Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Identical Won't Leave You All Shook Up

Plus, No No: A Dockumentary is a fascinating portrait of a trailblazing ballplayer, and Wetlands is wild and transgressive.

by | September 5, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got just one wide release: The Identical, starring Blake Rayne, Ashley Judd, and Ray Liotta in the fictional story of an Elvis-esque rocker and his twin brother. What do the critics have to say?

The Identical


It’s a heartbreaking — and undeniably intriguing — bit of trivia that every Elvis Presley fan knows: the King had an identical twin brother who was stillborn. What would have happened had Jesse Presley survived? Unfortunately, critics say The Identical takes this premise and squanders it on a schmaltzy, unintentionally funny plot sprinkled with bland tunes and uneven performances. Blake Rayne plays a dual role as brothers separated by birth. One grows up to become a rock ‘n’ roll pioneer, and the other is expected to join the ministry — though he finds the lure of music hard to resist. The pundits say The Identical is well-meaning but surprisingly ham-fisted; it’s a movie about a rock star that’s short on edge or memorable music.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • No No: A Dockumentary, a portrait of Pittsburgh Pirates pitcher Dock Ellis and the no-hitter he threw while on acid, is at 100 percent.
  • Wetlands, a transgressive dramedy about a teenager who acts out while dealing with her parents’ divorce, is at 94 percent.
  • Last Days in Vietnam, a documentary about the evacuation of South Vietnamese collaborators from Saigon, is at 92 percent.
  • Memphis, a drama about a few days in the life of a troubled soul singer, is at 75 percent.
  • God Help the Girl, starring Emily Browning in a coming-of-age comedy directed by Belle and Sebastian’s Stuart Murdoch, is at 71 percent.
  • Thunder and the House of Magic, an animated adventure about a cat who moves into a magician’s house, is at 68 percent.
  • Kelly & Cal, starring Juliette Lewis in a drama about an alienated suburban mom who befirends a teen from the neighborhood, is at 64 percent.
  • Trailer Park Boys: Don’t Legalize It, featuring the Canadian goofballs in a mockumentary about keeping marijuana illegal so as not to hurt their thriving business, is at 57 percent.
  • Frontera, starring Ed Harris and Michael Peña in a drama about a murder investigation along the Mexico-Arizona border, is at 55 percent.
  • The Longest Week, starring Jason Bateman and Olivia Wilde in a comedy about a writer who moves in with his best friend and falls in love with his girlfriend, is at 22 percent.
  • Innocence, a dark drama about a troubled girl at a sinister boarding school, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

