Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: WALL-E Is the Best-Reviewed Film of 2008

Plus, Wanted delivers the adrenaline-fueled goods.

by | June 30, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got lonely robots (Pixar’s WALL-E, directed by Andrew Stanton) and kinetic killers (Wanted, starring Angelina Jolie, James McAvoy, and Morgan Freeman). What do the critics have to say?

It’s rare that a picture earns comparisons with Chaplin‘s City Lights and Kubrick‘s 2001. It’s rarer still that said picture is also praised as intelligent, visually remarkable, darkly funny, and ultimately, heartwarming family fare. However, critics say the good folks at Pixar have done just that with WALL-E, perhaps the studio’s most audacious film yet. Set in a dystopian future, WALL-E is the tale of a garbage-collecting robot navigating an unpopulated Earth. Soon he’s joined by EVE, a female bot searching for vegetation, and falls head-over-treads in love. Critics have been heaping praise on Pixar for years, but there’s a reason for that: The studio re-invents the rules of CG animation each time out. The pundits say WALL-E deftly blends slapstick, political satire, heartbreaking romance, and masterful storytelling into a one-of-a-kind movie experience. At 96 percent on the Tomatometer, WALL-E is not just Certified Fresh. It’s not just one of the best-reviewed films of the year. It’s one of the best-reviewed films in Pixar’s history.

“Now where can we get some Brawndo?”

If you’re looking for realism and well-developed characters, you can safely skip Wanted. However, if visceral, kicky popcorn fun is what you crave, critics say this Angelina Jolie-toplined flick should largely satisfy. Directed by Timur (Night Watch) Bekmambetov, Wanted is the story of an average Joe (James McAvoy) who finds himself recruited into a secret society by the enigmatic Fox (Jolie), in which he learns how to be an efficient assassin before getting in over his head. The pundits say Wanted is ultra-violent and artificial, but also sharply-paced and loaded with visual flair. At 72 percent, Wanted is more alive than dead. (Check out our video interview with Jolie here, and our breakdown of McAvoy’s best-reviewed films here.)

“Clean up on aisle five!”

Also opening this week in limited release:

Louise Bourgeois: The Spider, The Mistress and The Tangerine, a documentary about the iconoclastic artist, is at 89 percent;

Beastie Boy Adam Yauch‘s Gunnin’ for That #1 Spot, a doc about street-hoops Mecca Rucker Park, is at 82 percent;

Catherine Breillat’s The Last Mistress, adapted from a novel by Jules Barbey d’Aurevilly and starring Asia Argento, is at 71 percent;

Trumbo, a doc about the blacklisted screenwriter of Roman Holiday, is at 64 percent;

Elsa & Fred, a romantic comedy about a wild love affair between two seniors in Madrid, is at 50 percent;

Finding Amanda, starring Matthew Broderick and Brittany Snow, a comedy about a compulsive gambler’s search for his drug-addicted niece, is at 46 percent;

Full Grown Men, a dark comedy about arrested emotional development starring Matt McGrath and Judah Friedlander, is at 44 percent;

And Hannari: Geisha Modern, a doc about the Japanese performance tradition, is at zero percent.

“I’m taking my Tomatometer with a grain of salt.”

Recent Pixar Movies:
95% — Ratatouille (2007)
75% — Cars (2006)
97% — The Incredibles (2004)
98% — Finding Nemo (2003)
95% — Monsters, Inc. (2001)

