Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Boxtrolls, The Equalizer, Fall TV

In limited release: Pride, The Two Faces of January, and Jimi: All Is by My Side.

by | September 26, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got misunderstood monsters (The Boxtrolls, featuring voice performances from Elle Fanning and Ben Kingsley) and an enigmatic vigilante (The Equalizer, starring Denzel Washington and Chloë Grace Moretz). What do the critics have to say?

The Boxtrolls


Witty, original, and darker than your average family fare, Coraline and ParaNorman proved that Laika was a force to be reckoned with in the animation world. Critics say the studio’s latest effort, The Boxtrolls, offers a less compelling story than those films, but it’s meticulously crafted and often delightfully weird. The titular creatures are kindly, goofy monsters that have raised a little boy named Eggs (voiced by Isaac Hempstead-Wright) as one of their own. But the nefarious Archibald Snatcher (Ben Kingsley) wants to wipe out the Boxtrolls for personal gain, so it’s up to Eggs and his new friend Winnie (Elle Fanning) to stop him. The pundits say The Boxtrolls is visually striking, but it lacks the charm and narrative pull of previous Laika features.(Check out our video interviews with Kingsley and Fanning.)

The Equalizer


The last time Denzel Washington and director Antoine Fuqua teamed up, the result was Training Day, a searing portrait of a crooked cop that earned Washington an Oscar. They’re back together for The Equalizer, but critics say the results are mixed this time; Washington is his usual compelling self, but the script often succumbs to thriller cliches. Washington stars as McCall, a man with a mysterious past who’s trying to keep a low profile. However, when he stumbles upon Teri (Chloë Grace Moretz) a troubled young woman under the thumb of heartless mobsters, McCall decides to take matters into his own hands. The pundits say The Equalizer is stylish and gritty, but the formulaic plot doesn’t always make the best use of Washington’s fine central performance. (Watch our video Q&A with Fuqua, as well as Washington’s best-reviewed films.)

Certified Fresh on TV this week:

Expanding upon the Batman universe, Gotham (90 percent), which stars Ben Mckenzie and Jada Pinkett Smith, delves into the history of the key players of the Dark Knight saga. The critics say Gotham features high production values, a talented cast, and an appealingly stylized approach to the Batman mythos.

black-ish (86 percent) stars Anthony Anderson and Laurence Fishburne in a comedy series about a father who’s concerned that raising his his kids in the suburbs will force them to lose touch with their African American roots. The critics say black-ish is smart, ingratiating, and often very funny.

Viola Davis is an exceptional talent, and critics say she’s the best reason to watch How to Get Away With Murder (84 percent). The pundits say this legal thriller is slick and exciting, which helps it to overcome its sometimes shaky plotting.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

