, and Kris Kristofferson, "Dreamer: Inspired by a True Story" is not a movie for cynics. Dakota Fanning and Kurt Russell work to bring a once-promising horse out of retirement (and, presumably, the glue factory) for a run at the Breeders’ Cup. Critics say Fanning is solid as always, but the film, while well-crafted, breaks about as much new ground as an antique plow pulled by an aging nag. At 48 percent on the Tomatometer, the critics are putting this "Dreamer" out to pasture.

"Memento," "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind," "Blow Up"…. Moviegoers love a good, twisty meditation on the human condition. "Good" is the operative word here. "Stay" stars Ewan McGregor and Naomi Watts in the story of a psychiatrist whose reality starts to crack as his life becomes entwined with that of his suicidal patient. The critics say the movie is certainly a brain-teaser, but it’s more tease than brain, and more murky that meditative. At 10 percent, critics are imploring viewers to "Stay" away from this one.

Recent Video Game To Movie Adaptations:
1% — Alone in the Dark (2005)
20% — Resident Evil: Apocalypse (2004)
6% — House of the Dead (2003)
23% — Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life (2003)
36% — Resident Evil (2002)
18% — Lara Croft: Tomb Raider (2001)
7% — Wing Commander (1999)
24% — Mortal Kombat (1995)
0% — Double Dragon (1994)
6% — Super Mario Bros. (1993)

