Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Other Woman is Short On Laughs

Plus, Brick Mansions doesn't measure up to the original, and The Quiet Ones is spooky but not all that scary.

by | April 24, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got spurned ladies (The Other Woman, starring Cameron Diaz and Leslie Mann), a ticking time-bomb (Brick Mansions, starring Paul Walker and David Belle), and a paranormal experiment (The Quiet Ones, starring Jared Harris and Sam Claflin). What do the critics have to say?

The Other Woman


As the saying goes, hell hath no fury like a woman scorned. Unfortunately, critics say the problem with The Other Woman is it’s a bit too tepid, offering a few decent laughs but never quite nailing the female empowerment vibe it’s aiming for. Carly (Cameron Diaz) is reeling from the discovery that her boyfriend is married. She stews for a while, but upon meeting his wife (Leslie Mann) and his other girlfriend (Kate Upton), she realizes the three women have a lot in common, and collectively they decide to exact revenge. The pundits say The Other Woman has a game cast and some clever lines of dialogue, but the scenario is alternately too implausible and predictable to resonate emotionally. (Check out our video interview with the stars, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Diaz’s best-reviewed movies.)

Brick Mansions


A remake of the gravity-defying, parkour-infused French import District 13, Brick Mansions promises balletic action and high-wire thrills. And critics say it does indeed feature a few strong set pieces, but they aren’t enough to compensate for an overabundance of plotting and an underabundance of character development. In a crime-ridden Detroit of the near future, an undercover cop (Paul Walker) must infiltrate a heavily fortified section of town in order to diffuse a bomb that’s fallen into the hands of a vicious crime lord (RZA). The pundits say Brick Mansions is a ludicrous action flick with a few exciting moments, but mostly, it’s a pale retread of its superior predecessor. (Check out RZA’s Five Favorite Films here.)

The Quiet Ones


Hammer Film Productions has long been a purveyor of a more elegant brand of horror film. Unfortunately, critics say The Quiet Ones is a little too classy for its own good; despite solid performances and a spooky sense of place, the film delivers occasional jolts but fails at sustaining tension. In a remote English estate, Professor Joseph Coupland (Jared Harris) and a team of students are experimenting on a young woman who’s purported to be possessed by a supernatural being. Coupland believes she’s simply mentally ill, but his hypothesis is put to the test when he and his researchers are bedeviled by increasingly terrifying incidents. The pundits say The Quiet Ones is visually striking and often creepy, but it’s also overly talky and rarely out-and-out scary. (Take a look through our gallery of movies that feature scientific experiments gone wrong.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Blue Ruin, a thriller about a drifter driven to exact revenge on the man who murdered his parents, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • Last Passenger, starring Dougray Scott and Lindsay Duncan in an action film about a group of commuters who must work together to stop the madman who has taken control of a London train, is at 92 percent.
  • Locke, starring Tom Hardy in a thriller about a man whose life unravels over the course of a long drive, is Certified Fresh at 90 percent.
  • The Machine, a sci-fi thriller about a couple that develops a self-aware computer the government wants to use as a weapon, is at 74 percent.
  • The German Doctor, a thriller about an Argentinean family that unwittingly offers shelter to fugitive Nazi war criminal Josef Mengele, is at 65 percent.
  • Who Is Dayani Cristal?, a documentary that explores the life of a man who was found dead in the Arizona desert trying to immigrate to the U.S., is at 57 percent.
  • Bicycling with Moliere, a comedy about a soap opera star who tries to convince his curmudgeonly actor friend to mount a production of Moliere’s The Misanthrope, is at 50 percent.
  • For No Good Reason, a documentary portrait of gonzo artist Ralph Steadman, is at 36 percent.
  • Walking With The Enemy, a World War II-era drama about a man who disguises himself as a Nazi officer in order to find his missing family, is at 25 percent.
  • The Girl and Death, a period melodrama about a young medical student who falls in love with the mistress of a vindictive aristocrat, is at 20 percent.

Finally, props to Caleb Paasche for guessing A Haunted House 2‘s nine Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Brie Larson Star Trek Drama El Rey Mary Tyler Moore Amazon American Society of Cinematographers sitcom BET Chilling Adventures of Sabrina adventure game show crossover Photos Black Mirror ESPN Acorn TV Trivia Vudu Awards Tour Musical Rocketman CMT composers facebook Starz dceu comiccon APB Tumblr Pop CBS All Access technology Disney Channel cults award winner Character Guide ABC TCA 2017 San Diego Comic-Con true crime Rom-Com First Look Rocky Certified Fresh LGBT CBS Awards elevated horror RT21 binge PaleyFest spinoff Creative Arts Emmys space MSNBC VICE Trophy Talk Fall TV 21st Century Fox ITV spider-man docudrama E3 Infographic zombie spy thriller A&E dc Red Carpet hist Anna Paquin Superheroe TV Land SundanceTV Holidays Dark Horse Comics Quiz Lionsgate Lifetime Food Network unscripted Shudder Paramount Masterpiece finale Britbox Netflix SDCC See It Skip It Cannes Fox News 007 discovery natural history 20th Century Fox 2016 YouTube Premium RT History golden globes period drama Summer Film Festival Mary poppins Grammys Spring TV GIFs Action Logo Comedy Central sports Pixar Oscars crime TV Pride Month TCA political drama Paramount Network HBO FXX Walt Disney Pictures Captain marvel ratings Spectrum Originals YouTube Red Countdown The Witch GoT Women's History Month diversity Comedy Best and Worst theme song Pirates Writers Guild of America TruTV DGA animated 2017 sequel blaxploitation Esquire Trailer Adult Swim anime Marathons ABC Family Polls and Games Premiere Dates Extras festivals comic Cosplay Toys Rock Universal WGN The Arrangement zombies Election PBS Song of Ice and Fire biography Hulu Freeform Martial Arts Tomatazos GLAAD VH1 Comic Book social media zero dark thirty police drama medical drama Kids & Family dragons AMC Teen Elton John Podcast vampires Fantasy miniseries Valentine's Day MTV Reality Competition BBC cats travel 24 frames History NBC psycho DC Universe Western Mindy Kaling TCM Set visit serial killer SXSW toy story Bravo what to watch Superheroes Crackle TNT Tarantino Nickelodeon CNN Mary Poppins Returns Sneak Peek YA New York Comic Con crime thriller harry potter nature Winter TV psychological thriller mutant science fiction TLC Horror 2019 Christmas Chernobyl based on movie National Geographic Star Wars OWN 45 dramedy Nat Geo X-Men crime drama green book justice league mockumentary DirecTV historical drama Pet Sematary strong female leads streaming Opinion singing competition TIFF Syfy Animation Box Office USA Network richard e. Grant doctor who thriller CW Seed DC streaming service Sci-Fi jamie lee curtis cops Emmy Nominations boxoffice DC Comics 2018 Disney LGBTQ adaptation Country Mystery Schedule Lucasfilm Year in Review Watching Series Marvel FOX Sony Pictures Ovation robots Sundance talk show cinemax Cartoon Network Thanksgiving The CW Showtime witnail HBO Max WarnerMedia Calendar E! Ghostbusters disaster transformers politics FX Emmys war supernatural Heroines aliens Winners Stephen King Ellie Kemper Warner Bros. Sundance Now Apple Reality cooking Music TBS romance USA BBC America Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Nominations Interview Columbia Pictures NYCC IFC Epix IFC Films television President 2015 Shondaland Super Bowl teaser Amazon Prime Musicals Biopics Mudbound Spike MCU Video Games Comics on TV anthology casting