Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Star Trek Is The Best-Reviewed Wide Release of 2009!

Plus, Next Day Air fails to deliver.

by | May 7, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a brand new Enterprise (Star Trek, starring Chris Pine and Zachary Quinto) and a failed delivery (Next Day Air, starring Donald Faison and Mike Epps). What do the critics have to say?


Star Trek

It boldly goes where no Trek has gone before. This new Trek will live long and prosper. No matter what clichés they may use, there’s no getting around the critics’ main point: JJ AbramsStar Trek is stirring mainstream entertainment, and breathes new life into the moribund franchise. It’s an origin story, one that tells the tale of how Kirk (Chris Pine) and Spock (Zachary Quinto) became, well, Kirk and Spock. The pundits say Abrams’ action-packed, visually remarkable take on such venerable material will reward both fans and newcomers alike, and sets an impressive new course for one of pop culture’s most enduring series. Not only is Star Trek Certified Fresh, it’s the best-reviewed wide release of the year. To top it all off, it’s the best-reviewed entry in the Star Trek franchise to date. (Be sure to check out Starfleet Command, RT’s one-stop shop for all things Trek. Also, see this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down all the previous Trek films by Tomatometer.)


Next Day Air

Caper comedies walk a fine line; if you get too bogged down in the crime itself, the laughs can suffer. Such is the case with Next Day Air, which critics say has some moments of madcap intensity but falters from a lack of discipline. The movie stars Donald Faison as an inept deliveryman who unwittingly drops a large shipment of cocaine at the apartment of two incompetent bank robbers; pretty soon, in Tarantino-esque fashion, a number of colorful characters intersect with wacky results. Or not, say pundits, who find the film’s tonal shift from slapstick to surprisingly cold-hearted violence unpleasant.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Audience of One, a documentary about a pastor’s attempt to make a Christian sci-fi epic, is at 80 percent.
  • The Dardenne BrothersLorna’s Silence, about a young woman who becomes entangled with the mafia, is at 80 percent.
  • The Argentine import The Window, a contemplative take of an elderly man’s final days, is at 80 percent.
  • Atom Egoyan‘s Adoration, a drama about the strange nature of interpersonal relations in our techie age, is at 76 percent.
  • Outrage, Kirby Dick‘s expose of closeted Congressmen, is at 75 percent.
  • Julia, starring Tilda Swinton as a lonely alcoholic who commits a desperate act of violence, is at 71 percent.
  • Rudo and Cursi, which reunites Y Tu Mama Tambien stars Gael Garcia Bernal and Diego Luna in a dark road comedy about two would-be soccer players, is at 69 percent.
  • Objectified, a documentary about commercial design and its impact on consumers, is at 50 percent.
  • Love N’ Dancing, starring Amy Smart in a dramedy about an unlikely pair that makes a run toward a national swing dancing competition title, is at 17 percent.
  • Little Ashes, a biopic of Salvador Dali’s early days starring Robert Pattinson, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

