Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Wolverine Is Pretty Sharp

Plus, The To Do List is uneven but sweet and funny, and The Way, Way Back is Certified Fresh.

by | July 25, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an embattled mutant (The Wolverine, starring Hugh Jackman and Rila Fukushima); an uptight valedictorian (The To Do List, starring Aubrey Plaza and Johnny Simmons); and a lonely teenager (The Way, Way Back, starring Liam James and Steve Carell). What do the critics have to say?

The Wolverine


Wolverine may rank among the most beloved heroes in the Marvel universe, but thus far he’s been deprived of a big-screen vehicle worthy of his stature. Still, critics say The Wolverine is much sharper than Logan’s previous solo effort, X-Men Origins: Wolverine; though it has a few dull patches, the film features terrific fight scenes and a typically full-bodied performance from Hugh Jackman. This time out, Wolverine heads to Japan for a reunion with a soldier whose life he saved years before. Soon, our hero must defend the man’s granddaughter from all manner of ninja and Yakuza assassin. The pundits say The Wolverine doesn’t reinvent the wheel, but it’s a rock-solid, smartly scripted, surprisingly introspective superhero flick. (Check out our gallery of X-Men on the silver screen.)

The To Do List


The female-centric teen sex comedy is a rare beast, which may be why critics find The To Do List so refreshing — or perhaps it’s the winning presence of Parks & Recreation wiseacre Aubrey Plaza. Intent on upending her prim-and-proper ways before college, recent high school grad Brandy Klark (Plaza) makes a list of every licentious activity she shunned in her pursuit of academic perfection — and quickly discovers how little she knows about teenage romance. The pundits say The To Do List is uneven and occasionally predictable, but it’s also immensely charming, thanks to a terrific performance from Plaza and a crack supporting cast. (Check out RT’s video interviews with Plaza, co-stars Bill Hader, Scott Porter, and more.)

The Way, Way Back


The Way, Way Back goes wide this week after charming audiences during its limited run, and critics say it’s a keenly-observed, well-acted coming-of-age tale that makes up in heart what it lacks in originality. Liam James stars as an introverted teenager who forms an unlikely bond with the manager of a water park (Sam Rockwell). The pundits say the Certified Fresh The Way, Way Backis funny, bittersweet, and true to life, and boasts excellent supporting turns from Toni Collette and Steve Carell.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Johnnie To‘s Drug War, an action thriller about a Chinese meth manufacturer who must turn informant to take down a powerful cartel and save himself from execution, is at 94 percent.

  • Springsteen And I, a crowdsourced documentary that compiles fan footage of the Boss in concert, is at 91 percent.

  • Woody Allen‘s Blue Jasmine, starring Cate Blanchett in a drama about a well-to-do socialite whose world collapses around her, is at 84 percent (check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Allen’s best-reviewed movies).

  • Frankenstein’s Army, a found-footage horror film about a group of Russian soldiers who stumble upon a legion of stitched-together soldiers in the waning days of World War II, is at 56 percent.

  • Wasteland, a crime drama about a falsely-convicted ex-jailbird who attempts to strike back at the drug kingpin who cost him his freedom, is at 45 percent.

  • The Time Being, starring Wes Bentley and Frank Langella in a thriller about an eccentric man who makes a series of bizarre requests to a young artist in exchange for patronage, is at 17 percent.

  • Breaking The Girls, starring Agnes Bruckner and Shawn Ashmore in a thriller about a college student who is drawn into a murder plot, is at zero percent.

  • Stranded, a sci-fi thriller starring Christian Slater as the leader of a lunar military unit left high and dry by a mysterious meteor shower, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