Tag Cloud

young adult international obi wan Shudder scene in color series police drama summer TV 2018 Sony Pictures President Spectrum Originals Instagram Live A&E Academy Awards cancelled television zombies deadpool 007 Best Actor The Arrangement Polls and Games spinoff Paramount Plus PBS See It Skip It crime drama Trophy Talk historical drama Focus Features docudrama Election anime Rocketman Hear Us Out Film Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt witnail blaxploitation saw HBO Go Best Picture X-Men Bravo HFPA golden globes disaster Musical Showtime ViacomCBS E! Cartoon Network Box Office 4/20 documentaries Quiz Captain marvel First Reviews Star Wars Celebration streaming movies what to watch Wes Anderson robots Comedy Hallmark Christmas movies royal family Tomatazos gangster 93rd Oscars cults Song of Ice and Fire Nominations HBO Max TV WGN Brie Larson YouTube The CW best critic resources supernatural 94th Oscars El Rey series comic book movies composers comics richard e. Grant Syfy toronto summer preview Calendar doctor who BBC USA Best Actress Trailer psycho Black History Month South by Southwest Film Festival Lifetime war rom-coms blockbuster rt labs die hard mutant game show parents streamig GLAAD Turner Classic Movies nature cops TCA 2017 DC Comics true crime worst movies dreamworks biopic japanese hollywood award winner Star Wars Thanksgiving summer TV preview Creative Arts Emmys all-time Adult Swim art house kids hidden camera 20th Century Fox stop motion chucky Reality DirecTV Tarantino movies Tokyo Olympics Dark Horse Comics versus Emmy Nominations Sci-Fi adenture scene in color film series Apple Stephen King Martial Arts 2019 Winners Marvel TIFF A24 Pop Drama women psychological thriller classics TV Land transformers politics new york miniseries TNT Sony halloween finale 79th Golden Globes Awards BAFTA scary heist movie know your critic criterion travel dragons Masterpiece dexter FOX Binge Guide target elevated horror Biopics christmas movies werewolf TBS Fantasy YA scary movies San Diego Comic-Con comic books 2021 sequel RT21 marvel comics TV One Netflix Funimation 24 frames Mystery sag awards Rock DC streaming service Marvel Television book live event quibi slashers Reality Competition renewed TV shows science fiction ABC Signature spain basketball documentary interviews hispanic crime Apple TV Plus cats Peacock Chernobyl Crunchyroll The Walking Dead spider-verse Comedy Central Year in Review CW Seed Travel Channel LGBT Columbia Pictures streaming facebook space Netflix Christmas movies directors Sundance Now Comics on TV 2017 Countdown Christmas telelvision Universal Pictures free movies south america a nightmare on elm street Family CBS Pet Sematary indie godzilla aapi Lifetime Christmas movies news NBC Paramount reviews Discovery Channel Warner Bros. television king kong latino 1990s legend Tubi Freeform cancelled FX screen actors guild dark Pacific Islander National Geographic rt labs critics edition debate PaleyFest mission: impossible nfl Action emmy awards Women's History Month video reboot Watching Series USA Network james bond GIFs BBC One Chilling Adventures of Sabrina slasher Alien Disney streaming service E3 binge fast and furious 73rd Emmy Awards trailers kaiju Native Mudbound biography BET unscripted Trivia based on movie Broadway Television Academy cancelled TV shows nbcuniversal concert game of thrones king arthur American Society of Cinematographers comic Disney movie Holiday action-comedy History Superheroe Kids & Family Avengers Hallmark Oscar adaptation TLC The Academy italian new zealand crime thriller TCA Awards Superheroes popular casting hispanic heritage month laika Marvel Studios Turner ratings zombie Disney Plus VICE joker Fall TV batman boxing comedies australia Paramount Pictures Winter TV The Purge FXX Fox Searchlight Comic Book Disney Channel Best Director justice league live action archives tv talk Rom-Com Hollywood Foreign Press Association Super Bowl OWN CMT TCA Cosplay 71st Emmy Awards Walt Disney Pictures indiana jones cancelled TV series black ESPN Vudu ABC Family monster movies political drama VH1 YouTube Premium serial killer HBO vs. APB Certified Fresh Set visit Amazon Prime Video Neflix Star Trek rotten movies we love golden globe awards First Look genre films discovery jamie lee curtis scorecard talk show VOD football LGBTQ zero dark thirty spanish OneApp toy story posters Epix Holidays 2016 romantic comedy TCA Winter 2020 diversity aliens Classic Film pirates of the caribbean anthology TV renewals video on demand boxoffice Indigenous Lionsgate spy thriller Country teaser MSNBC Elton John Mary Tyler Moore Anna Paquin 72 Emmy Awards Red Carpet Nat Geo YouTube Red 21st Century Fox Paramount Network dc critics Sundance TV DGA Grammys broadcast 2020 book adaptation Crackle TCM wonder woman canceled Infographic Hulu suspense marvel cinematic universe social media name the review foreign twilight Universal Awards Arrowverse universal monsters ghosts The Witch Esquire Ellie Kemper RT History Shondaland ITV Disney+ Disney Plus asian-american TV movies dramedy Amazon Studios cartoon Toys Acorn TV Animation kong rt archives Music Interview Character Guide romance vampires Fargo MGM PlayStation NBA medical drama Rocky Television Critics Association Pop TV black comedy Awards Tour 2015 thriller new star wars movies superhero 45 natural history sequels Nickelodeon Marathons Lucasfilm green book festival breaking bad trophy children's TV Cannes fresh TruTV Best and Worst remakes theme song stoner cooking prank Amazon Prime Pride Month mcc Podcast Food Network crossover Mary Poppins Returns Fox News Schedule Prime Video Image Comics Tumblr Starz Horror Mindy Kaling revenge NYCC Spring TV 99% animated Musicals period drama New York Comic Con 90s halloween tv comic book movie Extras CBS All Access high school Baby Yoda Sneak Peek ABC comiccon Summer canceled TV shows mob Amazon AMC Plus Sundance 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards sports Tags: Comedy Geeked Week Opinion Heroines IFC stand-up comedy Valentine's Day rotten child's play Spike Writers Guild of America Britbox scene in color SXSW 2022 strong female leads sitcom Film Festival franchise Exclusive Video jurassic park Endgame worst BET Awards razzies french dceu Teen WarnerMedia Pirates Comic-Con@Home 2021 Ghostbusters CNN Pixar Photos lord of the rings singing competition obituary mockumentary cinemax venice DC Universe IMDb TV The Walt Disney Company MTV Video Games sopranos screenings japan harry potter hist Western AMC SundanceTV cars technology satire adventure BBC America FX on Hulu superman dogs docuseries MCU SDCC spider-man independent Oscars Ovation feel good Mary poppins blockbusters ID SXSW spanish language GoT leaderboard Black Mirror Logo IFC Films target scene in color Apple TV+ Emmys festivals olympics Legendary Premiere Dates