Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Transcendence is a Sci-Fi Snooze

Plus, Heaven is for Real is heartfelt but uneven; Bears is beautiful and entertaining, and A Haunted House 2 wasn't screened -- guess the Tomatometer!

by | April 17, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a techno-dystopia (Transcendence, starring Johnny Depp and Rebecca Hall), a near-death experience (Heaven Is For Real, starring Greg Kinnear and Connor Corum), a bunch of furry carnivores (the nature documentary Bears), and some supernatural high jinks (A Haunted House 2, starring Marlon Wayans and Jaime Pressly). What do the critics have to say?



Sometimes a movie needs more than an intriguing premise, an all-star cast, and a distinctive visual look. Critics say that’s the case with Transcendence, a surprisingly dull and narratively muddled sci-fi drama that’s short on suspense and logic. Johnny Depp stars as Will Caster, a leader in the field of artificial intelligence research who uploads his consciousness to a computer with the intent of creating a sentient machine. In doing so, Caster runs afoul of a group of militant luddites, who fear that humans have become too dependent on technology. The pundits say Transcendence is sleekly crafted, but it largely squanders its cast on a story that never quite coheres. (Check out our video interview with the stars, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Depp’s best-reviewed movies.)

Heaven Is for Real


It’s an age-old puzzle for Hollywood: how to make films that appeal to devout Christians without alienating everyone else. Critics say that Heaven Is For Real ends up in the mushy middle, and the result is a well-acted, thoughtful tale that never quite follows through on the interesting questions it raises. Four-year-old Colton (Connor Corum) briefly flatlines during surgery; when he’s revived, he tells an incredible story about the deceased family members he met during his short visit to Heaven. Colton’s revelation awakens something in his father Todd (Greg Kinnear), a small-town pastor in the midst of a crisis of faith. The pundits say Heaven is for Real is well-made and often quite affecting, but its depiction of the afterlife leaves something to be desired.



With Earth, Oceans, African Cats, and Chimpanzee, the good folks at Disneynature have delivered an unbroken string of high-quality nature documentaries. Critics say the streak continues with Bears, which offers breathtaking images of these animals in their natural environs and tends to avoid shoehorning its subjects into a narrative. Narrated by John C. Reilly, the film follows a mama grizzly bear and her two cubs as they try to survive in the Alaskan wilderness. The pundits say that Bears‘ furry protagonists are engaging and lovable, and the footage captured here is crisp and intimate. (Take a look through our gallery of memorable bears in the movies.)

A Haunted House 2


Given the critical drubbing its predecessor received, it comes as little surprise that A Haunted House 2 wasn’t screened for reviewers prior to its release. Marlon Wayans stars as a man who moves with his new girlfriend and her kids to a new home that’s bedeviled by spectral spirits; hilarity ensues. Time to guess the Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Final Member, a documentary about an Icelandic museum that houses a vast array of male genitalia from humans and animals, is at 100 percent.
  • Gabrielle, a drama about a love affair between two developmentally disabled adults, is at 100 percent.
  • Manakamana, a documentary about a cable car in Nepal that carries tourists and locals to a temple in the mountains, is at 100 percent.
  • Soft In The Head, a dramedy about a troubled woman who ends up living at a halfway house for men, is at 80 percent.
  • Small Time, a drama about a used-car salesman who teaches his son the tricks of the trade, is at 71 percent.
  • Proxy, a horror film about a woman dealing with tragedy who finds herself embroiled in a conspiracy when she joins a support group, is at 69 percent.
  • 13 Sins, starring Mark Webber and Ron Perlman in a thriller about a financially-strapped salesman who must undertake a series of increasingly dangerous challenges dictated to him via cell phone, is at 60 percent.
  • Fading Gigolo, starring Woody Allen and John Turturro in a comedy about a man who becomes an escort to help a friend in financial trouble, is at 57 percent.
  • That Demon Within, an action/horror hybrid about a young cop who suffers from hallucinations after providing a life-saving blood transfusion to a ruthless criminal, is at 44 percent.
  • Make Your Move, a drama about a pair of young people from different worlds who bond whie dancing, is at 20 percent.
  • Tasting Menu, a comedy about a disparate group of people who assemble for the closing of a world-class chef’s restaurant, is at 13 percent.
  • Authors Anonymous, starring Kaley Cuoco and Chris Klein in a mockumentary about a group of aspiring novelists, is at zero percent.
  • A Promise, starring Rebecca Hall and Alan Rickman in a period drama about an ambitious young man who falls for his boss’ married daughter, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