dc 2019 Marvel Studios die hard Western dark miniseries comics HBO Max 24 frames CBS Mudbound nature Music video finale jamie lee curtis FX on Hulu Martial Arts satire Sneak Peek true crime a nightmare on elm street Writers Guild of America ABC Valentine's Day spain The CW Tomatazos what to watch reboot crossover Avengers cartoon Crackle stand-up comedy politics hispanic crime Podcast breaking bad Disney indie DirecTV Sci-Fi Family Best and Worst Box Office TIFF Syfy toy story Rocketman CMT Turner Classic Movies TV Land Horror versus crime drama Classic Film halloween comiccon Superheroe social media richard e. Grant Food Network Amazon Prime YouTube Red spy thriller medical drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Baby Yoda Adult Swim werewolf Awards serial killer movies DC Universe Trivia APB Toys Calendar war Paramount Network Turner Pop PaleyFest Acorn TV chucky Hear Us Out tv talk movie Netflix Christmas movies Comic Book cops Grammys dogs sitcom Comedy Central BBC One The Arrangement strong female leads Set visit Masterpiece Holiday Ovation criterion Fantasy teaser Fall TV quibi justice league cancelled LGBTQ AMC natural history romantic comedy CBS All Access Sundance Nominations ABC Family Awards Tour Television Academy Watching Series PlayStation spinoff Opinion kids anime MSNBC Red Carpet 21st Century Fox YouTube Action Chernobyl Rock renewed TV shows technology YA Logo Nickelodeon Musical dceu based on movie DC Comics mockumentary documentaries Disney+ Disney Plus television Teen San Diego Comic-Con Sundance Now screen actors guild zombie 2015 OneApp MTV Tubi theme song facebook rotten movies we love Crunchyroll Holidays Warner Bros. Election Cartoon Network book Universal Lionsgate Starz TLC animated Mystery 4/20 First Reviews Star Wars Pride Month science fiction Lifetime Christmas movies Marathons news anthology BAFTA Sony Pictures Stephen King TCA Winter 2020 transformers BET Awards scary movies TCA Awards NYCC hist adaptation Comedy Brie Larson dragons Super Bowl OWN travel Disney streaming service TBS latino space casting PBS 2016 ITV cars Peacock Animation Captain marvel series Christmas Paramount BBC America Hallmark concert HBO VICE National Geographic 2020 Trophy Talk Schedule Dark Horse Comics Mary poppins Heroines Hallmark Christmas movies Pixar comedies 71st Emmy Awards Premiere Dates cancelled TV series zero dark thirty aliens Disney Plus Ellie Kemper Polls and Games comic Endgame Funimation Quiz Disney Channel supernatural The Witch vampires See It Skip It critics IFC Women's History Month films VH1 unscripted SDCC game show south america Thanksgiving RT21 Trailer Television Critics Association Pop TV slashers political drama crime thriller Comics on TV Binge Guide Marvel free movies mutant blockbuster USA diversity CNN mission: impossible WarnerMedia Infographic El Rey Country Emmy Nominations 20th Century Fox TruTV Tarantino reviews Film X-Men Esquire ratings thriller Lucasfilm Vudu twilight The Purge documentary binge Cosplay children's TV Winter TV FXX police drama harry potter best Walt Disney Pictures History 45 Black History Month MCU independent batman CW Seed golden globes foreign Rom-Com zombies GoT Mary Tyler Moore Britbox boxoffice Photos GLAAD psychological thriller singing competition TV RT History The Walking Dead SXSW YouTube Premium Spring TV Kids & Family Reality Competition HBO Go revenge canceled TV shows Shondaland stoner FOX TV renewals Marvel Television Pirates TCA 2017 child's play Certified Fresh adventure TCM witnail New York Comic Con cats christmas movies SundanceTV parents FX 2018 Emmys disaster Reality screenings elevated horror Showtime canceled Amazon LGBT cancelled TV shows First Look doctor who E3 cinemax Nat Geo Year in Review dramedy spider-man indiana jones Video Games ESPN biography Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Elton John Rocky robots Columbia Pictures ghosts DGA Drama Apple TV Plus 2017 Apple Lifetime Freeform sports cults Superheroes docudrama joker asian-american VOD Star Trek directors Extras Hulu franchise DC streaming service Spike talk show Mary Poppins Returns Biopics President Netflix discovery Black Mirror cancelled television green book Film Festival psycho BBC 007 video on demand festivals Cannes Epix Mindy Kaling sequel NBC cooking Academy Awards romance Amazon Studios Musicals GIFs Song of Ice and Fire Tumblr USA Network IFC Films Apple TV+ Summer American Society of Cinematographers period drama blaxploitation Countdown Discovery Channel A&E WGN Character Guide E! BET TCA name the review all-time Shudder award winner TNT universal monsters Anna Paquin composers historical drama streaming Bravo Interview Pet Sematary sag awards Oscars Amazon Prime Video spanish language Travel Channel game of thrones Arrowverse Fox News Sundance TV A24 Winners Spectrum Originals Creative Arts Emmys Ghostbusters