First Look Family obituary Sundance Walt Disney Pictures YouTube Sundance Now Apple Crackle Disney Channel hist a nightmare on elm street Syfy Elton John CBS All Access spanish language reviews USA FX Cosplay Disney+ Disney Plus cults Western Cannes Heroines TruTV all-time Marvel DirecTV criterion Disney streaming service Reality TBS VH1 video on demand BBC One stoner Shondaland witnail Brie Larson dc Hallmark Christmas movies zombies ghosts indie crime drama Avengers war Tumblr best comic Extras CBS sitcom Countdown APB Binge Guide films Musical laika Calendar streaming 007 elevated horror cops canceled TV shows Academy Awards Mary Tyler Moore Podcast CNN concert documentaries YA CW Seed breaking bad Mystery First Reviews green book Sneak Peek Set visit Disney sequels Superheroes directors psycho halloween Logo comiccon spinoff game of thrones Pixar Funimation Stephen King anime Lifetime Christmas movies FX on Hulu stop motion El Rey DC streaming service Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Oscars Summer The Witch based on movie Pirates Universal dramedy asian-american Sundance TV Mary poppins Emmys die hard versus Paramount indiana jones blaxploitation cinemax Crunchyroll ABC Family politics 45 SXSW Superheroe Apple TV+ Peacock Travel Channel dark cars adaptation TV dogs science fiction canceled movies Acorn TV Marvel Studios Ellie Kemper Music Year in Review Creative Arts Emmys television NBC Britbox Dark Horse Comics cancelled TV series 2019 Masterpiece The Purge Rock discovery romantic comedy news Women's History Month zombie Lifetime Nominations christmas movies 2018 worst DGA Ghostbusters Anna Paquin Rocky Premiere Dates Bravo WarnerMedia what to watch TIFF Netflix Christmas movies spider-man slashers TCA Awards Interview Starz Mindy Kaling Character Guide miniseries Arrowverse PlayStation emmy awards Election Infographic Nickelodeon CMT AMC TCA 2017 historical drama Polls and Games Tomatazos IFC Films crime thriller thriller political drama Emmy Nominations theme song diversity 24 frames Comedy Central Holidays mockumentary MCU facebook A&E ABC scary movies Vudu IFC hispanic OWN talk show psychological thriller Hallmark GLAAD comics OneApp The Arrangement Red Carpet 71st Emmy Awards Star Trek adventure Comics on TV BET Awards blockbuster Reality Competition cats Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Box Office Television Academy Grammys Shudder nature serial killer Tubi Super Bowl 2015 richard e. Grant ESPN YouTube Premium superhero name the review Best and Worst FOX Hear Us Out singing competition vampires Fall TV Winter TV cancelled Netflix Song of Ice and Fire sag awards dragons Freeform parents justice league Amazon Studios police drama doctor who Esquire medical drama robots RT21 Valentine's Day Baby Yoda Awards Television Critics Association casting batman screenings Mudbound Mary Poppins Returns Marathons mission: impossible joker Apple TV Plus Sony Pictures American Society of Cinematographers quibi GIFs FXX video rotten movies we love Pop Paramount Network zero dark thirty natural history revenge Comedy San Diego Comic-Con Certified Fresh LGBTQ harry potter werewolf romance free movies docudrama Teen Discovery Channel award winner strong female leads Martial Arts Winners unscripted twilight Biopics New York Comic Con franchise 72 Emmy Awards toy story Showtime classics comedies Spike 2016 latino biography HBO Go Food Network technology Chernobyl universal monsters HBO Writers Guild of America TCA 2017 reboot aliens Fox News sports Trailer Christmas Cartoon Network Film Columbia Pictures Animation E3 Spectrum Originals Toys Star Wars DC Comics game show Epix boxoffice Pride Month Amazon jamie lee curtis critics period drama NYCC LGBT true crime BET Hulu TNT Country finale BBC screen actors guild MTV Amazon Prime Thanksgiving Disney Plus Action BAFTA 20th Century Fox chucky cancelled television MSNBC The Walking Dead Black History Month Rom-Com Turner Classic Movies tv talk PBS SDCC ITV spain Opinion foreign Horror Warner Bros. TCA Winter 2020 crime Sci-Fi independent book space Musicals Comic Book History The CW Film Festival teaser Kids & Family kids Turner Quiz Endgame GoT TV renewals cancelled TV shows animated Marvel Television Spring TV festivals cartoon DC Universe 4/20 BBC America SundanceTV Trophy Talk supernatural nbcuniversal Holiday Classic Film spy thriller series TCM X-Men A24 anthology Lucasfilm satire 21st Century Fox stand-up comedy travel TLC hollywood Adult Swim HBO Max Awards Tour Tarantino VOD Black Mirror E! Nat Geo rotten social media dceu composers Trivia See It Skip It cooking USA Network PaleyFest Photos Schedule Ovation President renewed TV shows VICE binge south america golden globes Pet Sematary Captain marvel documentary TV Land children's TV 2020 Amazon Prime Video National Geographic WGN Lionsgate child's play YouTube Red Video Games Fantasy Watching Series fast and furious ratings transformers Rocketman movie Drama sequel disaster RT History Pop TV crossover mutant