2021 Action live action DirecTV elevated horror Star Trek CMT reviews ABC Signature Drama Quiz mutant cinemax BBC America Schedule 21st Century Fox New York Comic Con nature The Arrangement dceu Stephen King concert comic books Pride Month Wes Anderson talk show rotten Photos festivals Apple TV+ Fox Searchlight Film Festival Paramount Plus Disney streaming service book adaptation TCA Winter 2020 X-Men Mudbound History SundanceTV franchise Pet Sematary medical drama CBS All Access RT History cancelled TV shows new star wars movies Marvel Studios monster movies Crunchyroll diversity Sneak Peek werewolf Film Song of Ice and Fire new zealand Winners anthology spinoff Acorn TV Musical Nickelodeon rt archives Tomatazos directors MTV transformers Amazon Prime Video DGA scene in color game show dragons toronto zombie Rocky The Walking Dead parents FXX Walt Disney Pictures universal monsters Black Mirror adaptation crime drama Thanksgiving Grammys Baby Yoda Election Trophy Talk Funimation Classic Film Awards Tour The Walt Disney Company Comedy doctor who sag awards adenture book batman stoner toy story lord of the rings Showtime quibi FOX TV DC Comics NYCC harry potter Emmys target Hulu VH1 movies Country biography Tubi TCA Awards Shondaland Pop TV laika Family sequel Red Carpet RT21 king arthur Amazon Prime LGBT WarnerMedia Opinion name the review unscripted dark HBO Max Writers Guild of America new york Crackle 2015 Food Network hollywood chucky San Diego Comic-Con TruTV video all-time Tokyo Olympics 4/20 Rock Amazon zombies Comic Book HBO mission: impossible National Geographic 90s 45 news fresh sitcom space USA Freeform Mary Tyler Moore composers APB 24 frames cancelled TV series Super Bowl travel films finale dc international TV movies Pacific Islander prank Netflix Horror DC streaming service The CW BET Awards theme song psychological thriller a nightmare on elm street HBO Go golden globe awards Pixar cartoon Fox News what to watch Chernobyl Comedy Central spider-man king kong Summer hispanic discovery Captain marvel Comic-Con@Home 2021 Spectrum Originals Box Office legend ratings Disney+ Disney Plus FX aapi Cannes asian-american french Lucasfilm Certified Fresh FX on Hulu AMC BBC Universal Christmas Music saw jurassic park Sci-Fi Disney Channel rotten movies we love Heroines Valentine's Day independent OneApp kids ESPN pirates of the caribbean Fantasy YouTube Red documentary Epix screenings Marathons boxing james bond dramedy Infographic heist movie The Academy breaking bad based on movie E! streaming movies Best and Worst award winner YouTube spanish language BBC One comic thriller TCA adventure anime Lifetime Christmas movies Sundance TV versus video on demand Animation President war canceled TV shows hidden camera worst CBS ITV cults Binge Guide spy thriller comics indie christmas movies romantic comedy SXSW streaming The Witch Lifetime tv talk Teen period drama Nat Geo OWN screen actors guild Biopics women 20th Century Fox blaxploitation TV renewals Netflix Christmas movies Legendary crime thriller TCM 71st Emmy Awards Paramount nfl Mystery Amazon Studios venice nbcuniversal documentaries cars joker Ghostbusters Adult Swim TCA 2017 Bravo vampires japanese casting NBA El Rey television stop motion Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Video Games Western best latino superman Mindy Kaling know your critic australia GoT WGN TLC Rocketman Ovation IFC Films TV One Superheroes justice league slashers Creative Arts Emmys Britbox First Look Countdown A&E Polls and Games PlayStation technology 2017 Comics on TV Mary poppins satire Discovery Channel PaleyFest indiana jones Calendar superhero Premiere Dates green book ABC Family ID blockbusters Shudder VOD Turner singing competition Marvel Television canceled Esquire crossover Sony Pictures Holidays Kids & Family suspense Trivia obituary Syfy Academy Awards classics Women's History Month Emmy Nominations olympics Television Academy NBC football Tarantino Image Comics halloween Endgame Podcast 93rd Oscars witnail Hear Us Out Trailer popular E3 GIFs Rom-Com Elton John movie Black History Month foreign USA Network die hard golden globes festival Watching Series Logo facebook reboot children's TV BET Oscars renewed TV shows TNT Superheroe VICE Character Guide Pop italian teaser CW Seed Warner Bros. Hallmark Christmas movies game of thrones richard e. Grant Winter TV DC Universe docuseries IFC The Purge cancelled television LGBTQ Sundance Now Masterpiece CNN Fall TV sports child's play Marvel twilight hist Paramount Network Columbia Pictures Turner Classic Movies First Reviews ViacomCBS zero dark thirty Apple TV Plus supernatural Cartoon Network revenge MCU Television Critics Association 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards serial killer 2018 Brie Larson historical drama Ellie Kemper wonder woman Peacock series deadpool politics Interview jamie lee curtis YA kaiju Alien Hallmark ABC free movies Anna Paquin Spike Travel Channel kong Broadway Awards scary movies spanish marvel cinematic universe 2016 YouTube Premium Martial Arts TV Land critics black docudrama science fiction comedies Set visit Vudu Reality cancelled rom-coms Holiday animated telelvision 72 Emmy Awards Mary Poppins Returns police drama 99% strong female leads basketball Starz sequels razzies Cosplay south america crime 2020 Exclusive Video spain natural history cooking Lionsgate Toys Musicals halloween tv TIFF Reality Competition miniseries Tumblr MSNBC Apple disaster binge Extras remakes TBS 2019 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina romance comiccon Disney Plus aliens PBS Spring TV ghosts stand-up comedy American Society of Cinematographers GLAAD fast and furious Nominations boxoffice Avengers political drama Star Wars BAFTA SDCC mockumentary cops japan godzilla A24 Sundance Disney social media trailers psycho dogs archives high school Dark Horse Comics 007 1990s cats true crime Arrowverse scorecard robots worst movies Pirates Year in Review emmy awards criterion See It Skip It blockbuster