Ovation Premiere Dates politics true crime period drama Prime Video venice batman OneApp vs. YouTube mutant rt labs critics edition leaderboard Film new zealand ITV directors cancelled rotten criterion international Broadway crime South by Southwest Film Festival aliens live action Kids & Family PlayStation unscripted mcc best based on movie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt indie Song of Ice and Fire gangster AMC Rocketman series documentary Lucasfilm Calendar twilight art house laika NBC television Awards Tour award winner facebook satire werewolf Oscar TBS Martial Arts Emmy Nominations VICE TruTV worst hispanic heritage month Endgame cars Pop TV kong news Crunchyroll robots OWN hollywood Shondaland Spring TV Disney south america critic resources canceled TV shows heist movie documentaries space Turner Classic Movies golden globe awards obituary ID singing competition 20th Century Fox docuseries breaking bad Rocky know your critic Indigenous WGN doctor who sopranos children's TV Tokyo Olympics Funimation dc classics DC Universe fast and furious Hear Us Out HBO Max Nominations spinoff parents Bravo Heroines ViacomCBS Emmys Image Comics Photos golden globes theme song science fiction AMC Plus E3 live event 90s versus Opinion Amazon Sundance TV Paramount Plus telelvision Fox News 94th Oscars justice league young adult 2021 SXSW Tubi Cosplay blockbuster die hard indiana jones LGBT remakes Black History Month japanese book adaptation dceu cops comic book movies 007 cats CW Seed DirecTV spanish language Walt Disney Pictures transformers summer TV preview Television Academy marvel comics Red Carpet 99% ratings USA Network Box Office First Look scene in color film series kaiju hidden camera SundanceTV New York Comic Con Film Festival Musical Rock tv talk football action-comedy Awards harry potter MSNBC Christmas sag awards El Rey 2020 streaming movies ABC Signature Marvel PaleyFest Elton John cults RT History Classic Film sequels romance summer preview Hallmark Christmas movies IFC Films chucky Superheroes Universal Pictures political drama jamie lee curtis MTV Netflix Christmas movies finale video dragons Arrowverse high school Mudbound toronto target Best Picture halloween tv screenings Peacock Nat Geo HBO BBC reviews Spike blockbusters Women's History Month Superheroe WarnerMedia Comedy Countdown Writers Guild of America Legendary Spectrum Originals new york 45 lord of the rings GLAAD Horror PBS strong female leads A24 Turner Infographic Best Actress Showtime TV movies diversity Neflix spain E! TCM USA BAFTA TNT crime drama christmas movies Sony Pictures Mary Tyler Moore stoner TCA Awards Dark Horse Comics 24 frames Set visit olympics Oscars technology kids The Witch summer TV crime thriller Sundance Now stop motion Cartoon Network See It Skip It Western Best and Worst HFPA psycho History comic books Disney streaming service Marathons rom-coms Masterpiece game show The Academy Academy Awards Certified Fresh streaming Anna Paquin broadcast TV renewals President royal family Quiz boxoffice dark festivals child's play richard e. Grant Biopics Best Actor wonder woman Syfy VH1 CMT Binge Guide The Walking Dead Character Guide Comic Book National Geographic japan The Arrangement comiccon adenture Discovery Channel Pacific Islander Travel Channel RT21 comic book movie Rom-Com canceled nature Brie Larson scorecard Teen mockumentary Paramount Pictures BET 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The CW Pirates Netflix Star Trek slashers FXX Sneak Peek Tomatazos VOD superman 4/20 Food Network films serial killer social media interviews YouTube Premium 2019 TV IMDb TV docudrama Tumblr MCU Nickelodeon Super Bowl A&E legend sports french women comedies concert Disney Plus name the review dogs Musicals Holidays Trivia Year in Review Starz popular Amazon Prime latino spanish Ellie Kemper Television Critics Association FX fresh Schedule new star wars movies Amazon Prime Video DC streaming service Lifetime Christmas movies Family 2015 hispanic free movies travel Trailer foreign Paramount Shudder Geeked Week natural history universal monsters Adult Swim BET Awards Marvel Studios zero dark thirty Fantasy dramedy Animation casting comics rt labs dexter Election TV Land The Purge Cannes Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Amazon Studios Avengers all-time BBC One Reality Competition Valentine's Day nfl anthology saw Comedy Central pirates of the caribbean Fox Searchlight stand-up comedy Comics on TV Columbia Pictures scene in color boxing italian ABC NBA scene in color series black Comic-Con@Home 2021 Freeform quibi deadpool halloween 71st Emmy Awards a nightmare on elm street Toys Focus Features book renewed TV shows American Society of Cinematographers Baby Yoda Grammys disaster cancelled television aapi Star Wars YA Star Wars Celebration FOX reboot Black Mirror SDCC black comedy mob 21st Century Fox razzies Interview Watching Series cancelled TV series Mary Poppins Returns 73rd Emmy Awards Podcast revenge godzilla SXSW 2022 spider-verse Stephen King Reality LGBTQ Summer sequel Hallmark historical drama Video Games Drama critics debate Pride Month spy thriller zombie comic Acorn TV james bond blaxploitation feel good mission: impossible Epix Action HBO Go Creative Arts Emmys streamig genre movies archives TCA Polls and Games cartoon trophy Mary poppins Apple TV Plus king arthur thriller suspense movie police drama 72 Emmy Awards Chernobyl obi wan war BBC America GoT Disney+ Disney Plus Pixar medical drama superhero jurassic park ghosts posters IFC vampires X-Men Fall TV worst movies psychological thriller marvel cinematic universe Tarantino crossover Hollywood Foreign Press Association Thanksgiving Crackle rotten movies we love Best Director basketball 1990s GIFs Sony biography cancelled TV shows Lifetime trailers Warner Bros. australia emmy awards talk show animated Country adaptation TIFF The Walt Disney Company Apple Pop Ghostbusters Vudu Apple TV+ slasher 2017 scary movies TCA Winter 2020 DC Comics Paramount Network spider-man nbcuniversal dreamworks DGA binge joker ABC Family adventure romantic comedy Mindy Kaling Exclusive Video target scene in color ESPN green book CNN Trophy Talk composers Instagram Live supernatural Fargo Marvel Television MGM 93rd Oscars zombies Tags: Comedy cooking Disney Channel 79th Golden Globes Awards sitcom cinemax biopic YouTube Red franchise APB 2018 First Reviews Britbox independent hist Pet Sematary 2016 Universal Native Winners teaser asian-american Logo screen actors guild Holiday elevated horror miniseries Sundance Winter TV prank CBS Alien FX on Hulu TV One Captain marvel Extras San Diego Comic-Con Lionsgate Music discovery rt archives scary video on demand witnail TCA 2017 TLC CBS All Access festival Mystery Wes Anderson game of thrones Sci-Fi king kong monster movies Esquire what to watch NYCC Hulu anime toy story