Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Identical Won't Leave You All Shook Up

Plus, No No: A Dockumentary is a fascinating portrait of a trailblazing ballplayer, and Wetlands is wild and transgressive.

by | September 5, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got just one wide release: The Identical, starring Blake Rayne, Ashley Judd, and Ray Liotta in the fictional story of an Elvis-esque rocker and his twin brother. What do the critics have to say?

The Identical


It’s a heartbreaking — and undeniably intriguing — bit of trivia that every Elvis Presley fan knows: the King had an identical twin brother who was stillborn. What would have happened had Jesse Presley survived? Unfortunately, critics say The Identical takes this premise and squanders it on a schmaltzy, unintentionally funny plot sprinkled with bland tunes and uneven performances. Blake Rayne plays a dual role as brothers separated by birth. One grows up to become a rock ‘n’ roll pioneer, and the other is expected to join the ministry — though he finds the lure of music hard to resist. The pundits say The Identical is well-meaning but surprisingly ham-fisted; it’s a movie about a rock star that’s short on edge or memorable music.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • No No: A Dockumentary, a portrait of Pittsburgh Pirates pitcher Dock Ellis and the no-hitter he threw while on acid, is at 100 percent.
  • Wetlands, a transgressive dramedy about a teenager who acts out while dealing with her parents’ divorce, is at 94 percent.
  • Last Days in Vietnam, a documentary about the evacuation of South Vietnamese collaborators from Saigon, is at 92 percent.
  • Memphis, a drama about a few days in the life of a troubled soul singer, is at 75 percent.
  • God Help the Girl, starring Emily Browning in a coming-of-age comedy directed by Belle and Sebastian’s Stuart Murdoch, is at 71 percent.
  • Thunder and the House of Magic, an animated adventure about a cat who moves into a magician’s house, is at 68 percent.
  • Kelly & Cal, starring Juliette Lewis in a drama about an alienated suburban mom who befirends a teen from the neighborhood, is at 64 percent.
  • Trailer Park Boys: Don’t Legalize It, featuring the Canadian goofballs in a mockumentary about keeping marijuana illegal so as not to hurt their thriving business, is at 57 percent.
  • Frontera, starring Ed Harris and Michael Peña in a drama about a murder investigation along the Mexico-Arizona border, is at 55 percent.
  • The Longest Week, starring Jason Bateman and Olivia Wilde in a comedy about a writer who moves in with his best friend and falls in love with his girlfriend, is at 22 percent.
  • Innocence, a dark drama about a troubled girl at a sinister boarding school, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