Tag Cloud

new zealand cancelled TV series Red Carpet 2019 Shondaland dark critic resources Hear Us Out 20th Century Fox razzies italian video on demand Mindy Kaling DGA 21st Century Fox documentary independent A&E Trophy Talk concert godzilla TCA 2017 robots Dark Horse Comics ABC festival cinemax streaming movies USA Network Discovery Channel anthology monster movies hispanic Mary Poppins Returns El Rey Holiday legend 93rd Oscars critics doctor who Cannes satire directors cats TBS Valentine's Day sitcom Musicals political drama YouTube Premium christmas movies WarnerMedia facebook TV movies CW Seed dramedy black rt labs critics edition SDCC Sneak Peek finale Black Mirror halloween witnail singing competition rom-coms discovery The Walking Dead FX FOX Winners OWN 71st Emmy Awards Image Comics Marvel Awards HBO Go RT21 psycho Winter TV Mary Tyler Moore canceled wonder woman ESPN 007 Tubi 2017 Pirates YA adaptation Anna Paquin lord of the rings Spring TV joker natural history spanish language criterion kids spinoff A24 Comedy Central Apple TV+ Vudu cancelled TV shows movies superhero Calendar slasher marvel cinematic universe American Society of Cinematographers Drama 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards true crime feel good FXX Hallmark Christmas movies San Diego Comic-Con live event Captain marvel Comic-Con@Home 2021 SundanceTV Disney+ Disney Plus Infographic Action renewed TV shows First Reviews nbcuniversal Summer cooking Stephen King young adult Pop TV Mudbound Year in Review Women's History Month Ellie Kemper sopranos IFC Films Crackle Baby Yoda streaming Marvel Television Apple GIFs international king arthur Ovation war science fiction foreign fresh dexter Syfy films romantic comedy Video Games Tarantino ITV Britbox technology scary movies animated Disney Plus scary archives vs. Peacock TCM NBC comic Sundance Cosplay HBO Max pirates of the caribbean Nominations Sundance TV 2016 new star wars movies hidden camera reboot social media Paramount gangster Spectrum Originals series Holidays Bravo blockbuster Logo The Witch best blockbusters ratings Musical Pacific Islander child's play worst royal family Tokyo Olympics Alien Brie Larson aapi docudrama parents Set visit stoner serial killer Universal Pictures Freeform Travel Channel Reality Competition Polls and Games spain Funimation Pet Sematary asian-american Showtime anime Amazon Prime game of thrones E3 richard e. Grant DC streaming service Marathons Schedule jamie lee curtis Lucasfilm biopic french classics Quiz stop motion canceled TV shows Spike LGBTQ VICE First Look Grammys ViacomCBS cancelled Apple TV Plus prank chucky National Geographic twilight DC Comics south america crime japanese binge USA Toys NYCC Chernobyl kaiju Song of Ice and Fire Netflix popular indie TruTV 2018 cults video Endgame basketball diversity leaderboard elevated horror crossover halloween tv TV One Trailer BAFTA rt archives boxoffice TLC Mystery adventure cops Watching Series what to watch spanish latino Nickelodeon stand-up comedy ABC Signature strong female leads Film women Kids & Family hispanic heritage month franchise New York Comic Con VOD BBC X-Men Tumblr biography art house The Walt Disney Company laika Country CNN name the review dragons zombies dc Adult Swim hist Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt blaxploitation Amazon Prime Video die hard 1990s Warner Bros. comic book movie period drama Rocky 2021 unscripted Fargo all-time dogs BBC America Netflix Christmas movies sequels Tomatazos adenture Interview universal monsters target breaking bad comedies batman king kong Oscars space superman toy story Creative Arts Emmys boxing Shudder Broadway travel Mary poppins PBS politics marvel comics Animation book adaptation psychological thriller President Disney cars Turner crime drama 73rd Emmy Awards Teen comic book movies Best and Worst Paramount Plus Crunchyroll AMC TV Black History Month dceu Comedy cartoon YouTube Hallmark Election Star Wars TV renewals Podcast movie Academy Awards 2015 MCU DC Universe obituary Amazon Western Neflix BET Awards police drama spider-man Lifetime Christmas movies toronto Martial Arts Rock E! tv talk SXSW TNT green book APB 90s BET indiana jones hollywood black comedy DirecTV composers Food Network live action high school Disney Channel Amazon Studios spy thriller Acorn TV Sundance Now The CW mutant ABC Family Comic Book free movies TCA Winter 2020 Comics on TV Awards Tour zombie Pixar Columbia Pictures aliens MTV debate venice scorecard mission: impossible Ghostbusters Television Academy mcc fast and furious trophy cancelled television television versus Extras CMT 72 Emmy Awards dreamworks Sony Pictures Super Bowl ID YouTube Red football Paramount Network trailers TV Land action-comedy 99% Cartoon Network PlayStation OneApp 4/20 Reality slashers Chilling Adventures of Sabrina news Avengers Character Guide saw suspense Trivia Arrowverse casting Starz jurassic park screenings comics zero dark thirty Fall TV sag awards History historical drama AMC Plus IMDb TV golden globe awards remakes sequel Marvel Studios werewolf transformers 45 scene in color Music vampires Fantasy Emmy Nominations harry potter talk show festivals NBA based on movie Legendary RT History olympics thriller james bond spider-verse Film Festival deadpool Certified Fresh Binge Guide HBO Superheroes docuseries kong Premiere Dates documentaries mob medical drama book IFC Universal Epix TCA PaleyFest a nightmare on elm street Television Critics Association BBC One Lionsgate Classic Film game show 2020 The Purge rotten Masterpiece emmy awards Rom-Com Instagram Live Fox Searchlight ghosts mockumentary Esquire Elton John nfl Exclusive Video Writers Guild of America posters Star Trek Emmys Turner Classic Movies Superheroe Countdown The Arrangement LGBT Heroines nature miniseries FX on Hulu TIFF See It Skip It comic books golden globes The Academy comiccon award winner disaster Horror Christmas Pride Month rotten movies we love Photos Biopics Walt Disney Pictures TCA Awards japan crime thriller justice league Wes Anderson Nat Geo Box Office genre screen actors guild reviews worst movies Opinion Family rt labs MSNBC Hulu quibi children's TV theme song revenge GoT telelvision 24 frames sports romance VH1 Disney streaming service CBS All Access Lifetime australia know your critic Fox News Sci-Fi heist movie supernatural Thanksgiving GLAAD WGN Pop Rocketman CBS teaser new york