rom-coms diversity First Look dceu debate book adaptation Neflix HBO Max YouTube Red Apple TV Plus 2018 IFC Films Columbia Pictures VICE medical drama Crunchyroll First Reviews olympics Disney+ Disney Plus Mary Tyler Moore BET Marvel Television king arthur video on demand Film Binge Guide mutant CNN Opinion period drama Horror Teen australia USA Network zero dark thirty strong female leads Tumblr TNT deadpool 2020 films based on movie halloween football fresh historical drama SXSW children's TV Peacock San Diego Comic-Con travel politics Heroines Comic-Con@Home 2021 scorecard Spike Black Mirror DirecTV IMDb TV Vudu BET Awards Martial Arts Infographic Holidays reboot Set visit Captain marvel Nominations comedies Film Festival Logo Exclusive Video Hallmark quibi Superheroes Apple TV+ Turner Classic Movies name the review psycho Pet Sematary Marvel Studios parents technology NBA BBC America Song of Ice and Fire game show joker space spider-verse Netflix Christmas movies 2017 hidden camera screenings MSNBC blaxploitation Election BAFTA stoner obituary Action Star Trek Pacific Islander Trailer AMC Plus FXX posters Pirates Polls and Games screen actors guild The Arrangement razzies mcc Winter TV dc saw jamie lee curtis police drama Legendary book romance See It Skip It FX on Hulu casting cooking The Walking Dead Freeform political drama HBO Go Character Guide 73rd Emmy Awards Hulu Comic Book nbcuniversal revenge Syfy venice Bravo Tags: Comedy CBS Comedy Ghostbusters Discovery Channel Rom-Com Sci-Fi Watching Series spanish Television Academy scary Stephen King streaming Nickelodeon finale nfl king kong asian-american Valentine's Day E! Disney streaming service nature SDCC stand-up comedy Grammys Walt Disney Pictures Sneak Peek directors Food Network Biopics GLAAD anthology Tubi indiana jones TIFF archives universal monsters 72 Emmy Awards Mary Poppins Returns lord of the rings DC Universe cancelled TV series all-time Red Carpet feel good Tarantino Pop Kids & Family Western criterion Reality NBC harry potter Music Lifetime Crackle TV movies biopic boxoffice spy thriller dragons miniseries satire cars Amazon Prime Video Country critics APB godzilla Classic Film suspense Paramount Network Disney thriller cats Drama YouTube Premium 2015 Quiz ESPN jurassic park Extras Comics on TV GIFs Amazon Studios basketball classics Thanksgiving green book WarnerMedia The Academy black Fall TV Fantasy New York Comic Con stop motion Broadway series sports Winners Funimation Reality Competition Awards foreign spain free movies Lucasfilm Epix Image Comics DGA elevated horror franchise Lifetime Christmas movies gangster Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Mindy Kaling Podcast AMC james bond crossover golden globes Animation Showtime NYCC The Purge critic resources Pixar PaleyFest Wes Anderson Dark Horse Comics leaderboard Disney Plus worst movies dark cancelled TV shows rotten Universal science fiction italian Nat Geo sag awards biography docudrama disaster hollywood twilight Cannes 71st Emmy Awards Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Television Critics Association WGN laika vs. Shondaland The Witch Universal Pictures boxing Shudder independent comic book movies Hallmark Christmas movies Pop TV 99% canceled TV shows Prime Video festival psychological thriller pirates of the caribbean TV renewals social media dogs Cosplay Amazon Prime wonder woman Brie Larson Rock Rocketman LGBT game of thrones Box Office zombie telelvision war streaming movies Adult Swim The CW MCU live action TCA 2017 superhero CMT DC Comics sequels slasher video Best and Worst Marathons Premiere Dates what to watch action-comedy trailers RT21 Instagram Live facebook popular hispanic heritage month canceled Chernobyl El Rey teaser Sony Pictures Fargo cinemax vampires Hollywood Foreign Press Association 2016 SundanceTV mob Photos RT History unscripted fast and furious south america latino CW Seed Mary poppins BBC One crime thriller VOD french reviews Baby Yoda genre renewed TV shows Year in Review rt labs critics edition documentary Netflix 79th Golden Globes Awards aliens VH1 hist Turner werewolf History Pride Month Creative Arts Emmys christmas movies Lionsgate 4/20 a nightmare on elm street YA Avengers supernatural 2021 TCA Winter 2020 Academy Awards mockumentary dexter high school Endgame justice league mission: impossible comic PlayStation 21st Century Fox comics Ovation international legend new zealand Emmy Nominations rotten movies we love kids President ID 45 007 art house true crime talk show women Sundance Now halloween tv theme song sequel cops BBC 2019 movie dreamworks Warner Bros. Rocky ABC GoT Trivia comic book movie remakes spider-man Disney Channel new star wars movies Interview adventure TCM witnail Spectrum Originals Hear Us Out scene in color Cartoon Network Sundance dramedy Elton John Amazon Sundance TV adaptation Tokyo Olympics TCA breaking bad target richard e. Grant live event Starz Fox Searchlight Women's History Month DC streaming service TV Masterpiece ratings OWN 93rd Oscars cancelled television ViacomCBS news 90s FX worst Countdown trophy docuseries toronto Anna Paquin Emmys aapi robots spinoff kong Mudbound best adenture serial killer HBO superman Ellie Kemper crime TLC Paramount Plus hispanic monster movies marvel cinematic universe The Walt Disney Company TCA Awards Super Bowl E3 Spring TV Musical emmy awards Comedy Central sopranos transformers TruTV National Geographic concert rt archives golden globe awards Superheroe Arrowverse 1990s Oscars cartoon TV Land sitcom Apple spanish language chucky ABC Family know your critic comiccon Fox News anime comic books heist movie discovery Writers Guild of America Mystery toy story black comedy new york prank TV One documentaries PBS Schedule slashers japanese natural history Travel Channel Esquire Marvel 24 frames blockbuster 20th Century Fox X-Men Video Games Holiday batman Britbox American Society of Cinematographers HFPA FOX cancelled Certified Fresh Musicals MTV binge zombies blockbusters marvel comics ITV animated kaiju OneApp ghosts doctor who Acorn TV Family Trophy Talk USA award winner Summer television indie movies tv talk LGBTQ versus die hard child's play japan crime drama Star Wars composers YouTube 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards romantic comedy young adult cults royal family scary movies TBS festivals ABC Signature A&E Toys Tomatazos A24 Awards Tour CBS All Access Christmas IFC Calendar Paramount singing competition rt labs Black History Month Alien