Emmy Nominations know your critic Academy Awards cults Anna Paquin Marvel Studios Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Instagram Live Acorn TV 20th Century Fox Infographic a nightmare on elm street nbcuniversal japan Paramount Network animated reviews Nickelodeon Lucasfilm Summer TCA Awards thriller comics quibi toronto social media deadpool foreign Premiere Dates australia Video Games trophy E! IMDb TV Musical television james bond Winter TV biography CNN New York Comic Con asian-american Tags: Comedy razzies Amazon Prime Trophy Talk live action what to watch YouTube Red BBC America comic book movies slasher action-comedy suspense finale Captain marvel Kids & Family 71st Emmy Awards ABC Signature NBC GLAAD laika sports Food Network Quiz HFPA WGN godzilla reboot PlayStation Rom-Com joker Netflix legend 45 black Alien Pacific Islander Election Opinion RT History The Walking Dead all-time dark spanish language emmy awards Fall TV Legendary Toys dc debate Mudbound 4/20 Syfy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Apple TV+ Mary poppins cops Best and Worst war Hollywood Foreign Press Association WarnerMedia stoner venice nfl spider-man 2018 obituary vs. YouTube Premium Trailer children's TV Marvel Television ITV Fox News Musicals based on movie AMC Plus lord of the rings SDCC kaiju mutant SXSW latino Peacock ABC Family Elton John DC Universe saw Bravo Nominations batman 2016 The Arrangement IFC President Turner Amazon Prime Video MSNBC X-Men Logo Calendar NBA The Academy docuseries rt archives VH1 dexter sopranos Superheroe genre Film historical drama hispanic heritage month comic book movie Walt Disney Pictures concert 90s Western 72 Emmy Awards 73rd Emmy Awards doctor who Prime Video video on demand BBC One Song of Ice and Fire hispanic 21st Century Fox Wes Anderson PaleyFest ESPN Tokyo Olympics Disney Channel Pixar Superheroes HBO Nat Geo canceled mob Marvel police drama Disney Hulu Black Mirror ghosts supernatural The CW political drama blockbuster classics docudrama mcc Endgame First Look indie criterion critic resources El Rey Vudu transformers rotten films Comic Book Apple TV Plus elevated horror Image Comics richard e. Grant Schedule composers Women's History Month scene in color miniseries SundanceTV Pet Sematary Rocketman festival Podcast HBO Go theme song TV One technology young adult robots spain christmas movies TV Rocky Baby Yoda Holidays teaser Watching Series video CBS All Access 24 frames jamie lee curtis Comedy Central History travel Shondaland mockumentary FXX feel good Tomatazos Sony Pictures scary movies Certified Fresh Stephen King BAFTA Mystery Rock critics japanese Arrowverse YA spider-verse romance Photos Netflix Christmas movies Action anthology name the review Amazon marvel comics talk show superhero TIFF Creative Arts Emmys IFC Films hidden camera Tarantino RT21 fast and furious Masterpiece telelvision singing competition serial killer remakes Grammys Awards Warner Bros. book toy story dreamworks A&E disaster TV movies popular Funimation franchise casting worst movies boxoffice superman Comics on TV trailers Starz spy thriller free movies psycho strong female leads TruTV blockbusters sequels CW Seed south america movies halloween comic Music FX streaming Dark Horse Comics VICE Shudder HBO Max Writers Guild of America Pride Month Horror USA Network king arthur best crossover Disney Plus comedies Mary Tyler Moore Oscars game show Family Sundance TV GIFs high school cartoon adaptation Adult Swim Hear Us Out CBS TCA game of thrones jurassic park new york Cartoon Network breaking bad Esquire Christmas zombies Fox Searchlight king kong ViacomCBS The Walt Disney Company sitcom Britbox MCU A24 Hallmark Lionsgate harry potter slashers space 2019 Turner Classic Movies Classic Film Spring TV Star Wars ABC anime wonder woman marvel cinematic universe TCA Winter 2020 boxing pirates of the caribbean adenture worst Tubi politics Broadway 99% Showtime renewed TV shows TV Land rotten movies we love Ellie Kemper Television Critics Association book adaptation streaming movies LGBTQ Disney+ Disney Plus Hallmark Christmas movies blaxploitation crime thriller independent nature Discovery Channel 007 dceu TCA 2017 The Witch Amazon Studios OWN ID 2021 dramedy romantic comedy period drama vampires new star wars movies CMT cancelled TV series AMC 79th Golden Globes Awards Universal rom-coms sag awards medical drama Binge Guide Brie Larson Spike football Martial Arts hist Pop documentaries Mary Poppins Returns posters 1990s Spectrum Originals gangster 2015 true crime Interview Biopics National Geographic TCM biopic green book heist movie cancelled TV shows zero dark thirty universal monsters unscripted Pop TV live event zombie The Purge Reality Marathons Reality Competition Country witnail chucky Year in Review archives Winners Comic-Con@Home 2021 MTV international mission: impossible DGA canceled TV shows natural history DC Comics scorecard kong San Diego Comic-Con new zealand 2020 rt labs critics edition justice league Polls and Games Epix YouTube fresh Cannes rt labs PBS target women Lifetime Christmas movies Animation Avengers golden globe awards binge satire italian comiccon OneApp aliens Cosplay Universal Pictures Comedy Apple Box Office 2017 Heroines basketball Red Carpet Black History Month Trivia cancelled television discovery 93rd Oscars Countdown ratings dragons cancelled Drama First Reviews leaderboard Fargo LGBT BET kids award winner die hard series FX on Hulu Paramount Plus monster movies directors spanish crime drama werewolf Freeform Sneak Peek Film Festival TLC See It Skip It Star Trek black comedy TNT DC streaming service FOX Fantasy Ovation Sci-Fi Lifetime adventure stand-up comedy stop motion Columbia Pictures screenings Travel Channel Set visit BBC NYCC revenge American Society of Cinematographers cooking Emmys cars APB BET Awards Sundance prank GoT Exclusive Video Neflix festivals Awards Tour Character Guide art house Television Academy halloween tv spinoff aapi Extras Disney streaming service diversity crime screen actors guild DirecTV versus Crunchyroll scary Chernobyl hollywood TBS Sundance Now TV renewals child's play USA documentary comic books Valentine's Day cats sequel Crackle VOD twilight Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt movie news french royal family golden globes Ghostbusters psychological thriller Paramount E3 cinemax Teen Thanksgiving facebook Tumblr tv talk parents Holiday Mindy Kaling dogs Super Bowl Pirates olympics indiana jones science fiction